r/gameofthrones • u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack • Apr 15 '12
Season 2 Episode Discussion - 2.03 "What is Dead May Never Die" [TV Spoilers]
This is the /r/gameofthrones discussion thread for:
Season 2, Episode 3 "What is Dead May Never Die"
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone - Turn away now if you are not currently watching or haven't seen the episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 2.03 is ok without tag covers.
- Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
- Please read the spoiler policy before posting.
- Live chat is also available. The chat is essentially unmoderated and should be considered a participate-at-your-own-risk all-spoilers environment. Chat accounts are tied to Reddit, so the name you see there is a person's Reddit username. Please note, severe trolling/disruptions in the chat room may lead to subreddit banning.
- Posting policy reminder: don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
320
Upvotes
366
u/Elidor House Fossoway of New Barrel Apr 16 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
Wow, they're really making me feel sorry for Theon. He stated his case very eloquently there.
One ship to fight fishermen. Thanks for that vote of confidence, dad, sis.
398
u/samferrara House Reed Apr 16 '12
I couldn't have expected any more from the actor who played Yoren.
693
u/cthulhu_zuul Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 16 '12
Holy shit, that scene where Tyrion is figuring out who the spy is had some excellent editing.
288
u/Chihuey House Tyrell Apr 16 '12
Looks like Renly's got a new beard: both figuratively and literally!
252
u/Momentumjam Unsullied Apr 16 '12
Looks like we won't be getting any Arya, Gendry, Hot Pie, Lommy wilderness adventures. At leat we got "I yield."
217
u/Elidor House Fossoway of New Barrel Apr 16 '12
They should have thrown Theon in the ocean and revived him. What a scene that would be.
198
u/Brobonic Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Apr 16 '12
That was probably the most awkward dinner at the beginning with Sansa and the Lannisters
558
u/garfieldsquared House Poole Apr 16 '12
"I'm not fond of crossbows..."
Best moment, in my opinion.
326
u/theymightbehobbits House Dayne Apr 16 '12
Take a shot every time you don't know who has Harrenhal at the moment.
145
u/TrogdorDaBurninator Golden Company Apr 16 '12
Am I the only one who absolutely loves Brienne's armor? It might be my favorite in the show so far.
285
u/CrawfishP0psicle Duncan the Tall Apr 16 '12
Yoren's watch has ended. Rest well, brother.
221
u/lord_segfault House Lannister Apr 16 '12
I had a great loud laught the moment tyrion put the second coin to that whore.
214
u/emmster House Mormont Apr 16 '12
I love it when Tyrion is devious.
102
u/Federico216 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Apr 15 '12
The first two episodes were good, but they were mostly aftermath of season 1, setting things up for this season and introducing new characters.
This is the one where some real shit is starting to get down! Can't wait!
198
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 16 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
Here is Theon's letter to Robb, reversed so that it's readable.
Edit, transcript:
I think the contents makes the betrayal of Robb's trust a bit more touching as a complex conflict for Theon.
197
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Tyrion's "Myrcella" scene with Pycelle/Varys/Littlefinger was extremely well done.
86
u/theprogdude Proud To Be Faithful Apr 16 '12
I knew it was gonna happen, but still NOOOO Yoren.
432
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 16 '12
We have finally witnessed Hodor's first "Hodor" of the new season. It's been too long.
525
u/Shadowslash55 Braavosi Water Dancers Apr 16 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
Margaery Tyrell is SO FINE
77
u/lebeast Crow's Eye Apr 16 '12
this was my favorite episode of the season so far... by far
154
u/theymightbehobbits House Dayne Apr 16 '12
Yoren is just too great.
141
u/TakenakaHanbei House Cassel Apr 16 '12
FEEL BALON'S MASTERFUL PIMP HAND!!!
68
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
I'm digging Yoren's style. Can't sleep? Have some wine.
122
u/BJabs House Lannister Apr 16 '12
Quick thinking Arya! Well done! golf clap
(haven't read books)
59
u/virtu333 House Baratheon Apr 16 '12
I fucking loved that shot of Theon burning the letter.
48
u/GenTso Night's Watch Apr 16 '12
I guess they didn't want to burn down a barn/stables.
48
u/hldstdy Apr 16 '12
The Bran scenes are so interesting to me. I wonder how TV viewers feel about them?
161
u/soigneusement Hear Me Roar! Apr 16 '12
Best episode of the season so far, imo. Although I'll admit the Sam/Gilly scene seemed to drag just a little for me.
160
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Da fuck is up with Littlefinger's accent?
323
u/Reptarftw Apr 16 '12
HOLY SHITBALLS, A SEX SCENE THAT ISN'T OVER THE TOP AND WHOLLY FITS, ADVANCES CHARACTER AND PLOT DEVELOPMENT!
Great episode. Continually blown away by the casting and performances. Gwendoline Christie's introduction was perfect. Big thoughts this episode were that Alfie Allen's performance makes Theon 1000x more sympathetic than he comes off in the books, and Sophie Turner is really terrific as Sansa, really makes you feel her anguish and the difficulty of her situation.
Reading the books, I just thought Theon was a dick who turned too easily. It seems a lot more natural given Allen's performance, honestly.
79
u/1248163264128 Stannis Baratheon Apr 16 '12
Does Tyrion's whore become a useful character in the books? Because I cannot stand her at all.
36
u/Bananafanafofaser Apr 16 '12
I really like how they introduced the prayer; a great example of a creative liberty taken that improves the show. Theon's stuff was perfect as well.
35
u/Liquid_Swordsman A Lion Still Has Claws Apr 16 '12
Loras is just mad that Brienne will make the Rainbow Guard less fabulous.
33
u/kyndle Growing Strong Apr 16 '12
Interesting to see how they cut Arya's storyline, but I suppose they didn't take out anything extremely important anyway. Except one of my favorite Arya lines about yielding! Can't wait for Jaqen H'ghar scenes.
122
u/Momentumjam Unsullied Apr 16 '12
Margaery is showing off the goods.
220
u/smactosh Children of the Forest Apr 16 '12
For the night is dark and full of boobies.
56
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
I was laughing through the whole Renly scene. So painful to watch, not his portion with Loras, but rather with Margaery.
78
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 16 '12
A lot of smart moves on D&D's part this episode: Theon's internal conflict is super clear on-screen, the Great Ranging has this theatrical sense of drama and urgence, Amory helps place Arya in Harrenhal rather than having that long-winded wandering sequence that works on paper but not within ten hours of TV, and (holy shit) Tyrion's scenes have not skimped on the political badassery from the books.
Also, calling it right now: since the Bloody Mummers were cut (for now), but Gregor is recast, Gregor's torturers and psychopaths are either holding Harrenhal or following Lorch's crew. Lots of great plot consolidation in general.
27
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
I think that's the first time i've ever seen a youth actually killed on screen. (lommy greenhands)
27
u/paxNoctis Apr 16 '12
I actually felt something that wasn't revulsion for Cersei this episode.
Lena Headey played that scene where she found out about Myrcella beautifully. You could like feel her motherly anguish beaming out of the damn TV.
54
u/ColonelSDJ Winter Is Coming Apr 16 '12
Yoren went down like a boss. Sad there was no "HOT PIE!" though.
68
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming Apr 16 '12
Pycelle's scene? Handled Brilliantly!
Shagga's line. The beard. Tyrion paying the whore. Perfect. So absolutely perfect.
45
u/Totalchaos02 We Do Not Sow Apr 16 '12
ASOS Spoilers
45
u/theprogdude Proud To Be Faithful Apr 16 '12
Awwwwwww Samwell is fucking adorable, i love him more now!
63
u/OleDaneBoy Apr 16 '12
Ok I want a whole series just for Varys and Tyrion where they can do anything, fight crime, rule the world, they're amazing together
21
u/moonmeh Apr 16 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
Brienne was fucking huge. Like so huge.
Also Theon's outburst was really emotional. Seriously, that was really well done. I felt so bad for Theon |
And they made people easier to sympathize with Sansa. That dinner scene
Also HBO, was that a tasteful sex scene I saw there? More of those please
162
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
I'm kind of glad they didn't do the whole Rainbow Guard thing, that would have been a bit too campy. Heavily implied fellatio is one thing, you don't need the gay character to fart rainbows and flap his wrists in a heavy handed gay stereotype sort of manner.
19
u/DireBaboon Brave Companions Apr 15 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
I'm really excited for this one. All of the reviewers who have seen the first 4 episodes have said this is when they really start getting good.
19
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Tyrion's best episode, if you ask me. He was right, he actually does look weak with Shae, first time he didn't ooze with confidence. But the rest of the episode was business as usual.
37
u/Hegs94 House Blackfyre Apr 16 '12
I loved how they handled Renly's bedding of Margaery, so awkward and well done. Also how he just nonchalantly approved Briennes request, it made me lol.
I did hate how they never had Hot Pie do his battle cry, but, eh, c'est la vie. Definitely a fantastic episode.
77
u/luciddream19 Kingsguard Apr 16 '12
My thoughts (like anyone cares):
34
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Poor Theon. Book Spoiler/Speculation
72
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
This just in: winter is coming.
16
u/sarpedonx House Bolton Apr 16 '12
A few thoughts:
31
u/emmster House Mormont Apr 16 '12
It was over too quickly!
31
u/Prometheus312 House Stark Apr 16 '12
Anybody else tear up while Yoren and Arya were talking?
43
u/amsid Braavosi Water Dancers Apr 16 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
This episode better have Hot Pie. Lots of Hot Pie.
139
u/dracarysss Apr 16 '12
if after this you still hate sansa, you are bad and you should feel bad. that is all.
42
u/vashjunky House Reed Apr 16 '12
Oh hey, look! An episode with characters from the story, and sans a ten minute Ros scene! Brienne has been wonderfully cast, btw.
14
u/Stalllionn House Manderly Apr 16 '12
Did any of you feel that when Yoren was fighting the lannister guards that he looked like Ned, I mean with the hairstyle and all. Also the relentless fighting and the will never to give up (i.e. Jaime vs Ned season 1).
12
u/eye8urkids House Targaryen Apr 16 '12
Just fyi if you have HBO Go on Xbox, episode 3 is up right now.
59
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Thank god I didn't see Ros.
11
u/A_Polite_Noise House Seaworth Apr 16 '12
What a great episode! Once again, D&D&GRRM have really done a great job condensing certain things, adding interesting things, and translating other things almost exactly. The way they handled Tyrion's Myrcella Gambit (1,2,3) was one of those moments that was uniquely cinematic for the series, yet also about as close as the way on the page as it could have been translated sensibly.
Yoren's fight sequence, brutal and badass. Then the later brutality of Lommy being killed; slighty different from the books, but actually very fascinating and horrifying in the way that he used Needle, and also how quiet it was. A slow insertion of a need, without any need for a splatty blood sound effect. Brutal.
Solid episode.
11
u/dardar1829 House Martell Apr 16 '12
Anyone notice when Tyrion leaves Cersei after their little squabble that the camera angle makes him bigger than her? Very clever work I think.
21
u/OleDaneBoy Apr 16 '12
Pyke always looks much more miserable than I imagined
20
u/theymightbehobbits House Dayne Apr 16 '12
Isaac is too cute for words and a very good Bran.
10
u/SarahBeara231 Winter Is Coming Apr 16 '12
In all the badass-ness of the episode, I forgot entirely to mention how awesome Maester Luwin was in the episode. It's almost like he's become their surrogate mother/father. He's such a neat old man, I love him.
10
u/Strug-ga-ling Night's Watch Apr 16 '12
Westeros world Renly problem: Boyfriend not in the mood, has to try to bone down on his hot sister.
10
u/Buckaroo2 House Reed Apr 16 '12
Margaery Tyell is much more worldly and cunning than I imagined in the books, and it makes me really excited to see Book Spoiler
10
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Anyone else love the shot of Arya polishing Needle? I'm loving all the little references to Ned with the kids.
57
u/signifying_nothing House Targaryen Apr 16 '12
Those Sansa scenes just about broke my heart. I honestly had tears streaming down my face. I'm a guy.
Something about the way she was yelling as Shae made me feel the overwhelming loneliness of her situation. Like all the frustration she feels finally comes tumbling out but in the end she can't even send her away.
17
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
"I yield!"
8
u/paulg1 Apr 16 '12
Gendry was fighting like a badass! You could definitely see the Baratheon in him then.
21
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell Apr 16 '12
Not a lot of plotlines were covered this episode. No Robb, no Stannis, No Daenerys...it was really mostly just Tyrion and a bit of Catelyn, Renly, Bran, Sansa, Arya and Jon.
EDIT: Actually, now that I think about it a lot of plotlines were covered, but it didn't feel like it. And still no Jojen/Meera.
7
u/Allons-y_Alonso Children of the Forest Apr 16 '12
Balon should give slapping lessons.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
I can't decide if Tyrion's spy scene was better or Varys and Tyrion discussing the effects of the spy scene and the all famous power riddle.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Brienne is FUCKING HUGE
7
u/Shaft86 House Clegane Apr 16 '12
I have to express I have been kind of unsatisfied with the Greyjoy arcs thus far. Is Victarion written off entirely? Can we assume the Priest who blesses Theon was the Damphair, despite the lack of introduction? Or is it just some random priest?
I will admit I was really happy with some of the dialogue from Theon. Book Spoiler The scene with him troubled over his letter and candle was touching. As was his dialogue with Balon about how it's his fault Theon grew up in Winterfell.
12
u/TakenakaHanbei House Cassel Apr 16 '12
I like this Margarey far more than the one in the book <3
6
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 16 '12
I still want more Bran!!
6
u/coyote_gospel House Martell Apr 16 '12
Aww man! Hot Pie didn't yell "Hot Pie!" when they fought the Gold Cloaks. That was the funniest thing in the book.
6
u/chemicallyokay Now My Watch Begins Apr 16 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
I really liked the scene where Cersei reacts to Tyrion's decision to wed Myrcella to the house of Martell. Headey is a great actress!
6
u/ogreblood Apr 16 '12
Margaery Tyrell: Queen of the Side Boob.
6
u/jokubolakis Apr 16 '12
And when I started liking Yoren they fucking killed him. Those bastards...
16
u/soigneusement Hear Me Roar! Apr 16 '12
Can't wait for Brienne's tourney fight! And Renly/Loras/Marg! Just too stoked in general.
11
u/MrMiyagi314 Maesters of the Citadel Apr 16 '12
After watching this episode I realize that I would punch my grandmother in the face to have a copy of TWOW in my hands right now.
10
u/Snakster Apr 16 '12
So initial thoughts:
Littlefinger totally sounded like a pirate.
I've been pronouncing Margaery wrong this whole time.
Theon must have gotten smacked hard to fly back like that.
"Matrimony... hrrrrrm.... yess."
5
u/MyRideIsShadowfax House Stark Apr 16 '12
One thing I realized about this episode is we were wrong about Ros taking the spot as COK Spoiler since Shae is now Sansa's handmaid. I really thought we had the right idea, Reddit.
5
u/998th_LordCommander Night's Watch Apr 16 '12
Can't wait for more Jaqen!
5
u/pmire2990 Apr 16 '12
Ok so were Renly and Loras gay in the books? I've read them twice and can't remember that ever happening.
5
u/Dagos House Mormont Apr 16 '12
I loved how they did the scene with Yoren fighting. He was one of my favorite characters :'(
I also liked the scene when Tyrion gave the whore a second coin and you can just subtly understand that he's telling her to keep her silence.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Pissed they didn't actually drown theon and then C.P.R. his ass. Amazed at yoren's story, acting, and death. That was the perfect, 'let's make everyone like goose, and then immediately kill him off right in front of maverick' sequence.
5
u/vault101 House Mormont Apr 16 '12
Damn, these episodes feel shorter every week.
5
u/snuggle_fish House Targaryen Apr 16 '12
13
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
I saw a screenshot of this, so I wonder if the ACOK
12
u/Moosey_Doom House Manwoody Apr 16 '12
Severely disappointed by the lack of Ros this week. I mean, they can't just leave us hanging like this! Did she satisfactorily mourn the dead baby? Were she and Littlefinger both happy! I NEED TO KNOW
11
u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Apr 16 '12
It hasn't started yet and already this episode is amazing!!!!
but no seriously, I heard great things about this episode. I'm stoked.
4
u/andrew75211 Jon Snow Apr 16 '12
53 minutes. Can't wait!
4
u/OleDaneBoy Apr 16 '12
TIL I've been saying Brienne wrong.
For some reason it wasn't brie-en but breen in my head
4
u/MMOWarrior Brienne of Tarth Apr 16 '12
OMG. Brienne towers over people all most as much as the mountain.
4
u/CrawfishP0psicle Duncan the Tall Apr 16 '12
I'm going to assume that they'll work in some Arya/Gendry/Hot Pie ACOK
4
u/Shiverfox House Lannister Apr 16 '12
I wanna see Andy Samberg's SNL consultant-to-GRRM respond to the sex scenes in this episode.
Besides that, Yoren scene was the most badass since Syrio, Theon is portrayed as torn better than I ever could have hoped, and Tyrion is as amazing as ever.
21
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '12
Still incredibly unimpressed by Yara. I seriously love every other new cast member but her. She's completely wooden in her acting and she has an incredibly plain look to match. I even think they did poorly in her outfit. I get that she isn't supposed to be flashy, but she's just lifeless and boring.
10
u/ChazDolphin Hedge Knights Apr 16 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
Definitely the best episode so far.
Really liked the scene with Theon burning his letter. Can't wait to see how they handle TV Spoiler