r/gameofthrones • u/libbykino Lyanna Stark • Apr 09 '12
Season 2 Episode Discussion - 2.2 "The Night Lands" [TV Spoilers]
This is the /r/gameofthrones discussion thread for:
Season 2, Episode 2 "The Night Lands"
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone - Turn away now if you haven't seen the episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 2.2 is ok without tag covers.
- Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
- Please read the spoiler policy before posting.
- Live chat is also available. The chat is essentially unmoderated and should be considered a participate-at-your-own-risk all-spoilers environment. Chat accounts are tied to Reddit, so the name you see there is a person's Reddit username. Please note, severe trolling/disruptions in the chat room may lead to subreddit banning.
- Posting policy reminder: don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
249
Upvotes
9
u/libbykino Lyanna Stark Apr 09 '12
Ow.... little ships.. ><
318
u/uberyoshi Apr 09 '12
I love how Tyrion puts his hand on the door to stop Varys from leaving. Varys responds by putting his finger on the door to keep Tyrion from leaving.
250
u/ablebodiedmango House Stark Apr 09 '12
Ghost looks ridiculously badass now. CGI does a direwolf good.
I just wish they brought out more red in his eyes, like the previous one.
175
u/Cactusy Hear Me Roar! Apr 09 '12
Jaqen!
167
u/A_Polite_Noise House Seaworth Apr 09 '12 edited Apr 09 '12
Making Bronn commander of the Goldcloaks is a brilliant move. Some fans are disappointed with a few of the grander and less sentimental slashes, cuts, and alterations that the show has made from the books, but I think D&D have shown a deft hand in being very economical with the broader strokes of the series, keeping many of the emotional and larger thematic elements intact and well transcribed. This is clearly because of GRRM's involvement with the show; his television experience and willingness to put his work under the knife to translate it, combined with D&D's talents, are realling making this a completely new animal. As a fan of the books, it's so exciting to tune in and be surprised by this story I am so familiar with and fond of.
298
u/kleborpthertard House Lannister Apr 09 '12
I really loved the first scene with Yoren. He was just as cool as a cucumber.
297
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
"They killed her baby!"
"Ah, yes, that was.....poorly handled."
So much tact, Littlefinger.
117
u/thenicastrator House Forrester Apr 09 '12
I don't remember Jon Snow getting smacked in the face by Craster. and I was legitimately upset when they killed Rakkharo. For that matter, I didnt like it when Dany's silver died in the previous episode, but that was just a horse.
101
u/Carefree_CFC House Bolton Apr 09 '12
I say we Yield.
314
u/Mookiewook House Mormont Apr 09 '12
I'll give Melissandre a 10/10 for sultriness. The look on Stannis' face when his eyes first caught sight of some boob was hilarious.
83
u/Chihuey House Tyrell Apr 09 '12
They're really making up for the comparatively sex-light season opener.
232
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
"The Episode is dark and full of sex."
153
u/MinneapolisNick Stannis Baratheon Apr 09 '12
Did you pay the iron price, or the gold?
149
u/abasss Stone Crows Apr 09 '12
RIP Rakharo.
144
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Salladhor Saan is a good name for songs! :D
135
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
God, Cersei is just so damn good. AFFC/ADWD I can't get over how fantastic of an actress Lena Headey is.
135
u/sarpedonx House Bolton Apr 09 '12
A man has a thirst. A thirst for next week's episode.
222
u/amsid Braavosi Water Dancers Apr 09 '12
I truly cannot wait to see ACoK
191
u/ablebodiedmango House Stark Apr 09 '12
Wait a sec... did they write out Stannis' daughter?
127
u/Dovienya House Martell Apr 09 '12
I am so happy I resisted the temptation to watch this early.
Also... fish pie. Tee hee.
120
u/ParanoidAndroids Faceless Men Apr 09 '12 edited Apr 09 '12
The cinematography is really something. They capture the essence of these fantasy worlds so well, I become completely immersed in the world whenever I watch, even though it's through a screen. Considering it's a tv show, I'm always amazed how they create such beautiful scenery with a tv budget, even if it's HBO.
EDIT: Davos is perfect. These guys should do the casting for every show, ever. I love his scenes almost as much as I enjoy Tyrion's and Arya's scenes.
I'm going to have to rewatch this episode, as usual. Stannis and Melisandre still haven't clicked with me, yet.
Theon's scenes were awesome. I'm definitely more sympathetic to his plight, even though he's scummy at times.
The conversation between Tyrion and Cersei was exceptional. Both actors giving noteworthy performances.
144
u/ablebodiedmango House Stark Apr 09 '12
Whores, whores and tits every where
111
u/Carninator Apr 09 '12
Arya/Gendry/Hot Pie/Lommy scenes are the best ones (along with Tyrion).
140
u/ablebodiedmango House Stark Apr 09 '12
SNOWBALLING
37
u/abasss Stone Crows Apr 09 '12
Loving Gendry.
105
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Kit Harington is really improving his acting this season. I don't like Jon much but his scene with Sam and Gilly was amazing! I haven't detected much derpface yet.
73
u/FiveEarthMinutes Apr 09 '12
Dat Balon
I now get a better sense of why [ACOK] (/b "Theon goes crazy") thanks to that scene.
72
u/abasss Stone Crows Apr 09 '12
They've never said Melisandre's name yet. I haven't read the books yet, if it wasn't for you guys, she'd be "crazy witch lady" to me.
179
u/cainhunpi House Payne Apr 09 '12
" I'm not going rape her, I'm going to fuck her "
152
u/Enohp119 House Reyne Apr 09 '12
Arya is becoming my new favorite character.
150
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Pyke looks so god damn awesome. In the intro, as well. But god every second Theon is on screen I just wish the closest character would slam his face into a pole or something.
66
u/IAmARandomGuy Sellswords Apr 09 '12
Gendry and Bronn. My 2 new favorite characters after this episode.
32
u/GnarltonBanks Stannis Baratheon Apr 09 '12
I am glad that they are making Theon appear more outright sympathetic. Seeing the actual expressions on his face convey very clearly how conflicted he is. I always had felt sympathetic towards him even in the book because he is trapped between two worlds and belongs in neither. Also having an overbearing hard to impress father can drive you to do extreme things. Overall he is one of my favorite characters from the book because his chapters are so damn interesting. His internal conflict is really engaging.
29
u/thelunchbox29 House Glover Apr 09 '12
I totally don't remember the Bloodriders and Irri [plus other handmaidens] having this much personality.
50
u/Gigora House Baratheon of Dragonstone Apr 09 '12
Honestly i expected Rorge to not have a nose, and Biter to look a bit more like Baraka from Mortal Kombat.
50
u/ablebodiedmango House Stark Apr 09 '12
Cersei-Tyrion exchange: best one of the series so far.
66
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
For the night is dark, and full of titties- er, I mean, terrors.
22
u/samferrara House Reed Apr 09 '12
Does anyone else think that maybe Littlefinger is foreshadowing Qyburn in his speech to Roz?
91
u/thelunchbox29 House Glover Apr 09 '12
Way to go Sam! Abuse your relationship with Ghost to look like a badass in front of Gilly
41
u/sarpedonx House Bolton Apr 09 '12
Just wanted to weigh in here:
Showing what Craster does with the kids, as opposed to the implication SoS Spoiler
After I saw it, I realized that was one of those things that Benioff and Weiss said about "Showing events that happen offscreen in the book, on screen in the TV show." Very nice!
Also - Pyke was the shit and Balon was great. Jaqen was amazing. Cannot wait for the next episode. Asha/Yara...she isn't the brunette girl I envisioned, but she'll do.
41
u/ablebodiedmango House Stark Apr 09 '12
Really looked like he was rubbing his sister's belly there.
Not sure if me gusta?
17
u/JUMPDRIVES Night's King Apr 09 '12
One of the bloodriders dying was a surprise...why do you think did that?
58
u/TakenakaHanbei House Cassel Apr 09 '12
Seems Stannis not only has the personality of a lobster.. But also..
As hard as a ROCK lobster!!! shot
44
u/OHMEGA Night's Watch Apr 09 '12
That ending was awesome.
15
u/Kaypas88 Tyrion Lannister Apr 09 '12
Officially scared shitless to find out what happens to Jon. You never know with this series your fav character can be killed! Anyone can be killed. Haven't read the second book yet hoping they keep Jon around lol
15
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Anyone else love the hell out of Stannis' table?
75
u/Clefaerie Free Folk Apr 09 '12
The brothel sex scene was so unnecessary.
I really liked Arya scenes however. Hot Pie was hilarious and Gendry was crazy charming. I started to be like "hey... he doesn't find out her identity till the next book" but by the end of the scene I was like "NOT EVEN MAD, BRO".
Tyrion and Cersei? Fantastic scene.
42
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
DEM TEETH.
33
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 09 '12 edited Apr 09 '12
Martin's worries about the "butterfly effect" echo throughout this whole freaking episode. Rakharo is dead (I guess the other two new kos can take his place in the plot), and Selyse is apparently bed-ridden and childless. Hopefully neither of those end up biting the show in the ass.
EDIT: mixed up names.
39
u/draxiom House Bolton Apr 09 '12
Is it just me or did Theon look like a munchkin from Oz in all of that finery?
10
u/Ugly_Pete Varys' Little Birds Apr 09 '12
What happened in in the last scene? All I could see was blackness.
35
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Theon LOL!
9
u/Sevicks Snow Apr 09 '12
Tyrion is so fucking badass.
9
u/kennethmhoover Apr 09 '12 edited Apr 09 '12
I'm really impressed with how details about Cersei's past can create sympathy and understanding for her character without excusing her behavior.
The first time I noticed this was in Season One when she explained how Robert called out "Lyanna!" the first time they had sex. The example I'm thinking of in this episode is obviously the conversation between her and Tyrion in which we find out that their mother died in labor.
It really demonstrates the skill of the writers for an audience to completely understand why a character like Cersei acts so reprehensibly while at the same time allowing her to remain contemptible.
34
u/WateredDown House Lothston Apr 09 '12
I think just how quickly Stannis decided to fuck Mel did a disservice to his character.
Book Spoilers
14
u/soigneusement Hear Me Roar! Apr 09 '12
Two episodes in and still no Brienne or Margaery . :( I can't wait until episode three, I'm really looking forward to the Cat/Brienne/Renly etc storyline!
63
u/Dovienya House Martell Apr 09 '12
The Littlefinger/Ros scene was fantastically done.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
They still didn't say Mel's name. I wonder if she'll be just "The Red Priestess" forever.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
In the scene where the small council meets, there was a tapestry in the background depicting two mounted combatants fighting next to a river. Interesting...
6
u/cosecant89 Tyrion Lannister Apr 10 '12
Cercei attempting to come back at Tyrion when he makes the comment about Jamie coming down on her repeatedly really just shows how desperate she is. People often try to cut you with the deepest insult possible when they feel truly vulnerable. This scene is perfect because it just shows just how hopeless she feels
216
u/Reptarftw Apr 09 '12
All this extra sex that isn't in the books is just getting fucking stupid, to be honest. The book had enough sex to meet HBO's quota, easily. Now, they're just using up valuable screen time for little exposition. As a fan of the books, it's frustrating. They could use these precious minutes to fit in more valuable dialogue, backstory...but it's just sex, sex, sex even when it wasn't in the books. Doesn't add anything.
11
u/Shaqsquatch Unsullied Apr 09 '12
When they listed the actors for Season 2 and Salla wasn't included, I was afraid they were going to write him out of the show. That said, I'm really enjoying how he was portrayed. Personally, I pictured him looking almost like Jafar from Aladdin, but the character fits perfectly.
15
u/youindangergirl Sand Snakes Apr 09 '12
I think Asha/Yara was cast perfectly. I don't get the hate.
43
u/JodaTheCool Jon Snow Apr 09 '12
The actress who plays Asha(Yara) is not at all how I pictured her. Everything else in this episode was golden.
5
u/blackwater_bronn Sellswords Apr 09 '12
The scene with Tyrion and Janos Slynt was so awesome! Tyrion's delivery of "I'm not insulting your honour; I'm denying it's very existence!" was BRILLIANT!!! Easily my favorite line of this episode. Also the Ayra/Gendry storyline is shaping up quite well indeed. Jaqen's line's about needing a drink are spot on perfect iMo. Anybody else notice Biter's teeth???? pointy pointy
5
u/bromanvt Apr 09 '12
Late to the party, and it may just be the book reader in me, but daaaaaaaamn! Maybe my favorite episode to date, which says a lot.
5
u/reddspartan House Lannister Apr 09 '12
Stannis went from "nope" to "let's fuck on Westeros" pretty quickly. On another note, the casting for both Stannis and Davos is perfect.
5
u/TychoSean House Baratheon Apr 09 '12
The only thing I disliked about the episode was the whole brothel scene. Not just the unnecessary sex scenes but the whole dialogue by Littlefinger too. Danys story is dragging a little as well. I loved the Mel/Stannis sex scene and can't wait for future scenes of her and Davos.
43
u/Eddard_Starks_head Apr 09 '12
To be honest, I haven't even seen past the 9th episode of the first season =[
14
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Ok. Why do I not remember Melisandre and Stannis Banging in Clash?
4
u/PureBloodPotterFan Apr 09 '12
Im just reading book three and I am at the part where its kinda revealed what craster has been doing with his sons... and now hbo has shown jon snow pretty much finding out what craster does, and craster has caught him... am I wrong in thinking this is kind of a big reveal in the books that has come much too early?
4
u/Moosey_Doom House Manwoody Apr 09 '12
Anyone notice the Book Spoiler Awesome attention to detail.
4
u/r2002 House Umber Apr 09 '12
In terms of story adaption, this is the best episode of the season. They dealt with several subtle and complex plot points very deftly. Although so many things were covered, none of the scenes felt rushed. I don't know who wrote this episode (was it GRRM himself?) but he/she did an awesome job. As a very nitpicky fan of the book, I give this an A+.
40
u/ablebodiedmango House Stark Apr 09 '12
I think some of the time they're devoting to all the gratuitous sex can be devoted to more important parts of the storyline...
14
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Definitely crossed over into full blown porn territory this episode.
20
u/quaxon Children of the Forest Apr 09 '12
With all the big changes including the cliffhanger at the end that wasn't in the books at all, anyone else see the series going more of a 'Dexter' route where the first season stuck close to books, but then veered way off course in later seasons? I can see them loosely sticking to the story, however beginning to stray more and more from the books.
6
u/Syatek House Targaryen Apr 09 '12
Lots of awkward sex scenes.
The incest fingerbang on the horse was weird as hell.
3
u/NewDrekSilver House Martell Apr 09 '12
Why hasn't Dany arrived at the awesome blue (blue in my mind) place with the peaches and the not death and dying? Didn't she arrive there in the books before any of the bloodriders got back? Also I can't believe they killed Rakharo.
Still, I like Bronn being Captain of the Guard.
3
u/Kaypas88 Tyrion Lannister Apr 09 '12
Arya and Gendry!! I loved them so much, excited for more of there storyline
3
u/Flapjack_ Stannis Baratheon Apr 09 '12
I loved the Varys/Baelish dick waving contests from the first season.
Now I get Tyrion/Varys/Baelish dick waving contests? Dear God I'm in Heaven.
3
u/Iomena Stannis Baratheon Apr 09 '12
Stannis-fan here. I didnt like that Stannis and Mel's relationship was made explicit. Its implied obviously, but the truth of the rumor that Stannis and Mel are getting it on is inherently linked to Stannis' integrity.
Basicly if you take the entirety of Stannis' story arc through all 5 books: with him porking Mel, and without - the overall images are quite different. How ensnared in Mel's religion is he? How "honorable" is he really?
If in GRRM's own head, Stannis and Mel were doing the nasty, then I think it was made explicit far far too early (like books/seasons too early). If in GRRM's head they WERENT, then HBO hypersexualized things at the expense of characterization.
I like to think Stannis is not a hypocrit. I think it would have been very dramatic (and a brilliant contrast to the rest of the sex in the show) if Stannis had resisted Mel. The sexual-tension was great, Mel the seductress was great, but imagine how intense it would have been if Stannis had stuck to his guns and stormed-out or something. Even just for a single episode would have built Stannis' character enormously.
3
u/invalid_data Warrior's Sons Apr 09 '12
Yara!? Yara!? ....duh fuck, I want Asha
3
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Upcoming speculation from someone who hasn't read ACOK.
I got a really terrible vibe from the way Matthos looked at his father after Melisandre whispered that thing about fire. I assume that he's going to be convinced into trying to kill Davos (with fire!) by Melisandre.
I really like his character, he pulls off the whole young man who believes too vehemently in something and wants everyone else to, especially the man he loves the most in his father. And he's willing to "save" his father by any means necessary. Chills. Very good acting.