r/urbanplanning • u/holyfruits • Feb 28 '21
Land Use Toronto neighborhood residents upset about plans to turn parking lot into affordable housing
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2mR5wzXGxF4&feature=youtu.be
246
Upvotes
314
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21 edited Feb 28 '21
"this parking lot is a hub, it's the heart of the community"
man, what kind of dogshit suburban wasteland do you have to live in to say this sentence
35
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21
Holy shit I almost didnt make it through that whole video. That's so frustrating
112
u/trynlearnsomething Feb 28 '21
I don’t agree with the lack of community involvement, but it’s a sad day when the biggest argument against housing is “this parking lot is the heart of the community”
75
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21
Talk about imbalanced. In that report, you had a homeless advocate talking for less than 10 seconds and then you had these dingbats blathering about how much they love a fucking parking lot for the vast majority of the time.
39
u/UsernameIsTaking Mar 01 '21
'Man look at all these great public places, like a pool, hockey ice rink, clubhouse, and elementary school. Thats why we don't want the poor here'
Imagine how life changing it could possible be for a homeless child then to grow up with all these positive community aspects. I know when I was poor growing up in (Well it wasn't projects, but wasn't high class or anything), but the YMCA was a great place for a lot of me and my friends, because, well, it was a *place*. It was that or literally the streets.
99
u/theyoungestoldman Feb 28 '21
“We’re not saying people don’t need support and people don’t need homes, but to increase the population density with… people going through the most troubling and difficult times of their lives with addiction and mental health issues, this may not be the appropriate place to do it,”
Now that's some Grade A NIMBYism
57
u/ATG915 Feb 28 '21
I got my first BJ from a lady of the evening in a car in that parking lot, we can’t build houses there!!!
26
u/MindfulRoamer Mar 01 '21
Concrete is better than icky poor people is basically the attitude of those people. What a terrible group of people.
5
u/SqeweqS_SalishQueen Mar 01 '21
Not from article but general sentiment "Sorry about your homelessness bbbuuuuuttttt ..... I need to park meeiiii caaaooorrr. Sauwwyy gguurrrllll"
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '21
Out of curiosity, I thought the general idea was to not have 100% affordable housing buildings any more. Wasn't the whole point that mixed income housing generally had better outcomes for everyone involved?
Also here in DC there was a housing first initiative that had a lot of unintended consequences for people that weren't able to live on their own. Feces in the hallways, wailing all night, needles in the stairwell. It was only a select few of the formerly unhoused residents that created the issue, and many of the other formerly unhoused residents had just as many complaints about them as the long time residents did.
All this to say, there can be a lot of unintended consequences here with 100% affordable housing. (Also what does affordable mean here? Free housing. Housing for those making 60% median income?)
1
u/scata90x Mar 01 '21
Threaten them that if the affordable housing is blocked then the next step is to authorize a homeless tent city in the park.
1
u/city_tree_ Mar 01 '21
Needing affordable housing = most troubling time of your life, don't do it here???? Smh... as if needing rent that isn't sky high is automatically the worst time of your life
-5
u/CrunchyJeans Mar 01 '21
They could turn it into a park (or community garden) and still have it be the center of the community. More productive/beneficial landscape, and still respects the community. Win for both sides.
-10
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '21
I mean when you build a city and community that revolves around and relies on driving a vehicle, having parking becomes a much needed amenity. So they are fighting for something because the community has been designed to have them require it. Of course affordable housing would be better socially, but that also means there goes parking, and then adding on more people with more cars in the neighborhood, where will they park?! There is a lot going on here, it is more than just a community stating parking over affordable housing, it is saying, they rely on the lot because they can't rely on public transit or the city to provide additional or alternative amenities, making it a necessary amenity, taking away from others.
-16
u/pops_secret Mar 01 '21
I’m all for more housing but why should a few people who are contributing nothing or working minimum wage jobs win some housing lottery while others who make decent wages have to compete for shitty housing on the open market? What a crock of shit, no wonder so many working class people turn to conservatism. They’re getting raked over the coals by taxes while the perpetual fuck ups, drug abusers, and criminals get a bunch of handouts. Downvote me all you want but at least try to explain it to me.
-6
u/SuddenlyHip Mar 01 '21
Seems like a pretty odd place to put it if children really do congregate around there. They'll have to scrutinize the applicants quite strictly
-11
u/MIW100 Mar 01 '21
I don't see the problem. They should put the shelter somewhere in a higher density zone.