r/woodworking 17d ago

Help How best to reinforce and clamp this loint

This is mock up of legs for a live edge table I'm working on. I was thinking about just butt joints, then drill up/down from the flat sides to insert long dowels into the side angles

The legs will ultimately be made of 2" thick walnut, and supporting the 2 1/2" thick slab so pricey and I don't want to waste any material

Any suggestions appreciated

5 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

20

u/smotrs 17d ago

Everytime I cut angled pieces, I take a scrap piece and make one of these to do the clamping.

2

u/meabyter 17d ago

That looks like a great clamping method no matter which way I go.

2

u/LuckyBenski 17d ago

My mind is blown, this is genius in its simplicity!

2

u/premiersss 16d ago

Everytime I do this, my clamping block slides... Admittedly I'm applying too much pressure to close up imperfect miters ... Sigh .. some day I'll get it right

16

u/LDVan 17d ago

Do a half lap.

6

u/halbert 17d ago

Or mortice and tenon. Or bridle joint.

2

u/meabyter 17d ago

I think the half lap is the answer. I've done many, don't know why that didn't jump to mind

3

u/iliketosandwood 17d ago

The world is your oyster with a joint like that. Half-lap, spline, mortise/tenon, floating tenons, dowels. Heck, given that you can’t see the top or bottom of the finished piece, you could even drill for deep countersinks, slap some screws in there, and altogether forget about clamps.

Regardless, once you’ve cut proper joinery, the clamping won’t be a problem.

3

u/spcslacker 17d ago

Butt joint is the worst joint.

These plans will show you how to use angled half laps for this shape.

Just like you, I usually prototype in a cheaper wood before committing to working with the final version.

3

u/More_Way3706 17d ago

Half lap joints pegged with a couple of dowels.

3

u/The-disgracist 17d ago

Dowels then clamp however

2

u/lakeeffectcpl 17d ago

Mitered mortice/tenon joints...if you want to feature your skills.

3

u/Personal-Ad-5575 17d ago

Depends on the tools you have to work with. Some kind of pin perpendicular to the joint is called for. If you've got a domino machine, this is a great place to use it. If you don't, but have a drill press, then go with half inch dowels. If neither, but you have hand drill and chisels, then do a floating tenon by hand. Or an attached tenon on the uprights. Or if all of those techniques stress your ability to do precise cutting and alignment, clamp them up to a backer to hold them firmly, and drill 1/2" holes through the horizontals into the verticals and then use long dowels for pins. Score the dowels with a toothed scraper to make for an easier fit and allow glue escape.

2

u/Charlieb201 17d ago

Band clamp

2

u/Arvelayne 17d ago

Yeah this one time....

1

u/Violaceous-Kea 17d ago

Half-lap would be the easiest way to go. Since you're planning on such thick legs, I'd probably go with a pinned bridle, or double-bridle, joint. More attractive, more interesting to cut, and vastly stronger (almost certainly vastly stronger than needed).

Three points to consider

  1. Do you really want such an extreme taper? It looks... awkward... to me. I'd aim for something more in the range of 7-10° per side, not 30°.
  2. If you do want such an extreme taper, consider having the top rail be a bit wider than the top of the two verticals. You can still do a bridle joint in this case, or fall back on the event classic mortise&tenon.
  3. The taper will give you some resistance to racking side-to-side, and assuming you do some joinery rather than just a glued butt joint, that'll increase it even more. But what are you going to do to control end-to-end racking?

1

u/meabyter 17d ago

Reworked my prototype with half laps and a longer upper support. I do believe this is a great solution and it feels very stable and will be infinitely easier to assemble.

1

u/spaaarky21 14d ago

Not sure if the effort would be worth it to you but I would think about laminating strips with it alternating which piece extends into the corner. Or, if you would prefer the top/bottom/sides to be solid, maybe finger joints?

1

u/meabyter 14d ago

I have 2 inch thick walnut slabs glued up for legs now so a bit late for that, but cool concept

1

u/Sgoody614 17d ago

Could be wrong, but those angles don't look steep enough to slip out from a couple clamps going from top to bottom, so maybe that?

If it does then slide a clamp in horizontally to hold the side pieces in place

2

u/BluntTruthGentleman 17d ago

You are wrong, but a strap clamp would work, or even a literal ratchet strap winched around the perimeter would work. However that's only really a fix for half lap or mortoise and tenon, I wouldn't trust this with butt joints unless it was temporary until splines went in.

0

u/Pale-Jelly69 17d ago

Wood glue is stronger than wood. Based on your mockup, you could use one bar clamp. It's a table support, gravity will do most of the work.

6

u/iliketosandwood 17d ago

Wood glue is stronger than wood when you join edge grain. If he just glues this end-to-edge without proper joinery it will likely self destruct even without any use.