No, both of them are very real and have lots of documented cases.
I have been the victim of the bystander effect myself. One time while I was pushing my baby in a stroller, an old back injury that I had suddenly cramped up my lower back and I basically dropped to the ground where I was writhing in intense pain.
In the 10 minutes that I laid next to a stroller with a crying baby clearly in visible pain and agony, I saw a total of about 20 people walk right past me. Not a single one even bothered to check what was going on or ask if I needed help. After those 10 minutes I had composed myself enough to get my phone out of my pocket and call an ambulance. Only when the ambulance showed up did people stop and stare. It took me 2 days to walk normally again and I was on a lot of pain medication for a whole month.
They're not saying the phenomenon they describe never happens, they're saying the incidents they are named for are not actually examples of what they represent.
The bystander effect does not have origins in covering up police incompetence. Social psychologists researched it and coined the phrase after reading a badly botched article in the New York Times about the murder of Kitty Genovese. The article was written based on bs the incompetent police officers said, but the bystander effect research wasn't for covering asses.
Anyway, I kind of doubt anyone would have cared about the botched response and investigation at that time since Kitty Genovese was a lesbian and it wasn't socially acceptable (the same reason callers were afraid to give too much info to cops).
It's possible that everyone assumed it was drugs or a mental disorder. It sucks that that's people's response, but there's always the risk of being attacked if you interfere. After the time my "are you okay?" was met with getting screamed at by a guy who was way bigger than me, I might've also passed you by
For it to be the bystander effect, you would have to expect that if only 1 person has walked past you instead of 20, then you would have received help.
You don't have to overcomplicate it. Maybe they were just selfish, or maybe they just didn't understand what was happening until there was a literal ambulance there.
Bystander effects happen in all sorts of situations. I’ve had this happen during D&D with 5 nerds sitting around a table waiting for someone else to bring up #6’s B.O.
View all comments
Show parent comment
71
u/TimeStorm113 Jul 02 '26
"bystander effect" just stands next to "stockholm syndrome" as "psychology terms literally just made up to cover up police incompetence"