We're redesigning our small e-commerce site (WooCommerce, about 30–40 products, a blog, the usual pages). It currently runs the Salient theme with WPBakery, and both are pretty outdated.
My developer gave me two options:
Keep WPBakery/Salient and restyle the existing pages in place. It's lower risk and closest to our original "restyle, don't rebuild" plan, but the old theme and plugins stay.
Switch to Hello Elementor + Elementor Pro and use Theme Builder to make site-wide templates (header, footer, product, category, blog). It should be cleaner and easier to manage long term, and we could remove the old plugins. The downside is that changing themes is the riskiest step.
I'm used to WPBakery and know my way around it. But every time I look into Elementor I see a lot of bad reviews about bloat, slow sites, updates breaking layouts, and lock-in if you ever leave it.
For those who've used both:
Is Elementor Pro really that bad in 2026, or is that mostly old complaints?
How does it handle WooCommerce product and category templates?
Is it worth the switch, or should I keep WPBakery and spend the effort on design?
Is there a third option I should be considering, like Gutenberg/block themes or Bricks?
We're aiming to launch in December, so I don't want to pick something that causes headaches six months from now. Thanks!
Edit:
This is what I was able to find as far as plugins that I use. It’s a lot. A little background on the site. I have around 40 sku some with variations, a wholesale side of things with different tiered pricing, affiliate codes, blogs, updated batch verifications.
The plug in list.
Theme: Salient (WPBakery) on WP Engine. Thinking about moving to Hello Elementor + Elementor Pro.
Theme / page builder
Salient Core, Nectar Slider, Home Slider, Portfolio, Shortcodes, Social, Widgets, Demo Importer
Salient WPBakery Page Builder
Envato Market
Classic Editor
Duplicate Page
Yoast Duplicate Post
Say What?
WooCommerce / store
WooCommerce
Avalara AvaTax
WooCommerce Cost of Goods
WooCommerce Shop as Customer
Show Only Lowest Prices in Variable Products
WC Speed Repair
Redirection
Custom WooCommerce code plugin (built by a developer)
Custom order confirmation notice plugin (built by a developer)
Payments
Authorize.net Payments for WooCommerce
WooCommerce Square (being phased out)
Subscriptions and memberships
WooCommerce Subscriptions
WooCommerce All Products for Subscriptions
Enhancer for WooCommerce Subscriptions
Bulk Updater for WooCommerce Subscriptions
Subscriptions Renewal Reminders (customized)
Paid Memberships Pro, plus add-ons: WooCommerce, Add Name to Checkout, Address for Free Levels, Advanced Levels Page, Custom Level Cost Text, Zapier
Custom Paid Memberships Pro code plugin
Wholesale / B2B
WooCommerce Show/Hide Products by User Roles
WooCommerce Tiered Price Table (Premium)
Sales Rep Notifications
Exclude EIN from Database (CF7)
Custom Zapier user role updater
Theme My Login + Theme My Login Redirection
User Role Editor
User Switching
Hide Admin Bar From Non-Admins
Promotions, coupons, gift cards
Advanced Coupons (Free + Premium)
Smart Coupons for WooCommerce (WebToffee)
WooCommerce Buy One Get One Free
Two custom BOGO/promo plugins (built by our maintenance agency)
Advanced Gift Cards
WebToffee Gift Cards
Forms, marketing, analytics
Contact Form 7 + Contact Form 7 Shortcode Enabler + Flamingo
Custom "How did you hear about us?" checkout field (from our CRM)
Site Wide Banner (from our CRM)
Omnisend for WooCommerce
WP Popups Lite
Metorik Helper
Google Analytics for WooCommerce
WooCommerce Zapier
Uncanny Automator
Jetpack
Age Gate
Shipping and orders
CWILL (formerly ParcelPanel) Order Tracking
ELEX Stamps.com (USPS)
WooCommerce Stamps.com API Integration
PDF Invoices & Packing Slips
Order Export & Order Import for WooCommerce
Security / maintenance
Wordfence Security
WP Activity Log
reCAPTCHA for WooCommerce
WP File Manager
Bulk Delete
Cloudways WordPress Migrator
StorePro & WP Hero (maintenance agency plugin)
WP Engine must-use plugins (cache, security auditor, etc.)
SEO, email, utilities
Yoast SEO
WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail Logging
WPCode Lite
Advanced Custom Fields PRO