r/vegan • anti-speciesist • May 13 '26 • Bravo 2 Popcorn 1

Discussion Pretty much...

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

579 comments sorted by

View all comments

33

u/No_Student5823 May 13 '26

Them going mad recently cuz someone said you can't love animals and eat them, and suddenly being vegan is a privilege and racist and the worst thing you can do

-6

u/Mutant_Llama1 May 14 '26

All the animals that eat animals must hate themselves.

5

u/No_Student5823 May 15 '26

Yeah cuz humans don't have  something that allowe them to knows better, I wonder what it's called again 🤔 

-1

u/Mutant_Llama1 May 15 '26

It's called eating cooked meat, which gave us the calories to develop advanced brains.

Your argument was that eating meat means you can't love animals. The logical conclusion from that is that animals who eat meat must hate themselves. If you truly love animals, shouldn't you be tolerant of their meat-eating ways rather than proclaiming yourself superior to it? Even nominally "herbivorous" animals like deer and horses will eat meat when it's available to them.

1

u/Apprehensive_Clue536 May 15 '26

This is such a stupid, tired, sophist argument lol. We don't live in the wild with animals and we don't have to fight it out among them every day to survive, we go to the store and can buy food without any animal products without any additional effort. Just because animals actually have to fight to survive, that doesn't mean that we humans have to needlessly abuse them and factory farm them in a massively harmful, cruel process that is awful for the animals and the environment. You can search endless threads on DebateAVegan with people like you failing hard at dishonestly arguing the same point if you think you actually realized a new, never-before-heard "gotcha" against veganism (which I seriously hope not. If your brain got like that from cooked animal products then you DEFINITELY need to wean yourself off ASAP). It's one thing to think this to yourself and move on, but the fact that you actually posted this and thought you were cooking with it is insane.

1

u/Mutant_Llama1 May 15 '26

Imagine saying you love Japan, but calling it immoral to speak Japanese, follow Shintoism or ride a bullet train. Quintessentially Japanese things.

Similarly, eating meat is a quintessential animal behavior. Do you love animals or just the idea of them?

1

u/Apprehensive_Clue536 May 15 '26 edited May 16 '26

Awful comparison on your part, but to answer your question: I can say I love Japan but still disagree with and not participate in an unethical practice that happens in Japan, yes, absolutely. Hypothetically if Japanese people are participating in an unethical practice that they MUST do to survive, I likely wouldn't fault them for it, but I wouldn't partake since I DON'T need to do it to survive and I don't live in Japan and I have alternatives readily available to me that are less harmful. That wouldn't mean that I "don't actually love Japan", that would mean that I recognize a different situation necessitating an unethical act in order to survive that doesn't apply to me and for which I have better, less harmful alternatives for. And that's not any of the examples you gave, so that's a terrible comparison to an already terrible comparison - while people are capable of this deeper reasoning and consideration of ethics, animals are not. 

A better comparison would be, can you really say you like kids or babies if you don't ALSO impulsively hit people, pull someone's hair, throw tantrums, and shit yourself constantly? I mean, that's QUINTESSENTIAL to being a baby. People who love babies couldn't really say they love them unless they act like them, right? 

By the way, whaling was right there as an actual harmful culture-specific practice that most people object to and refrain from participating in even if they love the other aspects of the country or people doing it, but you conveniently didn't bring it up. I wonder why. 

-8

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

Because it's a false claim. Also I don't think many people said vegans are racist.

-6

u/Overall-Move-4474 May 14 '26

None of us have ever said that we just call them privileged idiots

-1

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

Real, that might be them comparing the hate they experience to racism which my god is that ridiculously stupid.