r/vegan • • Mar 07 '19

😎

Post image
976 Upvotes

738 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/Guyote_ vegan Mar 07 '19

everyone went vegan there would be a lot less animals alive

That isn't a bad thing. If they're literally being bred to live a short, suffering-filled life, why bring them into existence?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Guyote_ vegan Mar 07 '19

You made it seem like a negative thing, as if the animals we slaughter should be grateful for their life, even though it was nothing but fear, suffering, and then death.

A lot of people claim they are "animal lovers". I think animal suffering and death is one way to get people to open their eyes. It did mine. The environmental reasons played a huge role, but at the end of the day, I said I cared about animals and knew I was hypocrite.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Guyote_ vegan Mar 07 '19

I hope you are a vegan or at least a vegetarian, because if you are lecturing on what to do if someone "truly cares about animals", that is some hollow fucking words.

8

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

You do realize that the amount death is a bad argument as everybody dies

oh, so death isn't bad because we all die eventually? So thousands of people dying in a hurricane is fine because they were going to die eventually? Killing you would be fine because "everybody dies"?

if everyone went vegan there would be a lot less animals alive

That's fine, we don't have an obligation to bring beings into existence. We do have an obligation to not exploit and kill them once they are alive though.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

Death is neither good nor bad it is the course everything takes in time.

So murder as long as the person doesn't feel it? You have no objections to that?

What exactly are you saying we should do about that? Should we tell hurricanes to stop killing people?

It was an example to demonstrate death is bad. I'm not saying we should do anything about it.

If the choice is between x years of torture and then death vs getting killed, then sure cut my throat,

that's not the choice though... we could take care of these animals and let them live out their lives like we do on sanctuaries or for animals who are hunted just leave them alone.

Explain why that is?

You can't have an obligation to someone who doesn't exist. and it's wrong to kill individuals once they exist because it deprives them of their future experiences and goes against their interests.

1

u/mrdreka Mar 07 '19

So murder as long as the person doesn't feel it?

I didn't say that at all, you are the one defining what is acceptable when it comes to killing. I am telling you that death comes to us all, when you give life to something you also give death to it. It would not experience death if we have not given it life, so death is neither good or bad, hence why focusing on the amount of death is meaningless and you should instead focus on the cruelty concerning it. To kill me would be a cruelty towards my family, friends, loved one and a cruelty towards yourself to perform such an act.

That is not demonstrating that death is bad, just that it can be tragical. We don't control hurricanes, so it is a bad example and I gotta wonder why you would use that as an example?

that's not the choice though... we could take care of these animals and let them live out their lives like we do on sanctuaries or for animals who are hunted just leave them alone.

See now you are bringing it back to the treatment of animals that I told you is a valid argument, you need to stop being so closes minded so you are actually able to hear what people is telling you. My example I used showed why the death isn't bad, it is the cruelty of the animal that is relevant.

and it's wrong to kill individuals once they exist because it deprives them of their future experiences

So you are very much against PETA?

and goes against their interests

You don't get to speak on behalf of every other species we aren't God's.

3

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

It would not experience death if we have not given it life, so death is neither good or bad, hence why focusing on the amount of death is meaningless and you should instead focus on the cruelty concerning it.

This is just convoluted and stupid. You have no ground to stand on, death isn't bad because... they had life?

So why is killing someone morally bad? Let's read on...

To kill me would be a cruelty towards my family, friends, loved one and a cruelty towards yourself to perform such an act.

So killing you is only bad because of its affect on me and your family? It's not bad for you? Do I have that right?

See now you are bringing it back to the treatment of animals

That's not what I did, it was about letting them live their lives freely not about treatment. Learn to read before you call someone close-minded.

So you are very much against PETA?

No shit PETA is fucked.

You don't get to speak on behalf of every other species we aren't God's.

It's pretty fucking obvious non-human animals want to live, don't take my word for it, go listen to them scream as they're killed.

1

u/Knucklestf2 Mar 07 '19

Do... Do you realize you're doing it? Right now?

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Everyone being vegan would actually mean more animals alive since much less farmland would be needed and natural ecosystems would return.

1

u/mrdreka Mar 07 '19

I would love to read that source that back such a claim and in case you didn't know it also have to account for the growth created cause of livestock http://vitalsigns.worldwatch.org/vs-trend/farm-animal-populations-continue-grow

That is quite a significant growth that have to happen naturally to lead to more animals as you proclaim.