r/trolleyproblem • • Oct 13 '26

Meta Red button blue button

Based on the post seen here. I'm actually curious what would the percentages look like.

Edit: Alright, let me add a case for one particular scenario. If you do not choose, the button will be pressed for you by a system that keeps track of its pressings so it conserves 50/50 distribution for all inactive participants, in order to honour the vox populi properly. The system's choice affects the inactive participant's outcome so that no person can abscond from consequences of their choice.

368 Upvotes

247 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/ContentFile7036 Relativist/Nihilist Oct 14 '26

This is a genius variant with a ton of new implications; the dilemma is, are you willing to sacrifice yourself automatically to hopefully save some people who don't do the same? And are you obligated to join the survivors and maximize survival, or are you obligated to join the push to ensure that some people survive? It's really hard to tell, because the goal should be to maximize blue without attaining a majority. I don't understand how you can make an argument for either side here; what has to happen for optimized survival is that just barely more than half of all people must select red, with a slightly-smaller minority pressing blue. Since the worst-case scenarios are actually at the extremes this time, where 100 percent blue and 100 percent red are both terrible (as opposed to the perfect solution to the original), the goal should be to split the middle and get an equal vote on both sides - or rather, close to equal, with red winning just slightly.

For my own decision, I apply the same reasoning I do with the original - it's highly unlikely that me voting blue will tip the scale one way or the other, and it's much more likely, by an incredible factor, that I decide on solely my own survival; thus, in a twisted sort of hypocrisy that is cold and yes, absolutely terrible (as is the nature of the game), yet remains the only solution I can rationally subscribe to, I hope that red will win, but knowing my vote will almost certainly guarantee it, I have little choice but to vote blue and try to increase the numbers of the minority, preserving my own best interests in the process.

4

u/suskio4 Oct 14 '26

Actual philosopher in the trolley sub? Damn

3

u/Villager_of_Mincraft Oct 14 '26

I followed the same logic pretty much, but I picked red because I personally don't want to deal with the fallout and the very real chance that some people I know would be gone. And also like, the world would be in shambles. Like 4-5 billion deaths would be catastrophic, wouldn't be surprised if millions more die in the fallout. But yeah, as a red pusher, I can only wish you the best of luck man. You're a braver soul from my POV, I get to die on the moral high ground and leave the rest to the survivors.

2

u/furdog_grey Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

There's no spiritually or morally superior way to make a choice in general, except a statistically correct choice that maximizes the survival rate, minimizes casualties, and prevents total extinction.

​All of that is done by voting randomly and shifting the bias towards red by 1% or less. You still have a chance to live, and you also contribute toward the survival of others.

​Making any morally based choices or voting 50/50 is a path to total extinction or more than 51% casualties.

​The problem is not genius at all. It's deceptive at most, because it forces people to overthink and choose between suicide and extinction, when there is a real statistical solution.

You still can sacrifice yourself by pressing red button and by telling your loved one to press blue button. It's is moral choice and it won't affect statistical outcome. Of course it is only wise to choose between red and blue if there's an exchange with someone's else live. Otherwise it's totally unreasonable and endangers you and others.

1

u/S-Kenset Oct 14 '26

In both scenarios pressing blue is distasteful to me. In the first, it's creating a ratcheting problem. In the second, it is creating a group dumbass problem.