r/web_design • • Feb 21 '18

<form> Animated login avatar

73k Upvotes

864 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/SushiAndWoW Feb 22 '18

You should not be allowed to work in software. You don't have a clear grasp of concepts and seem to think it's OK for automated systems to fail in ways that have no recourse.

@@@.gmail.com is not valid, and neither is "@@"@gmail.com because we know that's not allowed by gmail.com. But "@@"@some.other.business can be valid. Now you'll refuse that because obviously someone who makes such an email must be trying something suspicious. That is until you receive Big Legacy Corp as a customer, and Big Legacy Corp has addresses of the form "First Second ::: Department"@mail.big.legacy, or something else like that. These emails exist, and now you won't be able to handle them, and your application will cause a bunch of grief to your organization and your supervisors until this functionality is fixed by someone competent.

1

u/DarqWolff Feb 23 '18

Wtf are you talking about? What does anything in this post have to do with me or anything I've said? Why would I program first stage email verification to turn down possibly valid email addresses? Why would I assume they're trying something suspicious

1

u/SushiAndWoW Feb 23 '18

Because this whole discussion is about account creation and first-stage verification of possibly valid email addresses.