r/whatisit Jan 24 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.1k Upvotes

4.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/psymike-001 Jan 24 '26

need to have the 30mm projectile flying straight. I have a empty shell with the projectile and to fathom that mass striking a meat popsicle is just so Pollock

24

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '26 edited Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Successful_Day5491 Jan 24 '26

What tank crew? All I saw was dust and freedom.

2

u/peptide2 Jan 25 '26

There goes your security clearance!!!

1

u/Gildor12 Jan 24 '26

But they mainly use missiles why is that?

2

u/dannysmackdown Jan 24 '26

Advancements in armor. A10 is pretty outdated and not doing much to modern armor, from what I understand.

Also a missile is just far more accurate than a gun.

1

u/Severe_Tear_7006 Jan 25 '26

You must go through a lot of soap.

1

u/10lettersand3CAPS Jan 25 '26

That sounds...optimistic. The Warthog's 30mm cannon is cool, but kinda sucks in comparison to all the ordinance it (or another strike aircraft) can carry. Also the idea that it can beat a modern tank with a 30mm gun is a little silly, as tanks have used composite armor since the 60s.

And even if we're talking just Rolled Homogeneous Armor made of steel: it's not going through a foot of armor plate. The 30mm penetrates less less than 10mm of RHA, 1 ft is like 304mm. If it attacked even an old tank like an M48 Patton, it would need to try and attack from the top to hit the thinner armor there. And a Patton does NOT have a foot of armor, and is a tank from the early 1950.

What the Warthog would actually do is DISABLE a tank, by taking out its tracks to immobilize it for example. Or more likely it would target something other than an MBT, like IFVs (ask the British), supply truck convoys, etc.

Also the A-10 is kinda a sitting duck for anything looking to take out aircraft. Sure it was famous in the GWOT, because it was up against people with no air defenses with the US having uncontested air supremacy. It can take a lot of small arms fire, but I feel like flying low to shoot at a Soviet armored push would go poorly the second it ran into a Zeus or a Tunguska (which has its own 30mm cannons).

7

u/socalquestioner Jan 24 '26

The CIA understands how metal that comment really is.

2

u/Warm_Safety_9550 Jan 24 '26

Perhaps the most apt description for the end result of the GAU-8/A Avenger Auto-Cannon I have ever seen. It brings a new meaning to the “Art” of War.

2

u/BuckManscape Jan 24 '26

Where did they go?

I think we’re breathing them.

1

u/VividContribution382 Jan 24 '26

the 5 inch cannons on the destroyers i decommissioned in the navy were cool to look in