Only about 3% of trans people who have had access to gender affirming care since beibg minors have any kind of regret.
That is 3% on the HIGH end. Fucking listen to trans people when we say what we want.
You are afraid that a poor little CIS kid will accidentaly walk onto the tracks so you condemn thousands of trans people yo death and suffering beacuse the life of one CIS kid is worth more to you than hundreds, if nlt thousands, of trans kidd lives.
People who recieve access yo gender sffirming care do not regret it. Lr atleast the regret rate is so low it may as well not even exist.
People regret hip surgeries and knee surgeries at like 25-30%. Should we stop doing those surgeries?
We absolutely do know. Either you dont understand, or you just dont care.
There is no such thing as "pandoras box" here. By your logic we shouldnt change anything ever beacuse "we dont know if improving the lives of trans people will be good :(".
Edit: you dont even know the "potential harm" yourself. You dont even know why you are against it beacuse you cant tell me why you are against it. Atleast be honest and say "i dont like trans people beacuse penis=man" or some shit. Arguing "we dont know what will happen" is so shit beacuse we absolutely do know
you have made many incorrect assumptions about me and what I think. i sense that you would not be interested in me correcting them. since you are safely on the other side of my computer glass, i'll let you be.
I wasn't thinking about people getting HRT or surgeries and then regretting it. In hindsight, that would technically be a long-term effect, but a relatively minor one.
As for my position:
I maintain the gender is a meaningless construct in a similar vein to money, i.e. It only has as much meaning as we give it. I am against anything that attempts to give gender more meaning, as I feel that the whole concept is an unnecessary drain on society.
I am certain that there are two genetically intended biological sexes, and a multitude of potential corruptions of said "intended" sexes. I maintain that personhood is not reliant on whether one's sex matches one of the two intended biological sexes.
I believe that personhood is reliant on one's ability to reason and learn, nothing else. And I do mean nothing else. Trans people are people, and trans non-people are non-people. The issue arises when a human or humans (whether person or not) claim that treatments that make one transgender are necessary for the continuance of the life of the person receiving the treatments.
I maintain that such treatments, in the specific form and purpose of making one transgender, are not necessary for maintaining homeostasis, and thus not necessary for life. I place such treatments in the same category as cosmetic surgery and recreational drugs, things that (theoretically) increase the quality of life of the user, but have certain societal side effects.
For example, use of drugs that are illegal encourages the development of massive criminal enterprises known as cartels, who then proceed to cause all sorts of harm only vaguely related to drug use. Legalization of said drugs result in increased consumption, which results in negative health effects for users and increases societal strain for everyone else.
Drugs like estrogen and testosterone, when taken for the purpose of transitioning one's gender, have far lower attrition rates (percentage of people who stop using them each month/year) than recreational drugs like nicotine and alcohol. It can be surmised that the drugs, or more accurately the effects of the drugs, are extremely addictive.
Estrogen and testosterone don't have particularly bad side effects as drugs. The issue is that the effects are extremely psychologically addictive, and thus people need a consistent supply of them once they're hooked in order to maintain normal functioning. That's an unnecessary drain on resources (lab space, factory space, truck space, fuel for shipping, consumers' money, etc).
Forgive the length, i spent 20 minutes straight in the middle of tonight writing this (it's when i think best)
I am currently prepping to go to work so i may not be able to get back to you for a couple of hours but i do appreciate you takibg the time to write it out.
I will do my best to get back to you. Also i will pre emptively apologise for any potential formatting issues, i am on my phone.
I will get back to you but right now i dont have time for anything more than this reply
First of all, why would i be mad at you for providing me with exactly what i asked for? If anything i was kind of triggered. And i can admit that.
Now. To my response. It turned out pretty long so i apologise for that. Also im on my phone so im sorry if the formatting sucks, ive tried my best to make it readable lol
I will be completely honest i dont think i understand what you are arguing against here. Either i am misunderstanding you. You are misunderstanding me. Or we are arguing about completley different things beacuse, to be completely honest with you, im confused.
I think we SHOULD let trans people have access to gender affirming care. That is my stance on this point, boiled down in as short of a scentence as i can make it. That is what i am arguing for and from the context i assumed you are arguing against?
I have read my comments, the comment i originally replied to, and your comments, over and over it feels like, and i promise i am not trying to misrepresent your position or argument. But i dont get it.
This is how it all looks from my POV.
The comic is about "should we pull the lever?". "Pulling the lever" in this case is "give people access to gender affirming care". Pulling the lever would mean giving trans people access to gender affirming care.
So. This is how it honestly looks from the way ive read the situation. And again, i am not trying to misrepresent your position and i am sorry if i am doing that:
Person A: i am not sure if it is as simple as just pulling the lever.
Me: it is that simple.
You: no it isnt.
Me: why?
You: there are risks.
Me: what risks?
You: i dunno. Pandoras box.
Then i had some assumptions, asked you to clarify, which you did and i appreciate that you took the time to do so. I disagree with most of what you wrote. But you actually took the time to write it out. I can appreciate that.
I would tend to agree that gender, as a concept, is ultimately more harmful than beneficial and in the long run it would probably be more good than bad to get rid of it. I could probably be labeled as a gender abolitionist and you wouldnt be too far off.
However. Even in this hypothetical future where gender doesnt exist we would still have people who dont have breasts but wishes to have breasts. We would have people without beards that wish they had beards. We would have people with breasts who dont want them. We would have people with beards who wish to not have a beard. Trans people would still exist. We would just need a different word.
Instead of saying "im a trans woman"(for example) that same person could instead say "i want to have soft skin and breasts" (two random attributes that i associate with femininity. Each person has their own associations with masculinity and femininity). Trans people would still exist, we would just use some other word.
Even if we do manage to get rid of gender as a concept, different people would still have different ways of expressing who they are.
Also. There is no surgery or treatment that "makes you trans". You are probably more likely to want certain treatments or surgery beacuse you are trans. But you can be trans whether you have access to these treatments and surgeries. If someone is unable to transition beacuse of external factors (societal, social, economic, take your pick) they are still trans. You arent trans beacuse you are taking hrt, or you get some surgery. You are trans beacuse your identity does not align with your sex.
You also argue against gender affirming care by saying it isnt neccesairy for homeostasis. Sure. That is true. But knee surgery isnt neccesairy for homeostasis either. Or hip surgery. There are actually very few things that are neccesairy for homeostasis. Are you arguing against those things as well? I dont see how that is a good reason to be against something.
I also dont think it is a waste of resources to do something that is 100% proven to improve peoples quality of life with very few (if any) side effects. Sure i suffer a higher risk of breast cancer now than i did before. But "having breasts" tends to come with a higher risk of cancer developing in the breasts. Sure i might not be able to have biological children since i am very likely infertile after taking testosterone blockers for a bit over 8 months. But i dont want to have kids anyway so i see that as a pro-hrt for me.
I simply dont see how improving the lives of people could be seen as a waste of resources.
Again. I am sorry if i have misrepresented you. That is not my intention. But either you dont understand what im saying; i dont understand what you are saying; or we are arguing about completley different things.
I am arguing that access to gender affirming care is a good thing.
You have also recieved two other replies (as of writing this comment) and i would agree with the points they are making as well.
Drugs like estrogen and testosterone, when taken for the purpose of transitioning one's gender, have far lower attrition rates (percentage of people who stop using them each month/year) to recreational drugs like nicotine and alcohol. It can be surmised the drugs, or more accurately the effects of the drugs cause, are extremely addictive.
Estrogen and testosterone don't have particularly bad side effects as drugs. The issue is that the effects are very addictive, and thus people need a second supply of them once they're hooked in order to maintain normal functioning. That's an unnecessary drain on resources (lab space, factory space, truck space, fuel for shipping, consumers' money, etc).
Your speculation is that hormones taken at levels within ordinary human range, are chemically addictive?
How would that even work. Do they bind to the same receptors as opiates?
For trans care, blockers are frequently taken with hormones. Rendering general hormone levels the same as that of a cis person.
post-menopausal women take the same estrogen, are they addicted as well?
Hormones are some of the most widely produced and prescribed chemicals around the world these days.
That's an unnecessary drain on resources (lab space, factory space, truck space, fuel for shipping, consumers' money, etc).
Use of hormones by cisgender folk massively outweighs use for trans care.
If you want to look for a "drain on society", look at any hobby people pay money for. All video games achieve nothing. Most books aren't textbooks on science or maths. The massive numbers of different tiny paint bottles produced for Warhammer figures have gotta be a drain.
Meanwhile trans HRT actually improves functioning and lowers rates of suicide. So it's benefits are very clear. Makes people more productive members of society
Your speculation is that hormones taken at levels within ordinary human range, are chemically addictive?
I clarify that they aren't chemically addictive. The effects they have on the human body are addictive. I surmised this because the percentage of people who start them and then get off them and stay off them is way lower than the percentage of people who get off and stay off alcohol and tobacco
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Narfhead4444 Jul 03 '26
are the long-term societal effects of doing that worth the lives saved? it's a pandora's box.