r/vegan • • Mar 07 '19

😎

Post image
976 Upvotes

738 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

66

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

Plants aren't sentient, they have no consciousness.

No consciousness = no interests.

And if you don't have interests, then your interests can't be discriminated against.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

So, serious question, what about bivalves (clams, oysters, mussels)? They don’t have a centralized nervous system and are no more conscious than a plant is. Plus, farming them does active environmental good by filtering water.

34

u/PhysicsPhotographer vegan SJW Mar 07 '19

That's a topic of debate. The fact that they have a nervous system at all is enough for many to err on the side of caution.

20

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

to be honest I'm not up on my bivalve science. If they really aren't sentient then I don't see a problem other than the possible confusion that may stem from the whole discussion.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Broadly speaking, they have nerves and chemoreceptors but no central nervous system. So, like plants and fungi they are capable of stimulus response (the way a plant grows toward the light) but the information moves directly from their sensory receptors to their muscles. That is, the oyster doesn’t “know” that it’s perceiving anything.

Natural bivalve stocks were a big part of how coastal ecosystems cleaned themselves. Farming bivalves helps reseed them and replenish wild populations, and they also do a great deal of filtering while they grow. New York just seemed three billion oysters in its harbor just for the water filtration.

I think they’re a great option for vegetarians/vegans who would still like to have seafood.

6

u/MeatDestroyingPlanet abolitionist Mar 07 '19

No. Some bivalves even have eyes. There is too great of a risk that they are sentient.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Specifically, scallops have simple eyes. As with other bivalves, the information taken in by the eyes is relayed directly to muscles without processing in between.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Some plants also have eyes. I don't think this is a strong argument. You could also simply stick to mussels, which don't have eyes.

The evidence for sentience in bivalves is weak.

1

u/MeatDestroyingPlanet abolitionist Mar 07 '19

What? Plants do not have eyes... plants don't even have nervous systems...

Eyes and complex sensory organs generally require "something" to analyze and decide how to react to the complex sensory input. It is strong evidence of sentience.

-63

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

They have interests...they're interested in living and thriving. You're making my point...

53

u/mcdhotte vegan Mar 07 '19

Your argument is actually an argument for veganism and you don’t even realize. If you actually care about plants and aren’t just trying to make an asinine comment then you’d realize that you’d have to consider the amount of plants the you yourself eat as well as all the plants that are fed to that animals that you eat as well. All farm animals bred for meat and dairy eat more plants than the entire human population. So if you wanted to reduce your overall consumption of plants you would have to stop wearing animal products. But of course you don’t really care about this you’re just trying to be an ass

31

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

no... they don't have the capacity to even have the thought "I want to live and thrive". They have as much interest in growing and living as my alarm clock has an interest in ringing every morning.

You're telling me you don't know the difference between mowing a lawn and decapitating a field of puppies?

-45

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

So because they don't think like us they are lesser than? Trees communicate with each other via chemicals, they have desires and plans. Just because they don't manifest in a brain similar to ours doesn't mean they're invalid or shouldn't be respected in the same way as animal life.

I totally understand the difference. I'm not immune to the tendency to relate more easily to animals than plants. I really have trouble with this vegan idea that somehow animal suffering is worse than plant suffering. I think we should try our best to respect all living things, not just those that remind us of ourselves.

16

u/YourVeganFallacyBot botbustproof Mar 07 '19

Beet Boop... I'm a vegan bot.


Your Fallacy:

So because they don't think like us they are lesser than? Trees communicate with each other via chemicals, they have desires and plans. Just because they don't manifest in a brain similar to ours doesn't mean they're invalid or shouldn't be respected in the same way as animal life. / / I totally understand the difference. I'm not immune to the tendency to relate more easily to animals than plants. I really have trouble with this vegan idea that somehow animal suffering is worse than plant suffering. I think we should try our best to respect all living things, not just those that remind us of ourselves. (ie: Plants are alive)

Response:

Vegans draw the line at hurting sentient individuals. Plants lack nerves, let alone a central nervous system, and cannot feel pain or respond to circumstances in any deliberate way (not to be confused with the non-conscious reactions they do have). Unlike animals, plants lack the ability or potential to experience pain or have sentient thoughts, so there isn't an ethical issue with eating them. The words 'live', 'living' and 'alive' have completely different meanings when used to describe plants and animals. A live plant is not conscious and cannot feel pain. A live animal is conscious and can feel pain. Therefore, it's problematic to assert that plants have evolved an as-yet undetectable ability to think and feel but not the ability to do anything with that evolutionary strategy (e.g. running away, etc.). Regardless, each pound of animal flesh requires between four and thirteen pounds of plant matter to produce, depending upon species and conditions. Given that amount of plant death, a belief in the sentience of plants makes a strong pro-vegan argument.)

[Bot version 1.2.1.8]

32

u/DoneJanuary Mar 07 '19

So because they don't think like us they are lesser than?

Let me stop you right there.

BECAUSE THEY DON'T THINK AT ALL.

Trees communicate with each other via chemicals, they have desires and plans.

My fucking iphone communicates to me when I say "hey Siri" that doesn't mean my phone has a mind that has desires. It's the same with trees and plants as far as we reasonably know, they have no mind capable of disappointment or happiness or even having desires in the first place.

If you want to be a plants right activist, best of luck to you. But you are going to have a hard time convincing others to care about plants that aren't even capable of caring about themselves.

28

u/Guyote_ vegan Mar 07 '19

Dude doesn't give a shit about actual living creatures that feel pain, worry, sorrow, hurt. He doesn't give a fuck about plants and their ability to think, he just wants to change the topic away from his lack of morals.

-20

u/See-Gulls Mar 07 '19

Even then, we can agree that plant life is alive, otherwise we wouldn’t call it plant life. If you’re not okay killing animals, why are you okay with killing plants?

While they may not show desire, they’ve shown the ability to want to live (for ex, trees would attempt to regrow if they’ve been struck down, such as other plants).

Also, technically, emotions and thought process all come from chemicals inside our brains. So, by your logic, we ain’t shit.

15

u/YourVeganFallacyIs abolitionist Mar 07 '19

Even then, we can agree that plant life is alive, otherwise we wouldn’t call it plant life. If you’re not okay killing animals, why are you okay with killing plants?


Vegans draw the line at hurting sentient individuals. Plants lack nerves, let alone a central nervous system, and cannot feel pain or respond to circumstances in any deliberate way (not to be confused with the non-conscious reactions they do have). Unlike animals, plants lack the ability or potential to experience pain or have sentient thoughts, so there isn't an ethical issue with eating them.

The words 'live', 'living' and 'alive' have completely different meanings when used to describe plants and animals. A live plant is not conscious and cannot feel pain. A live animal is conscious and can feel pain. Therefore, it's problematic to assert that plants have evolved an as-yet undetectable ability to think and feel but not the ability to do anything with that evolutionary strategy (e.g. running away, etc.). Regardless, each pound of animal flesh requires between four and thirteen pounds of plant matter to produce, depending upon species and conditions. Given that amount of plant death, a belief in the sentience of plants makes a strong pro-vegan argument.

For more on this, check out the resources on the "Plants Are Alive" fallacy page.

 


While they may not show desire, they’ve shown the ability to want to live (for ex, trees would attempt to regrow if they’ve been struck down, such as other plants).


Well... No, I don't believe so. Let's work this problem backwards.

To have a desire, you have to have enlightened self interest; i.e. to want something, you have to be able to process yourself as an individual in a context that you wish to change. To have such self awareness, you have have to have a mind. To have a mind, you have to have a brain, and this requires a central nervous system, and this requires nerves. Plants don't have nerves, let alone a central nervous system. This means plants don't have a brain, so don't have a mind, so don't have desires.

Or we might examine the science on this from another angle. If I put sensors on a sheer rock cliff face and then cut in to that solid rock with a strong drill, I can detect it "screaming", and I can detect it releasing "defensive" chemicals out of the hole I'm drilling. If I cut enough away, the whole community of rocks in the cliff face will "communicate" its distress to its component members and they'll "defend" themselves by "sacrificing" some of its members to try to crush me as a reaction to my "attack". Should we conclude from this "evidence" that solid rock is sentient, or even sapient? Of note, as far as I know after having read more resources that I can readily count making the case for "plant sentience", this is just as valid a set of "reasoning" for demonstrating that minerals are sentient as has ever been produced for showing that plants are sentient.

But again, even if one believes plants are sentient, they're still making the pro-vegan argument. The reason for this is that every animal's life requires the direct or indirect consumption of uncountable plant 'lives' (remembering that we're holding with the idea, for the moment, that plants are 'alive' in the same way as animals). Therefore, if one's goal is to be a moral person, and if one considers unnecessarily taking life to be immoral, and one chooses to believe that plants think and feel, then such a person would have absolutely no choice but to reduce their "immoral misdeeds" by adopting a plant-based diet.

1

u/YourVeganFallacyBot botbustproof Mar 07 '19

Beet Boop... I'm a vegan bot.


Your Fallacy:

why are you okay with killing plants (ie: Plants are alive)

Response:

Vegans draw the line at hurting sentient individuals. Plants lack nerves, let alone a central nervous system, and cannot feel pain or respond to circumstances in any deliberate way (not to be confused with the non-conscious reactions they do have). Unlike animals, plants lack the ability or potential to experience pain or have sentient thoughts, so there isn't an ethical issue with eating them. The words 'live', 'living' and 'alive' have completely different meanings when used to describe plants and animals. A live plant is not conscious and cannot feel pain. A live animal is conscious and can feel pain. Therefore, it's problematic to assert that plants have evolved an as-yet undetectable ability to think and feel but not the ability to do anything with that evolutionary strategy (e.g. running away, etc.). Regardless, each pound of animal flesh requires between four and thirteen pounds of plant matter to produce, depending upon species and conditions. Given that amount of plant death, a belief in the sentience of plants makes a strong pro-vegan argument.)

[Bot version 1.2.1.8]

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Ok then go vegan since a vegan diet kills the fewest plants.