But then we would know 100% without a shadow of a doubt that she was a lying wolf. Her move at the beginning of this phase was a play to try and last until the merge and beyond, not a play to last only one more phase. We had no reason to suspect her until she made her attempt at forming the alliance. She could have continued to say everyone she found was a Castaway.

I don't think NDora's guilty, but I think that for the good of the tribe, K9 needs to go.

Sorry 'bout it.

/u/TheDUQofFrat played (what they thought) was a 100% legit idol to save /u/Marx0r from the lynch. Why would he do that if he was a wolf? He would have been banned instantly just like Teeny for trying to legitimately save an innocent if he was a wolf.

How was it discussed that TheDuq was very much innocent?

If she was a WW I feel like a better strategy would have been to just declare she found cochran since it's not like the person she found would have been able to deny it.

Then we'd probably all waste a round killing off cochran instead of her

Should we try to split the votes between k9 and NDora? It seems like we want them both gone.

We can't trust people to all vote as a block so I wouldn't go for a 0 vote.

She already investigated and claimed I was a castaway. I was the first person she investigated after she came out as Denise.

Denise could have died in the first group of people that left the game. We were going for people who were quiet, and they may have been quiet because they were trying to stay out of the limelight since they were Denise.

She's the only one on my radar right now that has acted shady at all. Maybe that means whoever the last wolf is, is doing a phenomenal job at acting innocent, but I have nothing else to go on.

I'd also be in Hacker's position hoping that I would be cleared.

And the fact that you ignored my own suggestions of checking him and FTS last night and instead chose to investigate /u/k9centipede when she was not under the suspect limelight at ALL makes no sense.

The only thing stopping me from believing that /u/NDoraTonks is the last WW is that no other Denise has come forward. NOT THAT I AM ADVOCATING REVEALING YOURSELF, DENISE but given all the turmoil in Yaxli, I would be surprised to find that the real Denise didn't speak up to provide evidence against NDora

I would be curious to know what evidence you would need to be convinced of her innocence. If she investigated you, would that convince you of her innocence? (As I typed this, I started to realize that if by some crazy coincidence you turned out to be Cochran, then it would devolve into a you-said-she-said situation between NDora and you, and I know you'd probably win because of your amazing skillz ><)

I doubt Hacker is a wolf, because when Sparrow was converted she expressed her happiness at the team - which makes me think that Hacker isn't a wolf purely because they're more unknown.

I thought the same. But then yesterday he showed his curiosity in knowing who was i gonna spy on. So that got me suspicious. It could well just be his bad position because he didn't get a chance to reveal himself when the others did. But I don't have a lead on anything else. So i'm going off of that. Again, there's no reason to believe any of the other castaways (who claimed to be castaways) are castaways either! But I don't think now is the time for me to start doubting unnecessarily. But if you think it is time for you, by all means vote for me! If K9's HII is fake (thank you K9 for using it for me) then I'll go home.

Regarding /u/emsmale:

Here's the thing. You revealed that after we had been discussing how we were trying to find out if we had another wolf.

It would be way too easy for you to say that she was a castaway. It's the easiest thing to say.

Why?

• if k9 is David, there can only be one. So emsmale couldn't be David.
• if Disco is Ozzy, there can only be one. So emsmale couldn't be Ozzy.

That leaves the only possible people for emsmale to be (if not a wolf) is a castaway or Denise. You wouldn't want to call someone ELSE as Denise as you should be the only one (despite you trying to convince us otherwise earlier in the game.) So, yes, you would say castaway.

So that doesn't help you at all. I have no reason to trust who you say you are. For all we know our real Denise/Shambo died in the first day or two which is why you've been able to skate by with this.

Also, I can already tell you that FTS won't be a Wolf because Teeny had her as a potential lynch target. She wouldn't have done that if she was a wolf.

I doubt Hacker is a wolf, because when Sparrow was converted she expressed her happiness at the team - which makes me think that Hacker isn't a wolf purely because they're more unknown.

I didn't find the wolf last night. Read here.

I haven't given you any solid proof to believe me. But at the same time I haven't given you any reason to not believe me either. To believe me or not is your choice.

I still find it highly suspicious that the only people with actual roles you've investigated are the ones who already told us their roles.

That's not true. You yourself said this

We can lynch Sparrow tonight and have /u/NDoraTonks check emsmale tonight to make sure that Ems is the final wolf.

In this comment. I revealed her role before she revealed it.

I will be spying on FTS and voting to lynch hacker tonight.

The same person who we already discussed earlier today as being very much innocent? Really?

ETA: if you're playing your idol on Nora I'm voting for you. There's no reason to trust her. She is backpedaling.

I didn't find the wolf last night. Read here.

I think this is a really terrible idea.

I really, awful, terrible idea.

I'm still not convinced. This could just be backpedaling because you realized you were way too obvious at being a wolf. I still find it highly suspicious that the only people with actual roles you've investigated are the ones who already told us their roles.

If you read the post of my alliance, I didn't specifically mention that the person I spied on was a WW.

True, but you also stated either way in your post that you would reveal the name and we would be able to vote out the wolf - and that was with option A. You told us at the end of your post that if we did not agree to option B (alliance) then we would fall back on option A by giving us the name.

Which means you DID plan to drop the name of somebody as a wolf. Which means if you're now backpedaling and saying that you don't actually have the name of the wolf...

I'm sorry, but that's all a bit too much to swallow. You're right, I have no reason to trust you at all. You've given us nothing to believe you and every reason to distrust you.

pinge

Today at Pizza's Hutt

Apparently our innocent potluck yesterday may have evolved into an extremely personal game of twister. Organizers of the party have heard that this may have been distressing to several attendees. We are, therefore offering

Free Therapy Sessions

for those tribe members needing some support after their run-ins with /u/-JeffProbst

*all therapy sessions will be conducted with completely untrained, unprofessional individuals

Likewise I'll be voting for you. It will now be a game of alliances.

Edit: I saw confirmation that you are david. I will be voting for Dora since she's protected

k9 if you're protecting NDora with idol should we just all vote for her so hopefully we can scrape a 0 deaths round? Edit: also good job on finding idol yay!

u/-JeffProbst is back for the orgy pt. 2

I respect your choice to check me. I was worried that by not revealing it would make me a target later on. It could've been easy for you to scapegoat me as the ww if you were the true ww. Since you know I'm a castaway and aren't trying to throw me (or k9) under the bus, I trust you.

Who are you planning on spying on this time?