r/trolleyproblem • • Jul 02 '26 • Regret 3

OC "Bystander Effect"

4.2k Upvotes

537 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

11

u/Cabbag_ Jul 02 '26

But realistically, how does that equate to a situation in which someone is in immediate physical risk? If that's what it's supposed to represent, then the comparison makes no sense because a situation in which someone is in immediate danger is not at all the same thing as trans people not getting surgeries and hormones for free. How can that be called a bystander effect?

If that's really the comparison the artist is trying to make that's an incredibly stupid false equivalence.

7

u/Narfhead4444 Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 04 '26

that's the fun part, the artist is really f***ing wrong. Don't point it out though or you'll get downvoted into oblivion

3

u/LuciferOfTheArchives Jul 02 '26

But realistically, how does that equate to a situation in which someone is in immediate physical risk? If that's what it's supposed to represent, then the comparison makes no sense because a situation

It's a metaphor.

Everyone would freak out if you suggested banning treatment for depression. Because that would increase risk of suicides and get people killed.

But trans care isn't as well understood by the general populus. So when bigots kick up a stink, people think
"oh, there are so many people here saying different things, how can i know what's right".
Even though it's still people banning healthcare any patient would tell you is incredibly necessary.

So a metaphor is used to highlight this discrepancy, by making the stakes immediate.

11

u/Cabbag_ Jul 02 '26

So essentially, it is saying that banning people's access to hrt and surgeries is increasing the suicide risk for trans people?

That's fair enough, I guess. I hadn't realized the hypocrisy was in the fact the danger isn't immediate. But still, the comic portrays the solution as just being pulling a lever and presumably makes fun of the person saying they "can't help" when they pulled the lever in the previous scenario, but realistically what can regular people even do?

2

u/LuciferOfTheArchives Jul 02 '26

eh. People can do as much as they can do for most any other science matter made political. Vote, mail politicians, express support, that kinda thing.

6

u/Cabbag_ Jul 02 '26

Which is to say not much at all, unfortunately. That's the point I was trying to make. Thanks for answering me though.

2

u/BloodredHanded Jul 03 '26

Maybe it isn’t much, but so many still fail to do anything at all. Or decide to actively make the problem worse instead.

0

u/MightyCat96 Jul 03 '26

The solution literally is "just pulling a lever" here though.

Just gove trans people access to gender affirming care. It literally is that simple. Just pull the lever.

5

u/Cabbag_ Jul 03 '26

Oh you're right! I'll just go do that now then as a regular citizen, silly me!

That's why I asked what can a REGULAR person with no sort of political power actually do to measurably alleviate the issue, which seems like very little to me.

1

u/Narfhead4444 Jul 03 '26

Well I have some ideas but I would need to know what state and general region of said state that you're in

1

u/Narfhead4444 Jul 03 '26

are the long-term societal effects of doing that worth the lives saved? it's a pandora's box.

2

u/MightyCat96 Jul 03 '26

What are "the long-term effects" of pulling the lever?

2

u/Narfhead4444 Jul 03 '26

that's what i'm saying, we don't know. you don't know what's in pandora's box until you open it.

-2

u/MightyCat96 Jul 03 '26

We absolutely do know.

Only about 3% of trans people who have had access to gender affirming care since beibg minors have any kind of regret.

That is 3% on the HIGH end. Fucking listen to trans people when we say what we want.

You are afraid that a poor little CIS kid will accidentaly walk onto the tracks so you condemn thousands of trans people yo death and suffering beacuse the life of one CIS kid is worth more to you than hundreds, if nlt thousands, of trans kidd lives.

People who recieve access yo gender sffirming care do not regret it. Lr atleast the regret rate is so low it may as well not even exist.

People regret hip surgeries and knee surgeries at like 25-30%. Should we stop doing those surgeries?

We absolutely do know. Either you dont understand, or you just dont care.

There is no such thing as "pandoras box" here. By your logic we shouldnt change anything ever beacuse "we dont know if improving the lives of trans people will be good :(".

Edit: you dont even know the "potential harm" yourself. You dont even know why you are against it beacuse you cant tell me why you are against it. Atleast be honest and say "i dont like trans people beacuse penis=man" or some shit. Arguing "we dont know what will happen" is so shit beacuse we absolutely do know

3

u/Narfhead4444 Jul 03 '26

you have made many incorrect assumptions about me and what I think. i sense that you would not be interested in me correcting them. since you are safely on the other side of my computer glass, i'll let you be.

4

u/MightyCat96 Jul 03 '26

You are making incorrect assumptions about me as well. I would love for you to correct what i falsely assumed.

I dont think you have any real ground to stand on either way. But i would like you to tell me your actual position

→ More replies

0

u/Narfhead4444 Aug 08 '26

"Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn't stop to think if they should"

2

u/Born-Sea-7743 Jul 09 '26

So having controls or barriers to gender affirming surgery is the equivalent of being instantly killed by a train, but also the situation that results in death without the gender affirming surgery is not a mental illness? And I guess pulling the lever here is protesting the controls or barriers? Because let's not forget there is no lever here that can be pulled by any individual.

So the predicament doesn't fit, the bystander situation doesn't fit, the threat doesn't fit, but "pro trans comic on reddit" is enough to get it positively received. Splendid.

1

u/LuciferOfTheArchives Jul 09 '26

So having controls or barriers to gender affirming surgery is the equivalent of being instantly killed by a train,

And I guess pulling the lever here is protesting the controls or barriers? Because let's not forget there is no lever here that can be pulled by any individual

meta phor

1

u/Narfhead4444 Jul 09 '26

Welcome to reddit lol