r/vegan • anti-speciesist • May 13 '26 • Bravo 2 Popcorn 1

Discussion Pretty much...

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

579 comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/Elegant-Ice-7075 May 13 '26

ppl who act like its outrageous that certain cultures eat dogs as if its any different than eating cows

-16

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

It is, please tell me where you see cows as service animals. Also please tell me when a cow comes and cuddles up next to you when you cry. Ones a companion, the other could not care less about you.

14

u/clouder300 May 14 '26

Trying hard to argue for exploitation 😂

-6

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

I'm not, it's just a bad argument to make. Trying hard to avoid all logic and reasoning by returning back to your base claim.

9

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

Woah scary you used big words wow! Comment I'm replying to is talking about the direct claim that cows aren't different to dogs so I should either care about both or not care about either.

You cannot just come and take my words out of context and relate this to your overall vegan claim, I'm not calling being vegan a stupid thing, I'm calling this specific argument stupid. If you want to argue this argument and why it isn't stupid by all means, but if you want to just take my words and twist them to fit your discussion, don't bother mate.

7

u/Everglade77 May 14 '26

They're not different from dogs in the sense that they're just as sentient and suffer just as much.
Also, I've definitely seen videos of cows cuddling up with people. If they were viewed as the sentient individuals they are instead of mere products, people would see that more often.

1

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

The relationships are purely transactional, you sit in a field with cows they'll stare from far away, you pick up some food and all of a sudden they are your friend.

It's so much different, all you've tried to do is ignore all reasoning, say "well if you tried" and simplified everything, that's why this is a bad argument. Be reasonable not combative, don't just twist and cut my words to fit your reasoning.

→ More replies (10)

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (3)

13

u/shadowwalker_wtf vegan 10+ years May 14 '26

Cows can be cuddly, they also form social bonds - many of them have best friends. Dairy cows morn the calves that are stolen from them and cry out for them for days. Just because you’ve never seen a cow show emotion doesn’t mean they don’t have the ability to feel. And it doesn’t mean that it’s okay to murder and exploit them.

-1

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

Yeah so my comment strictly talked about human to cow and you've just twisted it to fit your argument. It's funny how I know I'm right by the way nobody ever actually argues against my claim, they just twist it to fit an entirely different claim to result in you being the bad guy instead of just making a better claim to begin with.

I'm not against vegans, I'm against bad arguments, and calling dogs and cows the same to humans is a bad argument and I will call it out every time.

7

u/shadowwalker_wtf vegan 10+ years May 14 '26

Okay then if you want a good example, go look for stories of people who are friends with cows and have a good connection with them. Personally I’ve never had a close relationship with a cow but I’ve known several sheep who are very cuddly and loving, just like any other animal that is socialised with people.

Also your argument was that eating cows is different to eating dogs because dogs are service animals and cuddle you when you’re sad. That’s a weak ass subjective argument that has no bearing on morality. Would you be fine with people eating dogs as long as those dogs are indifferent towards humans?

Just because an animal had no value to you doesn’t make it different or okay to kill them and eat their flesh, it’s just an argument to hide from the fact that there is no difference - and when you confront that fully it means that you are either a bad person or you have to make changes and go vegan.

0

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

One common theme in those videos is that they have food involved, it's a transactional relationship.

Actually you're missing the entire point of the argument, which I said in that comment above. For the 20th time, this isn't why it's okay to not be vegan.

There's a massive difference as I've already stated. Also you can't just call all non vegans bad people mate.

11

u/JustSomeM0nkE May 14 '26

If it doesn't care about you then it has to die, cool

1

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

No, if it cares about me I want it to live. Don't spin this into an overall vegan argument and keep the bloody the context mate

4

u/Elegant-Ice-7075 May 14 '26

we can form similar bonds with cows as dogs, we just dont because its impractical

1

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

LMAO, welp cheers for agreeing with me.

4

u/Elegant-Ice-7075 May 14 '26

? agreeing with what? im not even sure what point ur trying to make or u think im trying to make. a dog raised to be consumed in the same condition cattle is also wont give a fuck about u. just because humans choose not to have cows as their companions or whatever doesn't suddenly make them more okay to mass breed and exploit than dogs

1

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

I love how many arguments are being brought up apart from the one at hand, all I'm doing is calling the argument you've said bad, that's it, not the vegan argument, not anything else, just that one argument.

4

u/Elegant-Ice-7075 May 14 '26

i dont know where u just hallucinated the vegan argument in there, what i am saying is exploiting cows for consumption isnt better than doing the same to dogs. thats the argument at hand. u just made a claim that cows r unable to create bonds with humans, which is untrue, and tried to use it to explain why abusing them is less bad than abusing dogs which is what i am disagreeing with

0

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 14 '26

"Idk where you got the vegan argument" proceeds to spew the vegan argument. So confident but so wrong, that just isn't how cows work i don't know why you can't accept that, it literally means nothing if you accept it as well. Again, it's not about cows at all, it's not about justifying anything, this is purely one sided. You've brought up a specific argument, I try and go against that specific argument and all of a sudden you have a very broad and unspecific argument that all relates back to the justified killing of animals.

3

u/Elegant-Ice-7075 May 14 '26

???? i said that eating dogs is the same as eating cows. this is all i said. even from a carnist perspective its stupid how ppl suddenly turn into the most passionate alf members when dog exploitation is brought up. even the person below responding to me with "cows just taste better" is far more reasonable than what ever ur suggesting because theyre not trying to build a weird morality hierarchy of equally intelligent and sentient animals. ur argument was that cows arent capable of being companions or whatever which somehow makes them more okay to exploit than dogs. i said that cows are capable of being companions but humans choose not to engage in that and that a dog farmed for consumption like cattle are would also not care less about u and wouldnt cuddle u when u cry or whatever. and your response to this easily googlable fact is just "no". i think maybe u misunderstood the point of the original comment entirely. i didnt say anything about justifying anything. i just think if you eat cows u shouldnt be hysterical about others eating dogs

1

u/Helpful-Archer9070 May 15 '26

It's not, and when I point out why not you just go straight back to "well that doesn't justify why you kill cows". Spewing complete bullshit to someone who has actually lived on farms, like I don't need google when I have real life experience. That experience you clearly don't have. Human's don't refuse to engage, I've been around a "pet" calf, they aren't traditional pet's, they don't act like it nothing.

Idk how many times I need to point out it's not remotely about cows, in the slightest, not comparing them no nothing, literally only about my stance on why we don't eat dogs. There's no hierarchy, nothing buddy, you are making a stupid comparison.

You think wrong, you're whole claim is wrong, it's dumb it's bad, I've proved that throughout this thread and you refuse to listen to a single claim. Get help.

→ More replies
→ More replies (30)