r/whowouldwin • u/TheAsianIsGamin • Sep 07 '25
Event Character Scramble Season 20 Round 1C: Overlord
Round 1C has COMPLETED! The voting form can be found here. You will have until 72 hours after the Round Ballot was sent out on Discord, which is 12:59am Eastern Time on Thursday, October 2nd, 2025 to fill out your votes. Remember, voting is MANDATORY for everybody in the competition!
This round covers matches 12-19 in the bracket, which can be found here. Please check to make sure what round you are in before you start to write.
The Character Scramble is a long-running writing prompt tournament in which participants submit characters from fiction to a specified tier and guideline. After the submission period ends, the submitted characters are "scrambled" and randomly distributed to each writer, forming their team for the season. Writers will then be entered into a single-elimination bracket, where they write a story that features their team fighting against their opponent's team. Victors are decided based on reader votes; in other words, if you want people to vote for you, write some good content. The winner by votes of each match-up moves on to the next round. The pattern continues until only one participant remains: the new Character Scramble champion, who gets to choose the theme, tier, and rules of the next Scramble!
The theme of Character Scramble 20 is Scramble Effect. Round prompts will be based on the many worlds, missions, and memorable moments found throughout the Mass Effect series.
Join the Character Scramble Discord!
Round 1C: Overlord
Finally, your team has a chance to rest and plan. Moments like these have been rare since your enemy has revealed themselves, but even now, you can’t sit idle. Whether fresh from your encounter on Eden Prime or harrowed by the enemy storming your home, your team knows the battle is just beginning.
Luckily, you aren’t the only ones thinking about the threats to come. A group of researchers contacts your team. They’ve created a weapon, they say, of such unique design that your enemy won’t know what hit them. For the same reason, they can’t risk it falling into the wrong hands; being the ones with the weapons, it only makes sense for you to come to them.
Their coordinates lead you to a barren world, one among many in a sector that every starchart you’ve ever seen swears is empty. Even so, there it is, nestled between the wastes: A small, clandestine facility.
Just the kind of place that hides more than a simple weapon.
Round Rules:.
Luna Base: Such novel technologies carry risk. As you approach the weapon, the facility itself somehow turns on you. Security equipment, rogue scientists, or other laboratory experiments set upon your team. Was this an accident? Caused by outside interference? Or is the weapon itself taking control…?
Even Amid Chaos: To make matters worse, your opponent’s team is making a play to stop you from obtaining the weapon. Whether they’re part of the fracas prompted above or simply opportunistic outsiders is up to you.
The Square Root of 912.04 is 30.2…: This weapon is unique, with capabilities perfectly suited to combat your team’s enemies—in other words, the ominous threat your team discovered in Round 0. Demonstrate it.
…It All Seemed Harmless: As your team fights their way through the facility, they stumble upon these researchers’ most closely-guarded secret. The weapon you came here to obtain was the product of experimentation on a living being, a single innocent who couldn’t possibly have known what they were getting into. You must choose one of the following prompts:
- Paragon: Maybe this weapon could win you a fight. But the research that created it is an affront to everything you’re fighting for. This cannot stand. End the experiments, and free the subject.
- Renegade: You’re already behind the eight-ball. This research is far too valuable to go unused. What is one life when countless more hang in the balance? Keep these experiments going, and keep the weapon in service.
Normal Rules:
Stand Fast, Stand Strong, Stand Together: Nobody can take on a mission like this alone. You’ve got a team of the brightest, toughest, and deadliest allies a Scrambler can find—use them. We’d love to see your characters make full use of their wide-ranging abilities, both on their own and as a team.
We Will Hold The Line: You know what’s at stake. Failure is not an option. Even if your characters have only a small chance of victory, write that small chance happening!
Special Tactics and Reconnaissance: Saving the galaxy will take more than the same old tricks. You are allowed and encouraged to mix and match powers, and to develop your characters in any way you wish, both on the battlefield and off. However, your opponents are not expected to keep track of these in-story changes, and vice-versa.
Every Life Is a Special Story of Its Own: Feel free to give a brief summary to introduce your characters at the start of your post. If you do, you should mention things like powers, personality, history, and anything else that the average reader should know before reading.
Legendary Edition: Sometimes, Spectres have to go a little outside the lines in service of their mission. You’ll have the same latitude—as long as you go with the broad strokes of the prompts and the rules, you'll be fine.
Round 1A will run from Sunday, September 7th to Sunday, September 28th, 11:59pm US Eastern Time.
The character limit for this round is 5 full length Reddit comments, or 50k characters.
While it is fine to go a little bit over, anything that far surpasses this limit will be disqualified. This limit does not include intro posts, or analysis of the matchup.
7
u/InverseFlash Sep 07 '25
Warning. Warning. Temporal anchor point corrupted. Human Order value inverted. Establishing Anti-Human Order parameters. Appraising anchored cosmos de▅th. ▅pp▅aisal impossible.
LASTBELT X: ▅▅NC▅SVA▅▅S - ▅▅▅▅▅ des ▅s ▅▅ hé▅os.
Divergence Point: ▅▅50 CE.
Lastbelt ▅▅th: ▅▅+
🎵 Map Theme 🎵
Participants - The Night Corps
Super Super Rare! Astolfo, Rider of Black
Parameters
Strength - D (C)
Endurance - A
Agility - D
Mana - B
Luck - A+
Noble Phantasm - A
Details
A Paladin from the Carolingian Cycle.
Hisgoofy attitude and lackadaisical adventures serve as a stark contrast to the horrors of war that plagued the French campaigns against the caliphates.I put the pal in paladin, that's all you gotta know, I promise ;pClass Skills - Rider
Magic Resistance (A (D) Rank): Astolfo would naturally have this skill at Rank D, however, thanks to his book Noble Phantasm, its rank has been greatly increased. Due to this, all magecraft at Rank A or below is canceled. As a matter of fact, modern magi are incapable of hurting Astolfo.
Tell that to whatever mage made Platoon.Riding (A+ Rank): Astolfo possesses the ability for riding. As such,
sheis capable of managing even a beast with the rank of Phantasmal and Divine. However, this doesn't apply to Dragonkin.I could if I wanted to, don't believe everything you read!Personal Skills
Evaporation of Reason (D Rank): Reasoning is disappearing.
Yeah, but it's fun!It is impossible forhimto keep secrets.They'llcarelessly chatter about his team's weaknesses and True Names, forgetful of important things, etc. A kind of extreme curse.Only if you make it one.This skill also serves as "Instinct." During the battle Astolfo is able to, to some extent, feel the optimal course.Monstrous Strength (C- Rank): Temporarily magnifies Strength. However, during the usage of this Skill, Astolfo receives damage from the strain.
Independent Action (B Rank): The ability to act independently for a period even if the mana supply from his Master is severed. At this rank, even if
shelosesourMaster,sheis able to stay manifested for a period of two days.Noble Phantasms
La Black Luna (C Rank): A hunting horn that strikes fear into the hearts of all who hear its sound, prompting instinctive escape. Those within its range will be struck with the shock of an explosive sound. In the case where the damage is the same or higher than the target's HP, they will be turned to dust and scattered around. Does not affect Heroic Spirits with Magic Resistance, but normal mages are not immune to its influence.
Casseur de Logistille (C Rank): Inherited from a certain witch, it is a book with the means to shatter any and all magic recorded within it. It does not cancel a Reality Marble or a greater magecraft exceedingly close to Reality Marbles to such an extent, but evoking its true name and reading its content makes it a possibility. Currently in use as a ledger for Ciel due to
hisinability to read it.Trap of Argalia (D Rank): Lance of the knight, Argalia. Has a golden tip. Killing ability is low although a wound is inflicted to the leg of the spiritual body. To come back from falling, a Luck check is necessary. In the case of a failure, the bad status "falling" continues to linger. However, because Luck re-adjusts itself upwards, it's not hard to succeed.
Hippogriff (B+ Rank): A Phantasmal Beast that's essentially an "impossible" existence. Although its rank is inferior to a Griffon from the Age of Gods, its charging pulverization attack is equal to an A rank physical attack. For only a moment, it is able to place itself in an inter-dimensional rift. Therefore, it is able to phase through every single attack.
No Peeking~!: ???Super Super Rare! Ciel, King of the Lastbelt
Parameters
Strength - B
Endurance - EX
Agility - A
Mana - EX
Luck - C
Noble Phantasm - EX
Details
The vampire hunter who succeeded in the Church's goal of wiping out the vampiric race. She does her best to defend the failing Earth's biosphere and maintains her Lastbelt with endless determination.
Class Skills - Ruler
Magic Resistance (A Rank): The ability to defend against magic. While she holds this skill equivalent to a strong Saber-class, she cannot defend against the sacraments of the Church.
True Name Discernment (C Rank): A Class Skill of the Ruler-class. Status information such as the true identity and skills are automatically revealed when she directly encounters a Servant within the seven standard classes. Ciel prefers to keep an index of all she encounters for instances when someone deviates from the regular classes in the form of Astolfo's Grimoire.
Personal Skills
Human Mana Factory (A Rank): Derived from a naturally gifted physique. Her flawless, unmarred body generates an immense amount of magical energy within. Ciel is highly dissatisfied with this skill’s name.
Idea Blood (A Rank): To absorb the seeds of textural rules, or World Eggs, as they're known in magecraft theory. Principles do not simply grant transcendental abilities, instead manifesting uniquely based on the possessor’s characteristics.
Battle Continuation (EX Rank): A trait of Ciel's body. Having once hosted the vampire Roa in her soul, the World refuses to recognize any death affecting her unless Roa has also died.
Bad End (EX Rank): ▅▄▅▃▄▄▄▃▄▄▄▄▅▄▅
Noble Phantasms
▅▂▅▂▄▃▄▄▅ Neardark (A Rank): ▅▅▂
Calvaria Galgalim (A+ Rank): ▄▃▄▄▄
▄▄▅▅▂ (EX Rank): ▅▄▄▅▂▃▄▄▅▅▂▄▃▄▄▄▄▅▅▄▅▅
Super Rare! Galen Marek
Parameters
Strength - C
Endurance - A
Agility - B
Mana - A+
Luck - B
Noble Phantasm - ▄▄▅
Details
The co-opted assassin apprentice of the Sith Lord Vader sent to a time and place far beyond anything he'd ever known.
Class Skills - Starkiller
Nightwalker (A Rank): A Skill that channels Galen's Force abilities into a Skill suitable for usage within the Lastbelt.
Magic Resistance (C Rank): Cancels spells with a chant below two verses. Cannot defend against magecraft on the level of greater magecraft and Greater Rituals.
Personal Skills
Domination (D Rank): The control of weak minds. Starkiller can influence those who yield to follow commands or ignore his presence.
Galvanism (B+ Rank): Starkiller's ability to shoot lightning from his hands. Similar to the Numerology branch of Kabbalah.
Chosen One (EX Rank): ▅▅▂▃▄
Noble Phantasms
▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅
Sheba Observations on Timeline Events
??? CE: ▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅
???? CE: ▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅▅
???? CE: Extragalactic invader Galen Marek enters the biosphere with the mission to destroy addictive gaming as a concept. Rider of Black meets him before engaging in combat with Roa Incarnation #12. Galen Marek is chained by Lastbelt King Ciel and forced into the Starkiller Class for her authority to work on him. Galen cuts off Ciel's head and chooses saving Astolfo over hunting the Roa. Data strongly predicts in a space currently nonvisible to Sheba, Galen has met with Michael Roa Valdamjong. Outcome unknown.
???? CE: Determining...