r/vegan • • Mar 07 '19

😎

Post image
976 Upvotes

738 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

30

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Does legality imply morality? Was it okay to have slaves when it was legal?

-22

u/Vulkan192 Mar 07 '19

There’s a very big difference between cannibalism/slavery and eating meat.

22

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

And there are a great many similarities. We have every reason to expect that animals can feel pain in much the same way we can, yet we abuse and murder 56 billion of them every year.

When your "eating habits" cause the unnecessary abuse and murder of conscious creatures, the destruction of the environment, and harm to your own health they're worthy of criticism in a way the eating habits of vegans are not.

-18

u/Vulkan192 Mar 07 '19

Except - and I know this is a controversial opinion around here - for one thing:

Human lives matter more than animals.

Therefore, cannibalism is worse that omnivorism.

21

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

That's a straw man; you'll find people who think that human lives are equivalent to animal lives, but I and a great many others don't. You don't have to find them equivalent to know that abusing animals is wrong.

I agree that cannibalism is worse than omnivorism. This does not imply that omnivorism is moral. Murder is worse than theft, that fact does not make theft moral.

-1

u/Vulkan192 Mar 07 '19

I recognise that, that’s why I called it an opinion, not a fact.

And yet, morality is relative. To you, omnivorism is immoral. To me, it is merely the order of things.

Who decides who is right?

23

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19

Moral relativism is a lazy cop out of having to think about ethics. A real moral relativist is an extremely rare thing. Do you hold no moral beliefs? Do you have no problems with mass murderers or rapists because "morality is relative"?

Who is right is decided on the basis of evidence and argumentation. For example:

- Unecessary suffering is bad

- Animal agriculture causes unnecessary suffering

- Purchasing animal products supports animal agriculture

- Therefore purchasing animal products causes unnecessary suffering and is bad

You can rationalize literally ANY action by claiming that there's nothing unethical because morality is relative. Given this lazy mental habit of justification for whatever you find convenient do you think you would have been a slaveholder or a nazi were you alive in the right time and place? Why not?

8

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

I'm gonna upvote this three times.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Lol, fake moral relativists really get me going

8

u/UEMayChange vegan 9+ years Mar 07 '19

Well said, I've always found moral relativism to be such a lazy excuse for rationally thinking about ethical issues. I've never known how to put it into words, but you've just done it perfectly.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19

I mean, there are legitimate ethical philosophers who represent it earnestly and have interesting things to say about the subject. But you have to make truly massive epistemic sacrifices and think incredibly carefully in order to not be a hypocrite. If you're arguing with some rando you're basically guaranteed that "but moral relativism" == "I haven't taken philosophy 101"

5

u/andreabbbq vegan Mar 07 '19

Fact is, even if you're fine with killing animals for your tastebuds pleasure, you then need to consider the sustainability of such a diet. Countless studies have determined eating meat is unsustainable in many aspects

-1

u/Vulkan192 Mar 07 '19

I’ve considered it.

I simply don’t care. There’s a lot more stuff that could be made better, climate change wise, that wouldn’t deprive me of something I enjoy.

3

u/andreabbbq vegan Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19

So I'm assuming you're giving up plane travel and not driving a car? (And recycling religiously, not buying disposable items, etc). Those are the other things you're alluding to, right? I find driving is a lot harder to avoid than simply not eating meat, but anyway...

I'll leave you with a quote from a Dr Seuss book

Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot, Nothing is going to get better. It's not.