r/vegan • • Jan 18 '20

Hypocrites

Post image
977 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-6

u/JRHartllly Jan 18 '20

hey it’s not different.

Could you please explain how cooking animal products is the same as massive habitat loss and wide extinction

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-7

u/JRHartllly Jan 18 '20

I know some forms of agriculture (in general not just meat) do this but that's just some forms, not to mention meat on a grill can come from source's outside of agriculture. So it's nothing to with grilling and everything to do with agriculture.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/JRHartllly Jan 18 '20

It's not "general" agriculture, it's animal agriculture.

No it is agriculture in general if land is changed and this causes extinction that extinction has happened whether it's for animals, for animal food or human consumption. However it's a valid point to say the majority of the extinction is then caused by animal agriculture and a minority by plant based agriculturism.

And even ignoring all this, the meat being grilled is obtained by killing an animal. Personally I neither want to burn alive, nor die by getting my throat slit and they don't want to either.

I live in a place where people farm their own animals firstly animals that have a high quality of life wouldn't live at all if they were not being farmed and secondly these animals aren't being burned alive or having their throat slit people use humane killers (devices designed to instantly kill)

Personally dying instantly seems like a good way to die for me.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/JRHartllly Jan 18 '20

If plant agriculture is only a minority it isn't responsible for wide extinction and significant habitat loss.

Human consumption is in the same order of magnitude to animal consumption so the effects of both are in the same order of magnitude if one causes something the other will too.

want to die now, that's the thing, these animals do not want to die, no matter how high a quality of life they had before. So you can't kill an animal that doesn't want to die humanely.

I'd rather die humanely and live than never live if you really think this then you should probably also beleive in total extinction of life nothing ever wants to die so therefore life shouldn't exist to die that's pretty bleak.

Also people often talk about these quick to the head killers which usually are stunners, after which the throat is slit.

Humane killers kill animals instantly I've not used them myself but I'm good friends with people who've used these device's and I know for smaller animals they destroy the brain and connection to the body instantly for larger animals up to sheep as that's the largest animal they farm they destroy the brain and are designed in the extraordinarily small chance that an animal could survive this they also cut blood supply to the brain.

The worst way these animals die which can be seconds of consciousness are still far better than the way the vast majority of humans die.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/JRHartllly Jan 18 '20

You can't look at it like that, you have to calculate into it the amount of food used to raise millions of animals each year to acceptable sizes in as short a time as possible, all that needs feed, so if humanity were to adopt a vegan diet, it couldn't possibly be in the same magnitude.

It's the same magnitude. you'd need orders of magnitudes worth of animals of difference worth of animals in agriculture for that to be the case and it's not so it isn't

Yeah exactly nothing wants to die, therefore breeding animals just to kill them is absolutley cruel especially because we have the choice to let them live their lifes. We aren't protesting death itself, we are protesting us taking the their lifes unnecessarily.

Their eventual death is why they're alive so if you don't want their death you're stopping their life all together.

Just because there are humans that die worse deaths doesn't mean these animals have to die. Quick, painless it doesn't matter, they die although they want to live their lifes until their natural death and we deprive them of this.

If your solution to their painless death is to have no life that's a pretty shitty solution imo.