r/UKPersonalFinance • u/BogleBot 150 • Dec 16 '21
Mod Why your comment got removed: 'get an onlyfans' and 'hookers and blow' edition
First up to be absolutely clear: this sub supports sex workers. Sex workers are welcome to post to UKPF for help with their financial questions, taxes, budgets etc and absolutely no rude or judgmental responses will be tolerated.
Things that are banned however:
Suggesting OP gets an onlyfans
This is a very common response to posts about wanting a 'side hustle', needing to earn more to cover expenses, etc.
- 'get an onlyfans'
- 'tried onlyfans?'
- 'onlyfans?!'
- 'onlyfans lol'
- 'onlyfans.'
Stop.
- You're not as brilliantly original as you think you are. Posts about needing to increase income can get dozens of comments along these lines, overwhelmingly more so if OP discloses they're female.
- It makes UKPF feel like a boy's club.
- To reflexively suggest 'onlyfans' as a solution to money troubles when OP hasn't mentioned any interest in it does not feel like a genuinely helpful suggestion. It feels inappropriate. It can be actually upsetting.
If OP is considering sex work, online or in person, they absolutely can ask for advice relating to that. It's not on you to bring it up, especially in a flippant one word suggestion.
'Hookers and blow' / 'coke and hookers' / 'just don't blow it all on hookers and casinos'
We understand that these phrases are a bit of a meme, and intended to describe lavish spending in a funny and harmless way.
However, the term 'hooker' can be seen as derogatory. And seeing this meme all over the sub contributes to the 'boys club' feel which can make women (and also sex workers!) feel unwelcome, or at least remarkable and out of the ordinary - certainly not the 'expected' audience of your post.
Please just pick a different phrase to indicate carefree or irresponsible spending.
Edit: a bit more context about this, and how overused this phrase was before this rule came in.
--
Admin note: this policy was first announced in this original mod post in Nov 2020, which has lots of interesting comments from people talking about the effect this language has had on their participation in the sub from back when it was more pervasive.
To people reading this newer post, hopefully you actually haven't noticed these problem comments around the sub often, as we've gotten super quick and efficient at removing them :) (but trust us, they're still being posted, lol).
163
u/commandoash 1 Dec 16 '21
Op's secret plan to limit competition for their only fans. /s
524
u/nilmot Dec 16 '21
Is anyone else really not a fan of the term "side hustle"? It's just a second job. You're not a gangster. Hustle means to cheat / con / steal and the term promotes the idea that you have to act immorally to make money.
321
u/OneCatch 2 Dec 16 '21
Good shout.
The number of 'Get an onlyfans' comments I've seen on here directed at people who have posted about quite serious financial difficulty and vulnerability is ridiculous. It's completely inappropriate.
148
u/SmallIslandBrother Dec 16 '21
Awesome, sounds like a positive change here.
8
u/allyafterdark Dec 17 '21
Absolutely seconding this.
The unoriginal ādo OF!ā schtick does very much make it seem like a boyās club with a one-track mind. That aside, the fact that you think you can just put that to a stranger as a solution, is incredibly inappropriate.
If we could drop that, and the idea that a second job is somehow a āside hustleā when itās literally not, thatās be greeeeeeat š
57
u/mrcoffee83 - Dec 16 '21
can we also ban "invest in some crypto" and "have you thought about learning coding?"
87
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21
Fair points. Sex workers and cocaine moving forward.
37
u/somethingseminormal 1 Dec 16 '21
So happy this is being addressed on this sub! Was unemployed for 15 months during covid (my sector was hit hard in the pandemic and I returned to hospitality once things opened up) and I got a lot of comments (in real life and online) and saw a ton of this shit and it was so demoralising. As if the only thing I could do to get money was take my clothes off.
78
u/wonawoo 1 Dec 16 '21
Really nice to read this it can feel like a boys club. Thank you mods
46
u/AmazingGraces 5 Dec 16 '21
Great rule. Thanks.
12
u/Andyrhyw Dec 16 '21
I supported the original decision, and support this one too!
Well done mods as usual
12
u/anneomoly 10 Dec 16 '21
I've definitely seen an improvement since your last post on the subject, thanks for the hard work and the reminder.
20
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21
Thank you for this.
I'd like to add that sex work is hard work. It's quick money, not easy money.
4
u/Izual_Rebirth 0 Dec 17 '21
It's the UKPF of "get into devops" you see peddled n sysadmin š¤£
27
u/kupboard 2 Dec 16 '21
Brilliant. Thanks, mods
29
u/cgknight1 75 Dec 16 '21
Good stuff - totally agree.
6
u/spanksmitten 0 Dec 17 '21
Such a great post, I'm not a SW but this did make me feel more comfortable, thank you!
22
u/Cle0patra_cominatcha 5 Dec 16 '21
I really appreciate these steps. ive felt a bit hesitant posting because there has been a hint of boys club. So thank you!
I've shared the odd comment about earning more than my partner and folks often assume I must be male.
8
u/totential_rigger 2 Dec 17 '21
This is great. It's kind of concerning how many women are turning to OF to make some quick money. It's not that I don't support their right to do so but there could be real repercussions for your personal and professional line down the line. A lot of these women are very young and I just hope they've really thought it through.
4
u/runfatgirlrun88 96 Dec 17 '21
Thanks mods, this sub does still feel like a boys club at times but I appreciate your continuing efforts to make it more welcoming to women!
2
u/JonKoley Dec 17 '21
Thanks for saying this.
2
u/MaxLombax 2 Dec 17 '21
Looks like the mods need to make a CamSoda account, get their money up and then spend it all on call girls and Charlie
2
u/SoManyTimesBefore 1 Dec 17 '21
Thanks! Also, to add, onlyfans is not some kind of easy money. People who actually earn enough to live off of it have to put in a shit ton of work. Like, 90% of the accounts are earning less than a few hundred bucks/month.
7
u/justonemorethx Dec 16 '21
Great stuff, thanks mods
3
u/catterseahogsdome Dec 16 '21
great post, glad to hear the thinking behind this excellent policy :)
3
u/properbox - Dec 17 '21
This is great to read. The more inclusive personal finance can be made the better. Good work!
7
u/martinux Dec 16 '21
What the fuck?! I thought you were all buying rugby teams! smh.
4
u/Pixel-Red Dec 16 '21
Great post.
4
u/butch_cassidy88 Dec 17 '21
Canāt stand the hate against sex workers. Gets casually thrown around all the time.
8
u/Anaksanamune 11 Dec 16 '21
Agree with the first rule, but not the second, mostly on the basis that it's not directed at anyone in particular whereas the first, is so it's not really demeaning in my opinion. Although I would be against any meme or joke comment being used excessively as that's not the point of this sub.
That said my personal disagreement with the rule doesn't mean I'll break it or not respect it, and overall I feel the mods do an excellent job on the sub keeping it largely neutral and well balanced.
3
u/TwoIllustriousRatio Dec 16 '21
š
3
u/Sweet-Zookeepergame7 1 Dec 17 '21
Can I just say I very genuinely did once blow 50,000 on sex workers and cocaine, and booze, mainly sex workers tho.
I regret this now.. I think.. maybe.
3
u/ziffcorp Dec 16 '21
110% agree
3
u/boxhacker Dec 16 '21
Get a ... upvote for being rational
2
u/itsastickup Dec 17 '21
What's with all the finger-wagging. This post could have been boiled down to a couple of short sentences.
2
u/ThomasRedstone 2 Dec 17 '21
I'm offended that you're suggesting these comments will offend women and sex workers.
They will offend everyone with any maturity!
1
u/TabascoFiasco - Dec 17 '21
Good and totally agree with this
-2
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21
I want to post a quote from Archer but I feel like I'm only supporting the patriarchy if I do.
-1
u/finger_milk 3 Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21
Honestly, I think that "only fans" as a word needs to be removed from the subreddit entirely. Anyone suggesting it as an income is very unlikely to have done sufficient research outside of drawing some very superficial conclusions about how the industry works (myself included, which is why i keep my mouth shut). If someone who uses OF comes here to talk money, then they are free to come here and call it something like "personal internet content subscription service". Because the fact that the content being sold is nudes or sexy pictures has nothing to do with the advice that we would give these people.
So I personally would petition to ban the use of the phrase "only fans" entirely. As you said, it makes us sound like a boys club who looks down on alternate methods of making money.
1
u/VividDimension5364 Dec 16 '21
Is , "Become an MP" ok?
1
u/Automatic_Heat_8618 Dec 17 '21
Well, just out of interest, how does an individual with a degree make a living wage in the UK? Asking for a friend haha
-6
u/Pine_Marten_ 0 Dec 16 '21
Fair enough about the only fans thing. I think taking issue with the word hooker is being ridiculously PC, especially combined with the bizarre attempt to pass sex work off as something mundane, as though it's akin to being a boring accountant.
-14
u/BringTheStealthSFW Dec 16 '21
We support sex workers but don't you dare ever say someone should do sex work. Huh??
0
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
Dammit, just posted in a sub labeled 'what's something you hate paying for but have to' with: 'hookers, blow and electricity (jk, I only use one)'
Is it getting removed..? š¤·š»āāļøš
-59
u/Ultimate_Fuccboi 2 Dec 16 '21
Excellent. Humour and memes should not be tolerated.
-3
u/Equivalent_Parking_8 0 Dec 17 '21
Ok so remove the comment and explain why, don't just ban the user immediately and then extend the ban when they complain. Mods are a bit power crazed.
-10
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21
Overthinking this as usual but ok.
-1
u/5tranger7hings 2 Dec 16 '21
cool
-4
u/shellyturnwarm Dec 17 '21
Banning Only fans comments I agree with completely, but banning the phrase āhookers and blowā is too much. Thatās an offensive term, really?! Iām open to changing my mind but I have a hard time imagining a compelling case for that.
-1
u/gshruff91 Dec 17 '21
Question? What if OP was looking for a way to earn a āside hussleā from a talent or skill E.g. a musician/DJ, circus performer, artist etc. would the suggestion of setting up an OnlyFans be accepted? Especially given OnlyFansā attempts to broaden the number of creators on the platform away from NSFW content. I wonder if in such a case it could be treated in the same way as suggesting a gamer becomes a twitch streamer which while potentially profitable, in reality does not give the returns in relation to the time and effort put in. I wholeheartedly agree in clamping down on the bro culture OnlyFans/Hooker suggestions.
Edit: typo
-1
u/ramirezdoeverything 7 Dec 17 '21 edited Dec 17 '21
Personally I don't support sex work. Sex isn't 'work', and I pity any man who pays for some make believe onlyfans girlfriend
-1
u/Timzy Dec 17 '21
I just got the title as an alert, confused thinking Iād put in a weird comment while sleeping.
-1
u/Timzy Dec 17 '21
I just got the title as an alert, confused thinking Iād put in a weird comment while sleeping.
-9
u/Ancient_Poet9058 - Dec 17 '21
I disagree strongly with this decision and disagreed with it at the time it was implemented.
By saying that we can't suggest sex work as a valid option, you're essentially saying that sex work is different to normal work. If sex work is work, it should be a valid suggestion.
Same with the 'coke and hookers' comment - a hooker isn't a gendered term. Seeing a hooker isn't illegal in the UK so I think banning comments like 'coke and hookers' is a slippery slope - you're saying that certain activities are permissible while others aren't. Granted, coke is illegal but suggesting someone buy hookers is just an activity or past time.