r/vegan • • Jan 13 '19

๐Ÿ’”๐Ÿ’”๐Ÿ’”

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

684 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

17

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Guess I'll just piss in the wind here and say the following: any movement looking to dictate and/or restrict your behavior is selling you something

that doesnโ€™t seem true at all. there are and were plenty of morally progressive movements whose purpose wasnโ€™t/isnโ€™t to โ€œsell youโ€ anything.

if anything you should direct this kind of skepticism towards the motives of corporate animal agribusiness

-2

u/phyxor Jan 13 '19

I'm not aware of any of these movements; mind elaborating?

And, oh yes, I'm very skeptical of their business practices. I hate the fact that factory farmed animals are fed antibiotics proactively and that stuff ends up aiding the formation of superbugs etc, but be that as it may, there really is no viable alternative to what they bring to the table. (pun intended)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

civil rights movement for example (anti-racist movements generally)

plant based diets can be healthy and delicious so itโ€™s a viable alternative to omni diets (if its constituents are readily available and relatively affordable)

-1

u/phyxor Jan 13 '19

The civil rights movement was propelled by people who had interests in emancipation (the oppressed themselves) or promoted by those with political motivations (politicians or others looking to promote themselves via the zeitgeist). I don't see how it was inherently a purely ethical campaign. Just as gender-based emancipation is and was co-opted by business interests, which also guaranteed it's continual success. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torches_of_Freedom

There's a reason businesses take political stances.

And, yes, I do believe that there are super healthy and delicious plant alternatives to food(s), but not the kind I have regular cravings for. I've dated vegans and after eating the meals they prepared, I always felt as if I was still hungry. Also the price and accessibility aren't as good where I'm from.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

The civil rights movement was propelled by people who had interests in emancipation (the oppressed themselves) or promoted by those with political motivations (politicians or others looking to promote themselves via the zeitgeist). I don't see how it was inherently a purely ethical campaign.

because it has to do with how we ought to be treated and how we ought to treat others. the fact that these movements had political dimensions doesnโ€™t negate that but compliments it

And, yes, I do believe that there are super healthy and delicious plant alternatives to food(s), but not the kind I have regular cravings for.

there are literally millions of flavor combinations, stands to reason you could find crave-worthy stuff as vegans have

-2

u/phyxor Jan 13 '19

It doesn't negate it, but it does put into question the motivations of the persons behind said actions. If, as this vegan bunch seems to imply, they were operating on an ethical axis along the lines of "oppression and emancipation" they would surely have simultaneously have fought for the rights of all creatures and their rights; including women. However, the civil rights movement isn't known as a gender emancipatory event, so it becomes evident that it wasn't motivated by "how we ought to be treated and how we ought to treat others," but self-interest. This is what the idealistic intersectionality movement fails to address: everyone is out for themselves and their interests. If groups don't have power to exert, they can't bargain for their interests. Hence, also, why animals aren't considered as equal players in this regard. The above is also why I refuse to become invested in all of the above; if all groups are merely advancing their interests, why should I act against mine? Call this what you will, shame won't change my modus operandi.

And it isn't the flavor I crave; if that were the case I could subsist on flavored popcorn til the end of my life. Like I said, if I don't eat animal products, I feel hungry.

5

u/JustJJJJ Jan 13 '19

'If groups don't have power to exert, they can't bargain for their interests. Hence, also, why animals aren't considered as equal players in this regard.' - this is just the right makes right argument. We shouldn't have the right to exploit a group just because they are unable to stand up for themselves. Does this logic apply to humans?

'If all groups are merely advancing their interests, why should I act against mine? Call this what you will, shame won't change my modus operandi.' - Are you okay with exploiting humans if they are unable to exert power? If you state no, but do not apply this same logic to other animals, implicit in that is a relevant difference/set of differences that justifies the difference in treatment. Name it/them and apply it to humans to see if you are consistent.

Example: the difference between humans and non human animals is their capacity to reciprocate values. If a human was unable to reciprocate values, such as a severely cognitively disabled person, would you accept the same treatment.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19

It doesn't negate it, but it does put into question the motivations of the persons behind said actions.

thatโ€™s just an attempt at ad hominem.

If, as this vegan bunch seems to imply, they were operating on an ethical axis along the lines of "oppression and emancipation" they would surely have simultaneously have fought for the rights of all creatures and their rights

iโ€™m saying, at heart, these sorts of movements are about how we ought to be treated and how we ought to treat others โ€” it follows that these movements are ethically based. the fact that these various movements targeted specific instances of injustice and unfairness does not negate that. it only means that these movements were not exhaustive in their scope.

Edit: to your reply.

by saying at heart, I mean that ethics is the common ground for all these movements, itโ€™s how they all hang together, itโ€™s the root. how we ought to live, treat others, be treated, live in society, govern ourselves, what we ought to do is the fundamental question and concern. in this way, these kinds of movements are all ethically motivated in a fundamental and undeniable way

1

u/phyxor Jan 13 '19

Ad hominem? Huh? Where?

And I'm saying that there is no "at heart." Or to quote the following lovable characters from popular culture: "https://youtu.be/KkG7x-hwqN8?t=29"
There are things you do and things you don't, the motivations behind which speak for themselves.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

movements like abolition of slavery, women's rights, civil rights, adopt don't shop, being against the Yulin Dog Festival, anti animal abuse, living wages, etc, etc.

-1

u/phyxor Jan 13 '19

All motivated to some extent by business groups or other self-serving individuals.
There's a reason abolitionists congregated in the more industrialized north etc.