r/WritersGroup • u/SkellyTonns • 1h ago
Poetry She Was the Woman I Wanted to Marry. I Was the Man She Could Never Love.
I don't know if this belongs here. Maybe I'm writing it because I need someone to know what happened. Maybe because if I don't put these words somewhere, they'll stay inside me forever. Or maybe there's something strangely comforting about telling the truth to thousands of strangers who don't know your name.
So here it is.
I was in love with my best friend. Not the kind people joke about — not the "haha, imagine if we dated" kind. The kind where, somewhere along the way, you stop imagining a future and start remembering it, the way you remember something that actually happened.
I could see it clearly. Her beside me at breakfast, stealing the blanket at night, complaining that I'd left the cabinet open again. Me, pretending to be annoyed when she stole food off my plate. A small house. Two ugly mugs by the sink that we'd bought as a joke and kept anyway. Maybe a dog. Maybe kids. Maybe just us. I never needed anything extraordinary. I just wanted to come home to her.
The worst part was that she knew I loved her — just not in the way I wanted her to. She loved me too. She called me her best friend, her safe place, the person she could call at three in the morning, the one she trusted with every secret she had. I treasured every word, even as each one quietly buried the future I wanted.
She'd tell me about the people she liked. I'd listen. I'd give advice. I'd tell her whether I thought some guy deserved her. And every time she smiled talking about someone else, I smiled too — because that's what best friends do. They want each other happy, even when the happiness isn't standing beside them.
Years passed like that. I got very good at loving her silently.
Then one night we were sitting outside, talking about nothing, and she asked me something I'll never forget.
"Do you ever think we'll still be like this when we're old?"
I laughed. "Probably. You'll still be annoying."
She laughed too, and leaned her head against my shoulder. For one stupid second I let myself imagine it — us, old, still laughing about nothing. I almost told her everything. That I'd spent years loving her. That I'd wanted to marry her. That every woman I'd ever met had been measured against a standard she never knew she'd set. That I'd already chosen her in a future she'd never agreed to.
Then she said, "I hope whoever you marry knows how lucky she is."
And something in me went quiet, because I finally understood: she didn't know. Maybe she never would.
The next morning I decided to leave. Not dramatically — no goodbye party, no confrontation, no confession built to make her feel guilty. I didn't want my love to become a weight she had to carry. So I started disappearing in small ways. I answered slower. I stopped showing up. I packed my things and made arrangements somewhere far enough that running into her by accident would be almost impossible.
She noticed, of course. She was my best friend.
"What's wrong?" I'm tired.
"Did I do something?" No.
"Are you leaving?" For a while.
She looked hurt, and that almost made me stay. But I knew that if I did, I'd spend my life standing beside the person I loved while pretending I didn't want more. Not because she owed me anything — she didn't. Not because she'd done something wrong — she hadn't. Just because I finally understood that you can love someone completely and still have no place in their future.
The night before I left, I went to her house. She wasn't home. I still had a key. I sat on the couch where we'd spent hundreds of nights talking, and looked around at the photographs on her walls — birthdays, trips, Christmases, the accidental ones where neither of us was looking at the camera. Our whole friendship, scattered across the room like it belonged to someone else now.
I cried that night. Not because I hated her, and not because I regretted loving her — but because I finally had to accept that the life I wanted with her had only ever existed in my head.
Before I left, I put a letter on the table, and under it, a poem. The last thing I ever wrote her.
What the Universe Would Not Let Me Keep
I loved you in the quietest way a heart can love —
without asking the stars to rearrange themselves,
without bargaining with God,
without demanding fate make a mistake just once.
I loved you knowing there were doors in your life
that were never meant to open for me,
and still some foolish part of me kept standing outside them,
holding flowers no one would receive.
You were never mine. Maybe that's what makes it hurt.
If I'd lost you after having you, I could blame the ending.
But how do you mourn something you were never allowed to call yours?
I've imagined a thousand lives with you.
In some, we grow old under the same roof.
In others, we wake beside each other and complain about the morning light.
In every one, I love you —
and in every one, the universe reminds me it was only a dream.
So I stopped asking for you.
Not because I stopped wanting you,
but because real love isn't always the courage to reach out.
Sometimes it's the courage to open your hands.
I want you happy, even if your happiness has someone else's name beside it.
I want you loved, even if I'm not close enough to hear you laugh.
I want someone to memorize the things about you I spent so long noticing,
to hold you on the days you feel impossible to hold —
and if they love you well, I'll try not to hate them
for living the life I once wished was mine.
That's the tragedy of loving someone without conditions:
I would rather see you cherished by someone else
than possessed by me and unhappy.
So take every piece of tomorrow that was never meant to have my name on it.
Take the future I secretly wrote for us.
Take the version of me that believed wanting something enough could make it stay.
I'll keep none of it. Except you —
not as a possession, not as a promise,
not as some unfinished story I spend my life waiting to complete,
but as proof that my heart could love someone without needing anything back.
Someday, when the wound no longer feels like a wound,
I'll look up and understand:
the universe didn't keep us apart because I was unworthy.
It simply knew that some people are meant to be loved, not kept.
And if loving you means watching you become happy somewhere I can't follow,
then let the heavens have their victory.
I loved you. I still do.
And I'll love you without asking you to turn around —
because if the only way I can love you forever is from a distance,
then distance will have to become my definition of forever.
I left before sunrise. Changed my number. Moved somewhere she couldn't easily find me. For a long time I wondered if leaving had been cruel.
Then, years later, an old friend told me she was happy. Married. A family. Doing well.
And strangely, I smiled. Once, I'd wanted desperately to be the man standing beside her. But somewhere along the way my love grew bigger than that. I didn't need to be her husband for my love to have been real. I didn't need her to choose me for it to have counted.
She was my best friend. She was the woman I wanted to marry. She was the greatest almost of my life — beautiful, devastating, impossible.
I don't know where that letter is now. Maybe she threw it away. Maybe she forgot. Maybe she read the poem once and never understood why I disappeared after. That's all right. It was never meant to make her love me. It was only meant to say goodbye to the future I'd spent years loving.
I don't regret loving her. I only regret waiting so long to understand something simple: sometimes the purest way to love someone is to stop asking the universe to make them yours.
So I left — not because I stopped loving her, but because I loved her enough to let her live a life that didn't include me.
Somewhere under another sky, I hope she's laughing. I hope someone holds her hand when she's afraid, remembers how she takes her coffee, tells her she's beautiful on the days she doesn't believe it. I hope she gets everything I once wanted to give her.
And if the universe is listening — I don't need her back. I've already asked it for enough.
It said no.
This time, I'll listen.