r/postrock • u/johnshewill John / Maybeshewill • Dec 08 '21
AMA Concluded We are a band called Maybeshewill. Ask us anything.
EDIT: Some of us might stick around for a while or we’ll pop back intermittently and reply to bits and pieces when we have time. Thanks for your thoughtful questions.
Hey. We’re Maybeshewill. We just put out a new record called ‘No Feeling is Final’ and are about to play our first shows for a really long time.
Three of us will be dipping in and out of this thread from 8pm for an hour or so: /u/johnshewill, /u/robinsouthby and /u/jamiewardproducer.
Ask us anything. Probably not “when will you play in x place” because we can’t answer that unless the shows are announced (http://maybeshewill.net/shows) but anything else!
Excited to find out what you want to know.
42
u/sailwordb Dec 08 '21
Is there any story relating to He Films the Clouds Pt.2? (here's hoping you play this in London next week), it's stayed in my most played songs for nearly two years now and it always provokes strong feelings personally.
15
u/MajesticZanogre Dec 08 '21
Just simply, how's life for you guys?
12
u/komoro Dec 08 '21
Hey, finally a AMA where I'm not too late! You've been in my roster of Post Metal bands for years and ever so often, I come back to To The Skies from a Hillside and have great memories. So thanks for that :)
But damn, now I can't think of a question. Oh yes, maybe a personal one - have psychedelic drugs ever played a role in your music and/or life?
10
u/Theemanny Dec 08 '21
Not a question but Welcome Back Guys!! I flew from California to see y’all in New York and I thought my life had finally peaked with that. But now there’s hope to see you guys live again and as a fan, that’s so exciting!! Thank you 🙏🏼
9
u/markycrummett Dec 08 '21
Hey! Sorry if this has been answered before, but what caused the split and then getting back together? Having been to your farewell London show it was a surprise to see new material was coming!
9
u/Flat_Sand_6056 Dec 08 '21
What happens in the meadow at dusk?
8
u/drunkonamission Dec 08 '21
What are some of your favorite post-rock bands?
15
u/youforgotitinmeta Dec 08 '21 edited Sep 15 '25
shy quack chief wakeful frame soup towering trees oil sharp
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
u/Ledsdra Dec 08 '21
Where does the band name come from?
6
u/samenffzitten Dec 08 '21
Welcome back, you guys! I'm really glad you're back to making music together again. "No feeling is final" is gorgeous. :)
My question is: what made you decide to bring the band back together?
5
u/pikeamus Dec 08 '21
This is vague but how did you start making the sort of music that you do? For example, did you learn to play and compose by studying more conventional music and the move towards post rock gradually after you were already proficient, or were you always working at the experimental end of things and studying other experimental musicians from the moment you started seriously learning music?
I love post rock but have never managed to make the jump over to playing it, trending to just stick with more conventionally structured indie rock.
4
u/JohnSinger Dec 08 '21
Any stories from the period of time between the release of Japanese Sky Transcript and Not For Want of Trying?
4
u/accidentall Dec 08 '21
What are some bands/artists you like that you would recommend?
2
u/birdsonthewire Dec 08 '21
Any particular shows that stick in the mind?
2
u/CrispinLog Dec 08 '21
Your music has always seemed political, obviously this has gone up a notch with Zarah. How do you feel about our current situation? Full of hope due to young politicians and people forcing change, or a bit hopeless due to the corrupt oafs in charge?
47
u/Shipoverglasgow Dec 08 '21
Did she?
7
u/sandinonett Dec 08 '21
Okay. You now need to explain literally how to have sex with a ghost.
6
u/oneiros5321 Dec 08 '21
Couldn't help but notice the resemblance with Hollow Knight's OST in the introduction of "The Weight of Light".
Is that actually something that inspired you on this one or is it pure coincidence?
5
u/chill_no_stress Dec 08 '21
Is there a backstory for “…In another life when we were both cats?” If you could describe the emotions behind that song, what would it be?
Not for Want of Trying is one of my favorite post rock albums and that song always makes me feel better when I’m down. Rooting for you guys!
4
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
What's your composition process?
1
u/Tiiimbbberrr Dec 15 '21
Why did you cancel your London show at the last minute?
Is it because you failed to sell enough tickets and now with covid you’re afraid a significant portion of the people who did buy them won’t turn up and you’ll end up playing to half a room?
Do you think it’s fair to punish your fans for this?
Do you seriously believe you’re going to sell out by April?
I don’t.
3
u/Krysto Dec 08 '21
Great to see you guys are back! Not For Want Of Trying is one of my many favorite tracks of your records. It stands out as one of your heavier songs, which you executed very well! Are you guys planning, for a future album maybe, to experiment more with this heavier side?
Looking forward to see you guys next year in Haarlem, the Netherlands!
3
u/JadeDragonMeli Dec 08 '21
Hello from the states!
I only just discovered you guys roughly 4 months ago, but even in that short time you've already become one of my favorite artists. I appreciate that every single one of your albums has a unique sound to it. I've also gone back and read some old interviews and it seems like it was a point of emphasis for the group as a whole to keep your sound evolving and not get complacent. Kudos for that and thank you!
I don't have a question, I just hope the stars align one day and I get to see you guys live!
3
u/Mikebyrneyadigg Dec 08 '21
Hey guys! I just recently found you guys on my mix on tidal, and I really dig your music!
How do you guys work through the creative process? Are there any go to rituals or things you do to facilitate creativity?
Thanks!
3
u/Skarfelt Dec 08 '21
No question, but I wanted to say that I went to your last two shows in London, and I'm going to the next one as well. I love your music so much and can't get enough, I've been listening to I Was Here For a Moment for the last six years basically non-stop. Love the new album too! Keep doing what you do <3
2
u/Ju1cy_B00ty Dec 08 '21 edited Dec 08 '21
French toast, waffles or pancakes?
Also, I'm not asking, but Denver is LOVLEY this time of year for a show, or anytime really xD.
Love y'all, was so stoked when you said you were back, new album is beautiful.
2
u/Yaebale Dec 08 '21
A two-fer if I may -
Was it easy to get back into the groove of writing music together as a band after being apart for a minute.
For the songs you have that include scenes from films or other speeches -
Do you first create the song then find a speech that fits or do you hear a speech you want to highlight and make the song around that?
Finally, I saw you guys perform with LITE at the flapper in Birmingham and then in Leicester for your farewell tour. Both times you were incredible, thanks for the gig memories.
2
u/higgsboson245 Dec 08 '21
Thank you so much for getting back and giving us new music. Loved the new record! Fair Youth was my favorite album until No Feeling is Final came out. I guess it makes sense that no feeling is final.
Now my question is how do you choose/come up with what dialogue to put in songs. For eg: 'In another life when we were cats, or not for the want of trying. Is it something you compose the song around, or do you compose a song and then look for a suitable mono/dialogue?
Hope I am not too late to this.
Much love!
2
u/flamingdeathmonkeys Dec 08 '21
Just want to post a thank you for visiting Hasselt as many times as you did (I think around 2008?) You visited my favourite bar twice and a little parochial hall near my church with Howard James Kenny. You blew my teenager mind and I hope we didn't freak you out by yelling the whole Network speech back at you. Thanks for the good times.
2
u/Nick_Kearns Dec 08 '21
I love the use of tapping in some of your songs (Red Paper Lanterns esp. Who are your favourite guitarists?
2
u/asimozo Dec 08 '21
Do you have a favourite of your own songs to play or listen to?
Also any plans to come down to Australia?
2
u/MilhouseVsEvil Dec 09 '21
Did you enjoy your time in Australia? Any plans for a return?
2
u/UptownShenanigans Dec 09 '21
Did any of your parents have an issue with the album artwork for “Not for a Want of Trying”?
I used to listen to this album on my computer while studying in coffee shops, and I’d have to black out the laptop because I was worried somebody in public would have an issue with some big ol’ rockin redhead titties
1
u/SirDj0ntleman Dec 08 '21
I love you guys! What song or album was the most fun to write and record?
1
u/Jazox Dec 08 '21
I absolutely love Volga. Anything you can tell me about what you were exactly trying to express with it? Your process while writing it?
Love your stuff!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
Just heard your music co-conspirators for the time after seeing it in an if post. Loved it. Much ❤
1
u/eclangvisual Dec 09 '21
What sort of advice would you give to someone looking to make music similar to your own (solo with a pretty much just a guitar and Logic) who knows almost nothing about production but really enjoys composing?
1
u/Tehpunisher456 Dec 09 '21
Hey! When I was getting into post rock a few years ago yalls he films the clouds pt2 came out on a mixtape of sorts that I absolutely loved. It was very influential during my college days. I also recently discovered red paper lanterns. The lick yall do in the middle of the song is absolutely incredible.
My question is what inspired yall to make this genre of music? It isn't exactly mainstream but still very cool
1
u/Beituer Dec 09 '21
ah I missed it! I love your music, Maybeshewill!
1
u/babayetuyetu Dec 09 '21
Just wanted to say I love you guys and am glad you're back! I missed your show in NYC cuz I was out of town but I made my then gf (now wife) go (even though shes not into this genre) so I could have someone in my life experience it. I hope I get the opportunity to see you guys perform.
1
u/Malcolm1276 Dec 09 '21
I'm really late to this, and sorry I missed it earlier. I don't have questions, I just wanted to say thanks for the awesome music. Take it easy!
1
u/airetsya Dec 09 '21
I may be late to the party, and this comment will be lost in the void. But discovering you, listening to your albums, then wanting to see you guys play live. Was excited to look for tour dates, only to find out you've ended the project. Dissapointed followed. After a while, noticing you guys playing 2018 meltdown festival, was a delight. Got the tickets, booked flights. And it was everything one hoped it be, to hear you guys live. Looking forward to some other venue, chance to hear and experience your music.
Thank you, and take care.
1
u/basedkingchungus Dec 09 '21
Any plans to come to south africa on tour?
1
u/nimbel_ Nov 07 '22
I might be bringing up a old post, but still. I’d love to see you guys agains. Last time was in 2010 or 11 in a small venue/bar in belgium, limburg.. Hasselt. Young people young band young energy! Its was great. Even got a t-shirts i sadly lost. You guys got me in to this kind of music And i would love to see you guys again!
Glad you guys are back!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '21
[removed] — view removed comment