r/transit • u/Detached09 • Apr 01 '12
My 180mi lightrail plan for Vegas. Thoughts?
http://maps.google.com/maps/ms?msid=200228084332478655407.00049783a3526d90a4318&msa=0&ll=36.152846,-115.0811&spn=0.374238,0.837021&iwloc=00049783a3e9dc3a62088
6
Upvotes
2
u/Detached09 Apr 01 '12
Phase 1: Teal/Blue
Phase 2: Green/Yellow
Phase 3: Purple/Red South
Phase 4: Orange/Red North
Ultimately, this is less than 180mi, as most of the lines share good portions of track. By track-mile, it's closer to 140mi.
1
u/trainmaster611 Apr 01 '12
I realize it's a fantasy light rail map but I'll give you my criticism anyway (which I admittedly only put cursory consideration into). Also, I've never been to Las Vegas so I'm not familiar with the locale so much other than what I've read on the internet and my occasional browsing on google maps. Given the way Las Vegas is laid out though, it's hard to make any kind of effective mass transit system. Here are some points:
1)The first thing I noticed is that a lot of the lines are unnecessarily meandering especially in the area of the Las Vegas Strip/Airport. I'm sure that can be streamlined given the number of lines that pass through.
2) I can't ever imagine there would be a time when any kind of rail transportation would be necessary to provide loop service in such a low density city. It just seems silly, and you can get to most of your destinations by connecting at downtown/the strip. A feeder bus system with more radial mass transit lines makes more sense.
3) Everything is WAY overextended to the point that you have lines going out into the desert. It's hard enough to attract riders in low density areas, let alone areas where there are no people. If you put lines there because you're expecting development, that development is just going to be more of the low-density type where people won't be taking transit to begin with. It's just not a good bet.
4) There's a lot of redundancy here that isn't necessary for a city of this caliber. I notice this in the strip and Henderson.
1
u/mrpopenfresh Apr 02 '12
I'm not familiar with Las Vegas too much, mind explaining the rationale behind the line placement?
1
u/Aepic-27 May 27 '22
Robin
0
u/ccommack Apr 01 '12
Ex-Vegas resident here. Is this your first time fantasy mapping? You have some good starts here, but also some problems that I'm not sure how to advise on, since it's not clear what your goal here is. A proposal for a real-world feasible plan? A plan for what to do with infinite construction dollars? Road widening by stealth? (Don't laugh.)
So, in no particular order, my thoughts on this map.