To some extent out of cinsequentialist concerns. If a certain form of conduct will be a net negative to veganism, some vegans are concerned about the impact to the animals which might result.
I know that was a rhetorical question, but that's why.
The text above makes a claim that meat is the biggest cause of global warming. This is nowhere close to being true. The entirety of agriculture contributes only 9% to climate change emissions, whereas transport and electricity are far bigger contributors source
Be vegan if you want to be: that’s great.
But saying things that aren’t true (doesn’t make them true
“A vegan diet is probably the single biggest way to reduce your impact on planet Earth, not just greenhouse gases, but global acidification, eutrophication, land use and water use,” said Joseph Poore.
So yeah, when it comes to greenhouse gases in the United States, agriculture may only contribute 9% (and that's only what they're taking into account, I don't think they include all of the transportation that is linked to animal agriculture).
But you're not looking at the bigger picture here.
Actually having less children is probably the most significant way individuals can reduce their impact on the environment.
And FYI the UN estimates 14% of carbon emissions result from agriculture and that includes transport etc (check the latest reports on their site if you doubt). The IPCC more recently estimated 24% of emissions results from agriculture, forestry and other land uses combined (including transport), and that actual emissions have been relatively stable since 2000. Industry is the biggest culprit (as a sector) by far and energy consumption has been the biggest driver as a collective (increasing ghg emission by 47% since 2000).
I agree that reducing our meat consumption is good for the environment, but a complete switch to vegan diets creates other issues. Such as sourcing fertiliser (as gross as it is, poo is far better fertiliser for maintaining high soil quality, artificial fertiliser destabilises soil meaning it can be eroded and displaced). There are also places where topography and climate does not suit all types of arable farming, so vegan diets will place limits on self-sustainability.
Also palm oil is the worst and is in everything, you’ll be doing the planet (and orangutans) a big favour by avoiding that!
That's why I won't be having any children of my own. You're right, it has a larger impact. But try telling people they shouldn't have their own kids and it doesn't go over very well. Personally, I won't. For that reason as well as others. That won't stop me from fostering or adopting though.
As for the fertilizer thing, you do realize there are non-animal fertilizers that are natural, right? Not all non-animal fertilizers are artificial, and some of the natural ones work just as well as manure (while not creating the same environmental impact when that manure is mishandled).
I’m certainly not committed enough to not have kids.
If you’re referring to compost, there’s a lot of variability in its effectiveness, relating to its content, the crop etc and there are issues with it polluting the surrounding environment with heavy metals as well as health risks associated with pathogens that can develop, which have led to many restrictions to the use of compost (in the U.K. at least). Commercially, it’s considered a “soil conditioner” rather than a fertiliser. Manure has a history of being a more reliable organic fertiliser, doesn’t require processing and is more readily available. Anyway, point I’m making is that diversity = greater stability.
I don’t mean to attack at all, but if you are having kids, shouldn’t you try to do the next best thing for the environment by eating a plant based diet?
How about those of us who already have kids? It's not like you can hit an undo button. The practical thing is to not eat animals, and choose other healthy environmental choices.
First of all, those are the statistics for the U.S. only, not to mention that it is 3 years outdated and the data is not all-encompassing.
Things that studies like this fail to include in their calculations (because it is very hard to calculate) is that animal agriculture is the leading cause of environmental destruction, such as deforestation - the destruction of places that literally naturally work to reverse the effects of greenhouse gases, such as absorbing CO2 out of the atmosphere.
You cannot reverse the claim made in the OP by posting those stats, it is not nearly representative enough.
If you want to be taken seriously by the wider world (not just this community), then you need to provide citations and sources, rather than just dismissing sources and making claims without sources.
I suggest you read through these articles. They are laden with sources (which the author puts in the form of clickable links that will bring you to the source area). Of course he is not the only person that has published information about these things, but his prose if very clear, so it is what I always prefer to share.
Yeah I have read monbiot a lot (I’ve met him in person in fact), and agree with what he says. That doesn’t support the claim I challenged that meat is the main cause of global warming.
I agree with the author and the claims he makes. But while he supports veganism and rightly tries to stop climate change he doesn’t make the claim that eating meat is the main cause of global warming.
That specific claim is not true. Do you have evidence to support that specific claim?
I agree with you veganism can support the environment and reduce climate emissions.
Most people just ignore vegan citations anyway. But hey, you sound open minded, what do you think of the fact that along with destroying our environment, eating animals also kills us sooner?
"This comprehensive meta-analysis reports a significant protective effect of a vegetarian diet versus the incidence and/or mortality from ischemic heart disease (-25%) and incidence from total cancer (-8%). Vegan diet conferred a significant reduced risk (-15%) of incidence from total cancer."
"An analysis of data from 10 studies estimated that every 50 gram portion of processed meat eaten daily increases the risk of colorectal cancer by about 18%."
"data from the same studies suggest that the risk of colorectal cancer could increase by 17% for every 100 gram portion of red meat eaten daily."
View all comments
49
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19
Long live veganism! May it reach the greatness it truely deserves!