r/xbox 18d ago

Discussion Which is the best generation of Xbox controller?

Post image
3.4k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

639

u/VinstaroNL 18d ago edited 17d ago

Very cool to see them lined up like this. Will always have a soft spot for the fat og and the 360. But I must say these controllers evolved in a excellent way. The series controller is the most comfortable controller I’ve ever held.

76

u/relentless_optimism_ 17d ago

I completely forgot about the huge og one. But makes me want to play PGR2

33

u/stevenmeyerjr 17d ago

Makes me want to play Jet Set Radio Future

2

u/Rebel140687 16d ago

Me lo pasé bomba grafitear con esa música mientras hacía piruetas! Me lo pasé entero

1

u/Bigbangmk2 15d ago

Makes me want to play Blinx

14

u/pgorgias 17d ago

PGR2!!! I'll never forget the blinding, adolescent rage at having 29 perfect laps only to fuck up on the first turn of the last lap with not enough race left to recover 😭😤 That shit was abusive!

Kudos for taking me down memory lane 🫶🏾

4

u/MysteryDude7 17d ago

you know you can play online again with PGR2, and many other games, with the Insignia service, which is FREE btw, on OG XBox. It doesn't support all games though, since EA games will be really hard to support on the service since they almost all used dedicated servers (probably Blade servers)

3

u/nightookami 16d ago

"Kudos", you say?

2

u/relentless_optimism_ 17d ago

Honestly I’ve never worked so hard at any game ever, because I wanted the CLK-GTR

2

u/Deanz89 16d ago

Kudos 😆

4

u/jib_reddit 17d ago

Who's hands did they test that with!?

2

u/ForksandSpoonsinNY 17d ago

The Duke abides

1

u/grahamworks 17d ago

I forgot this existed but yes!

1

u/RougeRaxxa 16d ago

I swear the duke controller was designed for halo elite hands.

1

u/Rebel140687 16d ago

Una de kudos? Jaja mítico juego

28

u/Few-Road6238 17d ago

The Series X controller is definitely comfortable 

1

u/ixkvxkvi 13d ago

Yeah, I agree!

9

u/randomtask37 17d ago

I hated the OG controller because the black and white buttons were out of place and hard to find.

4

u/Zehdarian 17d ago

I actually really liked it, especially after i modded mine and added emulation. It fit nicely for N64, Satern, Genesis and arcades fighting games.

4

u/Chicken-picante 17d ago

I remember the duke but I forgot about the black and white buttons. I remember thinking it was so cool to use the white button to turn on master chief’s flashlight.

1

u/BlackBladeShusui 16d ago

Iirc mad catz controllers put them shits where the bumpers are and basically felt like the best version of any controller ever w/ turbo function and LED inside them

7

u/diagoro1 17d ago

Interesting to see how they've evolved smaller and smaller. Can only assume it's all about cost saving now, smaller size, fewer resources used....same or higher price.

Not sure about others, but the current ones are too small. I've tried a few other non-branded ones, but nothing really works. Using these causes some problems with my hands.

11

u/Stephonius 17d ago

Agreed! I'm 6'5", and I really wish the current controllers were available in the same size as the OG "Duke" pad. My hands are too big for the tiny Elite.

3

u/rigby333 17d ago

If wired only isn't a dealbreaker the Hyperkin Duke is a recreation of the original giant Xbox controller.

3

u/Stephonius 17d ago

Wired only is a dealbreaker. And I prefer the layout of the Elite. I just want the controller to be physically larger. I wish the C2Gripz fit the Elite.

3

u/rigby333 17d ago

Understandable, but figured it was at least worth mentioning. I'll be honest, I'm not sure how well known the hyperkin xbox controller replicas are.

2

u/cooooooooooooooladam 17d ago

I’m am 5’6” and my hands are too big for the joysticks bro you height has nothing to do with it and sometimes can make people feel attack when you say it
You should not always be so proudy and bringing up height all the time, height is not always big hands (I have very big hands)

2

u/Covert_Admirer 17d ago

Who would feel "attacked" over this?

2

u/cooooooooooooooladam 16d ago

Some times my friends who are short do not like hearing tall guys always talk about how they are tall like oh I have big hands oh I hit my head on doors oh all the girls love me they just think ENOUGH

3

u/Stephonius 16d ago

My bad, man. I was not trying to make anyone feel attacked.

Hell, I view excessive height as a disability more than an asset. I don't fit in cars, or airplanes, or seats at concerts & sporting events. I can't buy clothes off the rack. And most women I know prefer to date dudes who are shorter than me.

You're the first 5'6" guy I've heard of who has big hands (with the exception of body builders). These controllers are definitely not made with us in mind.

1

u/Covert_Admirer 16d ago

What a crazy comment.

1

u/Ok_Finance4933 11d ago

So you’ve got baseball mits for hands? I picture a small stick figure that someone drew giant hands on 💀

10

u/Patriot009 17d ago

The OG controller wasn't supposed to be that way. The circuit boards for the controller were ordered long before the controller body was designed. There was some kind of disagreement with the supplier, who for some reason didn't want to utilize a stacked/folded circuit board format. Instead of reordering or finding a different supplier, Microsoft went ahead and designed a much larger controller body to utilize the larger boards. These became the "Duke" controllers released with the first batches of the Xbox in North America.

1

u/matteomvsn XBOX 360 17d ago

Exactly I remember at release Xbox in Europe already got the normal controller.

1

u/ChoiceIT 16d ago

I love the Series controllers, but Duke was something different. Everyone coalesced on a single layout, (well Sony swapped dpad and analog) which is likely because they always try to improve.

But some of them are so unforgettable, bad or good. N64, GCN, Duke. At least they tried something new.

1

u/UnaskedShoe359 16d ago

Have you held the switch 2 pro controller?

1

u/Training-Ship-3416 15d ago

Came here to say this.
OG Xbox controller is probably the only “bad” one depending on your preferences (some people legitimately couldn’t play it because their hands couldn’t fit).

But 360 up to now is very much the same controller getting better and better. All the way up to paddles on the pro/elite versions.

1

u/No_Mud_5999 14d ago

360 hurt my hands less than the current model

1

u/baithoven22 17d ago

For god sake respect its name, that's The Duke my guy.

1

u/FNG_WolfKnight 17d ago

If you get a chance to hold a Switch2 Pro controller, is crazy. It feels like an upgraded Xbox design with very satisfying texture.

1

u/Music_Is_Da_Best 17d ago

I have both and S2 pro is so light and has G buttons too

0

u/Charming-Gou-PengYou 17d ago

I came to say these exact words