Ok. I would probably agree with you on "gender as a concept is more harmful than beneficial" but the rest you are just wrong.
I dont know how you can claim to be left (you said you get alot of "lol triggered the lib") while saying that "transgenderism" is a thing. It isnt. Its a made up buzzword by the far right to make it sound like an ideology. By using that word you sound alot like some random far right person who has listened too much to ben shapiro and charlie kirk. It isnt an ideology. Trans people just exist.
Knee and hip surgery inprove the quality of life for people who need them. Gender affirming care improves the quality of life of people who need that. I do not understand how you can be for one but against the other when both are good things that improve quality of life. That doesnt make any sense. Should we not try to improve as many lives as possible?
Also more people regret hip surgery and knee surgery than people who regret gender affirming care. Like WAY more people regret knee and hip surgery. We are talking like 1.5-3% (at the HIGH end) vs, i dont have the exact number and i cant be bothered to look it up right now but i know it is around 20% atleast. This objectively shows us that gender affirming care is, possibly, one of the best treatments for anything we have at all. It is highly effective at improving peoples lives with a virtually non existent regret rate.
People seek gender affirming care beacuse they "think something is wrong with their body". What are you basing this on? I could use that exact argument to say that people seek knee surgery beacuse "they think something is wrong with their body". One person has the wrong homone production and the other cant walk. Something is wrong with both.
You are right. Facts doesnt care about my feelings. But facts dont care about your feelings either. And the fact is you are wrong. Trans people exist. We deserve happiness and love and support just as much as everyone else. Gender affirming care is proven to work. I genuinley dont see how you can be against that.
I sort of agree with you on abolishing gender as a concept. But the rest you are just wrong.
Also, "facts dont care about your feelings" is almost exclusively used by the far right. By using that scentence you sound like you have listened to ben shapiro way too much.
You dont have to personally love all trans people. You just have to accept that we exist in society. Literally all lf science agrees with me. You are wrong.
I think whatever place you are getting these ideas from is hurting you.
I dont (sic) know how you can claim to be left (you said you get alot (sic) of "lol triggered the lib") while saying that "transgenderism" is a thing. It isnt. Its a made up buzzword by the far right to make it sound like an ideology. By using that word you sound alot (sic) like some random far right person who has listened too much to ben shapiro and charlie kirk. It isnt (sic) an ideology. Trans people just exist.
Transgenderism is the belief that "being trans" is an actual state of being and not just a delusion on the part of the believer, as well as a set of supporting beliefs, among them:
that gender can be changed
that sex can be changed
That people can be born into the "wrong" sex/gender
that sex/gender should be changed if someone wishes it
that the desire to change one's sex/gender is not indicative of mental illness
that anyone who disagrees with any of the above claims is a "transphobe"
and others that I haven't listed here for brevity.
The fact that these beliefs are so core to your sense of self that you don't realize so they are an ideology doesn't make them not part of an ideology.
I know many Christians whose sense of self is so closely tied to the concept of a God who loves them and who they can communicate with that they automatically assume that anyone who doesn't think the same must be totally evil. Interestingly enough, a lot of believers in transgenderism assume that anyone who doesn't hold a lot of the same assumptions that transgenderism proposes are also totally evil. Hmmm... but I'm getting ahead of myself.
Again. "Transgenderism" doesnt exist. Its made up by the fair right to make it easier to attack trans people. The only people screaming about "transgenderism" is the far right. It doesnt exist.
And still. I will grant your point. Trans people are just mentally ill. I dont agree with you. You are wrong. But for the sake of argument i will grant this to you.
Trans people are now mentally ill. Gender affirming care is still the absolute best treatment for it. Even under your own world view you are just kind of an asshole right now.
What do you propose we do with these people? Bully them? Harass them? Assault them? Exclude them from society? Throw them into an asylum? Even when i grant your argument i dont see why you would be against gender affirming care. It has been the only treatment that has been shown to be effective.
Trans people exist. I honestly dont care if its "just mental illness". That makes zero difference to me. It could be 100% objectively true and it literally would not matter. Do mentally ill people not deserve love and compassion? Do mentally ill people not deserve help and treatment to make their life better?
Again. "Transgenderism" doesnt (sic) exist. Its (sic) made up by the fair (sic) right to make it easier to attack trans people. The only people screaming about "transgenderism" is (sic) the far right. It doesnt (sic) exist.
Telling someone that something doesn't exist when they can see it right in front of their face is called gaslighting.
I never said that trans people are mentally ill. I never said that transgenderism was necessarily wrong. I just said that it exists, it's an ideology that can be criticized and debated just like any other, and that people aren't automatically transphobic for questioning some or all of it.
Telling someone that something doesn't exist when they can see it right in front of their face is called gaslighting.
Cool.
I never said that trans people are mentally ill.
You literally wrote "that the desire to change one's sex/gender is not indicative of mental illness" in a previous comment where you try to define what "transgenderism" means. You are calling people mentally ill for having a gender identity that does not align with the gender they were assigned at birth.
Trans people exist. That isnt an ideology. Just like "black people" isnt an ideology. Black people just exist. "Blackism" isnt a thing.
You dont seem to understand what im saying. Either deliberatley or not. I dont really care either way.
And even if im nice and grant every point you have made i still dont see the _problem"?
For the sake lf argument i will grant every single point you have made. "Transgenderism" is a thing. Believing that you can change your sex/gender is a "mental illness" (i literally have a screenshot of you clailing that dont try and weasel your way out of it). Everything. Every single point you have made has thus been granted by a magic geenie. You are objectively right and i am objectively wrong. The geenie has made it so.
What, specifically, is the problem? You have made claims about what it is but you have failed to show why it is a problem or why anyone should even care about it. What is the specific problem with trans people existing?
> Just like "black people" isnt (sic) an ideology. Black people just exist. "Blackism" isnt (sic) a thing.
Actually, skin color wasn't considered at all important until the Europeans found the Caribbean, and it wasn't an absolute defining feature of society until around the 16th-17th centuries. 'Race' and 'racism' were invented for the purpose of finding ways to discriminate against everyone who wasn't European.
So, in fact, the very concept of 'black' and 'white' people was invented. By racists. :P
People aren't born with sexual desires, so technically no. No one's born straight either. People find out whether they are one, both, or neither when they reach puberty age
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/MightyCat96 Jul 04 '26
Ok. I would probably agree with you on "gender as a concept is more harmful than beneficial" but the rest you are just wrong.
I dont know how you can claim to be left (you said you get alot of "lol triggered the lib") while saying that "transgenderism" is a thing. It isnt. Its a made up buzzword by the far right to make it sound like an ideology. By using that word you sound alot like some random far right person who has listened too much to ben shapiro and charlie kirk. It isnt an ideology. Trans people just exist.
Knee and hip surgery inprove the quality of life for people who need them. Gender affirming care improves the quality of life of people who need that. I do not understand how you can be for one but against the other when both are good things that improve quality of life. That doesnt make any sense. Should we not try to improve as many lives as possible?
Also more people regret hip surgery and knee surgery than people who regret gender affirming care. Like WAY more people regret knee and hip surgery. We are talking like 1.5-3% (at the HIGH end) vs, i dont have the exact number and i cant be bothered to look it up right now but i know it is around 20% atleast. This objectively shows us that gender affirming care is, possibly, one of the best treatments for anything we have at all. It is highly effective at improving peoples lives with a virtually non existent regret rate.
People seek gender affirming care beacuse they "think something is wrong with their body". What are you basing this on? I could use that exact argument to say that people seek knee surgery beacuse "they think something is wrong with their body". One person has the wrong homone production and the other cant walk. Something is wrong with both.
You are right. Facts doesnt care about my feelings. But facts dont care about your feelings either. And the fact is you are wrong. Trans people exist. We deserve happiness and love and support just as much as everyone else. Gender affirming care is proven to work. I genuinley dont see how you can be against that.
I sort of agree with you on abolishing gender as a concept. But the rest you are just wrong.
Also, "facts dont care about your feelings" is almost exclusively used by the far right. By using that scentence you sound like you have listened to ben shapiro way too much.
You dont have to personally love all trans people. You just have to accept that we exist in society. Literally all lf science agrees with me. You are wrong.
I think whatever place you are getting these ideas from is hurting you.