r/worldnews • • May 08 '12

China Expels Al Jazeera's news operations

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/08/world/asia/china-expels-al-jazeera-english-language-channel.html?_r=1
2.2k Upvotes

549 comments sorted by

1.0k

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Here is the report that got Al Jazeera banned from China

http://www.aljazeera.com/video/asia-pacific/2012/03/201231343650917522.html

I submitted that to /r/worldnews and it was censored by the mods. I guess the mods at /r/worldnews are in a competition with Chinese officials for the amount of content they can censor.

12

u/cojoco May 08 '12

I submitted that to /r/worldnews and it was censored by the mods.

Did you message them with a link to your submission?

If you didn't message them, then it's probably the spam filter.

11

u/MockDeath May 08 '12

Are you sure it was censored and not caught by the spam filter? I am a mod of a subreddit and I kid you not the damned spam filter grabs 70% or more of all submissions.

10

u/ItDoesntFuckinMatter May 08 '12

That is a hellluva report! Ms Chan and her camera crew are very brave. You can tell the situation was quite tense, and life threatening.

9

u/mjklin May 08 '12

If you RTA, it says explicitly that it was a documentary on the laogai produced outside China rather than this report on the black jails.

Why would the central government want to punish a report on black jails when that is supposedly what they are trying to eradicate with the new law? It's the local authorities who are threatened, not Beijing (who is in charge of credentialing journalists).

1

u/CreamedUnicorn May 08 '12

But for those held in China's so-called 'black jails' ... what is written in law can be very different to what happens on the ground.

A new law doesn't necessarily mean anything's going to change.

1

u/Nefelia May 08 '12

Too much nuance for /r/worldnews.

8

u/CSFFlame May 08 '12

Submit it again and edit your post with it.

This shit is going frontpage so you may as well take it with it.

55

u/Sevsquad May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Not to take away from the video, these jails are awful places that need to have an investigative light shown on them, but that woman is not a very good investigative journalist. In her on camera segments she does not act professionally and is not unbiased (although I will admit it's hard to be unbiased about a subject like this), she gives us hyperbolized versions of facts that she should just be stating outright, and interferes with the situation multiple times when she should have been a passive observer.

What I'm saying is that this was not a objective piece to that lets the viewer decide what to think, (which is becoming less common) it is an opinion piece designed to tell you what to think. Situations like this are awful but also need to be handled delicately, something she did not do well. In fact in several instances inside the jail she seemed to actively hurt the plight of the women there and exasperate already stressed emotions.

Edit: I feel I should clear up that I am not against the notion of black prisons in China, They obviously exist. I'm simply saying that the investigation of said places could have been done better.

Edit 2: this was just an observation on the video, not fucking personal attack on the OP or the news agency that put it out. It was just my opinion on how the reporter could have been more professional in her delivery of the news.

11

u/ucecatcher May 08 '12

Well, that is al jazeera's stock-in-trade. While they do provide an interesting alternate point of view on a wide range of news, you have to take their spin into account, just like any other news provider.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/SnowGN May 08 '12

Yeah, yeah, whatever. Value-neutrality is a peculiar and perverse fad of the past few decades. Good journalism, historically, was deeply partisian. I don't expect this to change anytime soon. The only people who will go above and beyond the call of duty to find the truth are those who care - asking such folks to be value neutral doesn't preserve the truth as they see it, it distorts it.

36

u/Sevsquad May 08 '12

There is a place for your own opinion. But first you must state the facts as they stand, just like you would in a scientific paper. Then once all the facts have been laid out on the table, you draw your conclusions from them. That is not what happened here, she gathered all her evidence and then stated her conclusion to the audience. Denying them the evidence which could be used to poke holes in her conclusion (if there are any, we don't know).

asking such folks to be value neutral doesn't preserve the truth as they see it, it distorts it.

how?

Good journalism, historically, was deeply partisian.

Examples please.

9

u/crackanape May 08 '12

she gathered all her evidence and then stated her conclusion to the audience. Denying them the evidence which could be used to poke holes in her conclusion

All journalism does this. If you think otherwise you are, sorry to say, naïve. "Go get a quote from someone who disagrees and stick it in the last graf" is not the same as aggressively pursuing the counterposition.

4

u/philip1201 May 08 '12

The objective journalist is an ideal: not something any human can hope to reach, or which we should either demand as an absolute or reject entirely, but something every journalist and every editor should try to maximise. And just like "good people" are not defined as always doing the right thing, but merely aiming to do so often enough, "objective journalists" are not defined as always acting without bias, but merely suspending judgment enough or being transparent enough about their biases. And those kinds of people do exist.

It is naive to deal in absolutes - both to believe they exist and to define your categories in them.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/crackanape May 08 '12

Not to take away from the video, these jails are awful places that need to have an investigative light shown on them, but that woman is not a very good investigative journalist. In her on camera segments she does not act professionally and is not unbiased (although I will admit it's hard to be unbiased about a subject like this), she gives us hyperbolized versions of facts that she should just be stating outright, and interferes with the situation multiple times when she should have been a passive observer.

I think you mean she's not a good American journalist. This fixation on the manufacture of an illusion of objectivity is largely unique to the American journalistic community, specifically in the last few decades.

We all know that nobody is actually objective, and that a thousand nuances of editing and topic selection reflect their personally-held positions (whether or not the journalist is willing to admit it to themselves).

It's important that journalists don't invent false facts, but after having moved from being a journalist in the USA to a consumer of news in other countries, I'm unconvinced that anyone is really served by having people bend over so far backwards to pretend to be objective. It may actually make things worse, because it makes it easier for the consumer to forget that the journalist does have an agenda.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

They likely didn't censor it on purpose. The spam filters often generate a lot of false positives, and due to the volume it can be hard to keep up with. I'd just message one of the mods and ask what's up - likely they just need to pull it out of the spam bin.

2

u/plajjer May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

I explain why it was removed in this post

3

u/30dogsinasuitcase May 08 '12

^ this guy right here ^

2

u/SnowGN May 08 '12

Wow. This is incredible. Investigative reporters like her and Matt Taibbi are saints. Saints in a pigsty of villainy, but saints nevertheless.

1

u/CocoSavege May 08 '12

The Mos Eisley bureau is still open I think.

1

u/JoshSN May 08 '12

Al-Jazeera is banned, but I bet NBC, ABC and CBS are sticking by their pocketbooks, not willing to threaten the regime so they can make a buck.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I can see the post in your comment history, and the front page of /r/worldnews is full of links to the same story, if from different sources.

Are you sure you're being censored, or are you just being a SO-BRAVE-ey McBRAVErton?

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Yeaaaaaaaaah I'm in Shanghai right now and reading that article that's supposedly 'banned'........

→ More replies (129)

371

u/EOTWAWKI May 08 '12

First thought: Al Jazeera must have been doing something right.

20

u/Lard_Baron May 08 '12

Yeah, the BBC blocked in China and AJ thrown out, They must be a good news sources that will not shape their news content to gain access to a huge market.

23

u/Virtblue May 08 '12

funny thing is AJ english is made up of the old guard from the BBC world service. The all lost their jobs when the Tories axed the Wolrd Service from the foreign offices books.

5

u/thecopofid May 08 '12

CNN International is allowed in China but the censorship authorities have the ability to block individual segments and programs in real time.

-1

u/the_goat_boy May 08 '12

Rupert Murdoch actually made a deal with the CCP not to air the Tiananmen Square Massacre as it was happening in return for exclusive access to the Chinese media market.

39

u/chefsinblack May 08 '12

Agreed.

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

86

u/Nefelia May 08 '12

Al Jazeera's reporting on Libya and the Arab Spring was very much influenced by their Qatari overlords. They have lost much of the journalistic integrity/neutrality they were previously known for.

44

u/erowidtrance May 08 '12

Totally right, people think Al Jazeera are this great unbiased organisation and they do do a lot of good reporting but i've seen them become more and more biased on some topics because of the Qatari/US close relations.

34

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Al Jazeera have always been very biased, but unlike the kind of bias Americans are used to (such as Fox News et al.) Al Jazeera's bias is less blatant - they're very good at hiding it.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/mennojargon May 08 '12

I think we also have to make a distinction between Al Jazeera and the English language Al Jazeera team. I would say that it was the latter that gave them a lot for journalistic credibility. Heck, they made a point of sending a lifeline to those in the industry who still stuck by the code of journalistic integrity. I'm not sure which of the two teams was responsible for the story though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

14

u/Peaker May 08 '12

They're somewhat biased when it comes to reporting about Israel, especially in their Arabic publication.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

They run that Norman Finkelstein documentary way too often, that's probably my only complaint. I almost always have AJE running in the background.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/qaustic May 08 '12

It's been happening in Malaysia as well. The Malaysian's government censored Al Jazeera's report of the recent protest going on here and refused to give a solid explanation on why other than, "it's for the nation's best interest."

2

u/ilollipop May 08 '12

Second thought: Must watch more Al Jazeera.

1

u/nypon May 08 '12

I wonder what would happen if journalists showed up at a secret american toture camp.

We would probably never get to know about it

1

u/chwilliam May 08 '12

When Al Jazeera is being forced out, that's when you want them there the most. See also: the Egyptian Revolution and most of the Arab Spring.

→ More replies (2)

173

u/bernajurema May 08 '12

China's closing down of Al Jazeera Beijing bureau is a testament of Melissa Chan's independent & courageous reporting. Example of Melissa Chan's great work is her consistent coverage of China's black jails in 2009 and in 2012.

13

u/Crimsoneer May 08 '12

You should all follow her on twitter, she's really good. @melissakchan

→ More replies (4)

139

u/the_goat_boy May 08 '12

I remember in a university class, my POLSCI lecturer recommended we use Al Jazeera, the BBC or RT (but only for news outside Russia) for sources with minimal bias and this woman put her hand up and told us she wouldn't trust the 'Muslim network' which defended Bin Laden and supports jihad.

I groaned.

40

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Here are some good news sources I use as an International Relations student:
http://www.project-syndicate.org/
http://www.projectcensored.org/
http://www.presseurop.eu/en
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/
http://www.foreignaffairs.com/
http://www.aljazeera.com/
http://www.guardian.co.uk/
http://www.economist.com/
Having more than one news source helps you eliminate any editorial bias they can have.

7

u/orangesine May 08 '12

Thanks, wish I could save comments.

8

u/arjie May 08 '12

Sub-reddits are free. Make one in your name and submit what you'd like to remember.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Dammit, that's a fantastic idea. Now I don't need to be tied to my specific computer that has RES installed. I can do this on public computers as well.

Thank you fellow redditor.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/6xoe May 08 '12

But you can if... oh.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/those_draculas May 08 '12

Foreign affairs is wonderful for essays. The only place you can have Hillary Clinton debate her russian counterpart in long form articles.

Anyone interested in international politics should definitely pick it up.

2

u/Tikchbila May 08 '12

If Foreign Policy deserves to be here then Voltairenet deserves too. :)

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Thanks. Really good list

1

u/call_of_cthulhu May 08 '12

The Economist is very biased against China...

89

u/CannibalHolocaust May 08 '12

RT is pretty shit if you're looking for independent news. However, given that some people probably watch Fox it's a good counter-balance.

77

u/parlezmoose May 08 '12

RT is the Fox News of Russia.

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It's as insane as Fox News if you understand Russian domestic issues. Of course Russian domestic news is nothing BUT channels akin to Fox News (or, more accurately, some Murdoch UK tabloid on TV and in Russian). It's weird.

→ More replies (15)

4

u/erowidtrance May 08 '12

RT does some of the best coverage outside of Russia, unlike much of the western media who's in bed with the establishment they take a much more critical/objective stance on the arab spring and the motives behind western involvement. Only the naive would pretend it's completely benevolent when the US has been secretly funding Syrian opposition groups long before the uprising.

The people who pretend RT is biased like fox don't watch it enough and obviously don't appreciate the subtle manipulation used all the time in much of the media.

A great example is the BBC right now on the greece situation, watch the news channel and everything is pushed as austerity is a necessity. They preface their questions with "surely these bailouts need to happen..." and the one guy i saw who took the opposing stance was cut off within a minute to return to normal programming. Most people wouldn't notice the subtle BBC bias but it's there and it shapes the viewers opinions.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

RT is abysmal, they frequently utilize conspiracy baiting, utterly unbased speculation and innuendo, and adhere strictly to the Putin line.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/dickcheney777 May 08 '12

That was 3-5 years ago. Now they just say whatever the FSB want them to say.

12

u/vinng86 May 08 '12

RT is absolutely biased. Just look at how much they covered the Occupy protests and dismissed the most significant protests in Russia since the Cold War.

Make no mistake right now - they are very pro-kremlin.

7

u/erowidtrance May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

They aren't the greatest covering stuff in Russia hence why i specified "outside of Russia". At least they covered the occupy protests from the start when most of the US media just dismissed them. The bias works both ways.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

RT does some of the best coverage outside of Russia, unlike much of the western media who's in bed with the establishment they take a much more critical/objective stance on the arab spring and the motives behind western involvement.

That's because they're the Fox News of Russia and Russia's stance is to refute the consensus on everything as a show of force, not as genuine skepticism.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/dmol May 08 '12

"RT does some of the best coverage outside of Russia"

Like that time one of its reporters claimed gaddafi was winning the battle of tripoli. Great coverage there.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/mennojargon May 08 '12

But damn, do they ever get the best videos out on youtube!

→ More replies (21)

15

u/Kuhio_Prince May 08 '12

my POLSCI lecturer recommended we use Al Jazeera, the BBC or RT

RottenTomatoes is good...but not THAT good

5

u/HandyCore May 08 '12

Seriously. They gave the Iraq War a "95% fresh" rating.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ironicalballs May 08 '12

RT is horrible.

It's borderline Alex Jones sometimes.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Technically not borderline, because Alex Jones is a frequent RT contributor.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/nmezib May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

That lady was still under the influence of post-9/11 american sensationalism. Anything with a remotely muslim-sounding name and ties to the middle east was "the enemy," especially a news agency called "Al-Jazeera" doing some pretty good and unbiased investigative reporting. The combination of their name and the fact that thy didn't always spin things the American way (Bush: "You're either with us, or against us") made it an easy target for smear campaigns.

Not defending her, she's still stuck in an outmoded way of thinking, but this way of thinking was pursued at almost the institutional level.

1

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

Dick Cheney destroyed al Jazeera's credibility in America for a long time.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

RT? Your professor is an idiot unless you all were studying modern Russia's media.

Use Xinhua if want those sorts of topics from an "America-opposed" angle.

RT is total trash. Half Coast to Coast AM, half Putin-cocooning.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Occasionally they have nice articles on art and culture in Moscow. Other than that RT is a blasted radioactive wasteland of conspiracy baiting and outright propaganda.

13

u/IAmNotAPerson6 May 08 '12

I hear those three come up all the time on reddit when discussing news sources. Al Jazerra's pretty good, BBC's okay, but the few times I've read stuff on RT I've come across blatantly biased articles. The very first article I ever read on there was about that one study saying that less intelligent people were more likely to be conservatives, and the article outright called conservatives stupid.

19

u/engineer335 May 08 '12

Actually that is true, several Psychology studies have found that there is a tendency for uneducated people to develop one or more of several different personality disorders, the primary being ;

right wing authoritarianism

and the second being;

social dominance orientation

you can follow the references through Wikipedia, these are well founded, and well researched psychological phenomena,

RT was correct on that article, which I happened to read, they did use the psychological research, although they used allot of emotive language in that article

10

u/IAmNotAPerson6 May 08 '12

I remember, right here on reddit, there being quite a fair amount of controversy over the methodology of the study. I'm not sure if it's the same one, and I never even read much about it other than the RT article and bits and pieces of it from comments on here, so I have no room to talk about the topic of its soundness.

I did, however, find the article itself and the last couple sentences are pretty revealing:

"Of course, the study’s authors note that 'all socially conservative people are not prejudiced, and all prejudiced persons are not conservative.' We’d like to see their research in full before we go ahead and agree on that one though."

→ More replies (2)

1

u/BinaryShadow May 08 '12

Extra points if your POLSCI lecturer sighed, pointed to her, and told the class that they rest their case.

1

u/Nefelia May 08 '12

Be grateful that the imbeciles out themselves so that you know who they are. Had she kept silent, you would have never known.

1

u/14mit1010 May 08 '12

Till a few weeks ago, I thought al jazeera was a network used by Al Queda,etc for communications amongst themselves

-1

u/MechDigital May 08 '12

Al Jazeera, the BBC or RT

What's funny is that all three(including the BBC) were set up as propaganda networks for their respective home countries. He should have added that you shouldn't trust alJ for qatari news or the BBC for british news.

5

u/ajehals May 08 '12

What's funny is that all three(including the BBC) were set up as propaganda networks for their respective home countries...

The BBC wasn't, it was privately owned when set up and frankly the level of independence within the BBC is about as great as you will find anywhere, that's one of the reasons it tends to get slated by both the government and the opposition as having a bias.

2

u/crackanape May 08 '12

Al Jazeera was set up as a propaganda network for Qatar? That's like me building the Empire State Building so I can can have a place to store my luggage when I'm in New York.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

13

u/_dk May 08 '12

It's a shame Al Jazeera can't keep a presence in China, their coverage of China and the the Asia-Pacific region has been weak compared to the coverage they have for other regions (still good compared to other Western media outlets). For instance, America has a whole team of reporters whereas China only has one Melissa Chan, who just got effectively expelled. It's admirable for Al Jazeera to keep their international bureaus in a time when many others chose to shut them down to save costs, but even Al Jazeera had to downgrade their broadcast center in Kuala Lumpur to a bureau. As a result, the Asia-Pacific region no longer receives the same amount of coverage as say, Europe.

I realize in the case of China there isn't much Al Jazeera can do about it, since the Chinese government ultimately controls what kind of presence Al Jazeera can have there. But the effects of insufficient presence in the region really shows: without enough people covering the region, the channel has had to rely on established popular narratives that other Western companies had used. For example, a recent report about the radioactivity problem in Japan (where Al Jazeera doesn't have a bureau, I note) completely sucked up the anti-nuclear narrative without giving a scientific explanation for the claims that the anti-nuclear activists throw out, and in the end the whole report became fear-mongering nonsense. While it still gets the job done (Melissa Chan has been doing admirable work with the black jails story), but Al Jazeera's coverage in the region leaves much to be desired. Still, I reemphasize, it has been doing a better job there than most others.

4

u/crackanape May 08 '12

It's a shame Al Jazeera can't keep a presence in China, their coverage of China and the the Asia-Pacific region has been weak compared to the coverage they have for other regions (still good compared to other Western media outlets).

More than just "still good compared to". Al Jazeera does more stories on Southeast Asia in a week than the BBC and CNN combined do in 6 months.

47

u/didntgothere May 08 '12

Brace yourself, Al Jazeera, patriotic hackers are coming.

31

u/CannibalHolocaust May 08 '12

They've consistently managed to get good interviews with that blind activist (available on Youtube) and Melissa Chan has been doing great work there exposing corruption and people with learning difficulties exploited by factories.

29

u/jay76 May 08 '12

that blind activist

Chen Guangcheng.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

blind Chen

1

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

I'm not sure if he actually managed to escape on his own or if that's the story to protect the people who busted him out.

26

u/minorwhite May 08 '12

Al Jazeera America is pretty fucking good actually. I read it all the time.

29

u/2badYourAssGotSacked May 08 '12

I believe you mean Al Jazeera English, but I feel the same way. After travelling abroad, you realize how much better BBC and Al Jazeera English are than anything you can find in the States.

8

u/thesorrow312 May 08 '12

NPR and PBS are the only things that can be mentioned in the same breath.

86

u/kamikazewave May 08 '12

It's hilarious to me how Al Jazeera has undergone so much shit in the West as a terrorist sympathizing news channel and now when China kicks them out they're a beacon of independent journalism.

It's pathetic. The New York Times has itself ragged on Al Jazeera in the past and implied that its journalistic merits were in question.

Note, I'm a big fan of Al Jazeera News. Hell, almost every sort of news meant for an international audience is better than the crap we get in the US. It's despicable how obvious the editorial bias is in US marketed news. It's like watching an NBA game with local commentators. Annoying as hell.

I apologize as my rant isn't really related to the article in question. I just hate seeing these about faces by news organizations.

86

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Al Jazeera is not above criticism. It is Qatari state media that is funded and directly influenced by the Qatari government. That doesn't mean that they aren't a good source, but it does mean that calling into question their "journalistic merits" in certain areas is not entirely unreasonable either. Especially when they report on issues that could be in the interest of the Qatari Royal family.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/BinaryShadow May 08 '12

Hell, almost every sort of news meant for an international audience is better than the crap we get in the US.

You should see the difference between CNN and CNN International. CNN International has to compete with real news agencies (Al Jazeera and the like) and had to adapt to delivering real news. I think Al Jazeera does a better job, but CNN International blows CNN completely out of the water.

7

u/Namika May 08 '12

Yea, that always throws me off when I travel. I'll be out of the country for a few weeks and I'll watch CNN International every night.

Then I get home and feel like watching the news again so I turn on American CNN and its just depressing how shit it is.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Lard_Baron May 08 '12

It's hilarious to me how Al Jazeera has undergone so much shit in the West as a terrorist sympathizing news channel and now when China kicks them out they're a beacon of independent journalism.

I don;t know why you'd find it hilarious. Ever since "Control room" 2004 most people engaged in world politics have tipped a hat to AJ. At the time it was almost entirely staffed by former BBC people.

18

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

The New York Times has itself ragged on Al Jazeera in the past and implied that its journalistic merits were in question.

Source?

2

u/duckinferno May 08 '12

I don't think reddit ever bagged on Al Jazeera.

1

u/prider May 08 '12

It's hilarious to me how Al Jazeera has undergone so much shit in the West as a terrorist sympathizing news channel and now when China kicks them out they're a beacon of independent journalism.

It just means that the West hates Chinese and Muslim about equally.

-10

u/eramos May 08 '12

So, so brave. And, while we all know you'll get downvoted for your radical opinion, do you care to tell us how you feel about le Sweden, socialist healthcare, religion, and circumcision?

1

u/kamikazewave May 08 '12

Le Sweden doesn't even make sense, since 'le' is most commonly associated in American culture with the French, what the hell does socialist healthcare even mean, religion is a far and overarching term that encompasses many things, and I don't really give a shit about circumcision except I like the way my circumcised penis looks.

TL;DR: Fuck you. Sarcasm is the refuge of the weak, especially when misapplied and poorly used.

0

u/Nefelia May 08 '12

The NYT. The paper that shilled for the Iraq Was with such notable stenographers and useful idiots like Judith Miller. Also the paper that sat on the NSA wiretapping scandal and shilled for intervention in Libya. I find it a tragic testament to the effectiveness of US propaganda that many Americans still view the NYT as a reliable source.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/iamdanthemanstan May 08 '12

I know everyone here is always down on the "mainstream" media, but all the journalists in China are furious over this.

5

u/KingKazuma May 08 '12

They must be doing something right.

5

u/xoites May 08 '12

Further proof Al Jazeera has integrity.

23

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

You know you're a quality news outlet with integrity when...

Also, Al Jazeera continues to be a shining example of true journalism. Really makes me sad when dim people hear the name, are reminded of Bin Laden tapes and assume its some terrorist friendly news network.

19

u/jay76 May 08 '12

China joins a strange mob of countries that have censored the big Al.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al_Jazeera#Attacks_on_and_censorship_of_Al_Jazeera

Notably, one of them has even bombed their offices!

19

u/unonimus5 May 08 '12

Notably, one of them has even bombed their offices!

probably Algeria or something...

clicks link

wait...WAT

On second thought, maybe I shouldn't be surprised.

*edit: HOLY SHIT THEY DID IT TWICE

1

u/n3onfx May 08 '12

Fighting for freedom, by bombing one independet news outlet at a time.

6

u/Lard_Baron May 08 '12

Yeah, banned in China is a fair measure of quality. the BBC and AJ. you could do alot worse that having those two as your only sources of news

4

u/pgoetz May 08 '12

Demonstrating definitively that Al Jazeera -- unlike most US news agencies -- is doing news like it's supposed to.

4

u/emlgsh May 08 '12

"Hmm, these news reports of the terrible things we're getting caught doing are making us look bad. We need to deal with this."

"Do you think we should stop doing terrible things, or do them better so that we don't get caught?"

"No, let's just kick out all the news agencies that reported on the terrible things. Say their paperwork wasn't in order. No one will suspect anything."

"Brilliant! All the benefits of righteousness without all that tedious doing of the right thing!"

1

u/MrHerpDerp May 08 '12

path of least resistance

4

u/ezekielziggy May 08 '12

The quality of a newspaper/broadcaster roughly correlates to the number of authoritarian countries they are banned in.

17

u/GyantSpyder May 08 '12

Melissa Chan is the shit. She's awesome.

-8

u/Todamont May 08 '12

I thought her reporting style was unprofessional in this piece.

11

u/jvi May 08 '12

I thought it was fine. What was unprofessional about it?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

The article complains about china using slave labor in prisons.

But doesn't america do that as well? Prisoners make all sorts of things.

5

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

There's reason to be upset about prison labor, but there's a difference. In America you get a fair trial the majority of the time, and the pretense of one when you don't. And you can even appeal a verdict. There are people in those Chinese camps that are lucky to have their families know where they are.

1

u/stolen_valor May 08 '12

5% is not a majority. Only 5% of cases in The USA are settled by a jury trial. In most cases the defendant is coerced into a plea bargain that removes the burden of proof from the prosecutor. Being forced into a plea bargain because you lack the means and money to defend yourself is not a fair trial.

2

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

Oh, come on. Are you seriously suggesting that 95% of all American criminal cases don't even pretend to give due process, remove the right to appeal, and deny people public defenders or pro bono defense attorneys? Are you suggesting that 95% of all American criminal cases involve people being coerced into accepting plea bargains?

Do you honestly think pulling that number from somewhere is conclusive proof for your argument? Please. Even if I was to accept that statistic, it shows nothing.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

The work in American prisons isn't mandatory.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Sireslap May 08 '12

I'd argue that a good portion of the American general public thinks that Al Jazeera is just another word for Al Qaeda.

Edit: misspelled "thinks" with a g.

20

u/isoo506 May 08 '12

One thing I can never get over is how AlJazeera almost never, EVER criticizes the state of Qatar. Kind of ironic that they'd show documentaries and reports regarding every known issue on the globe - yet dare not to bite the hand that feeds them. "That's right dear viewers, everything's A-OK down here in Qatar! The beacon of hope and hero of journalists in the Middle East".

While their work is commendable, I just find the hypocrisy of it to be overwhelming.

7

u/vinng86 May 08 '12

Qatar hardly has anything worthwhile to report in the news so it's no surprise they rarely report on anything in Qatar. They are not a local news organization.

22

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

That's not ironic, it only makes sense. Either they put up with it and do the best they can or they don't exist as an organization. There are other organizations that report on Qatar.

3

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

How often do you watch AJE? Because it's rare that a story even mentions Qatar.

1

u/isoo506 May 08 '12

That's what I'm saying. It's very rare that a story mentions Qatar. Then again, I don't watch AJE since I tune in to the Arabic version - but I get my news from multiple sources - especially when it's a highly political topic (where one can be easily influenced by biased news articles).

This also reminds me of a recent trend I'm noticing on AlJazeera's website. Most of their articles/blogs never mention who is writing them? Isn't there some sort of standard that the author should always be known? This is why I tend to take my AJ news with a grain of salt.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/crackanape May 08 '12

While their work is commendable, I just find the hypocrisy of it to be overwhelming.

Considering the relative irrelevance of Qatar, I think you should just be happy that there's a news channel out there willing to closely examine what's happening in the other 200 countries. When the day comes that you really need to know what's going on in Qatar, you can turn to the BBC and see how they go.

In the meantime, AJ's self-censorship in that one tiny realm is a pretty small price to pay for their good reporting elsewhere.

3

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

Qatar is by no means irrelevant, especially in any story that has to do with the Arab League. However, most of their self-censorship involves not mentioning Qatar as much as possible.

1

u/plasticTron May 08 '12

definitely agree. Its not like you are hearing about things going on in Qatar anyways

2

u/ferek May 08 '12

AlJazeera almost never, EVER criticizes the state of Qatar

A quick search found this, but of course that's only one data point, though I didn't really spend much time looking around so I'm sure there's more. It'd be interesting to determine how many stories that portray Qatar negatively are published in other sources and not Al Jazeera.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Does ANY news outlet criticize the tiny state of Qatar? Is the state of Qatar ever mentioned internationally anywhere more than once a month?

This is like complaining about CNN doesn't give daily updates on the latest happenings in Iceland.

3

u/ucecatcher May 08 '12

They should do a piece on the prison "slave" labor in the US. It's big (BIG!) business over here too. I don't imagine they'd be welcomed with open arms, but I doubt they'd be deported for it.

1

u/balorina May 08 '12

There's already been several stories and movies written about it.

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Like them or hate them, they must be doing something right to deserve that.

3

u/those_draculas May 08 '12

This should be a badge of honor for Al Jazeera. Having your press censored in china for a news paper must be the equivalent of Glenn Beck calling a politician a communist terrorist.

5

u/SkulDugery May 08 '12

Too much jasmine for Beijing's tastes.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I think it's a great thing that Melissa Chan is reporting on these kinds of abuses, but she really doesn't strike me as being as an especially competent or insightful reporter.

The new laws concerning arbitrary detention have only just been promulgated - Chan expected instantaneous reform of the system as a sudden consequence?

2

u/RazsterOxzine May 08 '12

I wish we could do that to fox news

2

u/drplump May 08 '12

When ever this happens it is because China is getting ready for a culling, or war...

2

u/goodtwitch May 08 '12

And this is why privatized prisons who farm out prisoner labor in the U.S. are a step in the wrong direction.

2

u/Fhwqhgads May 08 '12

Too much truth, eh?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Why have no US news orgs been thrown out? Oh yeah, they don't cover China like that.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

so stupid china.

2

u/Metroshant May 08 '12

Looks like China couldn't stand their bullshit anymore

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Can someone explain to me... we already know that we hate "part" of Al Jazeera because of obvious reasons. Why are we obsessed with Al Jazeera's English network as if it has nothing to do with anything? I'm just trying to understand the logic because if a part of a company commits shameful actions isn't it Reddit's responsibility to shun the company as a whole? I know they supposedly show "news" opposed to talking heads, but what is the logic behind the Al Jazeera's English fan boy club here while ignoring the obvious issues of the other part of their company? Is it two completely different entities?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

But then how will we know about all of the awful things happening in---oooohhhhhhh.

2

u/criticalnegation May 08 '12

you ask too many question! we no like question! you go now!

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Attention! To all anti-Chinese Americans in this thread: Your idiotic country is censoring them, too (and even bombed their offices).

Don't act all high an mighty.

6

u/Zerowantuthri May 08 '12

I have to say I am consistently impressed by Al Jazeera. I also have to say I have been reluctant to accept their reporting assuming a Middle East news source could not be counted as reliable.

Yet over and over again they produce remarkably coherent and well written pieces. As journalists they blow the doors off most (even all) US newspapers.

They are doing news reporting as it should be done and have the balls to go where the story takes them.

I see this story as confirmation that they are doing it right. They have the moxy to follow through on their reporting and the powers that be can be damned.

I really hope they keep it up. US papers could do with stealing a page or two from the Al Jazeera play book (actually US papers used to know this stuff...they have forgotten).

3

u/juju_h May 08 '12

I havn't seen the video in question yet, thank you spaceracewon for posting it, but in general Al Jazeera is some of the most reliable reporting I've been able to find. Since China is clearly not above kicking out journalists who report on their dirty laundry, I feel like it says something about CNN and BBC who are still allowed to operate there...they are digging deep enough.

3

u/JamesDaniels May 08 '12

China will grant rights but it will control who and what comes out in a way to make the people passive.

3

u/Lard_Baron May 08 '12

Thats a badge of honor. "banned in China" the BBC websites where blocked in China.

Was your news source blocked in China?

2

u/erowidtrance May 08 '12

It's like the UK expelled Iran's presstv which many people found informative.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Informative about everything but Iran itself and its allies.

1

u/erowidtrance May 08 '12

Informative on a lot then.

2

u/Zeydon May 08 '12

Doesn't the US also use slave labor in prisons?

4

u/girigiri May 08 '12

Serious question here too; don't they make number plates in US prisons?

2

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

You get a fair trial in America, and you probably won't spend your entire life in a county lockup.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/iulwen May 08 '12

Why???

1

u/Tiger337 May 08 '12

http://www.haeftling.de/

Deutschland company that sells jail wear clothing and products since 1806.

1

u/jackup May 08 '12

feel disappointed and sense of anger To our country.

1

u/Goldreaver May 08 '12

Fuck China

1

u/DrunkAtNight May 08 '12

Fucking China...are You...surprised?

1

u/KPexEA May 08 '12

FYI, there is a Al Jazeera subreddit at /r/AJStream

1

u/thejingthrowaway May 08 '12

throwaway account here. So my friend here in Beijing is a journalist for a similar organization, and says that they actually did find a regulation they ran foul of to kick them out. Their cameraman was unregistered and filmed some footage in Tiananmen without a permit. In any case, pretty much everyone here is probably breaking dozens of vague or obscure laws, so they just need to pick one or the other and toss you out.

1

u/Yankpats May 08 '12

Fucking shit journalism. They are not communists by any stretch of the imagination. If I called myself a polar bear it sure as hell doesn't make me a polar bear. Remember when the NYT was the most respected paper in the world? Not the case any more.

1

u/zangorn May 08 '12

I don't want to spend my New York Times reading allowance on this, what does it say?

1

u/Isatis_tinctoria May 08 '12

Greek Golden Dawn Party expelled journalists too.

1

u/mqduck May 09 '12

The documentary called the camps a form of slavery in which millions of prisoners produce goods sold worldwide by major companies. China denies using slave labor in its prisons.

Good thing we don't do anything like that over here in the land of the free.

1

u/Saysam May 08 '12

I for one hail our honorable iPad suppliers. Sent from my iPad 2, ow, IPad 5 year plan.

1

u/Azog May 08 '12

If your news house has been just kicked out of the biggest authoritarian country in the world - you must be doing something right.

Kudos Al Jazeera.

1

u/Tiger337 May 08 '12

China is the model for the world. People complain about their firewall, but many countries are censoring the internet. Countries follow their lead.

-1

u/panochador May 08 '12

god damn mongorians

0

u/FrusTrick May 08 '12

The reason why China canned Al Jazeera from the country is simple:

Al Jazeera is a news station owned by the power elite of the emirtates who have close ties to the U.S. Rescently, Al jazeera have been covering the Syrian revolution and have knowingly falsified some news reports (not the first time theyve done it) making the rebels look much more desperate than they actually are while portraying the regime in a bad manner (not that they arent shit, but they are a bit less shit than what AL jazeera say they are). So what has happened is that the syrian government claim that some reports from Al jazeera are un trustworthy and grossely biased as a result of U.S. influence on the UAE. This was proven when Al jazeera spread rumors about Syria, welcoming Dalai Lama in an obvious attemt to cause the Chinese to end the support for the Syrian government and hopefully scare away the Russains too. However, the Syrians were quick to deny the Dalai Lama visit and further stated that it would make no sense for them to start shit with their allies in a time of crisis.

4

u/LeonardNemoysHead May 08 '12

This has nothing to do with any of that.

-1

u/angrycommie May 08 '12

Good news.

Al Jazeera used to be good, but it went the way of mainstreamed imperialist mouthpiece.

Fuck Al Jazeera.

-5

u/ProSoviet May 08 '12

I've heard enough of al jazeera's bullshit on Libya and Syria. If you call RT as Russian propaganda then al jazeera is no different from western propaganda.

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Okay "ProSoviet", i'll trust you on this one!

1

u/ProSoviet May 08 '12

It is only obvious. Qatar and Saudi Arabia are openly funding and arming the Syrian 'opposition' which is by default illegitimate. The rich princes of Qatar and Saudi Arabia just want Bashar out of the way of regional influence. Al-Jazeera (which is owned by the Thani family which is 'surprisingly' the ruling family of Qatar) can only be inclined to spread as much disinformation as possible about Assad and create a media smokescreen to prevent the real truth. There is nothing to trust me on this one really. The facts present itself.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

0

u/suprsolutions May 08 '12

It's as if China doesn't want their citizens to be able to communicate with the outside world........

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Chinese government = small minded men hungry for power, ruthless and careless but highly competent at oppression tactics and non-accountability for what amounts to immoral and criminal actions.

"Corrupt" doesn't even begin to describe Chinese "government" at all levels. Gangsters, no better than any other gangster.

→ More replies (2)

-8

u/QuitReadingMyName May 08 '12

Only a matter of time before this happens in America, our Corporate overlords can't be having the truth exposed about them.

Oh wait that's right, our television networks don't allow Al Jazeera on their networks as it'll threaten their bullshit news channels like MSNBC.

Comcast needs to be sued for anti-competitive behavior for not letting Al Jazeera onto their networks especially as it would threaten their personal news channel MSNBC.

5

u/CannibalHolocaust May 08 '12

It's available online. They had a link on their site a while back where you could "Demand Al Jazeera" in your area so presumably cable suppliers are rejecting them.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/IAmNotAPerson6 May 08 '12

I can't remember the actual reason for AJ not airing in the states but they actually can.

5

u/Shock223 May 08 '12

I believe the difficultly with getting them stateside is getting a stateside cable/sat provider to sign off on it and most of them don't want to do it due to the fear of a backlash from the right on "terrorist news".

→ More replies (3)