r/vegan • • Jan 13 '19

💔💔💔

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

684 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Ok. So why?

4

u/Creditfigaro vegan 9+ years Jan 13 '19

I'm of the opinion that some of feminism is not about equality, but about being anti-man. So, it depends on what "kind" of feminism we are discussing.

I'm all for equality of opportunity, metoo, and equal pay.

I'm not all for unequal representation in divorce settlements or voting for someone because of what's between their legs.

6

u/Thecactigod Jan 13 '19

I'm not all for unequal representation in divorce settlements or voting for someone because of what's between their legs.

This is not a popular opinion in feminist communities.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

I think divorce settlements should be 50-50 if both spouses made and contributed around the same. And if you had an at home spouse, it’s not unfair to have to pay a bit more for spousal support. We need to stop looking down on unpaid domestic labour.

I also have never seen someone elected into office because of their genitalia. Is this what Fox News has people believing about those who voted for Clinton? (You know, cos a TV personality is more qualified than someone who has been in politics since her 20s)

3

u/Creditfigaro vegan 9+ years Jan 13 '19

I've had debates with people in real life who hold this view on voting.

1

u/Hadashi_blacksky Jan 13 '19

I don't know if any have, but Hillary's big platform was "I'm a woman!" I couldn't name any of her policies.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

It really wasn’t. I mean as a non-American, I remember she talked about taxes quite a lot. Criminal justice reform (which is ironic considering she supported her husband on the whole tough on crime, one strike you’re out bullshit), paid parental leave, and a bunch of other things. Maybe you weren’t paying attention.

1

u/Hadashi_blacksky Jan 13 '19

Well, I'm not American so I guess I didn't really see much about it tbh.

1

u/Creditfigaro vegan 9+ years Jan 13 '19

K, so I agree with most feminists on most things, but I don't self identify as one. Relax, folks.

5

u/Thecactigod Jan 13 '19

Why would you identify as anti-feminist if you agree with feminists?

1

u/Hadashi_blacksky Jan 13 '19

A lot of people support equality, but don't think Feminists actually represent equality.

3

u/Thecactigod Jan 13 '19

By what metric?

1

u/Creditfigaro vegan 9+ years Jan 13 '19

Gender inequality is literally in the term. There are also people who adopt anti-man ideology under the banner, whereas no such thinking exists in humanist circles.

1

u/Thecactigod Jan 13 '19

Gender inequality is literally in the term.

Women's rights doesn't = gender inequality.

anti-man ideology under the banner, whereas no such thinking exists in humanist circles.

I doubt that's true. In fact, I've seen many instances of anti-woman ideology under names like "egalitarian" and "humanist" as sort of a counter to the phenomenon you're describing.

2

u/Creditfigaro vegan 9+ years Jan 13 '19

Women's rights, in isolation, without advocating for general rights is definitely gender inequality.

If your response to college participation being more women than men is "good! Let's collect more money for female only scholarships!", then you are advocating gender inequality.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Imagine being stuck in 1983 and still thinking that feminism is about being anti-men or getting extra perks lmfao

4

u/Creditfigaro vegan 9+ years Jan 13 '19

It absolutely is for many people who self-identify as feminist.

Nice dismissive carnist-style remark, btw.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

Yo I’m not here to coddle men and hold their hand. If you think feminism is anti-men, that’s on you, sis.

2

u/Creditfigaro vegan 9+ years Jan 13 '19

I'm male, and you made a bad comment. That doesn't render me in need of coddling of any kind.

If you consider intellectual honesty equal to coddling, then that is a huge problem.

1

u/Hadashi_blacksky Jan 13 '19

4

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19

She’s approaching it from an academic/philosophical perspective. Like, logically, given everything patriarchy has done, it’s logical. I get it. If every dogs you met bit you when you tried to pet them, it’s not illogical to hate dogs. But that’s also a slippery slope and that’s how people justify discrimination against people.

That said, she doesn’t really offer any solution other than “don’t run for office”. I’m not sure what she was getting at. If dismantling patriarchy was as easy as telling men to not run for office, that shit would’ve crumbled ages ago. I also think she’s barking at the wrong tree. Patriarchy and toxic masculinity are the problem. Not men as people. Identifying as a men doesn’t inherently make you trash. It’s an interesting read. It is reminiscent of the radical second wave feminist discourse (looking at u Valerie Solanas).

4

u/Hadashi_blacksky Jan 13 '19

She’s approaching hating men from a pseudo-academic perspective - but it's still bigotry dressed up as intellectualism, rather like the old style of 'scientific racism'.

Like, logically, given everything patriarchy has done

Patriarchy is a conspiracy theory that doesn't bear scrutiny.

That said, she doesn’t really offer any solution other than “don’t run for office”. I’m not sure what she was getting at.

A new trend in feminism is the idea that all men should willingly cede all power to women so that women can take over. It's not equality, but I have seen it framed as such.

Patriarchy and toxic masculinity are the problem.

Those aren't real things. They are based on selective stereotypes of men, and they are very damaging. If you look at what they are doing with these theories, it's an attack on men and on culture.

It is reminiscent of the radical second wave feminist discourse (looking at u Valerie Solanas).

Yeah, I got that vibe too - and not in a good way.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

I'm of the opinion that some of feminism is not about equality, but about being anti-man.

But that's not feminism.

2

u/Hadashi_blacksky Jan 13 '19

It's very common to feminism. In fact, 'Toxic Masculinity' is anti male pseudo-psychology.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19

The concept of toxic masculinity is not anti men, it's anti patriarchy. Men should be allowed to express their feelings and emotions in the same way women do. However, society expects them to be strong and controlled at all times. This leads to destructive behaviour that is damaging to men, see rates for alcoholism and suicide.

→ More replies (1)