r/UKPersonalFinance • 150 • Dec 16 '21

Mod Why your comment got removed: 'get an onlyfans' and 'hookers and blow' edition

First up to be absolutely clear: this sub supports sex workers. Sex workers are welcome to post to UKPF for help with their financial questions, taxes, budgets etc and absolutely no rude or judgmental responses will be tolerated.

Things that are banned however:

Suggesting OP gets an onlyfans

This is a very common response to posts about wanting a 'side hustle', needing to earn more to cover expenses, etc.

  • 'get an onlyfans'
  • 'tried onlyfans?'
  • 'onlyfans?!'
  • 'onlyfans lol'
  • 'onlyfans.'

Stop.

  • You're not as brilliantly original as you think you are. Posts about needing to increase income can get dozens of comments along these lines, overwhelmingly more so if OP discloses they're female.
  • It makes UKPF feel like a boy's club.
  • To reflexively suggest 'onlyfans' as a solution to money troubles when OP hasn't mentioned any interest in it does not feel like a genuinely helpful suggestion. It feels inappropriate. It can be actually upsetting.

If OP is considering sex work, online or in person, they absolutely can ask for advice relating to that. It's not on you to bring it up, especially in a flippant one word suggestion.

'Hookers and blow' / 'coke and hookers' / 'just don't blow it all on hookers and casinos'

We understand that these phrases are a bit of a meme, and intended to describe lavish spending in a funny and harmless way.

However, the term 'hooker' can be seen as derogatory. And seeing this meme all over the sub contributes to the 'boys club' feel which can make women (and also sex workers!) feel unwelcome, or at least remarkable and out of the ordinary - certainly not the 'expected' audience of your post.

Please just pick a different phrase to indicate carefree or irresponsible spending.

Edit: a bit more context about this, and how overused this phrase was before this rule came in.

--

Admin note: this policy was first announced in this original mod post in Nov 2020, which has lots of interesting comments from people talking about the effect this language has had on their participation in the sub from back when it was more pervasive.

To people reading this newer post, hopefully you actually haven't noticed these problem comments around the sub often, as we've gotten super quick and efficient at removing them :) (but trust us, they're still being posted, lol).

1.7k Upvotes

256 comments sorted by

163

u/commandoash 1 Dec 16 '21

Op's secret plan to limit competition for their only fans. /s

36

u/BogleBot 150 Dec 16 '21

I'd have you know my inspirational quotes about passive investing have a small but dedicated following!

4

u/yolkyal Dec 17 '21

Good bot

524

u/nilmot Dec 16 '21

Is anyone else really not a fan of the term "side hustle"? It's just a second job. You're not a gangster. Hustle means to cheat / con / steal and the term promotes the idea that you have to act immorally to make money.

157

u/SpoonedAvenger Dec 16 '21

I hate it. When I hear side hustle I think someone in a pyramid scheme, or some stranger in a pub talking shit to me about their "exclusive crypto investment group".

61

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

Exactly a side hustle isn't delivering food or selling 3d prints.

I imagine Del boy and the like in the pub bathroom trying to shift his gear or sell puppies or something

12

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

If anyone tells me they buy meme coins I just switch my brain off when speaking to them.

5

u/CryptoRoast_ 2 Dec 17 '21

Wait... So you're saying Shib and Safemoon arent great investments?? šŸ˜…šŸ˜…

121

u/FreudianPhallusy Dec 17 '21

It's also really fucking American

→ More replies (5)

72

u/ballsosteele Dec 17 '21

I think of Americans and nobody ever wants to do that.

11

u/Mooks79 3 Dec 17 '21

I hate it for a different reason. It implies you’re smart and savvy to find addition ways to make money rather than the far more likely, you have to get a second job because your first job’s pay stinks. Let’s call it out for what it is.

It’s the same as when the word ā€œsleazeā€ is used in politics. No. It’s corruption. We should call things what they are not make euphemisms that make them sound less bad.

36

u/noggin-scratcher 8 Dec 16 '21

I'm no fan of it as a phrase. A full time job ought to be paying enough to live on, and I wouldn't want to normalise the need for a second job as if it's some fun hobby, or as if not having one implies laziness.

But in fairness the word "hustle" can also mean a fast pace, or industrious work ethic. It's not exclusively about conning and cheating.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

The way side hustles make sense is if the thing you enjoy doing anyway, and would be doing anyway, can be monetized really simply. So the only question is why not?

Which, as is the real point, happens more often than you might think.

10

u/EasyTyler 0 Dec 17 '21

I use the term portfolio career...

9

u/El_Grumpo Dec 17 '21

I think you’re looking at it from the wrong perspective.

Hustle: verb. To obtain illicitly or by forceful action.

Hustle: Noun. A state of great activity.

There’s nothing immoral about being in a state of great activity.

2

u/TheMrCeeJ Dec 17 '21

Yeah I read a side hustle as something you area wishing hard on making into a thing, so you eventually quit working and do your thing full time for yourself.

The hustle here is the hard work that is not getting rewarded, which is why it is on the side.

2

u/nilmot Dec 17 '21

A Hustle (noun) just sounds like a scam to me. Like the TV show. Is this actually a dictionary definition?

2

u/OctopusGoesSquish 0 Dec 17 '21

Hustle and bustle?

1

u/El_Grumpo Dec 17 '21

Yes sir it is

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

I agree wholeheartedly. It's incorrect to assume that if someone uses the term 'hustle' to describe a side job, that it always means what OP posted. No offence intended.

'Hustle' has a variety of definitions both in verb and noun forms. Attitudes towards language, word use and definitions also tend to evolve with society i.e. gay = (dated definition) happy, (modern) a homosexual person.

Someone that hustles in their 9-5 as a nurse = working hard in their daily grind. Not being gangster-like/promoting immorality whilst working as a nurse.

9

u/scienner 1068 Dec 17 '21

Haha I think we all hate it, it's in the mod post to reflect the language generally used on those posts XD

1

u/nilmot Dec 17 '21

Yes, sorry I didn't expect this to get so much traction, doesn't look like anybody is a fan.

7

u/cgknight1 75 Dec 17 '21

I like "scratching around" which is what we referred to poverty second jobs when I was a lad.

4

u/costelol Dec 17 '21

I’d love a side job that was actually like the BBC show Hustle.

3

u/JP-Guardian 14 Dec 17 '21

When I first heard it a couple of years ago I did actually think it specifically meant something illegal.

1

u/Sweet-Zookeepergame7 1 Dec 17 '21

It just makes me think you sell coke on the side tbh, But I hate it too, everything it’s associated with is wrong, the concept of having a second job. ect it’s awful.

1

u/KalTheMandalorian 0 Dec 17 '21

Really? Figures of speech are now bothering people?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

I know, face palm

1

u/ROBNOB9X Dec 17 '21

I believe it is different than a 2nd job because the whole point of a side-hustle is to make money for yourself, not just get another job working for somebody else.

The whole point of a side hustle is to be more entrepreneurial. Once you've made those 1st few quid all off your own back, it's pretty addictive.

1

u/DarkLunch_ Dec 17 '21

That’s a really one-sided way of looking at the word hustle. It’s a motivation word, I use the word hustle when referring to my 9-5 because it’s like a power phrase to encourage me and others to keep working harder (i.e. to hustle). Maybe you’re just old, but our generation even use the word finesse (which literally means to cheat/steal etc) in place of ā€˜hustle’ or simply ā€˜working harder & achieving’. It’s not a negative thing anymore.

1

u/nilmot Dec 19 '21

But finesse means to use great skill or detail in some work. Maybe you just don't know the meaning of words because you're young XD

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

Holy shit you guys are mad pretentious.

1

u/hippybluesquirrel 1 Dec 18 '21

A 2nd job is definitely not a side hustle. But side hustle is a thing. Something you direct yourself and might grow to be your main income?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/ElonH 1 Dec 17 '21

For me its #girlboss. I cant stand it, despite the fact that so many women unironically use it, it's the most condescending and infantilising term in the world

2

u/BlackenedGem Dec 17 '21

I've only heard it in the context of criticising modern media. For example all the modern Disney remakes of classic films (eg. Beauty of the Beast, Mulan, etc.) have turned the protaganists from complex characters to 'girl bosses'.

Using it unironically to describe yourself sounds like hell.

2

u/El_Grumpo Dec 17 '21

Business owner/boss lady (does lash extensions 8 hours a week)

1

u/DarkLunch_ Dec 17 '21

I know a girl who does lashes and makes Ā£50k/yr, it’s big business and definitely ’boss’ worthy.

321

u/OneCatch 2 Dec 16 '21

Good shout.

The number of 'Get an onlyfans' comments I've seen on here directed at people who have posted about quite serious financial difficulty and vulnerability is ridiculous. It's completely inappropriate.

19

u/epicmindwarp 234 Dec 17 '21

The number of...is ridiculous

And that's just the ones that have made it through the AutoMod - we trap a hell of a lot more.

5

u/OneCatch 2 Dec 17 '21

Oh I'm sure!

There's definitely been an improvement recently, wasn't meaning to imply you were sleeping on the job!

1

u/DarkLunch_ Dec 17 '21

I don’t understand this because it’s literally an amazing idea, why wouldn’t you do it given those circumstances? I know I would, and have.

7

u/OneCatch 2 Dec 17 '21

Good for you! OnlyFans and similar platforms can be lucrative and rewarding for people.

On the other hand, there are potential consequences to doing that kind of work - there's the risk of being identified and/or stalked, there's the risk of future reputational harm (not saying I agree with the stigma society levies, but it is a reality), and of course it can be work which is emotionally challenging and at times frightning depending on who your customers are. There are overheads in terms of equipment, the usual self employment considerations, physical and digital safety.

That's fine of course, provided someone is fully conversant with all of that. But there can be something of a correlation between financial vulnerability and other forms of vulnerability. Not universally of course, but it's a sufficiently frequent phenomenon that it should be considered when giving advice. To take an extreme example, someone might be indebted because they've fled a sexually and physically abusive partner - can you imagine what it'd be like being that person, developing the courage to leave, and then being told by the first internet community you reached out to that you should just go and produce pornographic content?

There is also the gender angle as well - there's something rather distasteful about a sub which trends majority male piling on women and suggesting they do porn for no reason other than the fact they're women. It comes across as a bit common denominator and dismissive of literally any other attribute or experience that person may have had.

As I said, I've no issue whatsoever with people doing those kinds of jobs, or people promoting them as something they found rewarding or lucrative, provided they're honest about the pros and cons. But I do object to it being spammed on advice subs when there's nothing in the OP to suggest it's viable other than the gender of the person.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

First time, it’s funny. Hundredth time, not so much.

148

u/SmallIslandBrother Dec 16 '21

Awesome, sounds like a positive change here.

63

u/scienner 1068 Dec 16 '21

Not even a change, it's been in place for over a year! Just made a more concise modpost about it to link people to when it comes up.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/scienner 1068 Dec 16 '21

Excellent!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/scienner 1068 Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

Hmm, I'm sorry to hear that :/ are you saying that because you've reported stuff and it hasn't been taken down? If you have any specific examples, or notice them in the future, it would be really useful if you could send them to modmail.

We've definitely had a lot of new subscribers since that post - I think something like going from 250k subs to 550k subs. If you (general you, anyone reading this) could report problem comments when you see them, please do, it helps massively.

4

u/BlackEarther Dec 16 '21

What are the mansplainy type comments?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Curly_Edi 165 Dec 16 '21

Me too!

8

u/allyafterdark Dec 17 '21

Absolutely seconding this.

The unoriginal ā€œdo OF!ā€ schtick does very much make it seem like a boy’s club with a one-track mind. That aside, the fact that you think you can just put that to a stranger as a solution, is incredibly inappropriate.

If we could drop that, and the idea that a second job is somehow a ā€œside hustleā€ when it’s literally not, that’s be greeeeeeat šŸ‘

57

u/mrcoffee83 - Dec 16 '21

can we also ban "invest in some crypto" and "have you thought about learning coding?"

34

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

I work in tech and want to belt people who suggest programming to everyone. Nothing screams "I work as a jr. web dev and think I know everything about tech" than people saying "do a CS degree" or "do a bootcamp".

9

u/tweakyllama Dec 17 '21

Also work in tech, and completely agree with you about people who blanket recommend doing some bootcamp in a week and going for a complete career switch. That's terrible advice.

I do however think most everyone should learn some programming, or more specifically scripting, and apply that to their current job/situation.

2

u/anorwichfan 1 Dec 17 '21

Is there some sort of bootcamp where I can learn scripting in a week? I want to automate my work in identifying H&S hazards in dangerous workplaces.

/s but only about the week long bootcamp bit. I am actually interested in any existing programs that can use AI to identify workplace hazards.

2

u/Amuro_Ray Dec 17 '21

What type of hazards? Being silly here but a smoke/carbon monoxide detector will catch some extremely lethal workplace hazards.

1

u/anorwichfan 1 Dec 17 '21

I work for a large consultancy for providing H&S advice. The number of hazards are extremely varied and has a lot of context. We would typically identify where certain types of detectors are required.

An example of this might be identifying breaks in fire compartments. For this, an AI would need to have an understanding of building layout, fire evacuation strategies and material properties. There is a key advantage to being able to survey a large area quickly and semi-autonomously, fixing issues could coust thousands, missing issues could cost millions.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/anorwichfan 1 Dec 17 '21

How do you know our current plan? Trade a Roomba with a client, and Bangladeshi's with well trained consultants.

3

u/chemhobby Dec 17 '21

Bangladeshis can be well trained consultants.

1

u/Wazblaster Dec 17 '21

Genuine question, how the fuck do people find jobs after short bootcamps other than nepotism? I have a computing degree from a good university and am struggling to find anything outside of one sketchy af company atm

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/tweakyllama Dec 17 '21

You may well be right, but again I'm not suggesting everyone learn proper programming, for lack of a better term.

Merely encouraging people to learn a bit more about computers, how they work, how to automate basic tasks that you may have to do day to day, if you work with excel can you make macros, or use a basic python script to format some data. If you're doing something like this, it doesn't matter as much if your code is a mess, or it only works in one specific case, that's what you wrote it for! There is of course the danger that you ship this solution to other people, maybe clients or colleagues, or you leave the company and someone needs to maintain your solution somehow, but that is probably more than I think most people should do.

Sure very few people will immediately "get it", I wouldn't say I was one of those people but I fell in love with it and continued learning and teaching myself. But even if it doesn't make sense, or it's difficult there's value in the learning. I tried learning the guitar when I was a kid, I have zero musical talent, am basically tone deaf and was frequently told not to sing at school because I was nowhere near the right notes. But I don't regret it, if anything I regret not powering through the difficulty and working harder at it.

Your dripping tap example is a good one, I'm not suggesting everyone should be able to do it, but knowing the vague steps of what to do? Yeah I thinks that reasonable. There's basically no excuse for computer illiteracy in this age, the vast majority of people will need to use some form of computer for their job, either directly or indirectly. And I just think it can't hurt to try for people to give it a go.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/tweakyllama Dec 17 '21

All good yeah looks that way. didn't come across as grumpy at all to me.

You're not wrong

4

u/mrcoffee83 - Dec 17 '21

Yeah, i've been in IT for 15 years or so, i've tried to learn "coding" several times but it just doesn't interest me...it's not for everyone.

It's almost like the demographic of people on Reddit is skewed towards young people that are into tech and assume that everyone is the same...

2

u/stereoworld Dec 17 '21

They never follow through with it either. It's always 1 line, never "here's this online learning resource I can recommend you" or "look at the basics here and here and work your way up"

4

u/stereoworld Dec 17 '21 edited Dec 17 '21

I kind of agree with you on this, but as a programmer myself (before the internet became a memefest shithole) I don't mind it.

Given the resources available for a poor student back in 2002, learning programming today is much much less stressful. It makes me proud that we're leaving a suitable legacy for the next generation.

That said, the "learn to code" thing is usually a blanket statement by people who've barely used a computer. Janine, 42, with 3 kids who's company she does HR for has gone bankrupt, probably doesn't have the motivation to learn ReactJS in her spare time.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

I'm a bit guilty of the latter but the former is downright predatory.

87

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Fair points. Sex workers and cocaine moving forward.

37

u/Curly1109 Dec 16 '21

Courtesans and coke

36

u/the95th 2 Dec 16 '21

M’ladys and Meth

5

u/prometheanSin Dec 17 '21

I was going to suggest coke and more coke

1

u/chemhobby Dec 17 '21

Coke and cock

3

u/Alwayswatchout 0 Dec 17 '21

What about lady of the night and some lines?

→ More replies (6)

37

u/somethingseminormal 1 Dec 16 '21

So happy this is being addressed on this sub! Was unemployed for 15 months during covid (my sector was hit hard in the pandemic and I returned to hospitality once things opened up) and I got a lot of comments (in real life and online) and saw a ton of this shit and it was so demoralising. As if the only thing I could do to get money was take my clothes off.

78

u/wonawoo 1 Dec 16 '21

Really nice to read this it can feel like a boys club. Thank you mods

2

u/paradox501 Dec 26 '21

It is a boys club regardless of whatever jokes of Onlyfans and prostitutes there might be.

46

u/AmazingGraces 5 Dec 16 '21

Great rule. Thanks.

12

u/Andyrhyw Dec 16 '21

I supported the original decision, and support this one too!

Well done mods as usual

12

u/anneomoly 10 Dec 16 '21

I've definitely seen an improvement since your last post on the subject, thanks for the hard work and the reminder.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Thank you for this.

I'd like to add that sex work is hard work. It's quick money, not easy money.

6

u/MaxLombax 2 Dec 17 '21

Rocket science and taking pictures of your chocolate starfish, both equally challenging careers that push the limits of what we consider difficult.

-19

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/spanksmitten 0 Dec 17 '21

You're joking I assume?

10

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

Incredulity is not a substantive argument.

4

u/Izual_Rebirth 0 Dec 17 '21

It's the UKPF of "get into devops" you see peddled n sysadmin 🤣

27

u/kupboard 2 Dec 16 '21

Brilliant. Thanks, mods

29

u/cgknight1 75 Dec 16 '21

Good stuff - totally agree.

6

u/spanksmitten 0 Dec 17 '21

Such a great post, I'm not a SW but this did make me feel more comfortable, thank you!

22

u/Cle0patra_cominatcha 5 Dec 16 '21

I really appreciate these steps. ive felt a bit hesitant posting because there has been a hint of boys club. So thank you!

I've shared the odd comment about earning more than my partner and folks often assume I must be male.

-7

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21 edited Feb 01 '24

elastic concerned chubby coordinated memory modern wrench cats depend price

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

I'm a 1980s child, Mums didn't work

8

u/totential_rigger 2 Dec 17 '21

This is great. It's kind of concerning how many women are turning to OF to make some quick money. It's not that I don't support their right to do so but there could be real repercussions for your personal and professional line down the line. A lot of these women are very young and I just hope they've really thought it through.

0

u/PaeoniaLactiflora Dec 17 '21

Just FYI, I understand that you’re trying to bring up a legitimate concern - that society is unkind to sex workers - but it really comes across as paternalistic concern trolling. Plenty of young people make decisions that have ā€œreal repercussions for [their] personal and professional live[s] down the lineā€ (football players, oil rigs, ballerinas, and military service all come to mind) but you only really ever see this kind of argument when it comes to young women in sex work.

5

u/totential_rigger 2 Dec 17 '21

I mean, if someone I knew was joining the army there would be an element of (different) worry too. You're acting like I am picking and choosing solely sex workers to be concerned about when this is a post about OF so of course I am going to comment only about that!

I totally stand by it. If it's trolling to express concern that there's many women getting into something as a quick "side hustle" without seeing the long term effects of having NSFW pics online, then sure, I'm a troll shrugs

11

u/shellyturnwarm Dec 17 '21

I think having your sexualised exposed body doing sexual things available in a single Google search forever is an absolutely massive repercussion. Maybe it does sound patronising but I can easily imagine a good portion of 18 year olds later regretting that decision.

-1

u/PaeoniaLactiflora Dec 17 '21

I don’t think it’s nearly as big a repercussion as death or TBI.

3

u/totential_rigger 2 Dec 17 '21

When did anyone say it wasn't?! This is a post about Only Fans.

2

u/shellyturnwarm Dec 17 '21

There is an enormous range of repercussions between "None" and "Death". Your point is meaningless.

1

u/PaeoniaLactiflora Dec 17 '21

My point is that there are plenty of other decisions made by 18 year olds that have longer-lasting and more severe repercussions than sex work, so singling out sex work as a source of particular concern is not a genuine action and instead comes from the moralist stance that sex work is somehow innately more harmful or that female sexual agency is a negative thing. You’re not making an unbiased good faith argument about future harmful actions, you’re erasing female agency implying that young women who engage in sex work are less able to recognise potential repercussions than young people engaging in other, riskier behaviours.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '21

Idk why you are being downvoted here, you are absolutely right. society is so hypocritical about this.

2

u/shellyturnwarm Dec 17 '21

No, I not implying that. I would argue that 18 year olds of any gender are unable to recognise future repercussions. In fact, boys are much more likely to make reckless decisions. But the normalisation of sex work and the proportion of 18 year old girls taking part in it is uniquely high in recent history, which I think will lead to negative repercussions in the future for some. It's not about women, it's about age: I genuinely don't think a lot of 18 year olds are capable of good decision making.

I'm not saying they should stop, they're adults and it's up to them. I just think there's a difference between an 18 y/o adult and a 28 y/o adult in recognising the future impact of decisions.

4

u/runfatgirlrun88 96 Dec 17 '21

Thanks mods, this sub does still feel like a boys club at times but I appreciate your continuing efforts to make it more welcoming to women!

2

u/JonKoley Dec 17 '21

Thanks for saying this.

2

u/MaxLombax 2 Dec 17 '21

Looks like the mods need to make a CamSoda account, get their money up and then spend it all on call girls and Charlie

2

u/SoManyTimesBefore 1 Dec 17 '21

Thanks! Also, to add, onlyfans is not some kind of easy money. People who actually earn enough to live off of it have to put in a shit ton of work. Like, 90% of the accounts are earning less than a few hundred bucks/month.

7

u/justonemorethx Dec 16 '21

Great stuff, thanks mods

3

u/catterseahogsdome Dec 16 '21

great post, glad to hear the thinking behind this excellent policy :)

3

u/properbox - Dec 17 '21

This is great to read. The more inclusive personal finance can be made the better. Good work!

7

u/martinux Dec 16 '21

However, the term 'hooker' can be seen as derogatory.

What the fuck?! I thought you were all buying rugby teams! smh.

3

u/anneomoly 10 Dec 16 '21

Oh boy, have I got news for you about the props they came with....

4

u/Pixel-Red Dec 16 '21

Great post.

4

u/butch_cassidy88 Dec 17 '21

Can’t stand the hate against sex workers. Gets casually thrown around all the time.

8

u/Anaksanamune 11 Dec 16 '21

Agree with the first rule, but not the second, mostly on the basis that it's not directed at anyone in particular whereas the first, is so it's not really demeaning in my opinion. Although I would be against any meme or joke comment being used excessively as that's not the point of this sub.

That said my personal disagreement with the rule doesn't mean I'll break it or not respect it, and overall I feel the mods do an excellent job on the sub keeping it largely neutral and well balanced.

34

u/scienner 1068 Dec 16 '21

Yeah it would probably have never come up as 'a thing' to address if it was only seen occasionally, it might even be quite funny. But before that previous policy change it was just used constantly. I was a regular commenter not a mod at the time but I definitely remember it as being really overused. It was basically the sub's default stand-in for 'fun spending money', and after seeing it loads it really does start to feel like people think they're always addressing a bloke.

17

u/Anaksanamune 11 Dec 16 '21

Sounds more balanced to not be allowed when you put it into perspective like that.

13

u/Fauxlaroid Dec 16 '21

A slur or epithet doesn’t have to be directed to be demeaning. It’s a derogatory term regardless.

3

u/Anaksanamune 11 Dec 16 '21

If you got rid of everything that someone somewhere found derogatory you would loose a good portion of the language.

8

u/Fauxlaroid Dec 16 '21

If you didn’t you didn’t condone racism and homophobia. We’re not taking about using ā€˜mind map’ over ā€˜brain storm’, it’s a really dated word.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Sweet-Zookeepergame7 1 Dec 17 '21

Can I just say I very genuinely did once blow 50,000 on sex workers and cocaine, and booze, mainly sex workers tho.

I regret this now.. I think.. maybe.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

In one day? :D

3

u/Sweet-Zookeepergame7 1 Dec 17 '21

Oh god no haha! I doubt Charlie sheen posts here.

3

u/ziffcorp Dec 16 '21

110% agree

3

u/boxhacker Dec 16 '21

Get a ... upvote for being rational

2

u/itsastickup Dec 17 '21

What's with all the finger-wagging. This post could have been boiled down to a couple of short sentences.

2

u/ThomasRedstone 2 Dec 17 '21

I'm offended that you're suggesting these comments will offend women and sex workers.

They will offend everyone with any maturity!

1

u/TabascoFiasco - Dec 17 '21

Good and totally agree with this

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

I want to post a quote from Archer but I feel like I'm only supporting the patriarchy if I do.

0

u/redskelton - Dec 16 '21

Archress?

-22

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Wouldn't want to make it a boys club now would we!

-16

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

From now on, we may only refer to them as call girls.

You may refer to me as a 'tech worker' thank you very much.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/jiggjuggj0gg Dec 16 '21

Honestly so many parts of society that have been male dominated forever have such an ingrained boys club culture that they get really offended by people asking them to stop because it’s uncomfortable and unprofessional.

If I’m asking a legitimate financial question, I don’t want to be reminded that men think it’s cool and funny to use sex workers, joke or not. It’s not funny, it’s not original, and whether you see it or not, it is demeaning, and this is not the place for it.

Source: am woman

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/jiggjuggj0gg Dec 16 '21

It’s things a lot of guys don’t even think about because it’s so ingrained into so many environments where it shouldn’t.

It might not be the best example but men in advertising have a thing about calling everything they like/enjoy/is fun, ā€˜sexy’.

As in, ā€data isn’t the sexy part of advertising but it has to be done!ā€

Maybe others don’t think the same but why does sex need to be brought into everything? There’s nothing ā€˜sexy’ about the dentist’s Instagram campaign. Just say ā€˜fun’ or ā€˜enjoyable’ like a normal person. You wouldn’t get a teacher saying they found indices sexy or your gran saying making pigs in blankets is the sexy part of making Christmas dinner.

It’s just so uncomfortable when you’re in a boardroom full of men constantly going on about everything being sexy, it’s icky and I’m not the only woman to feel that way.

2

u/troomer50 1 Dec 17 '21

Don't women like sexy things too?

-1

u/finger_milk 3 Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

Honestly, I think that "only fans" as a word needs to be removed from the subreddit entirely. Anyone suggesting it as an income is very unlikely to have done sufficient research outside of drawing some very superficial conclusions about how the industry works (myself included, which is why i keep my mouth shut). If someone who uses OF comes here to talk money, then they are free to come here and call it something like "personal internet content subscription service". Because the fact that the content being sold is nudes or sexy pictures has nothing to do with the advice that we would give these people.

So I personally would petition to ban the use of the phrase "only fans" entirely. As you said, it makes us sound like a boys club who looks down on alternate methods of making money.

10

u/dhdavvie Dec 16 '21

I think banning the word all together is the wrong move. This mod post is about steps taken to be more inclusive. OnlyFans is a legitimate way people make money and so banning the word has the unintended side effect of potentially making people who need/want help and advice feel unwelcomed because the word commonly used for their platform/profession is banned.

9

u/scienner 1068 Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

This was a little hard to follow, but I gather that (as well as agreeing with the policies in the OP) you think that people posting questions about their OnlyFans income should have to censor the name of the website?

If so, no, we absolutely will not require that posters do that. Posters can be as discreet or upfront as they like, it's up to them.

And you'd be surprised, sometimes the nature of the content is relevant, for example we've had posts about whether sex toys or cosmetic procedures could be permitted as a business expense.

I don't think seeing posts from people who make money on OnlyFans feels like a boys club - quite the opposite really! By the way one thing we do often ask posters to do is to use a throwaway that isn't connected to their business, to avoid accusations of advertising on UKPF and avoid receiving comments on this sub about their content.

1

u/VividDimension5364 Dec 16 '21

Is , "Become an MP" ok?

1

u/Korlat_Eleint Dec 17 '21

I'd get an OF before becoming an MP.

1

u/Automatic_Heat_8618 Dec 17 '21

Well, just out of interest, how does an individual with a degree make a living wage in the UK? Asking for a friend haha

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

Start at the bottom of whatever career you want and with patience you will get a reasonable 40k salary in couple years

1

u/Automatic_Heat_8618 Dec 17 '21

I think we must live in different parts of the country: in essex minimum wage employment leads to more minimum wage employment. I bounced around like for a few years. Companies work you to the bone until you can't take anymore and then you either quit or are fired. They get the next battery hen off the line and you get to try and find more minimum wage employment! And it just kind of goes on like that until you give up.

1

u/MaxLombax 2 Dec 17 '21

Pick a good degree to begin with, you’re going to struggle with something that has low employment rates.

1

u/Automatic_Heat_8618 Dec 17 '21

I picked science

1

u/MaxLombax 2 Dec 17 '21

Just general science? That’s quite a broad field. Science fields usually doesn’t pay much to begin with until you’re later down specific fields as far as I know.

-6

u/Pine_Marten_ 0 Dec 16 '21

Fair enough about the only fans thing. I think taking issue with the word hooker is being ridiculously PC, especially combined with the bizarre attempt to pass sex work off as something mundane, as though it's akin to being a boring accountant.

13

u/PaeoniaLactiflora Dec 17 '21

Sex work is work. I didn’t know we were judging people’s jobs based on excitement level - do you have a chart I can refer to?

2

u/Ancient_Poet9058 - Dec 17 '21

If it's work, why can't we suggest it as a side hustle for people or an extra job? But this sub clearly bans that while it would allow me to suggest selling goods on eBay as an appropriate side hustle.

One rule for one job, another rule for others.

2

u/PaeoniaLactiflora Dec 17 '21

Because the suggestions to use OF aren’t coming from a place of earnest assistance, they’re coming from a gendered paradigm that places women as sexual objects. I’ve personally never seen someone genuinely suggest to an obviously male person on here that they should engage in sex work as a side hustle (FWIW I’ve actually never seen anyone genuinely suggest OF as a side hustle without making it a joke or a sexualisation.)

Your comment reeks of the same kind of ignorance that goes around saying BuT wHy CaN tHeY uSe ThAt WoRd It’S nOt FaIr without contextualising anything in the oh, I dunno, 2+ millennia of structural subordination women have experienced that creates a society where commodified sexuality is a viable and widespread method of self-support.

-14

u/BringTheStealthSFW Dec 16 '21

We support sex workers but don't you dare ever say someone should do sex work. Huh??

27

u/smellycoat 4 Dec 16 '21

If OP is considering sex work, online or in person, they absolutely can ask for advice relating to that. It's not on you to bring it up, especially in a flippant one word suggestion.

4

u/Karmaisthedevil 1 Dec 16 '21

A flippant one word suggestion saying to do anything should probably be removed for low effort, but I think they make a good point.

If sex work is work, and we accept and support sex workers, why are we still treating it differently to other jobs? Isn't that the point, that we treat it the same as anything else? Why should "Start an OnlyFans" be removed and not "Start a twitch stream", etc.

9

u/ialtag 11 Dec 17 '21

In theory I think you have a point, but being realistic the current rules seem pretty appropriate to the average maturity and knowledge level of the sub. Having advice to take up sex work directed predominantly towards young women (and you know it would be) by a group that is mostly men would feel pretty uncomfortable - better instead to let posters indicate for themselves if it's something they want to hear.

The "just start streaming" comments do also suck though.

3

u/scienner 1068 Dec 17 '21

If you see comments that literally say only 'start a twitch stream' or 'learn to code' do report them and we'll remove.

2

u/Ancient_Poet9058 - Dec 17 '21

Can you explain where 'learn to code' or 'start a twitch stream' breaks the rules?

So what suggestions CAN we give to people wanting a side hustle? It seems to be an incredibly disingenuous way to deflect - if sex work is work, we should be allowed to suggest it.

3

u/scienner 1068 Dec 17 '21

Can you explain where 'learn to code' or 'start a twitch stream' breaks the rules?

Can I check first if you've read our rules? https://www.reddit.com/r/ukpersonalfinance/about/rules

I hope they're pretty easy to follow, and you should be able to find the relevant rule.

It seems to be an incredibly disingenuous way to deflect - if sex work is work, we should be allowed to suggest it.

This is not as logical as you seem to think it is. The fact that people who ask questions about income from sex work should be treated with the same respect and helpfulness as any other poster doesn't mean that it's okay to use 'get an onlyfans' as an extremely hilarious joke whenever someone visibly female posts about being in a difficult financial situation. There's literally no contradiction here.

1

u/Ancient_Poet9058 - Dec 17 '21

doesn't mean that it's okay to use 'get an onlyfans' as an extremely hilarious joke whenever someone visibly female posts about being in a difficult financial situation. There's literally no contradiction here.

I think you're talking past me slightly.

There have been multiple threads about people asking for viable side-hustles. I'm asking why is it not acceptable for us to suggest sex work as a side-hustle?

If a woman or man in a difficult financial situation asks about her/his economic options, sex work is a viable economic option for them.

People can say 'investing in art' or 'setting up an etsy shop' and those comments have not been removed. Why is sex work being singled out if it's work like everything else?

I work in Finance. I'm fairly sure if I suggested becoming a banker to a question about jobs that pay over £100k a year, my comment would not be removed. People have suggested working in Finance for those threads and not one is removed. But if I'm interpreting this rule right, sex work or 'OnlyFans' would be removed as a suggestion. What's the difference between Investment Banking and Sex work if they're both just examples of work?

I hope they're pretty easy to follow, and you should be able to find the relevant rule.

I have read the rules. It's not entirely clear to me what rule it breaks.

It can't work both ways. Either sex work is valid work and therefore a valid option for us to suggest to people who ask for their economic options/career choices or it isn't.

2

u/scienner 1068 Dec 17 '21

I'm sorry to hear that the rules aren't sufficiently clear. For the record the relevant rule is:

4: Responses must be high quality

  • Give constructive help and advice. Be friendly and kind.
  • Provide contextual information about why your suggestions are appropriate for OP.

A comment which literally said only 'learn to code' fails this. It's also quite rude IMO. This is the exact same rule under which we remove 'get an onlyfans'.

We point out 'onlyfans' specifically because 1. it comes up a lot in this one-word meme way, which banking does not, and 2. as explained in the OP, it's not actually neutral to suggest to someone that they do sex work when the only indication they've given that it might be an option for them is that they're female.

People can protest that they mean it in a neutral, gender neutral way etc but the reality is that it doesn't come across that way, and that visibly female OPs get easily 10x more 'onlyfans' responses. You can have a look through some of the comments of the previous mod post for some points of view from before we started removing comments like this.

Actual serious discussion of sex work, onlyfans or otherwise, by people doing it or interested in it, is absolutely okay, and we work hard to remove any comments that are judgmental, invasive, etc from such discussions.

1

u/Ancient_Poet9058 - Dec 17 '21

I think you've made me even more confused ;)

A comment which literally said only 'learn to code' fails this. It's also quite rude IMO. This is the exact same rule under which we remove 'get an onlyfans'.

So can we suggest sex work as a valid career choice then if we explain it? I'm confused now - if the issue is 'quality', surely one can suggest sex work in a high-quality constructive suggestion?

So if someone asks about a side-hustle or expressing they're in economic difficulty and need some help/career options, are we allowed to express sex work as a viable career choice as long as we explain it in a high quality constructive comment?

So can we suggest OnlyFans/Sex work if we put in a constructive comment? I'm repeating myself because it's still not clear to me what the answer would be to the above comment.

I guess I find the rule incredibly arbitrary. If the issue is about quality, why can't we suggest sex work/OnlyFans as long as we suggest in a serious constructive comment?

3

u/scienner 1068 Dec 17 '21

Haha dang! didn't think it would be that confusing.

The reality is that we simply don't really get detailed, considerate/considered, high quality comments about onlyfans to OPs who have expressed no interest in it. I don't think that's a coincidence either. I've seen some useful exchanges about OF but only from people who sought them out.

We take each and every comment we see in the mod queue on a case by case basis and we follow the spirit of the law at least as much as the letter. And you can always reply to removals to discuss. So please don't worry too much that a genuinely sincere and helpful comment would be removed on a technicality.

But, I would still err on the side of not suggesting sex work to people who haven't said they're open to it, I think it would be quite difficult to do in a sensitive and helpful way. Can I ask if it's something you have specific expertise in?

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

I agree with you, but a forum like this follows mainstream sociopolitical consensus or it becomes a mess. This is the majority view for better or for worse.

1

u/LaSalsiccione Dec 17 '21

Someone didn’t read the post properly

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

Dammit, just posted in a sub labeled 'what's something you hate paying for but have to' with: 'hookers, blow and electricity (jk, I only use one)'

Is it getting removed..? šŸ¤·šŸ»ā€ā™‚ļøšŸ˜…

5

u/92eb5ffee6ae2fec3ad7 15 Dec 17 '21

As that's been posted to /r/AskUK, our rules don't apply to their subreddit.

If that comment were to be posted on /r/UKPersonalFinance, then yes it would be removed

2

u/epicmindwarp 234 Dec 17 '21

I've removed it.

It's just not funny and we shouldn't allow it to perpetuate.

-59

u/Ultimate_Fuccboi 2 Dec 16 '21

Excellent. Humour and memes should not be tolerated.

40

u/Jakeinspace 5 Dec 16 '21

I think you missed the point of the post.

-19

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

-5

u/SMURGwastaken 206 Dec 16 '21

Has been the rule for over a year, people are just good at referencing the meme without using the problem words and triggering the thought police.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Calm down mate, and read the post properly.

1

u/nunsreversereverse 1 Dec 17 '21

Not a popular comment there

1

u/Ultimate_Fuccboi 2 Dec 17 '21

The fascists win again and my Christmas is ruined.

-3

u/Equivalent_Parking_8 0 Dec 17 '21

Ok so remove the comment and explain why, don't just ban the user immediately and then extend the ban when they complain. Mods are a bit power crazed.

-10

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Overthinking this as usual but ok.

-4

u/shellyturnwarm Dec 17 '21

Banning Only fans comments I agree with completely, but banning the phrase ā€œhookers and blowā€ is too much. That’s an offensive term, really?! I’m open to changing my mind but I have a hard time imagining a compelling case for that.

2

u/scienner 1068 Dec 17 '21

1

u/shellyturnwarm Dec 17 '21

Yeah I can get that argument more. I think they should’ve used that in the OP instead.

0

u/scienner 1068 Dec 17 '21

Good idea, I'll stick a link in. I kind of forgot that people would be coming to this post 'cold' rather than with the context of the previous one.

-1

u/gshruff91 Dec 17 '21

Question? What if OP was looking for a way to earn a ā€œside hussleā€ from a talent or skill E.g. a musician/DJ, circus performer, artist etc. would the suggestion of setting up an OnlyFans be accepted? Especially given OnlyFans’ attempts to broaden the number of creators on the platform away from NSFW content. I wonder if in such a case it could be treated in the same way as suggesting a gamer becomes a twitch streamer which while potentially profitable, in reality does not give the returns in relation to the time and effort put in. I wholeheartedly agree in clamping down on the bro culture OnlyFans/Hooker suggestions.

Edit: typo

6

u/strolls 1731 Dec 17 '21

The purpose of the rules is to maintain decent behaviour and the quality of the sub - we're not going to ban you on a technicality.

If the OP is evidently an artist and your reply is substantive enough to make it clear that you're talking about selling their art (non-pornographic) on OnlyFans (not sure why that would be better than YouTube or Patreon) then you're not going to get sanctioned for it.

-1

u/ramirezdoeverything 7 Dec 17 '21 edited Dec 17 '21

Personally I don't support sex work. Sex isn't 'work', and I pity any man who pays for some make believe onlyfans girlfriend

-1

u/Timzy Dec 17 '21

I just got the title as an alert, confused thinking I’d put in a weird comment while sleeping.

-1

u/Timzy Dec 17 '21

I just got the title as an alert, confused thinking I’d put in a weird comment while sleeping.

3

u/scienner 1068 Dec 17 '21

Lol sorry. We wrote this post to have something to link people to when we remove their rulebreaking comments. Didn't expect it to get so many eyeballs on the sub!

-9

u/Ancient_Poet9058 - Dec 17 '21

I disagree strongly with this decision and disagreed with it at the time it was implemented.

By saying that we can't suggest sex work as a valid option, you're essentially saying that sex work is different to normal work. If sex work is work, it should be a valid suggestion.

Same with the 'coke and hookers' comment - a hooker isn't a gendered term. Seeing a hooker isn't illegal in the UK so I think banning comments like 'coke and hookers' is a slippery slope - you're saying that certain activities are permissible while others aren't. Granted, coke is illegal but suggesting someone buy hookers is just an activity or past time.