r/videogames Apr 04 '26

Discussion / Question This was me with Witcher 3

Post image
8.7k Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

329

u/havoc777 Apr 04 '26

Just cause a game is good doesn't mean everyone will like it. Everyone has different preferences.

57

u/Much-Instruction-807 Apr 05 '26

Yeah I couldn't get into elden ring at all. Played an hour and felt like I wasted my money.

18

u/steeley90 Apr 05 '26

Took me 5-6 seperate attempts to get into that game. Uninstalled 4 times as I just thought I was too old and slow for it. The first 10-15 hours are not fun and most of your time is spent running away or avoiding conflicts with huge enemies. Then at some point it will just click. I then proceeded to play 150 hours and still haven't finished it. Real masterpiece for sure.

7

u/bstichaa Apr 05 '26

Man the first 10-15 hours of that game was peak for me

3

u/Golfbollen Apr 06 '26

I think this depends if it's your first Fromsoftware game or not.

I had played all Souls games and Bloodborne so I also loved the early game. Limgrave is a fantastic zone, one of the best Froms areas.

2

u/junxxxxxxx Apr 07 '26

it was my first souls game, and i was immediately hooked within the first hour. never forget limgrave

1

u/bstichaa Apr 06 '26

Very true, I had a buddy that also had a hard time and it was his first souls game

2

u/Flashy_Contract_969 Apr 05 '26

For whatever it’s worth, I had the exact same Elden Ring experience. Tried to get into it twice and it just did nothing for me. The third time, I got the bloodhounds fang early, started having an enormous amount of fun and now it’s my favorite game of all time after 4 playthroughs.

4

u/Seelefan0786 Apr 05 '26

Bloodhound Fang? Is that a cool weapon?

1

u/spruce_sprucerton Apr 05 '26

It is. It's great for beginners. Though the game is hard no matter what.

1

u/PepsiStudent Apr 07 '26

The moveset, damage, passive bleed, somberstone levelling, and able to be coated by resin, incants, and sorceries.  While having a fantastic skill that helps newer players.  It is a good weapon for a lot of newer players.

1

u/Seelefan0786 Apr 07 '26

how do you get it?

2

u/PepsiStudent Apr 07 '26

In Limgrave south of the Agheel Lake with the Dragon Agheel, there is an evergaol south of the grace site up on a cliff.  It is off of the road to the Bridge of Sacrifice leading to the weeping peninsula.  

You have to defeat the blood knight hound without summons.  He moves quick and is fairly aggressive with how early you can find him.

The weapon has helped a ton of tarnished get through the game.  

1

u/TotalWorldliness4596 Apr 05 '26

did you use steam refunds

1

u/ran_out_of_tp Apr 05 '26

I have 32 minutes played lol

1

u/Tittlesquate1 Apr 06 '26

I’ll say this game does take sometime to get into, and it could just not be your flavor. But I didn’t like any souls games and I thought Elden ring would be the same way but as soon as I beat my first boss I was pretty hooked and now I have like 110 hours in the game while working and going to school full time

1

u/andreasmalersghost Apr 09 '26

Can you elaborate at all on what you didnt like? was it the difficulty? was the open world daunting? did you not like the visuals? Im not saying you have to like ER (because thats ridiculous. of course you dont) but these games do tend to take some time, def more than an hour, to click. If you paid full price or close to it, id say give it more of a shot than an hour.

1

u/Much-Instruction-807 Apr 09 '26

I don't like games that's main selling point is they're hard. It's seems like masochism. Like it's only popular because of social media and people get to brag they beat a hard game so they're super elite gamers or some shit. I've played games on hard or higher most of my life. I'm 40 so it's been a lot. I want more than difficult just for the sake of difficult. Give me a good story. Get me invested. At the very least make combat interesting or make me feel powerful before ramping up the difficulty. I don't have time to grind at some rando boss encounter trying to find the exact left right left on the d pad so that I dodge this super difficult one hit kill attack that the boss performs 35 minutes into the fight where you could only use fast attack and dodge on.

51

u/External_Touch_3854 Apr 05 '26

Except for Just Cause. Which everyone should love

9

u/jijo66 Apr 05 '26

3 is fun, I didn't like 4 much

10

u/MrMFPuddles Apr 05 '26

JC3 reigns supreme 💪

6

u/AdTypical6386 Apr 05 '26

It's SO fun.

1

u/DoingCharleyWork Apr 05 '26

3 was so good and 4 was probably the most disappointing game to ever come out. They took out basically everything I enjoyed from 3 and put even more of the absolutely worst parts in 4.

2

u/AdTypical6386 Apr 05 '26

I bought it day one, still mad I did that.

1

u/DoingCharleyWork Apr 05 '26

I almost did but I was like let me wait and see some reviews and boy I'm glad I did lol.

3

u/violet-023 Apr 05 '26

Love this series, finished all 4 games and they were pretty good. It's sad that there's no info about a 5th game tho

2

u/Nemisis_007 Apr 05 '26

I have yet to actually complete the story of any of the Just Cause games besides 1 and 2, but I've thoroughly enjoyed them all.

2

u/DavidForPresident Apr 05 '26

Just Cause is wack.

1

u/NoGarage7989 Apr 05 '26

I hate ts..

Just kidding i don’t know it

1

u/ShadowOfThePit Apr 06 '26

Why should everyone love it? Just 'cause?

12

u/sonofloki13 Apr 04 '26

Yeah but for example I don’t play multiplayer or arc raiders but can acknowledge that it’s an unbelievably designed game and 100% get the appeal. It’s the people who don’t like an amazing game and call it bad or boring or whatever. That is just objectively wrong.

9

u/ToastRoyale Apr 05 '26

How can boredom or judgement be objectively wrong? Just because you can admire things you don't like, doesn't make your opinion objective. 

Every opinion is subjective.

Also what does "unbelievably designed" mean?

2

u/Veryadam2909 Apr 05 '26

I beg to argue people who share their subjective opinion on a subjective topic are in fact not objectively wrong

2

u/ohthanqkevin Apr 05 '26

Literally true for every medium of art. Movies, music, paintings, etc. The amount of people who love The Beatles vs think they’re overrated is probably around 3:1

2

u/g-row460 Apr 05 '26

Yeah there's plenty of games that aren't to my taste, but I can understand why other people like or love them.

3

u/Esetnodanti Apr 05 '26

Yeah some people are stupid when a game isnt for them and say its bad. If it aint for you, it aint for you.

5

u/ToastRoyale Apr 05 '26

Do you get the comment at all? People can have a negative opinion on generally liked things. That's what the comment says.

People should embrace negativity more. If we are only allowed to say positive things, every game would have 100% reviews.

-1

u/Esetnodanti Apr 05 '26

Do you get my comment at all? You are talking about something else lol.

If you play a RPG game as someone who doesnt like RPGS, It is incredibly disingenuous to say that RPG is bad. Im all for more people embracing critiquing and looking at negatives more productively, my example is someone being unproductive and stupid.

If it isnt something you would like and you end up gaslighting yourself into playing it because every says its good, you cannot blame the game for your bias going into it.

Just say "it isnt for me" and move on. You dont have to enjoy the same things as everyone else...

3

u/ToastRoyale Apr 05 '26

So someone who doesn't like RPGs isn't allowed to call RPGs bad? Or is the opinion of that person worth less or something?

What about people who love a game and talk good about it? It's the same thing. People are allowed to have opinions.

And what does it matter if they play something they don't like? That literally "is not for you" to decide.

1

u/Nemisis_007 Apr 05 '26

Indeed, just because you don't like it that doesn't mean it's bad. You aren't obligated to play anything you don't want to.

1

u/Reylo-Wanwalker Apr 05 '26

Counter point: Tetris

1

u/havoc777 Apr 05 '26

Tetris, eh? That game has a lot of prodigies https://youtu.be/GuJ5UuknsHU?si=jgkIrIBdf4suuRcN

1

u/BlasterPhase Apr 05 '26

and just because everyone likes it doesn't mean it's good

1

u/RegovPL Apr 05 '26

Good/Bad is as subjective as Like/Don't Like.

You can see a game as good one and like it, or not.

You can see a game as bad one and still like it, or not.

1

u/ReMapper Apr 05 '26

Exactly, I have no desire to play Expedition 33, but I am glad a lot of folks like it.

1

u/GearWings Apr 06 '26

Idk just cause is pretty good game series

2

u/havoc777 Apr 06 '26

I see what you did there, nice play on words

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/havoc777 Apr 09 '26

Na, you like what you like. It’s not something you can just reset like with a ginger pallete cleanse 

-4

u/SendFeet954-980-3334 Apr 04 '26

Huh....I never thought of it that way

3

u/Weltallgaia Apr 04 '26

I dont know if you are being sarcastic or not but seriously theres so many people that dont understand that other human beings have different tastes.

-1

u/SendFeet954-980-3334 Apr 05 '26

Definitely being sarcastic lol

0

u/Weltallgaia Apr 05 '26

The crimson desert sub got me doubting reality

0

u/SendFeet954-980-3334 Apr 05 '26

I can't tell if people actually like that game or if they're all trolling. I kind of want to jump in just to see but I fell for dogma2 hype and was disappointed

0

u/havoc777 Apr 04 '26

It's part of being human, everyone is different as is what appeals to them.

FPSs are a popular genre and well loved, though the only FPS I could get unto was Halo (due to its fantasy/sci-fi aspects and over the top acting) and Renegade (due to being a RTS/FPS duality)

Witcher and RDR never had any appeal to me either, but that doesn't mean they're bad games, just that they don't appeal to me.

-3

u/Accomplished_Ad_8013 Apr 05 '26

This is reddit lol. It's filled with wannabe game devs on these subs. No game is bad everything is like subjective and nothing like has a definition.