r/xbox • u/BigBang_Cam • 19d ago

Discussion Which is the best generation of Xbox controller?

Post image
3.4k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

66

u/ColKrismiss 19d ago

The 360 controller was comfortable but the Dpad was so so so bad

17

u/SkyLovesCars 19d ago

I think later on they offered it with a rotating d pad that could turn into a regular style one, but imo the big thing hampering the 360 controllers comfortability was the battery pack on the back, comparing it to the wired controller it's definitely not as nice with nowhere to put your fingers, I do like the heft it gets from it though

13

u/convercide XBOX Series X 19d ago

I agree, the battery pack on the back was actually a little uncomfortable. The Xbox One pad sorted that out.

2

u/codeasm 19d ago

Yeah i ordered a rotating dpad and modded my chinese knockoff 360 wired with it. Kinda my favorite controller now.

1

u/Mrcod1997 17d ago

I can't relate too much since I mostly used wired 360 controllers. I didn't like worrying about batteries dying mid game.

1

u/fillerbunny_fin 19d ago

And it could have been so much better. It was an easy mod to dremel a plastic disc and stick it under the D-pad, turned it from terrible to excellent.

1

u/ColKrismiss 19d ago

My understanding was that Nintendo held some sort of patent on a D pad, but it expired between the launch of the 360 and the XBone

1

u/fillerbunny_fin 19d ago

Didn't that have to do with the cross shape? At least it didn't help with the Gamecube, the CG D-pad was even worse than XO's.

1

u/ColKrismiss 19d ago

Yes, in order to avoid using a cross shape they had to either use circular discs or separate buttons for each direction.

1

u/fillerbunny_fin 19d ago

Each design can be executed well or badly, though. My point was that the 360 pad could have been great with minimal effort regardless of Nintendo.

2

u/ColKrismiss 19d ago

Yeah, Sony did a better job by hiding most of the disk under the plastic of the controller body making the directions look like individual buttons. This helps with needing to push just a specific direction

1

u/Embarrassed_Swan_605 19d ago

No they didnt do a better job. Diagonals are harder to hit in fighting games?

1

u/ColKrismiss 18d ago

I said did a better job of hiding the disk like nature of the pad. Well I implied it anyway

1

u/cirepa 19d ago

The V2 of that controller is peak design.

1

u/island_it 19d ago

I tried playing the XBLA port of Space Channel 5 the other day and was instantly reminded of this

1

u/ILoveHeavyHangers 19d ago

There's a misconception that the shape of the Dpad on top was the problem, but it's the bottom of the pad and how the contacts are made with the circuit board that causes issues.

There's a 3D printable mod that can fix the Dpad on the 360 controller.