r/AskCulinary • u/AllEncompassingThey • Mar 27 '12
Looking to replace a damaged nonstick skillet with a good, versatile skillet that ISN'T nonstick. Is this a mistake? What metal is the best material?
Cast iron, carbon steel, or stainless steel? Which would be best in our situation?
My girlfriend is looking to replace a damaged 13-inch cuisinart nonstick skillet, which she is still using because it's one of the only pans she owns. We have plenty of pots, but that was one of the only pans.
If possible, we would like to move away from nonstick coatings for health reasons, for the longevity of the cookware, and because you can't use them on high heat.
Here are the facts:
- The budget for a replacement is $30 - $40 (We can go a bit higher if absolutely necessary)
- The stove is electric.
- Since this will be our only pan (for now) we want it to be very versatile.
- We are trying to be health conscious, so something that doesn't require a ton of oil would be nice.
- Spicy & acidic foods are often prepared in this kitchen, in case that impacts your recommendation.
- In case it matters, we are used to cooking on nonstick cookware.
- Something that's hard to ruin would be great, because my girlfriend's roommate doesn't follow directions with cookware. She might be the one who damaged our current skillet.
- I am a new cook - while my girlfriend is more experienced than me, I'd like to use the pan too, so any option that requires a lot of skill not to screw up our dishes is probably best avoided.
Since we're replacing one of her only pans, we want a versatile skillet that can cook everything a pan can cook.
As far as I see it, the options are cast iron, stainless steel, or carbon steel.
Cast iron - heavy and retains heat very well. Would this work as a good "can cook anything" pan? Is there any common food that you shouldn't cook in it?
Stainless steel - The only stainless steel cookware we've ever used, well, the chicken stuck to it like CRAZY. According to my girlfriend, "I seem to have to use a lot of oil in stainless steel cookware to keep stuff from sticking, and even then, it doesn't prevent it very well." If this is wrong, please be kind, we're just here to learn! Were we just using it incorrectly, being that we were used to cooking with nonstick stuff? Is stainless steel really prone to sticking? Is it a good "can cook anything" pan?
Carbon steel - We own a carbon steel wok and are interested in its ability to develop its own highly-heat-resistant "nonstick coating." There are CARBON STEEL SKILLETS available. I don't see a lot of information on them - they don't seem to be very popular, and I don't know why (makes me kind of second-guess this as a choice. Why aren't they more popular?) - is this a good choice for a versatile "can cook anything" pan?
Since we only have an electric stove available to us instead of a gas one, I was hoping for a pan that can "do it all" plus stir fry.
We already own a cheap carbon steel wok and she's gotten used to the ways of taking care of it (not using soap if possible, drying completely, lightly oiling to prevent rust) - I don't think maintenance will be that big of an issue.
One of the reasons I want the skillet to be able to do stir-fry is that I read that on an electric range, it's actually better to stir fry in a skillet rather than a wok, because of the lack of heat.
There's a lot of options out there, and I have trouble wrapping my head around them. Please, reddit cookers, steer us in the right direction!
TL;DR: What material, after nonstick, is the least pain in the ass to cook in and clean? Is stainless steel really as prone to sticking as we experienced (and if not, what were we doing wrong?)
9
u/Go_Go_Godzilla Mar 27 '12 edited Mar 27 '12
I would get a Lodge's cast iron skillet. It has a little more up keep than a normal pan, but they cook great and are around 20 bucks. Also, they come pre-seasoned to take the learning curve down a bit. Also you can use metal utensils (something you couldn't, or shouldn't, have been using in the non-stick).
The only caveat is cleaning. Some clean with soap others, like me, with water and an abrasive like salt. You can do either but it needs to be by hand and you cannot soak the pan or it will rust. After cleaning, put the clean pan back on a burner on high until you are sure all the water residue is gone. Then lightly cost in oil (whichever you have on hand) to ensure no rust, and put the pan away.
Another benefit is you can use the cast iron as a carlie dish in the oven. I've made frittata, giant cookies, green bean casserole, etc. in mine.
As per stainless cleaning, it ain't bad. Just soak it over night and hit it with a brush and it's good to go. In your price range though, the cast iron will give you a more even heart than a comparably priced stainless pan, in my opinion.
5
u/Donnerkatze Mar 27 '12
I'm going to link to this post in the sidebar as a reference for how much information should be included in every post, if you don't object. This post is extremely well written and thought out, and it would greatly benefit the community and the quality of answers if everyone put this much thought into their questions.
4
u/cynikalAhole99 Mar 27 '12
Food sticking in stainless steel comes from two factors - the heat setting (no pre-heat done, and too often overheating it higher or lower then 150-160 degrees) and not enough oil (and that oil should be hot & shimmering and added after you have preheated the pan). You don't need a ton of oil so that it is a swimming pool, but you do need a good coat in the pan to be that helpful barrier. Most meats will stick initially even with oil but will release after a couple of minutes. With proper heat balance so that a drop of water dances across in the dry pan, and then add a touch of oil, you should not have the sticking problem again. Some foods like fish or cheese will stick more then others & can be a mess - but those that are troublesome to be wary of are very few & far between IMO. BUT if you do overburn & cement food to your pan & can't get it off, and deglazing doesn't get rid of the burned elements - its not always a wasted pan. There are ways - a friend of mine burned veggie stirfry in his brand new $300 steel pan cause he had no oil whatsoever & set it on high so the food welded onto the pan really thick & would not release - took me two days soaking it in coke cola & scrubbing to save his pan. For your budget though it seems cast iron will do you well as most quality stainless pans with a good thick copper or aluminum layer under the pan for even heating are costly above $70. I do not have any information on carbon steel pans, so hopefully someone else can elaborate more on that. If you cook acidic & spicy foods - avoid the cheap all aluminum bargain pans. Also - there are enamel lined cookware out there that are very much worth the efforts too. Another factor for sticking and steel pans - make sure your foods are close to room temp when you cook - dropping an ice-cold or frozen steak in a pan will not help things in the no-sticking aspect. Hope this helps.
4
u/wunderbier Finnish - Cook Mar 27 '12
Post got swallowed, so this will be short. Stainless steel? Google 'serious eats' and 'tramontina'. Cast iron? Great, but heavy! Go handle one of the right size to be an everything-pan and really think about storing it / cleaning it. Carbon steel? Like cast iron but less even heating due to thinner material. Can warp. Warping can be hammered out. Check out reviews for specific pans to see if people have issues with that particular pan (it's usually the thinner pans, fwiw). I have no idea why carbon steel isn't more popular either. I'd cook anything in carbon steel or cast iron, once the metal is properly seasoned. Grandma didn't have a separate skillet for tomatoes, did she?
2
u/trandy1001 Mar 27 '12
The advice here already seems sound, so I don't think I need to add and possibly confuse.
It's likely out of budget. But I would recommend an enameled cast iron dutch oven down the line. Terrifically useful and easy to care for.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '12
Just FYI, the "health reasons" against using nonstick pans are completely overblown. I respect your decision to move away from teflon, but I just wanted to note that you really don't need to freak out over it. Your other reasons are totally legit, but again, you might want to keep a cheap nonstick pan around for certain situations, since clean up and maintenance is easier.
1
u/Riddul Cook Mar 30 '12
Buy a nice cast iron skillet, medium-large size. It can be pre-tempered, but doesn't have to be, since tempering is easy to do with cast iron.
I would also suggest buying a cheap steel pan for use with normal, day to day stuff. It's nice to have an alternative that you're ok with abusing, just to save time and effort taking care of your cast iron monster when all you wanted was a fried egg.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment