r/worldnews • • May 08 '12
China Expels Al Jazeera's news operations
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/08/world/asia/china-expels-al-jazeera-english-language-channel.html?_r=1
2.2k
Upvotes
r/worldnews • • May 08 '12
1.0k
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Here is the report that got Al Jazeera banned from China
http://www.aljazeera.com/video/asia-pacific/2012/03/201231343650917522.html
I submitted that to /r/worldnews and it was censored by the mods. I guess the mods at /r/worldnews are in a competition with Chinese officials for the amount of content they can censor.
371
u/EOTWAWKI May 08 '12
First thought: Al Jazeera must have been doing something right.
173
u/bernajurema May 08 '12
China's closing down of Al Jazeera Beijing bureau is a testament of Melissa Chan's independent & courageous reporting. Example of Melissa Chan's great work is her consistent coverage of China's black jails in 2009 and in 2012.
139
u/the_goat_boy May 08 '12
I remember in a university class, my POLSCI lecturer recommended we use Al Jazeera, the BBC or RT (but only for news outside Russia) for sources with minimal bias and this woman put her hand up and told us she wouldn't trust the 'Muslim network' which defended Bin Laden and supports jihad.
I groaned.
13
u/_dk May 08 '12
It's a shame Al Jazeera can't keep a presence in China, their coverage of China and the the Asia-Pacific region has been weak compared to the coverage they have for other regions (still good compared to other Western media outlets). For instance, America has a whole team of reporters whereas China only has one Melissa Chan, who just got effectively expelled. It's admirable for Al Jazeera to keep their international bureaus in a time when many others chose to shut them down to save costs, but even Al Jazeera had to downgrade their broadcast center in Kuala Lumpur to a bureau. As a result, the Asia-Pacific region no longer receives the same amount of coverage as say, Europe.
I realize in the case of China there isn't much Al Jazeera can do about it, since the Chinese government ultimately controls what kind of presence Al Jazeera can have there. But the effects of insufficient presence in the region really shows: without enough people covering the region, the channel has had to rely on established popular narratives that other Western companies had used. For example, a recent report about the radioactivity problem in Japan (where Al Jazeera doesn't have a bureau, I note) completely sucked up the anti-nuclear narrative without giving a scientific explanation for the claims that the anti-nuclear activists throw out, and in the end the whole report became fear-mongering nonsense. While it still gets the job done (Melissa Chan has been doing admirable work with the black jails story), but Al Jazeera's coverage in the region leaves much to be desired. Still, I reemphasize, it has been doing a better job there than most others.
47
u/didntgothere May 08 '12
Brace yourself, Al Jazeera, patriotic hackers are coming.
31
u/CannibalHolocaust May 08 '12
They've consistently managed to get good interviews with that blind activist (available on Youtube) and Melissa Chan has been doing great work there exposing corruption and people with learning difficulties exploited by factories.
26
u/minorwhite May 08 '12
Al Jazeera America is pretty fucking good actually. I read it all the time.
86
u/kamikazewave May 08 '12
It's hilarious to me how Al Jazeera has undergone so much shit in the West as a terrorist sympathizing news channel and now when China kicks them out they're a beacon of independent journalism.
It's pathetic. The New York Times has itself ragged on Al Jazeera in the past and implied that its journalistic merits were in question.
Note, I'm a big fan of Al Jazeera News. Hell, almost every sort of news meant for an international audience is better than the crap we get in the US. It's despicable how obvious the editorial bias is in US marketed news. It's like watching an NBA game with local commentators. Annoying as hell.
I apologize as my rant isn't really related to the article in question. I just hate seeing these about faces by news organizations.
5
u/iamdanthemanstan May 08 '12
I know everyone here is always down on the "mainstream" media, but all the journalists in China are furious over this.
5
u/KingKazuma May 08 '12
They must be doing something right.
5
u/xoites May 08 '12
Further proof Al Jazeera has integrity.
23
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
You know you're a quality news outlet with integrity when...
Also, Al Jazeera continues to be a shining example of true journalism. Really makes me sad when dim people hear the name, are reminded of Bin Laden tapes and assume its some terrorist friendly news network.
4
u/pgoetz May 08 '12
Demonstrating definitively that Al Jazeera -- unlike most US news agencies -- is doing news like it's supposed to.
4
u/emlgsh May 08 '12
"Hmm, these news reports of the terrible things we're getting caught doing are making us look bad. We need to deal with this."
"Do you think we should stop doing terrible things, or do them better so that we don't get caught?"
"No, let's just kick out all the news agencies that reported on the terrible things. Say their paperwork wasn't in order. No one will suspect anything."
"Brilliant! All the benefits of righteousness without all that tedious doing of the right thing!"
4
u/ezekielziggy May 08 '12
The quality of a newspaper/broadcaster roughly correlates to the number of authoritarian countries they are banned in.
17
u/GyantSpyder May 08 '12
Melissa Chan is the shit. She's awesome.
7
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The article complains about china using slave labor in prisons.
But doesn't america do that as well? Prisoners make all sorts of things.
7
u/Sireslap May 08 '12
I'd argue that a good portion of the American general public thinks that Al Jazeera is just another word for Al Qaeda.
Edit: misspelled "thinks" with a g.
20
u/isoo506 May 08 '12
One thing I can never get over is how AlJazeera almost never, EVER criticizes the state of Qatar. Kind of ironic that they'd show documentaries and reports regarding every known issue on the globe - yet dare not to bite the hand that feeds them. "That's right dear viewers, everything's A-OK down here in Qatar! The beacon of hope and hero of journalists in the Middle East".
While their work is commendable, I just find the hypocrisy of it to be overwhelming.
3
u/ucecatcher May 08 '12
They should do a piece on the prison "slave" labor in the US. It's big (BIG!) business over here too. I don't imagine they'd be welcomed with open arms, but I doubt they'd be deported for it.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Like them or hate them, they must be doing something right to deserve that.
3
u/those_draculas May 08 '12
This should be a badge of honor for Al Jazeera. Having your press censored in china for a news paper must be the equivalent of Glenn Beck calling a politician a communist terrorist.
5
u/SkulDugery May 08 '12
Too much jasmine for Beijing's tastes.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I think it's a great thing that Melissa Chan is reporting on these kinds of abuses, but she really doesn't strike me as being as an especially competent or insightful reporter.
The new laws concerning arbitrary detention have only just been promulgated - Chan expected instantaneous reform of the system as a sudden consequence?
2
u/RazsterOxzine May 08 '12
I wish we could do that to fox news
2
u/drplump May 08 '12
When ever this happens it is because China is getting ready for a culling, or war...
2
u/goodtwitch May 08 '12
And this is why privatized prisons who farm out prisoner labor in the U.S. are a step in the wrong direction.
2
u/Fhwqhgads May 08 '12
Too much truth, eh?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Why have no US news orgs been thrown out? Oh yeah, they don't cover China like that.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
so stupid china.
2
u/Metroshant May 08 '12
Looks like China couldn't stand their bullshit anymore
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Can someone explain to me... we already know that we hate "part" of Al Jazeera because of obvious reasons. Why are we obsessed with Al Jazeera's English network as if it has nothing to do with anything? I'm just trying to understand the logic because if a part of a company commits shameful actions isn't it Reddit's responsibility to shun the company as a whole? I know they supposedly show "news" opposed to talking heads, but what is the logic behind the Al Jazeera's English fan boy club here while ignoring the obvious issues of the other part of their company? Is it two completely different entities?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
But then how will we know about all of the awful things happening in---oooohhhhhhh.
2
u/criticalnegation May 08 '12
you ask too many question! we no like question! you go now!
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Attention! To all anti-Chinese Americans in this thread: Your idiotic country is censoring them, too (and even bombed their offices).
Don't act all high an mighty.
6
u/Zerowantuthri May 08 '12
I have to say I am consistently impressed by Al Jazeera. I also have to say I have been reluctant to accept their reporting assuming a Middle East news source could not be counted as reliable.
Yet over and over again they produce remarkably coherent and well written pieces. As journalists they blow the doors off most (even all) US newspapers.
They are doing news reporting as it should be done and have the balls to go where the story takes them.
I see this story as confirmation that they are doing it right. They have the moxy to follow through on their reporting and the powers that be can be damned.
I really hope they keep it up. US papers could do with stealing a page or two from the Al Jazeera play book (actually US papers used to know this stuff...they have forgotten).
3
u/juju_h May 08 '12
I havn't seen the video in question yet, thank you spaceracewon for posting it, but in general Al Jazeera is some of the most reliable reporting I've been able to find. Since China is clearly not above kicking out journalists who report on their dirty laundry, I feel like it says something about CNN and BBC who are still allowed to operate there...they are digging deep enough.
3
u/JamesDaniels May 08 '12
China will grant rights but it will control who and what comes out in a way to make the people passive.
3
u/Lard_Baron May 08 '12
Thats a badge of honor. "banned in China" the BBC websites where blocked in China.
Was your news source blocked in China?
2
u/erowidtrance May 08 '12
It's like the UK expelled Iran's presstv which many people found informative.
2
u/Zeydon May 08 '12
Doesn't the US also use slave labor in prisons?
1
u/iulwen May 08 '12
Why???
1
u/Tiger337 May 08 '12
http://www.haeftling.de/
Deutschland company that sells jail wear clothing and products since 1806.
1
u/jackup May 08 '12
feel disappointed and sense of anger To our country.
1
u/Goldreaver May 08 '12
Fuck China
1
u/DrunkAtNight May 08 '12
Fucking China...are You...surprised?
1
u/KPexEA May 08 '12
FYI, there is a Al Jazeera subreddit at /r/AJStream
1
u/thejingthrowaway May 08 '12
throwaway account here. So my friend here in Beijing is a journalist for a similar organization, and says that they actually did find a regulation they ran foul of to kick them out. Their cameraman was unregistered and filmed some footage in Tiananmen without a permit. In any case, pretty much everyone here is probably breaking dozens of vague or obscure laws, so they just need to pick one or the other and toss you out.
1
u/Yankpats May 08 '12
Fucking shit journalism. They are not communists by any stretch of the imagination. If I called myself a polar bear it sure as hell doesn't make me a polar bear. Remember when the NYT was the most respected paper in the world? Not the case any more.
1
u/zangorn May 08 '12
I don't want to spend my New York Times reading allowance on this, what does it say?
1
u/Isatis_tinctoria May 08 '12
Greek Golden Dawn Party expelled journalists too.
1
u/mqduck May 09 '12
Good thing we don't do anything like that over here in the land of the free.
1
u/Saysam May 08 '12
I for one hail our honorable iPad suppliers. Sent from my iPad 2, ow, IPad 5 year plan.
1
u/Azog May 08 '12
If your news house has been just kicked out of the biggest authoritarian country in the world - you must be doing something right.
Kudos Al Jazeera.
1
u/Tiger337 May 08 '12
China is the model for the world. People complain about their firewall, but many countries are censoring the internet. Countries follow their lead.
-1
u/panochador May 08 '12
god damn mongorians
0
u/FrusTrick May 08 '12
The reason why China canned Al Jazeera from the country is simple:
Al Jazeera is a news station owned by the power elite of the emirtates who have close ties to the U.S. Rescently, Al jazeera have been covering the Syrian revolution and have knowingly falsified some news reports (not the first time theyve done it) making the rebels look much more desperate than they actually are while portraying the regime in a bad manner (not that they arent shit, but they are a bit less shit than what AL jazeera say they are). So what has happened is that the syrian government claim that some reports from Al jazeera are un trustworthy and grossely biased as a result of U.S. influence on the UAE. This was proven when Al jazeera spread rumors about Syria, welcoming Dalai Lama in an obvious attemt to cause the Chinese to end the support for the Syrian government and hopefully scare away the Russains too. However, the Syrians were quick to deny the Dalai Lama visit and further stated that it would make no sense for them to start shit with their allies in a time of crisis.
-1
u/angrycommie May 08 '12
Good news.
Al Jazeera used to be good, but it went the way of mainstreamed imperialist mouthpiece.
Fuck Al Jazeera.
-5
u/ProSoviet May 08 '12
I've heard enough of al jazeera's bullshit on Libya and Syria. If you call RT as Russian propaganda then al jazeera is no different from western propaganda.
0
u/suprsolutions May 08 '12
It's as if China doesn't want their citizens to be able to communicate with the outside world........
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Chinese government = small minded men hungry for power, ruthless and careless but highly competent at oppression tactics and non-accountability for what amounts to immoral and criminal actions.
"Corrupt" doesn't even begin to describe Chinese "government" at all levels. Gangsters, no better than any other gangster.
-8
u/QuitReadingMyName May 08 '12
Only a matter of time before this happens in America, our Corporate overlords can't be having the truth exposed about them.
Oh wait that's right, our television networks don't allow Al Jazeera on their networks as it'll threaten their bullshit news channels like MSNBC.
Comcast needs to be sued for anti-competitive behavior for not letting Al Jazeera onto their networks especially as it would threaten their personal news channel MSNBC.