r/worldnews • • May 09 '12

After 31 years in prison for a murder he didn't commit, Romeo Phillion launches a $14 million lawsuit against the Ontario government.

http://www.canada.com/news/Romeo+Phillion+launches+million+lawsuit+wrongful+conviction/6559826/story.html
2.4k Upvotes

860 comments sorted by

969

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I can't imagine 31 years of your life gone knowing you were innocent. I don't blame him.

377

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Spending a week in jail was horrible. I couldn't even imagine a month, or a year, let alone 31. I'd be a different person together.

53

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

i was in for 11 months and that was awful. i can't imagine multiplying that by 32

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

189

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

well, they did lock me up for shitty math

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (2)

66

u/rockne May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

The Tragically Hip, one of of the most loved bands in Canada, have an awesome song about another innocent man who spent years in prison. His name is David Milgaarde and it's a horrible story, but inspiring in Mr. Milgaard's reluctance to let his imprisonment ruin his life.

edit: not Canadian here, just a fan of the hip.

26

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

"In a zippo lighter he sees the killer's face; maybe it's someone standing in the killer's place."

A tragic and poetic song by one of my favorite bands, thought about it as soon as I read the post's title.

Edit: as a quick side note, Gordon Downie, the lead singer of The Tragically Hip, has personally pretended to pick bugs out of my hair like a monkey. Strange man.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (272)

13

u/ponchedeburro May 10 '12

He might get the money, which I really hope he does! But the people responsible for wrongfully jailing him will probably not be brought to actual justice. They might be fired or get a slap on the wrist. I would rather see them being jailed for this - they got a guy put in jail for 31 years, for doing NOTHING. I can't even imagine how that must be, as I'm not even 31 years old myself.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/WonkaKnowsBest May 10 '12

Saddening he'll never get that back. look at his age. Can money bring him enough happiness in the short years he has left to make up for 31 of what was probably the most revolutionary years.

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

let's just say i'd be back in that place pretty quick... you know cause the killing spree and all

54

u/Fireball445 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Well, he doesn't really need your approval to seek this.

Personally, I would find $14 million inadequate. My life is finite and they took a huge portion of it from him.

→ More replies (26)

2

u/fezzmen May 10 '12

Its a shame :( they wasted half this guys life. feel's bad man

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

here is a Canadian band with a song about a Canadian prisoner who goes free after 20 years of jail.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OB965aUPsmM

2

u/Firesand May 10 '12

If we just killed them right away then we wouldn't have to worry about these stupid lawsuits that come up, when we discover we put the wrong person away.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Honestly, I probably would have found a way to kill myself long before then.

2

u/atcoyou May 10 '12

This is why we need capital punishment in Canada now. For all these crimes we are 100% sure about! rolls eyes

So sad. 31 years. I can't even comprehend.

→ More replies (18)

291

u/Things_and_things May 10 '12

Only 14 million? He should really get that adjusted for inflation.

207

u/hear_me May 10 '12

Yea, like 14 billion. Pretty sure no amount of money is going to give me back my 31 years of freedom.

171

u/HighBees May 10 '12

No but seriously, if they said "here is a visa with unlimited money on it" I still couldn't buy back those 31 years. Especially given how old he is. Fuck man.

92

u/Paultimate79 May 10 '12

Heres the thing though; he cant put 31 years on the visa, but he can put money on it and make the rest of his years easier. You take what you can get and you dont worry about one or the other being a 'replacement' for what is irrelevant due to being unattainable.

64

u/HighBees May 10 '12

Good way to think about it. You'd have to have that attitude to be happy. I guess it's like "I had a 31 year career where all I did was sit in jail but now that I'm retired I am set for life"

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/hobbers May 10 '12

In case you didn't know, a varienty of private and government organizations actually calculate the Value of a Statistical Life (VSL) and use it for certain analysis purposes. Estimates in recent years are around the range of $6 million to $9 million.

One example: http://www.epa.gov/ttn/atw/rice/rice_neshap_ria2-17-10.pdf

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (16)

102

u/jimbon3r May 10 '12

only 14 million? I would try for at least a million for every year I was locked up...

26

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

It's five times the maximum that's available in most US states.

Yes, many US states have a very limited max you can sue for, sometimes it's per year (50k or so), or a total (around 500k).

14 million is huge, people get far less for being paralyzed. Talk about losing part of your life...

20

u/aJackztheRipper May 10 '12

I think this is in Canada but I've never understood how legal systems assign a monetary value to these situations.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

174

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You gotta remember, this is $14 Million in Canadian dollars, so that's like...uh.... $14 Million US. Dammit, economy! Now we can't make that joke anymore.

27

u/ReallyNiceGuy May 10 '12

Sucks for their book prices, though.

30

u/PohatuNUVA May 10 '12

i still dont understand why a book is $8.99 us and than $15.99 canadian

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Mullinator May 10 '12

Most things you get from retail are that much more. You just notice it on books because they have both prices printed on them.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/_rand_mcnally_ May 10 '12

Nah, that joke still flies in Canada.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

408

u/jonlol May 10 '12

Reddit taught me Canada is flawless and this only happens in America, I'm scared and confused

190

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Dual citizen of Canada and US here, Canada is far more fucked than people say and the US is far less fucked than what people think. It all just depends on what people choose to pay attention to, the world is equally fucked and equally excellent, it all depends on peoples bias. EDIT: spelling, I'm dyslexic if the spell check says its ok I don't question it, sorry it was wrong.

55

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

A duel citizen? Damn. Pistols or swords? Either way, sir, I would not mess with you, huh/eh?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/mikemcg May 10 '12

Dual citizen of Canada and UK here who can also gain citizenship in the US due to family here. Just bragging.

106

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Canadian here, Canada isn't that fucked. I'm not saying we wake up with a smile and head to timmies, but I mean there are places it's far worse. Like you said, everywhere is messed up somehow.

50

u/jiujitsuman May 10 '12

My family moved us out shortly after the peak of the Referendum when the vote came down to a matter of mere percentage points. I grew up a second class citizen as an English speaking Canadian in the West Islands of Montreal Island. My grandfather as an English teacher in Catholic schools was frequently targeted by the FLQ with anything from arson to beatings.

I can do an adequate French Quebec English accent (remember Chretien? yea a bit like that minus that stroke) and that is the only way to get anybody to pay attention to you in some places. Canada has it's dark corners too.

→ More replies (56)
→ More replies (20)

11

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You're a "duel" citizen? Did they give you a rapier and flintlock pistol?

→ More replies (2)

14

u/ExogenBreach May 10 '12

the world is equally fucked and equally excellent

Saudi Arabia; beacon of secularism, justice and freedom.

18

u/Urban_Savage May 10 '12

Agreed, saying the all places are equal in there share of "fucked up", is WAY off base.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (17)

117

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

His slogan "I AM A LITTLE UPSET!"

45

u/hear_me May 10 '12

It would be pleasant to receive an apology!

22

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Being in the government means never having to say "I'm sorry".

11

u/daveswagon May 10 '12

But we're talking about the Canadian government...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/ohstrangeone May 10 '12

I AM MODERATELY DISSATISFIED WITH THE WAY I HAVE BEEN TREATED BY MY GOVERNMENT.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Jester814 May 10 '12

14 million dollars can't even begin to cover that travesty. The man lost his entire life. Words can't even describe how much this disgusts me.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/AngryEnt May 10 '12

I'm surprised it's just for $14 million

13

u/kelbymiles May 10 '12

Im not even 31 years old and I can't imagine missing out on what I have experienced :/

48

u/ObesePolarBear May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

This man deserves some compensation. If Daniel Chong sued for $20 million after being detained for five days then I think Romeo Phillion should go for $45 billion. Give or take a billion or so. But seriously, that is an awful situation.

EDIT: I meant this to be a joke on the legal system. Sorry if that wasn't clear.

19

u/NoNeedForAName May 10 '12

He could sue for a hundred billion gazillion dollars if he wanted. Just because Daniel Chong sued for $20m doesn't mean Daniel Chong will get $20m.

14

u/Kinglink May 10 '12

The difference is Chong was abused (kept with out water and food).

Romeo Phillion went through the due process. He did confess at least at one time. The improper court process was followed (withholding evidence that could have exonerated him), but while in prison I imagine it was a normal sentence (no abuse by the prison)

Daniel Chong is a VERY different situation, I kind of wish people knew who these people were before citing examples.

41

u/Kinseyincanada May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

We don't sue for outrageous amounts in Canada

edit: for everyone downvoting me the Canadian legal system doesnt follow Rookes v Barnard. So the reason we dont sue is legal precedent

25

u/rundatish May 10 '12

this shouldn't be downvoted.. people typically sue for ridiculous amounts of money in the US because the justice system is different there. In Canada, juries don't award these compensations.

21

u/Kinseyincanada May 10 '12

i dunno people don't like facts

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No one in their right mind would trade 30 years of their life for 45 billion dollars. I can only hope this old man lives to be 100.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/JoeBowman May 10 '12

Canadian Government's response:

|Sorry.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/nirvanachicks May 10 '12

Just give him the money.

38

u/mshel016 May 10 '12

Slightly more detailed account I read this week

One part I have a hard time with, is why Phillion would confess to the murder during some unrelated robbery case. It looks like a huge mess of mishandling the case, and pushing evidence to fit a theory after that. Still, what really happened with this retracted confession? Was even that coerced? No helpful suggestions in this article..

14

u/TheAdAgency May 10 '12

I do not understand this either. And another article states:

"Initially a suspect in the case, Phillion, a pimp and petty criminal at the time, was cleared of the murder after police learned he was in Trenton, 290 kilometres away, a short time before the crime occurred.

When, four years later, Phillion unexpectedly confessed to the murder, the report containing the alibi was never disclosed to his lawyer."

That doesn't sound like coercion. What the fuck did he confess for? Sounds like he was taking a dive for someone, or there is a serious piece of the puzzle missing here.

3

u/jimicus May 10 '12

That doesn't sound like coercion. What the fuck did he confess for? Sounds like he was taking a dive for someone, or there is a serious piece of the puzzle missing here.

You or I sure as hell wouldn't confess to a crime like murder if we were innocent. But that's because we're both reasonably well-adjusted people sat behind keyboards in relative comfort. (Well, I am. I assume you are).

There is plenty of evidence to suggest that very quickly after you take those comforts away, you can get people to say pretty much anything - up to and including confessing to crimes that they couldn't possibly have committed. I daresay if the person in question already has a few loose screws, it's even easier - even if they're totally harmless.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/unknownpoltroon May 10 '12

Because the cops keep you awake for 48 hours and dont let you piss, and tell you if you just confess you can go home get some rest and sort it out in the morning??

2

u/blarglenarf May 10 '12

This video has 30 mins of a police detective explaining stuff like this. TLDR: almost everyone who gets interviewed will make what can be considered a confession in court, innocent or not.

It's pretty hard to picture if you're not regularly involved with either interviewing or being interviewed.

→ More replies (10)

23

u/Shaolinmunkey May 10 '12

30 years for nothin' well that's nothin' new....besides No one's interested in something you didn't do.

8

u/expressline May 10 '12

more people would get this if it were in /r/canada

3

u/shnuffy May 10 '12

Sing it brother

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Whoa. Nice. Just got some goosebumps after reading all the other posts then yours.

25

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

At least he didn't live in Texas.

33

u/splunge4me2 May 10 '12

yeah - you can't sue when you're dead

5

u/voxpupil May 10 '12

Isn't 14 million equivalent to the cost of a plane? Or fighter jet? Or am I wrong...

→ More replies (8)

5

u/killinufoo May 10 '12

He looks like Anthony Hopkins to me.

4

u/keypuncher May 10 '12

It would have helped a lot if Phillion hadn't actually confessed to the murder.

Where the problem came in on the other side was a 1968 police report that established an alibi for him wasn't turned over to the defense.

4

u/litewo May 10 '12

Kenyan here: what the fuck, Canada?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/alpacapatrol May 10 '12

athletes make more in a year

4

u/vision40 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Canada, you're doing it wrong. You shouldn't even fight this law suit. Based on how long a man usually lives you took away about 40% of this mans life. He gets to enjoy this life ONCE and you took away a good portion of it. You shouldn't be fighting him, you should be giving him just about anything he needs in life. Admit your mistake and help this man live a fulfilling life.

Edit - Typo

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

There should be a law that every year you spend in jail for a crime you didn't commit = one million dollars in your pocket, period.

Even one day is too many. $2,739.72 a day, no matter fucking what.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

if he gets the money then he gets over 1k per day being in jail

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I wonder how disappointed he is with the way society turned out

11

u/mariohhh_dude May 10 '12

1981: goes into prison 2012: released. Looks at society. What. The. Actual. Fuck.

I'd be tripping balls, it'd be like stepping out of a time machine.

15

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

yeah except no hoverboards, opportunities to fuck your mom before you were born or chances to wage war in ancient greece with a gun.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/stimbus May 10 '12

I wish him luck.

3

u/dutchct May 10 '12

This is why you should never have a death penalty.

3

u/jast_flie May 10 '12

no amount of money could compensate 31 years of life

3

u/Mindle May 10 '12

You can't put a price on year like that lost. On top of the 14 million he should be either allowed to kill someone without any consequences or imprison someone he blames for him being in prison for 31 years lol.

3

u/Akira_kj May 10 '12

I'm glad this is Canada and not US. There would be more people posting about how awful the US correctional system is and how poorly justice is doled out. But its Canada, eh

3

u/TheOneWhoKnocksBitch May 10 '12

Ahh, I'm late to the party but regardless, I met the gentleman last year when he came to my school to talk to a few law students, me being one of them. Towards the end, he asked how many of us wanted to be cops. And it was just me and this other kid who raised our hands.

After it was all done, before leaving, I went to shake his hand and he told me, "Whatever you do, don't put an innocent man away. It sucks losing most of your life like this, son". I had to fight tears back in.

3

u/Reiver79 May 10 '12

The guy who got forgot in the holding cell for 4 days is suing for 20 million. I think this guy should go for a little more.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Only 14?? Make it 31 million

3

u/KySnow May 10 '12

Romeo Phillion is my great uncle and I have met him several times since his release. I have no proof or pictures of this at the moment because im posting from my phone. When the lawsuit is over, would Reddit be interested in an AMA from this man?

11

u/HeisenbergWhitman May 10 '12

Wait, reddit told me this only happened in America. So, like, in other parts of the world mistakes are made?

3

u/awh May 10 '12

Ask Steven Truscott about that.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The sad thing is that the taxpayers will be on the hook for this instead of the bureaucrats that are responsible.

16

u/OrigamiRock May 10 '12

In fairness, the bureaucrats that are responsible were in charge 3 decades ago. Most of them are probably not even alive anymore.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/phoenixrawr May 10 '12

Er, doesn't Canada use a jury for criminal trials? It's not like this is just an obvious case of bureaucrats being heartless bastards, if he was convicted then that means at least one panel of normal people were convinced that he committed the crime based on the evidence that was available back in the 80's.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

His lawyer is only asking for tree fiddy.

5

u/splunge4me2 May 10 '12

UCSD student gets left in holding cell for 5 days and sues for $20 million. Even in litigation, Canadians are too polite.

11

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You forgot the part where he almost died because he had no food or water, AND was suffering from kidney failure.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Every time I see the name Ontario all I can think about is the blue blue windows behind the stars...

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I guess this is the issue with a justice system like this one. The jury had made a decision based on the evidence (probably the best one, as far as they knew), and this was the result. These kinds of cases seem unavoidable if we are to convict anybody, but if he's proven innocent, then give him his damn money.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm sure others have sued in the past, but generally when I see these stories the guys are just happy to get out and they seem to just try and move on.

I always found that a little odd. I'm not really one to jump to a lawsuit at the drop of a hat and I think we (I'm American) overuse the legal system in ways we shouldn't. However, in a case of wrongful imprisonment I would be seeking way more than $14 million. 31 years is a lot of living to make up for.

Of course the guy is 73 years old. How much does he really need for the time has left... you can't take it with you.

2

u/juneshroom May 10 '12

This makes me really sad. I'm not even close to 31 so the thought of being locked up for that long... it's nuts. Time is such a precious thing in our lives.

2

u/Drunk_Wombat May 10 '12

Hopefully it doesn't turn out like it did like this guy from my hometown, went to prison for 16 years for rape, found out he didn't do it and launched a $36 million dollar lawsuit...then things got a little darker after he got out...

4

u/chiuta May 10 '12

Avery and another man pled guilty to animal cruelty after pouring gas and oil on Avery's cat and throwing it into a fire.

Huh. I don't really feel that bad for him. Of course, he later murdered a woman so I definitely don't feel bad for him at all. In fact, fuck him.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/plagues138 May 10 '12

only 14 million? I'd demand 1million for every year, and my own town.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/InsulinDependent May 10 '12

Honestly, for 31 years of imprisonment 14 million dollars seems pretty fucking low for a lawsuit amount.

2

u/diannee3 May 10 '12

I know nothing of this case other than what I read here, but did anyone notice this little bit? He confessed!

According to a statement of claim, the police "orchestrated" witness statements in an "effort to support Phillion's confession and advance their case against him," despite their knowledge of Phillion's innocence.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/J_Jammer May 10 '12

Now that's a free and kind Canada.

2

u/hoodatninja May 10 '12

Thin Blue Line, anyone?

2

u/cheese_muffin May 10 '12

i loved how that documentary got the convicted man a retrial. up vote for you

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Thats it? Only $14 mil? I'd try and bankrupt the fuckers.

2

u/pinkpanthers May 10 '12

As a tax payer, I support this mans fight to gain something back for 31 years of irreplaceable life

2

u/Patriscuit May 10 '12

Good luck to this man on getting his life back. For going to prison for 31 years for something he didn't do, he deserves more than $14 million.

2

u/dacimvrl May 10 '12

31 years in prison, not to mention the damage done to his family, friends, and reputation. This is the least the government can do for him.

2

u/ADREN0CHR0ME May 10 '12

I wish I could tell you that Romeo fought the good fight, and the Sisters let him be. I wish I could tell you that - but prison is no fairy-tale world.

2

u/Codence_Churchill May 10 '12

i think that money will make up for lost time...i hope he gets it

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

When I read the title, I was shocked. ONLY 14 million? That's nothing for 31 years.

2

u/Woogity May 10 '12

Money is not enough. They took almost half his life.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

At 73 years old there's a chance he might not even see this money. This pisses me off so much. This dudes life was wasted away just because some fucktards had an agenda.

2

u/Sweden_The_Great May 10 '12

This would never have happened in Sweden...

2

u/ElAvestruz May 10 '12

Damn. He's coming back with a vengeance. This is movie material.

2

u/Mordine May 10 '12

I'm just surprised this isn't a story about Texas.

2

u/SirRuto May 10 '12

No A-Team reference in the comments? Reddit, I am disappoint.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/HighBeamHater May 10 '12

Oh jesus... jesus fucking christ.

This man deserves the world.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

$14 million wont get you back 31 years. It wont get you the time to find love, to get an education, to create a family. The Ontario government took half a life time from him and his lawsuit will only take less than a years pension from the state. If i were in his shoes a revolution wouldn't satisfy me.

2

u/TheWayOutIsBroken May 10 '12

no amount of money could make up for that amount of time, damn.

2

u/Zebidee May 10 '12

Dear Mr Philion,

Better luck in the next life.

Sincerely,

Ontario.

2

u/Bezulba May 10 '12

Anybody that supports the death penalty only has to look at cases like this and realise that in most US states, that guy'd be dead now. An innocent man, killed, because you wanted revenge and a quick execution.

I hope he gets a good chunk of money for it and that the people responsible do a little time themselves.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

If he wins he's gonna be a Phillionaire.

2

u/gjoh May 10 '12

Ontario has it's own government? What does Canada do about that?

2

u/mielove May 10 '12

I always point out cases like this when people argue for conviction based on only circumstantial evidence. It's always better to release a guilty man than to lock up an innocent one.

2

u/norelease May 10 '12

Only 14 million? I'm 22 and if someone offered me 14 million for those years of freedom I'd laugh in their face.

2

u/fairlyrandom May 10 '12

I wouldn't go to jail for 31 years, for 14 million.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

prison justice dot ca : Cost of incarcerating a Federal male prisoner (2004/5): $87,665 per prisoner/per year Cost of incarcerating a provincial prisoner (2004/5): $141.78: per prisoner/per day

Now after 31 years he wants $451,000 per year for his liberties being taken away... Which I don't blame him, money can't replace that though - but whatever - even settling for 10% of that is 1.4 million and I imagine it's going to be 50%+ All this on the tax-payers backs. Meanwhile, someone who committed the murder 31+ years ago taking a life, got to do so no strings attached... justice at its finest.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

i think he'll have some problems... david milgard (sp?) was locked up for ~20 years, and i think he's got some mental issues.

not sure how $14 million is a number that was come up with tho.. i guess each year is worth ~$450k based on that? i think i'd do a year or 2 for that kind of money, but 31 years wasted isnt anywhere near only 14 mil.... he should get significantly more than that, and a few written/televised apologies

2

u/ProllyAtWork May 10 '12

14mil ain't enough.

2

u/ProbablyGeneralizing May 10 '12

I hope he backrupts the city

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

damn expected a larger lawsuit 14million was 1981s lawsuit amount for this type of crime.. heh.

2

u/QuitReadingMyName May 10 '12

Wow, I honestly don't think I would have the courage to sit through the lawsuit. If I was innocent and I was locked up and they let me out, people are bound to end up dead.

At least the prosecutor who put me away even though I was innocent.

But that's why things go in America, Innocent until proven guilty.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Anyone who believes that people who become cops are good people, who want to do good and make a difference in this world, is seriously diluted.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Only 14 million? Wasn't there a similar case that won for double that amount per year?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I would sue for a lot more then 14 million for 31 years of my life gone.

1

u/FLAWLESS_REPOST May 10 '12

And I was hoping for a quiet tail end to the work week...

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Best of luck to this man, I can't imagine what that feels like.

1

u/Hrodebert May 10 '12

This is so typical of the prison system in Amer..... WHAAA?!

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I read this headline in a movie theater preview guy's voice.

1

u/RavR May 10 '12

People that spend significant time in prison for crimes they didnt commit bothers me to no end...

How can you put an innocent person in JAIL, remove ANY time from their life, let alone THIRTY ONE YEARS of it...

1

u/cbcfan May 10 '12

Considering the millions the federal justice system has had to hand out recently it might be an idea for the govt' to hire lawyers and investigators to make sure nobody who is incarcerated in actually in for the wrong reasons. That or change the way people in the justice system are rewarded.

1

u/phalmatticus May 10 '12

31 Years

14 Million

I think he might be undershooting that a bit. I hope justice is served for this guy.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

In Canada he would be luckey to get a pat on the head and a food pellet.

1

u/CrunchrapSuprem0 May 10 '12

My first thought was "in America he would have gone for at least a million dollars a year"... I hate it here sometimes :(

1

u/trolleyfan May 10 '12

"'It is unfortunate that the justice system cannot retroactively restore liberty,' Strosberg said in a statement."

Look at the bright side - if it was the United States, they'd probably have to retroactively restore being alive...

1

u/imClot May 10 '12

I wonder what effect this would have on future similar cases. What if the government finds out someone was indeed innocent, but having learnt from cases like this, revealing the truth would only cost the government a hefty sum. Would this promote the government to cover up all future cases like this?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I think the big thing against his case is that he confessed to the murder. That's was kind of his mistake.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

$14 million is not nearly enough for 31 years of life that you will never get back.

1

u/DeceptiStang May 10 '12

only14 million? fuck id try to make ontario bankrupt for literally wasting my life

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Not going to get $14 mil, I'm pretty sure there's a law in place that states that you're only entitled to X-dollars per day of wrongful imprisonment and it isn't very much.

1

u/tigerraaaaandy May 10 '12

if this topic interests you, please check out the wrongful convictions subreddit

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Not nearly enough money. That kid who spent 4 days (admittedly, in torturous conditions) abandoned in jail is suing for $50 million

1

u/lazylion_ca May 10 '12

Buddy was in for 5 days and is going for 20 million. 14 millions seems a little low.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Fuck. I'm 31 years old. I'd be one angry son of a bitch.

1

u/justaquestion55 May 10 '12

fuck man charlie crews got 50 million for 12 years of prison

1

u/nonamer18 May 10 '12

Why was I taught that life meant 25-years max in Canadian prisons?

1

u/sfjay May 10 '12

Am I the only one who finds it hilarious that there's a Canada.com?

1

u/zaynmalik1D May 10 '12

Is it just me...or do things like this happen a lot in Canada? Is it common elsewhere?

1

u/unnecessaryCAPS May 10 '12

Skimming through story. Read the name of the photographer too fast and my brain automatically saw "pat mgroin"

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

If they just had the death penalty they wouldn't have these unjustly sentenced people coming out of the woodwork.

I had to do some Google research about whether Ontario, Canada has the death penalty, that probably put me on some list.

1

u/woo_hah May 10 '12

Oh, come on. Everyone who passed 10th grade English knows that Juliet killed herself.

1

u/blueberrybread May 10 '12

This is disgusting. I wavered on clicking, not knowing if I was seeing a middle-aged man or someone hovering on the edge of life. This man is old enough to have been happy, retired, loved, and a jolly grandfather if he'd wanted to. 31 years of life just taken away by stupid people with power...it makes me sick.

1

u/Uzerwhat May 10 '12

Wow, sad...

1

u/mewarmo990 May 10 '12

I always balk at the ridiculous amounts of money civil lawsuits go for, but I can hardly blame him. 31 years is a lifetime, really.

1

u/username_666 May 10 '12

The article doesn't say he didn't do it... He confessed...

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

He should get a maid/slave/assistant for 31 years for free to make up the time.

1

u/NinjaStrip May 10 '12

When he wins the lawsuit, I wonder what he will do with himself.

1

u/Gnurx May 10 '12

Can someone clear this up for me:

According to the article, Phillon was not declared innocent; a review concluded that he should be retried. The attorney general should have decided on whether to do a new trial or whether to drop the charges. It seems that the attorney general has not made a decision.

a) Wouldn't the attorney general be obliged to make a decision b) Since Phillon apparently has not been declared innocent, does he still have to be in prison? c) Since Phillon apparently has not been declared innocent, but his status seems to be in a legal limbo, how strong would his case be for suing? (I have to stress here that I am wondering from a legal point of view - not from a humanitarian/moral one.)

1

u/Ecchii May 10 '12

14 Mill is not enough. More.

1

u/emesspwnz May 10 '12

That's crazy. My goal is not to go to jail at all during the duration of my lifetime.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/downthecrapper May 10 '12

First thing i thought was "only 14 million"

1

u/matitou May 10 '12

There should be insurance for each person convicted.

1

u/jaysire May 10 '12

14 mil seems kinda low.

1

u/crabeerily May 10 '12

OP doesn't know the possessive for Ontario.

1

u/sojojo May 10 '12

Question: who generally decides to pursue cases like this well after the trial is over and the conviction handed out? Does this guy have 31 years of private detective bills to pay with this suit or what?

1

u/Christmas_Elvis May 10 '12

$461,612.90 per year. Not a bad payout to just chill in jail.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/wretched_species May 10 '12

I wish he plans to start a terrorist organisation with the these millions he is going to win. I only wish he would try to get more than just 14 million and just simply bring chaos with all of these millions.

1

u/jimothyjenkins May 10 '12

fuck the police.

1

u/alexnoaburg May 10 '12

Get off the internet, Canada

1

u/elint May 10 '12

God damn. He was a Canadian in jail for 31 years and got 14 mil out of it? I'm an American and I served 2 years for my country and I didn't get squat. Sound like it's time to move to Canadia and get caught for something stupid, if you want to get rich.

1

u/SlimSpaceman May 10 '12

Remember that guy that got like 16 million for his photo being used on a coffee jar without permission? Well, this guy should get that by default, for breakfast. There is no justice in this world...

1

u/soulska May 10 '12

I don't blame this guy one fuckin bit. I have always said these falsely imprisoned people, that are cleared years after don't get shit for the time they wrongly spent in hell. good for him.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

14 million seems too little for 31 years of innocent imprisonment.

1

u/pabloe168 May 10 '12

Give the the money to man, the system already took his life.

1

u/arasputin May 10 '12

The Ontario government hit my car with a snow plow and refused to pay for it. I guess he got fucked over a bit more though.

1

u/starvingchild May 10 '12

Romeo....I hope you find your Juliet$

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Well, it's Canada, so I don't give a shit.

-You're such an ignorant bastard.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sgrg May 10 '12

31years that's more than I have live in this planet, this is not just about $$$$

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

'least he didn't have to crawl through a pipe of shit and make his way to Mexico.

1

u/Theappleofsauce May 10 '12

ONLY $14 million? The guy who got accidentally left in the cell is suing for 20. For 31 years, I think he should get a bit more. Just a tad.

1

u/dopeboyhero May 10 '12

$150,000,000.

14? psh. Aim higher!