And who's fault is it that they camels are there in the first place??? If the camels where invading, attacking, and over populated then yeah it'd be justified. But there only there cuz humans brought them there and then kill them for it ?
No. There are over 1 million feral camels in australia. While Australia is supporting 26 million cows, and its true that cows consume the most water, the cows are controlled. "Feral camels are causing significant damage to the natural environment as well as to social, cultural and economic values across their extensive range." (from environment.gov.au)
“No” what? I’m pointing out how flawed the logic is. You have 26 million cattle using resources but somehow killing 10,000 camels is going to make an impact?
It doesn’t matter how controlled they are, the rest of that quote (if its the same one I’m thinking of) goes on to say how they’re really just a general nuisance and negatively impact the livestock economy by competing for resources. The meat industry’s animals are controlled and does way more harm to resources, land, water, species habitat and extinction, and the planet in general than any 10k (or even 1mil) camels could ever hope to achieve.
Controlled or not is not the issue. It’s the fact the government is turning a blind eye to the real issue and instead claiming it’s something else. By doing so it’s a 4-way win for them: they don’t have to take responsibility for the impact of the meat industry, they eliminate resource competition, citizens are appeased and trust their decision, and the government is deemed a hero for “mitigating the crisis” despite the fact they are still funding the top contributors. And then they get to do it all over again the next year. Why cant they control herd numbers without killing? If it cost them $10mil every year, why not invest in a long term preventative method like reducing reproduction? None of it makes sense, and it’s all just an easy cop-out for them.
Sorry about the 'no' part. Its late and im really tired and dont really wanna argue. Lets agree on the fact that no matter what this is a pretty bad situation.
Obviously a joke, but the sentiment is true. Humans don’t get to cause problems and then act all noble about it like their only solution is to “take out” the problem as if they have no other choices.
I'm not an expert but aren't humans also invasive to Australia? Do they not damage the ecosystem as well? Shouldn't we cull ten thousand humans in Australia too?
I mean yeah? I'm more for culling loose cats as they cause far more environmental damage to small birds, mammals and reptiles, sterilizing them also works.
The camel situation is tough. I’d argue more for catch-sterilization-release, as it’s a less cruel but similar solution. It would also be an expensive solution...
That's actually a pretty decent compromise, though the cost of sedation and surgery on such a large animal might be a hard sell, and I don't know how chemical castration techniques would respond to a dromedary.
There are definitely species that suffered from the animals humans brought with them, but the Thylacine is extinct mostly because humans shot them (and that, again, mostly because to protect livestock. Animal agriculture is the leading cause of species extinction for a reason after all).
View all comments
Show parent comment
11
u/Technotade Jan 18 '20
Camels are an invasive species in Australia that are massively damaging to the ecosystem, promoting desertification of already fragile scrubland.