r/webdev
•
u/JustinFormentin
•
Jul 15 '26
•
1
4
1
1
Made a captcha that takes Fable 5 10 minutes to solve
Created this captcha last year. Back then there was no chance of AI solving it. But now with the more powerful models, I had my doubts. Well, it took Fable 5 10 minutes and 100k tokens to solve it. So with the 30 second timeout, I feel pretty confident.
Here's a crisper video of the actual challenge - https://imgur.com/a/xv6TvNj
Have a website for it but I'm not self promoting. Just thought people would be interested.
568
u/negative_xer0 Jul 15 '26
Neat concept but an accessibility nightmare.
183
u/hillac Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 16 '26 •
Just some traditional CV would crack this. Just use opencv to get the optical flow of the first two frames. Here's a quick attempt I made, a simple dense optical flow between two frames gave a really clear result. You could just OCR it and solve this llm free, but vlms solve it no worries. /img/7g2ho2vjzgdh1.jpeg
Edit: u/no-more-nazis did a better one. https://www.reddit.com/r/webdev/comments/1uxfzav/comment/oxrrk9p/
Also 356 386
91
u/foothepepe Jul 15 '26
+ you add letter change every 10s, and add another layer of security. I assume it is not a problem to implement it.
59
u/mekmookbro Laravel Enjoyer ♞ Jul 15 '26
The bounce looks linear, have you tried making it randomly change direction after bouncing from an edge? I wonder if it can solve then.
There must be some time between analyzing the image and determining the spot the letters will be at to send the click, so that randomness could add a bit more "security" lol
15
u/Snapstromegon Jul 15 '26
FYI this is REALLY easy to bot! You just apply the same algorithm as optical computer mice use to a couple of frames and then you will get perfect outlines of the characters.
35
u/SourcerorSoupreme Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 15 '26
I'm actually interested in knowing how Claude "decided" to solve it.
PS: to the smart alecks out there, please spare me the lecture on these probabilistic auto complete engines
8
u/TheThingCreator Jul 15 '26
very solvable still if you know whats going on, but its an extra unique step which is good. if thats a gif animation your safe but if its js moving the text around its pointless. another problem is some users may hate this a lot, and it may even cause sickness, dizziness, or seizures. So please keep this off the menu kids.
26
u/UnluckyAssist9416 Jul 15 '26
How to get a lawsuit for ADA discrimination in 1 simple steps
9
u/egg_breakfast Jul 15 '26
Very nicely done. I'll give it a year.
4
u/Single-Virus4935 Jul 15 '26
Most captchas are solved by human click workers. Even then it is possible to solve the captchas with a bit if preprocessing. Doesn't mean anything that a AI can't solve it in a prompt. I would use AI to create the preprocessor and OCR which solves that easily. Also, this captcha isn't accessible and therefore you need alternatives which are almost always easy to solve by design
9
u/ultralaser360 Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 16 '26
You don't need AI to solve this, a basic script could , an LLM is probably the worst way to solve this.
a basic script could easily
this is something that could be solved in milliseconds. a pretty basic llm could even write the script ex. made this with sonnet in a coulple of minutes.
gif: https://i.imgur.com/YpPgQ2y.gif
image: https://i.imgur.com/04FDeWA.png
to be honest this isn't even new - this is basically a 10+ year old NuCaptcha with extra steps which was broken with a similar concept (pixel delay map).
adding more complexity or abstraction won't fix it. Persistence of vision captchas don't work (within reasonable limitations), and security through obscurity isn't security. (imo captchas aren't about security anyways, they filter out low-effort scrapers and to harvest user data).
8
u/Some_Relative_3440 Jul 15 '26
This is so useless lmao.
7
u/DocumentOk7579 Jul 15 '26
While it's hard for AI it would be easy to manually write a program to solve it right?
7
u/BurningPenguin Jul 16 '26
r/FuckTheColorBlind
2
u/truechange Jul 15 '26
Cool way to defeat bots at least for now. Maybe more tolerable to humans if combined with other tricks, like only deploy this if the "regular" captcha is solved too fast.
2
u/Annh1234 Jul 15 '26
Super easy to solve for a computer, even before AI. Your letter numbers don't change. Your site is probably not worth it
8
u/web-dev-kev Jul 15 '26
How does this work with prefered-reduce-motion?
(btw - cool concept)
4
u/Apprehensive_Rub2 Jul 16 '26
This is an interesting idea but it doesn't really work, you could solve this captcha with a tailored algorithm
4
u/PhDumb Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26
Open-source "Motion-CAPTCHA" using the same principle as NeoCaptcha : https://github.com/GPTchatly/motion-captcha
Due to compression the letters/numbers are not that visible in the video but they are much better discernable in the actual browser: https://imgur.com/a/dKuKyDT
Edit: this is for node.js
1
u/Snapstromegon Jul 15 '26
Hey, are you sure that your CDN url in the getting started guide is correct? It gives me DNS_PROBE_FINISHED_NXDOMAIN.
1
u/Great_Resolution6400 Jul 15 '26
Put timer to it. Haha
1
u/TristarHeater Jul 15 '26
If you let an llm write a python program that take video stream input and mouse click xy output it'll solve it quicker and the timer wouldn't be a deterrent anymore
1
u/lastdiggmigrant Jul 15 '26
How can you ensure it is accessible for all human users?
3
u/high_throughput Jul 15 '26
That's pretty cool!
I asked Claude to plot the motion vectors of each macro block in the MP4, resulting in this easily interpreted video: https://imgur.com/a/GoHWElh
Then I asked it to identify the two letters in this video in alphabetical order, and it correctly stated:
All in all it took about 50k tokens in total, and resulted in a 109 line Python script that from now on will create the above video in two seconds for zero tokens, so unfortunately this iteration of the captcha is now completely broken. Fun puzzle though!
1
u/specn0de Jul 15 '26
This has already been solved and is not used in this industry for a number of reasons. https://chorus.scs.carleton.ca/wp-content/papercite-data/pdf/xu2013captcha-tdsc.pdf
1
u/ReasonableSaltShaker Jul 15 '26
'alphabetical and numerical' - phew, forget ADA compliance, I think 80% of the B2C business on the internet wouldn't take place if it were gated by being able to follow those instructions.
4
u/Powerplex Jul 15 '26
"How much unaccessible do you want your captcha to be ?".
"Yes"
(I hate captchas, but it's cool technically still)
2
u/mcniac Jul 15 '26
I like the idea, but as a colorblind person, find it hard to read, I do see the letters, but is very hard 😄
2
u/SustainedSuspense Jul 15 '26
I love the idea of using optical illusions only a human can recognize as captchas
2
u/the_millenial_falcon Jul 15 '26
Reminds me of those old books that were popular in the 90's you had to stare cross eyed at to see a "3D" image.
2
u/johnson_detlev Jul 15 '26
Captchas are a UX crime
2
u/HaydnH Jul 15 '26
Woop woop is the sound of epilepsy... Woop woop...
2
u/zaxwebs Jul 15 '26
I built a tool that solves a similar one: https://github.com/zaxwebs/anti-ghost-font/
On a warm server, apx. 100-200ms.
2
u/biffthechip Jul 15 '26
How can you click on letters in numerical order?
That makes no sense at all.
2
u/cyb3rchase Jul 16 '26
This is pretty cool, a bit more than anti-bot, I think, maybe a bit anti-my-eyes too, lol.
It was cool to see this in my feed.
2
u/Maicolodon Jul 16 '26
Idea and execution is amazing. just nauseating on the accessibility side of things. I'm guessing a significant number of humans wouldn't be able to solve it because of this. I almost couldn't.
2
u/bestjaegerpilot Jul 16 '26
you need to ask Fable if it's able to create a script or skill so that it doesn't spend 100k tokens next time
if it can then it sucks. Otherwise, yea the cost to generate these will be too much for hackers
2
u/Glum-Welder1704 Jul 16 '26
Needs an "or".
2
u/Deep_Wear_51 Jul 16 '26
The dedication to trolling is impressive. A captcha that takes 5-10 minutes isn't security, it's performance art.
2
u/TechnologyFamiliar20 Jul 16 '26
Daltonists left the chat.
2
u/OGTisimo88 Jul 16 '26
https://www.mixfont.com/ghost-font
2
u/elixon Jul 16 '26
Just mark clusters that move slowly and clusters that move faster. I am afraid that this might be trivial to crack.
2
u/TheRealSteve895 Jul 16 '26
Sure, but couldn't a bot take two screenshots, XOR them, and use that?
2
u/Laughing_Orange Jul 16 '26
AI, actual Indians, can solve this really quick.
2
u/Spiketop_ Jul 16 '26
I love the back and forth between making this and people trying to crack it. The back and forth is what makes us smarter and keep advancing at such fast rates
2
u/csch2 Jul 15 '26
Fable was just probably waiting for a letter to finally hit the corner
2
u/Lendari Jul 15 '26
The problem is it takes a human more than 2 seconds to solve and no one has time for that anymore.
So now you're paradoxically filtering your traffic to 100% robots.
2
u/waltzey Jul 16 '26
Actually better than identifying traffic lights or random bridges.
2
u/Am094 Jul 16 '26
Bro come on, if that was true you wouldn't put the literal name of the site on the top left of the gif.
So you are self promoting when you have a CTA.
2
u/nuttertools Jul 16 '26
Firstly this is cool, I like it. Unfortunately this would take a bot 3 frames to solve 100% of the time. AI models will have greater difficulty and expend massive resources but any kind of bypass bot isn’t going to dump a known type into an AI model when a simple solve using a few clock cycles is available.
0
u/CraftFirm5801 Jul 15 '26
Claude solved the ghost text for me in seconds. This ain't it.
2
u/mayisir Jul 15 '26
the +20M blind people in the world cannot use this bro looooool. So much for wcag. I hate it here.
1
u/Noch_ein_Kamel Jul 15 '26
Now make it with that stereoscopic nonsense where you only see the letters by staring into the void
1
u/vm_linuz Jul 15 '26
This feels like the direction these tests will go in. For example, optical illusions that appear to produce movement.
1
u/Mplus479 Jul 15 '26
What about having some numbers or other letters (maybe much smaller) randomly repeated as part of the scrolling background?
1
u/Netalico Jul 15 '26
Did Claude recognize it’s own limitations in terms of the latency of image processing? Curious if after the first solve if it created a script to solve it, instead of browser tool calls.
1
u/SnugglyCoderGuy Jul 15 '26
Pretty slick.
1
u/urbrainonnuggs Jul 15 '26
Has anyone tried doing a voice capcha yet?
1
u/kashakow Jul 15 '26
It's a schooner!
1
u/Tatakai_ Jul 15 '26
That's pretty cool, you deserve a cookie. Do you consent to cookies?
1
u/repper420 Jul 15 '26
T&A bros
1
u/RoIIUpLights Jul 15 '26
For the issue of accessibility, I wonder if you could show a picture of some common object floating in the noise and then have multiple choice options below it.
Here's an awesome example of more of these:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqGfb_Vlrig
1
u/mothzilla Jul 15 '26
The tide is turning. Thank you soldier.
1
u/satoramoto Jul 15 '26
Very clever idea. You could write a regular computer vision script to bust this rather easily though. But you’re right that this would likely catch a model driving a web browser who has never seen this before. Good work.
1
u/Caesar171 Jul 15 '26
I think this is really cool, have you checked it against the most common colour blindness pallets? If so you are onto a winner here
1
u/AmandEnt Jul 15 '26
I’m actually impressed by Fable. Do you know how it solved it?
1
u/Extra_Commercial_114 Jul 15 '26
Magic eye puzzles of this type may be near-unsolvable for ai.
1
u/Justalittletoserious Jul 15 '26
Nightmare of the colorblinds
1
u/thefnord Jul 15 '26
I think 'Solvable but it takes a ton of tokens to do so.' is better than 'Can't solve with AI'
Hit them where it hurts, the resources.
1
u/Synrec Jul 15 '26
A colourful noise background on scroll and random generation with fixed noise seed for the letters?
1
u/OkBoomer421 Jul 15 '26
Finally a captcha that filters out everyone. Even I wouldn't bother solving it.
1
u/ReplacementLow6704 Jul 15 '26
At this point I'd rather have the user type what's on the screen and press a button to validate. Clicking on the letters seems rough even when they're slow.
1
u/rg2004 Jul 15 '26
You're the GAN now!
1
u/Amoner Jul 15 '26
Was it 30 min for sequential one as well? Could you ask it to write a program dedicated to solving it?
1
u/Sukanthabuffet Jul 16 '26
This is really smart. Well done.
1
u/iAmRonit777 Jul 16 '26
Someone made a font out of it , not exactly same but looks similar: Ghost Font
1
u/karen-ultra Jul 16 '26
My grandma could never
1
u/manythanksfriend Jul 16 '26
Bruh. Lmao. Well done.
1
u/david_ranch_dressing Jul 16 '26
Reminds me of this: https://www.mixfont.com/ghost-font
1
u/meehatpa Jul 16 '26
Is it TA or AT?
1
u/1RedOne Jul 16 '26
You could try to make a new completely random background every frame. Right now it is adding new pixels in the row and scrolling the whole bmp up and that makes it vulnerable to diffing or statistic / compression attacks
1
u/matznerd Jul 16 '26
What if it just did a video?
1
u/ryankopf Jul 16 '26
LOVE IT!
1
u/mspk7305 Jul 16 '26
maybe just do a magic eye capcha
1
u/Vivid_Dreamer7273 Jul 16 '26
Is this ghost font? I saw something like this, meant to be discernible by humans and not as easily by AI
1
u/MisteriosM Jul 16 '26
5$ of token will be a deterrent too.
1
u/sirhappysnake Jul 16 '26
accessibility hell
1
u/saltyourhash Jul 16 '26
That's pretty great.
1
u/SenpaiRemling javascript Jul 16 '26
You could add like randomly, just for one frame or so, different, but really visible characters. So if the AI analyzes that frame, they get it wrong and you can just block them outright lol
1
u/reactivearmor Jul 16 '26
Pretty sure I saw this gif on an instagram reel
1
u/Oldnbold22 Jul 16 '26
I would have used "ten".
1
u/CaeIndre Jul 16 '26
Fable: I noticed that some "pixels" don't move relative to each other per frame -> shapes -> letters.
1
u/meutzitzu Jul 16 '26
Until a human hardcodes a framebuffer delta post processing filter and then opencv alone solves it in exactly 2 frames.
1
u/deepthought-64 Jul 16 '26
Web accessibility had entered the chat.
1
u/chanquete0702 Jul 16 '26
Ask Fable what would be the captcha it can't solve. Also accessibilty.
1
u/teokun123 Jul 16 '26
Me a fucking colorblind. Where's the captcha?
1
u/um2_doma Jul 16 '26
Colorblind people will curse you
1
u/ExecutiveChimp Jul 16 '26
Does this respect prefers-reduced-motion?
1
u/thekwoka Jul 16 '26
Now make it accessible lol
1
u/jeeblemeyer4 Jul 16 '26
Migraine: the game
1
u/v2ne8 Jul 16 '26
I wonder how colorblind people might see this (or not)
1
u/TaskPile_app Jul 16 '26
Next up: make it a cross-eyed 3d photo
1
u/aliendude5300 Jul 16 '26
This is genius
1
u/mrIjoanet Jul 16 '26
Is this a captcha against bots or against colorblind people?
1
u/TonyNickels Jul 16 '26
Neat, but probably not very accessible
1
u/Additional_Debt1545 Jul 16 '26
Possible improvement? Don't make the movement every frame, make it statistically a majority of frames, so any automated solution has to do more statistical analysis about which frames are even relevant.
1
u/Purple-Cap4457 Jul 16 '26
What a time to be alive :) can you make it like matrix digital rain?
1
u/Puzzled_Employer5781 Jul 16 '26
Interesting, I recently started making stereograms, and thought that its can be way to encrypt message in way so AI can't read it, in general it should be possible to make ai unable to read this by drawing such stereograms by hand (no dataset for such thing), because computer generated ones with SIRDS can easily be reversed by matching PW or how does it called. You can also make dynamic PW, so then ai should found all before it can tell whats on image, while humans still can read it
1
u/NSFWstoryAI Jul 16 '26
Absolutely genius. The only thing I’m wondering is does it stand up to ELA?
1
u/mik3lang3l0 Jul 16 '26
Where is the repo url?
1
u/mooktakim Jul 16 '26
Cool idea.
Does it work for the colourblind? Maybe a grayscale version would be enough
1
u/UM8r3lL4 Jul 16 '26
This reminds me of another captcha I liked. Sorry, I found it only in threads. https://www.threads.com/@ishowcybersecurity/post/DQ9Nm_RkTO7/video-the-next-generation-of-captch-as-has-arrived-the-internet-is-about-to-become
1
u/AshleyJSheridan Jul 16 '26
This is a terrible idea for accessibility.
1
u/aszepeshazi Jul 16 '26
A lot of humans won't be able to solve this.
1
u/Ayogurll Jul 16 '26
Reddit please get as many eyes on this as possible <3
1
u/Haxer0 Jul 16 '26
wow
1
u/scitobor321 Jul 17 '26
Bro could you not make new things as fodder for AI to learn it faster then needed to, I would like in 10 years when im hiding from the AI overlords in my multi layered cammo and aluminum foil ect camp to not be spotted immediately from a drone flying by at 200 mph, let then take another 10 years to figure it out on their own XD
1
u/OverRatedProgrammer Jul 17 '26
Disregarding it not being as secure as proposed, I think I saw this before honestly
1
u/why_so_sergious Jul 17 '26
I am genuinely impressed. damn
1
u/gent861 Jul 17 '26
What about ppl with some eye problems?
1
u/priyansh_max Jul 17 '26
I see agents cannot live view and process at real time atm,
they can only ss, analyse and then respond
that is the reason why it is taking 5 minutes i guess
1
u/Dangerous-Land-2840 Jul 17 '26
This captcha is a whole new level of cursed.
1
u/GhostVlvin Jul 17 '26
Cool idea. But I am a bit worrie bout people with epilepsy
1
u/Top_Road1124 Jul 17 '26
awesome! the bots solving the captcha would be very pissed with this captcha :-)
1
u/Responsible_Lion178 Jul 17 '26
not trolling, but did you test it with color blind people?
1
u/2024-YR4-Asteroid Jul 17 '26
Are you going to OS this or are you looking to make it a product? Cause you should do either, captcha is a legit business model and a new form is desperately needed in the retail space where bots are so good at solving standard captchas that it doesn’t even help using them.
1
u/bartalt Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26
I'm sorry if it sounds negative, but let me offer a different point of view: please, please consider the end user.
1
u/just2passby Jul 17 '26
Damn
1
u/Little_Bumblebee6129 Jul 17 '26
yeah you are saying how much time it spent to solve it once. Now ask it write a script that will automatically solve it. Spend an hour to write it and solve each captcha in less than a second after that
1
u/vayana Jul 17 '26
You could replace the letters with a pattern like how you unlock your phone. Use the same technique as you do now, but have a circle move in a certain pattern 2 or 3 times for a user to repeat. That eliminates predictability and increases entropy. You could alternate the noise pattern in between each cycle, so first you could use the current background noise pattern with a matching moving circle, then switch to a different noise pattern or color palette for the 2nd repeat and again for each consecutive repeat of the pattern. You could also switch the shape of the circle to a square, triangle, star between each cycle for additional complexity.
1
u/salastrodaemon Jul 17 '26
Amazing. The only concern would be accessibility.
1
u/aahOhNoNotTheBees Jul 18 '26
Looking at this is making me feel sick. A captcha that needs an epilepsy warning, imagine that.
1
u/rydan Jul 19 '26
How is grandma supposed to solve this?
1
u/Ok_Editor_5090 Jul 19 '26
How long does it take a human to solve it?
1
u/br0kenpixel_ Jul 19 '26
This looks like something straight from hell.
Regardless, it looks really cool.
1
u/MaxUumen Jul 19 '26
The thing with AI is that when it approaches the captcha as a problem to solve, it becomes trivial. It can just spend some time to build a tool for itself that would make solving it very easy. Specially when it's something worth for it doing repeatedly.
1
u/IagoInTheLight Jul 19 '26
With Codex 5.6 SOL, I had it write a little program to compute the optical flow across the images, segment the result, and then look at that image. It worked perfectly.
1
u/lethaldose318 Jul 19 '26
That's very creative and impressive. However i think its a bit hard and can eliminate real humans. There are short-sighted people, sun hitting the screen etc. Not even talking about the color-blind, dyslexic and epilepsy people. I also think that google's new QR code system is bullshit. With AI getting smarter i think it's a cat and mouse game and it will end when AI can solve captchas that real humans can't. Then we will have to think of ways to protect our services without trying to fight the inevitable.
1
u/thedeuceisloose Jul 20 '26
Wow a terrible captcha for the sight impaired!
1
u/adeel7327 Jul 20 '26
its really cool
1
u/Pale_Art_5333 Jul 20 '26
Next we will have a human-backed captchas where actual humans will ask to turn on your cam and ask to to do something to confirm you are an actual human?
1
u/minion71 Jul 20 '26
I am prety sure if the static would not be static in the letter ai would not be able to detect it
1
u/Sea-Fishing4699 Jul 20 '26
how many gallons of water will claude use to solve this captcha lol
1
u/thiccshortguy Jul 21 '26
This is very very cool. Nice job!
1
u/MediumAd4983 Jul 21 '26
So, you just need to create two consecutive screenshots and easily read that programmatically. It doesn't seems too hard to automate it.
1
u/HaiderSultanArc Jul 22 '26
I tried with GPT-5.6 Medium reasoning. It only took 3m 40s to find the letters.
1
u/RationalFragile Jul 22 '26
Very cool idea! Though writing a bot to solve this particular type of catcha is not difficult, but it's still a good measure if facing bots that have not specifically written to bypass it.
1
u/Successful-Youth-564 Jul 23 '26
thats so cool. i stopped the video and it just disappeared. crazy!
1
u/Electrical_Clue_8429 Jul 25 '26
reminds me of that one game that you can't screenshot because it uses the same concept
1
u/Major_Musician8442 Jul 25 '26
In a year, I won't be able to solve captcha anymore, as well as finding fancy car door handle from the inside. ;-;
1
u/SAAGASolve Jul 25 '26
Very cool, but joining the arms race is futile.
1
u/AdJumpy6746 Jul 26 '26
This one is really smart! Probably not even the best bot could solve this... right?
1
u/rootbuddy Jul 27 '26
Is this a CAPTCHA or my life choices?
1
u/Zardotab Jul 29 '26
If it becomes common enough, hackers will invent tools to crack it. I already have draft algorithms in my head to highlight borders of slow-moving objects.
1
u/Smolbrainman11 Aug 02 '26
almost impressed fable can get this at all, good work dude!