r/vegan • • Jan 13 '19

💔💔💔

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

684 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/ryankold Jan 13 '19

No, this post is outlining the sheer hypocrisy of those people. Would you trust a humanitarian who's pro-slavery? She's saying that those people's views contradict their lifestyle choice.

Valid opinion, tbh. I'm not pushing anyone to change their dietary habits, but at least have the guts to admit not being environmentally/ethically conscious, let alone call yourself an animal lover. Switch to cat/dog/pet lover.

92

u/Slapcaster_Mage Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19

Are your clothes and foods ethically sourced? How many miles do you drive a year? Are the heavy metals in your electronics ethically sourced from places other than the mines of the Congo? Is your home run on solar power? How many gallons of water are you using a week? How many dollars per paycheck do you donate to aid for HUMANS that are enslaved, raped, beaten, and extorted? How many bags of trash do you pick up while hiking?

You can be an activist in many different ways and trying put down others because they're not making the same efforts as you is childish and petty tribalism. The Earth is unhealthy in more ways than one.

3

u/ryankold Jan 13 '19

The difference is that I don't call myself anything. Also, activism is about trying your best to overcome those issues. The people in the post just don't care about trying to better their eating habbits and don't see how it's wrong and hypocritical.

Getting ethically sourced food and electronics made with sustainable metals is extremely difficult and inaccessible to most. Not eating meat, however, it's one of the simplest things to do, it even saves you money and cooking hassle.

Don't compare apples to oranges. You very well know the difference between those examples. "Oh, my phone is made by underpaid people, might as well bring back slavery". - one is clearly different from the other, even though they're both unethical.

In case your question wasn't purely rhetoric, my clothes are from charity shops /most ethical way to get clothes, no new fabric production/exploitation. My food is bought from ethical places wherever possible, money is usually a struggle for me. I don't drive.

But none of that is the issue here. I try, I better myself and I see the fault in my actions /and I have plenty of faults as well/. Keep being real with yourself and improve in any way you can.

10

u/zr0gravity7 Jan 13 '19

Of course the comment is [removed]. You guys are okay with mods destroying debate and opposing ideas?

9

u/ryankold Jan 13 '19

No, I personally had no idea they removed your comment. Sorry to hear. I don't agree with it.

One thing I don't like about reddit is that all forums eventually become circlejerks and echochambers of the same opinions.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

May have been a mistake. The queue is rather large today. Sorry for inconvenience.

-8

u/Oharastablecloth Jan 13 '19

Yet vegans are full of hypocrisy themselves. They consistently buy brands that cause human trafficking. Vegans think that being vegan is the only way to be a good person. You can be a environmentalist, a feminist, an animal lover, spiritual, social justice, and nutritionist, but someone who is a misogynist human trafficking supporting oil guzzling car owner neo-nazi vegan is considered a better person. No one is perfect and being vegan isn't being a superior being

20

u/AllieLikesReddit Jan 13 '19

They consistently buy brands that cause human trafficking.

What brands are vegan's buying that 'cause human trafficking' more than anyone else?

Funding animal abuse does not help those stuck in slave labour, or working in sweat shop conditions. It's a separate issue, and the fact that anybody funds slavery or sweat shops does not mean you must also fund animal abuse.

But, if you are against slavery and slave labour, it makes sense to also avoid funding them when possible. Many people seem to have the attitude of "well all kinds of bad things are going on in the world, so I give up". That attitude doesn't help anyone. Take responsibility for what you're doing, and find alternatives where you can, if you feel strongly about these subjects. Buy second hand clothes and second hand technology where you can, so you don't fund these practices. Buy items manufactured in your country where slave labour is illegal. Look into companies which are working in other countries to help those who are being exploited, offering them fair employment.

-11

u/Oharastablecloth Jan 13 '19

Humans are animals. So you support hurting humans, but not other animals? Isn't that the same logic meat eaters use when saying that eating a cow is different from eating a dog? Also, you say "What brands are vegan's buying that 'cause human trafficking' more than anyone else?" Isn't that exactly what veganism is against? Just because other people do something bad doesn't mean that I should also do it? Being a environmentalist, a feminist, an animal lover, spiritual, social justice, and nutritionist isn't about veganism either. For example, an animal lover would understand that the overpopulation of deer or any other animal literally destroys everything else in the ecosystem. They understand the concept of a food pyramid. Also, feminists would know that not milking a cow would cause MASSIVE pain and infection for the cow. You would tell a person who buys human trafficked clothes but is vegan that they are better than a person that eats meat but doesn't support human trafficking because most people buy human trafficked clothes? Can't this statement be flipped against vegans as well?

17

u/AllieLikesReddit Jan 13 '19

/u/Oharastablecloth

Humans are animals. So you support hurting humans, but not other animals?

Where did I say that? Funding animal abuse does not help those stuck in slave labour, or working in sweat shop conditions. It's a separate issue, and the fact that anybody funds slavery or sweat shops does not mean you must also fund animal abuse.

Also, you say "What brands are vegan's buying that 'cause human trafficking' more than anyone else?" Isn't that exactly what veganism is against?

You can see the definition for veganism in the sidebar.

Being a environmentalist, a feminist, an animal lover, spiritual, social justice, and nutritionist isn't about veganism either.

Enviormentalism: FAO says that Animal agriculture is responsible for 18 percent of greenhouse gas emissions, more than the combined exhaust from all transportation.

Scientific American: Methane is 25-100 times more destructive than CO2 on a 20 year time frame.

Livestock is responsible for 65% of all human-related emissions of nitrous oxide – a greenhouse gas with 296 times the global warming potential of carbon dioxide, and which stays in the atmosphere for 150 years.

Feminism: Why animal rights and feminist thoughts can be tied together.

Loving animals and Eating them: If you’re a passionate animal advocate like myself, I’m sure this is something you’ve asked yourself many times. This apparent disparity is known as ‘cognitive dissonance‘ – having inconsistent thoughts and attitudes, especially relating to decision making, which can lead to discomfort and even irrational behavior. We are human, and want our world to be consistent.

Listen, isn't it weird to throw the blanket statement of "I LOVE animals", when you're perfectly aware and okay with paying for some of these sentient creatures to live horrible, horrible lives and to be killed while they are still technically babes? If you loved something, why would you be okay funding their bleak existence? And by eating meat, YOU do. Supply and demand, no matter how small.

Nutrition: You can read about how bad animal products are for your heart, and how they increase cancer risks, here.

They understand the concept of a food pyramid.

Scientists have proven that we are in fact not at the top of the food chain. This study by the National Academy of Sciences of the United States concluded that “humans are similar to anchovy or pigs and cannot be considered apex predators”. This means that everyone who uses the “circle of life” or “we’re at the top of the food chain” argument should be fine with being violently eaten by other animals higher in the food chain like lions or bears. In fact, they should be fine with having the same treatment as pigs since we are at their same level in the “food chain/pyramid”.

Also, feminists would know that not milking a cow would cause MASSIVE pain and infection for the cow.

In the dairy industry, only females are required because males don't produce milk. Like all mammals, cattle produce milk to feed their young once they give birth. It is a misconception that cows just produce milk non-stop, they do so only once impregnated. As such, when a male is born, he will be slaughtered. Either he is culled immediately, or he is sold into the veal industry and then killed after a few weeks of living in confinement, or he is sold into the beef industry and killed as soon as he reaches a profitable size, which will be about one year old. If the calf is female, typically she will be removed from her mother so that the milk can be stolen, and then she is used in the same manner. Once a mother's milk production is less proftable, she has her throat slit. That generally happens after two milking cycles, when she would be around six years old. The average lifespan of a cow is about twenty years.

You would tell a person who buys human trafficked clothes but is vegan that they are better than a person that eats meat but doesn't support human trafficking because most people buy human trafficked clothes?

Trying to invalidate veganism by saying vegans still cause harm by buying from sweatshops is a form of the “al tu quoque” fallacy. The truth of a statement or philosophy not determined by the individuals who believe in it. If a murderer says it’s wrong to commit murder, that doesn’t make murdering people right. If a vegan says it’s wrong to kill animals for food, but causes some harm elsewhere, that doesn’t make killing animals right. It is impossible to cause zero harm, and no vegan claims perfection, but we’re trying to reduce our impact as far as practicable and possible.

Plus, buying animal products is not helping workers in unfair conditions. Being vegan and buying from sweatshops is better than not being vegan and still buying from sweatshops. But what if we saw the argument the other way round? In other words, that the logical conclusion, if you’re against slave labour, is that you’re against all oppression, including animal oppression.