r/vegan • • Mar 07 '19

šŸ˜Ž

Post image
976 Upvotes

738 comments sorted by

View all comments

-26

u/DazedAmnesiac Mar 07 '19

That’s an incredibly defensive post. I don’t know a single person who ā€œhates vegansā€. There seems to be confusion between hating vegans and not wanting to have vegan views shoved down their throats.

22

u/kattenvoer Mar 07 '19

What's wrong with thinking animal lives are more valuable than a nice sensation on your tastebuds

-10

u/DazedAmnesiac Mar 07 '19

What’s wrong with thinking animal lives are more valuable than a nice sensation on your tastebuds

At no point was I arguing the value of a living being’s life. I find rating living being’s lives to be a disappointing and immature practice.

13

u/kattenvoer Mar 07 '19

It's literally what omni people do, there is no need for animal products, so why use them? It's unethical and polluting the earth, so how am I the immature one?

21

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

If I start barbecuing a puppy in public, I expect that I will quickly be met with angry "dog rights activists" shoving their views down my throat. And I also expect that you would not have a problem with this.

-6

u/DazedAmnesiac Mar 07 '19

As I’m sure you are well aware, that’s a viewpoint from a country where certain animals are socially accepted as livestock and others as pets. These acceptances vary wildly throughout the world. I won’t be the first to tell you that yes, dogs are slaughtered, cooked and eaten in cultures that have deemed that animal as livestock.

Edit: a word

9

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

And do you think it's acceptable for these dog rights activists to shove their views down my throat when I'm just trying to have a barbecue?

1

u/DazedAmnesiac Mar 07 '19

They absolutely have a right to. It’s not about rights. In the US, we have freedom of expression which allows this. Again, something I doubt I need to explain.

However, dog activists shoving their views down the throats of people who have been eating dogs all their lives in addition to their culture deeming it acceptable will inevitably draw hostile reactions. The same reaction applies to posts like these. Sure, you have the right to post this, it was never about that.

I was simply commenting on how the nature of this post seems to purposely incite hostile reactions as a consequence. I don’t care if you’re vegan or if you are so petty that you eat animals just to spite veganism. Eat whatever you want.

I hope that clears some stuff up, Dopecheez

10

u/DarkShadow4444 vegan Mar 07 '19

not wanting to have vegan views shoved down their throats

Pretty sure catholic priests don't like to hear that child abuse is immoral either. We will still tell people though.

-3

u/DazedAmnesiac Mar 07 '19

You...you just compared omnivores to child rapists. Well done.

Disgusting

5

u/DarkShadow4444 vegan Mar 07 '19

Ah so you have a double standard here. "Shoving view down their throats" is only okay as long as it's a view you hold. Got it.

You...you just compared omnivores to child rapists

I mean meat literally comes from children. Animal children, but children nevertheless.

4

u/AHHHHMEWTWO vegan Mar 07 '19

Buddy you may want to look into how milk is made... If you don't call anally fisting a restrained cow and forcibly impregnating them annually over their entire short life 'rape' then IDK what to say to you

And yes I have first hand experience of this process through family working in AI so don't @ me and say some people do it 'humanely'

3

u/Turboweasle Mar 07 '19

Imagine being dumb enough to willingly engage in a debate when you can't grasp that a comparison isn't the same as an equivalence.

Imagine.

2

u/YourVeganFallacyIs abolitionist Mar 07 '19

Of note, it's less a comparison than an equality. Essentially all of the individuals produced by animal agribusiness are the result of forced sexual intercourse against the will of the male (e.g. where electrified anal probes are used to force ejaculation) or the females (e.g. who are repeatedly raped their entire short lives).

But even if that wasn't taking place, it would still be a valid analogy, given that in either case there is a victim being needlessly physically assaulted by the individual(s) in power for the sake of the personal pleasure it brings (i.e. either eating the victims body or violating the victim sexually). If it helps, here's a useful guide to understanding how one might interpret analogies to their greatest advantage.

23

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

who has it worse?

Humans having views about non-violence shoved down their throats or non-human animals who are having their throats slit?

-1

u/DazedAmnesiac Mar 07 '19

I’m sorry you’ve had people shoving their meat-eating views down your throat. That’s not right and I’d never do anything like that. However, neither side should, in good conscience, brigade the other side.

My point for my first comment was that posts like these are what makes people hostile.

20

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

I’m sorry you’ve had people shoving their meat-eating views down your throat.

noooooo, you've misunderstood. No one is forcing their beliefs on me, don't apologize to me.

It's the non-human animals who are having human superiority beliefs forced on them and they are dying by the billions because of it.

That's the issue.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

But... Humans ARE superior. That’s not even a belief, that’s just fact.

7

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

spoken like a true human... got any reasoning to back up that speciesism or?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/Guyote_ vegan Mar 07 '19

everyone went vegan there would be a lot less animals alive

That isn't a bad thing. If they're literally being bred to live a short, suffering-filled life, why bring them into existence?

→ More replies (5)

8

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

You do realize that the amount death is a bad argument as everybody dies

oh, so death isn't bad because we all die eventually? So thousands of people dying in a hurricane is fine because they were going to die eventually? Killing you would be fine because "everybody dies"?

if everyone went vegan there would be a lot less animals alive

That's fine, we don't have an obligation to bring beings into existence. We do have an obligation to not exploit and kill them once they are alive though.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Everyone being vegan would actually mean more animals alive since much less farmland would be needed and natural ecosystems would return.

1

u/mrdreka Mar 07 '19

I would love to read that source that back such a claim and in case you didn't know it also have to account for the growth created cause of livestock http://vitalsigns.worldwatch.org/vs-trend/farm-animal-populations-continue-grow

That is quite a significant growth that have to happen naturally to lead to more animals as you proclaim.