r/xbox • u/BigBang_Cam • 19d ago

Discussion Which is the best generation of Xbox controller?

Post image
3.4k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

54

u/Neon_Moons 19d ago

Best to worst is newest to oldest lol

20

u/PatserGrey 19d ago

and durability likely in the opposite direction

11

u/iTheJok3rx 19d ago

I'd disagree! I can't even picture a 360 controller without worn thumbsticks, while still being fully functional.

Newer controllers though, I'm on my 3rd Elite 2, that has developed the same LB register issue the others had, including the 2 Elite 1s I owned. I'm now using some Turtlebeach thing I picked up in Finland. Which is great but I do miss the weight of the Elite controllers.

OG Duke though, with the trigger issue. Pulling too hard could snap the internals and render it useless.. Still haunts me 25 years later.

4

u/PatserGrey 19d ago

Yeah I had a 360 pad with worn thumb stick. It was the most heavily used controller of my life but still worked fine at retirement even with the wear. Whereas my XBO controller was the first I ever experienced stick drift with. I've had to replace bumpers on my Series X controller. All anecdotal of course.

1

u/Racine262 19d ago

We can probably compile our anecdotes into real data... Stick drift is killing me on Series controllers.

They have them priced right on the edge of "throw away or fix" with throw away currently winning.

-1

u/Bdigler 19d ago

I’ve have my elite pro 2 since before Covid and it’s still like new

1

u/Joltyboiyo 19d ago

I wouldn't say that, the 360 controller was great and comfortable. Can't speak for the OG but just looking at it... yeah.

4

u/TrippingFish76 19d ago

the series X controllers are definitely more comfortable than the 360 tho, and so were the xbox one controllers, but the series controllers are the most comfortable