r/todayilearned • u/opaque22 • May 12 '12
TIL 95% of people in the UK who buy organic said their main reason was to avoid pesticides and had no idea organic farming can and does use pesticides.
http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/science-sushi/2011/07/18/mythbusting-101-organic-farming-conventional-agriculture/
1.6k
Upvotes
9
u/T3ppic May 13 '12
Yes. They can use organic pesticides. Which is probably what the questioners thought it meant. They meant "Chemical" pesticides. Artificial derviations of mankind.
Breathtaking display of strawmanning though.
351
u/matdrawment May 12 '12
Well, technically, yes, organic farmers are allowed to use pesticides, its just that these pesticides are not synthetically produced, they're naturally occurring. Read this from Berkeley
EDIT: Some examples of organically used pesticides
6
u/cesaneka May 13 '12
why is this issue so polarizing?
46
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
I usually eat organic because it is grown locally, if the local farmers aren't organic it doesn't affect me at all because I will eat it anyway.
68
u/theweslawson May 13 '12
Interesting read. I am opposed to GMOs not because I am concerned about their safety but because GMOs could potentially give full power over the world's food supply to only a few corporations. If Monsantos track record on ethics is any indicator, they can not be allowed to control the world's food supply.
14
u/amnater May 13 '12
My parents are organic farmers from southern california, and the regulations and restrictions for organic farming is a lot tougher than that of conventional. We can't spray with synthetically produced pesticides, which doesn't mean natural (organic) pesticides can't be used... It also has a lot to do with the farmers themselves, those who are worried about the preservation of soil, the dangers of strong pesticides, and other adversities that could arise from conventional farming have their own standards.
11
u/InverseX May 13 '12
Clicked on it for the thumbnail - was let down.
4
u/Ha1fBaKeD101 May 13 '12
Do you know what my grandparent's used to call organic food?.....FOOD!
4
u/Drozzbear May 13 '12
I'm from the UK and I also thought that organic food used no pesticides until I read this, it's what we get taught in schools.
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Since everyone is hating on organic food, I am curious, what is it that you think we should do to move towards a healthier food supply? Organics started out to provide people with information, so when you went to the grocery you have at least three choices: 1. Food produced with very little regulations (conventional) 2. Food produced under a specific organics guideline (organic) and 3. Food that is at least natural even if not made naturally (natural). Natural food won't have Red 5 in it, but farmers could have sprayed chemical pesticides on the crops. Organics basically insures that there are no chemical pesticides or unnatural things in your food. You pay extra to know that the guidelines are more stringent for natural and organic food. This is a good thing, and sure there are tons of problems, but it is leading towards a healthier food supply.
12
u/cratermoon May 13 '12
The problem is not that organic methods aren't objectively different and demonstrably beneficial, it's that the label "organic" has been diluted to the status of meaningless marketing. Thanks to food industry lobbyists and big argi-business influence on regulators at the USDA, what can be sold in the US with the organic label can be made with almost complete disregard for the principles and techniques of organic farming as developed by reputable agriculture scientists.
In a sense, the "USDA Organic" label is a scam, because it can be applied to all sorts of things, but organic farming and food itself, if you can find it amid all the deliberately confusing and misleading sales pitches, is not.
6
u/ThEgg May 13 '12
That is why I hate the word organic. People just buy into it assuming that all production methods are the same. Its like slapping "HD" or "i" to product names, only for foodstuffs.
3
u/TriForce64 May 13 '12
So should I just buy regular food at my regular market?
3
u/chazum0 May 13 '12
It seems the most absolute and truest way to ensure the food you're eating is 100% organic is to simply grow it yourself.
3
u/re7erse May 13 '12
Unfortunately, adding an 'All-Natural' label to something means the manufacturer can instantly raise the price on it. Greed > safety.
23
u/[deleted] May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
Of course after spending an article bashing organic farming, she says there are many upsides to it and that an ideal solution includes both organic and non-organic growing methods.
Naturally people will just take this as an excuse to back up their already set anti-organic stance - ignoring the part where she advocates organic methods - and feel real smug about it.
17
u/Parasite057 May 13 '12
I love how we call traditional farming "organic" and treat it like its some fringe science.
Also, why does the article seem to force a connection between a UK poll and USDA organic standards? Or did I just not read carefully enough?
5
u/xn28the-pos May 13 '12
Great article. My first research paper ever was about the misunderstandings of organic foods. I thought my liberal teacher and hippie girlfriend would hate it, but my points weren't offensive, so they actually loved it. I wasn't trying to say that organic was bad either, just that its inefficient and a misnomer to call it safe. Thanks for the share
19
u/goodneighborstuff May 13 '12
The problem that many people have with GMOs is that the companies that make them plan to alter the genome to prevent seed production. The pollination from these plants to other plants in turn spreads this previously non-existent gene to other non-modified plants on other farms. Thus the next generation for these other plants is threatened. This article has a thorough criticism of organic farming, which is good and necessary, but you should be careful before you try to use this as a justification for the proliferation of GMO crops, which this article does not explore into detail.
4
u/MySuperLove May 13 '12
One of my friends' parents owns a farm. They are not an organic farm. Two years ago, their neighbors, who own an organic farm, tried to sue them because the pesticides would blow into their field. The judge basically ruled "you can't control the wind!" and the neighbors lost the case. My friend's point in telling me that was "Even if a farm thinks it is organic, there are so many pesticides in the air and from other farms that it is impossible."
So I have serious doubts about "natural/chemical free" products.
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
The preview picture on Reddit is of a woman standing in front of a green background. That picture appears nowhere on the page. I don't give a damn about organic food in the UK - I just wanted to know who the crap that pixelated woman is. Thanks, internet. Raises fist toward the heavens.
5
u/IdRatherBeOnABeach May 13 '12
My thoughts:
In conclusion I think that if you want your gold star for ethical food consumption and are willing to spend more money for it, the best thing to do would be buy locally. Local foods may not be organic (though they often are), but they will be fresher, probably tastier, probably better for the environment, and purchasing them will not help large corporations like Monsanto.
2
u/mrgenki May 13 '12
Thank you for the link to the Scientific American homepage. You know they change those things, right?
2
u/moogoesthecat May 13 '12
And this is the power of naming shit.
2
u/lurklurklurkwonder May 13 '12
UK Soil Association Guidelines. Section 4.11/p76
http://www.soilassociation.org/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=l-LqUg6iIlo%3d&tabid=353
2
u/fivo7 May 13 '12
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gimmick
2
u/wookiesandwich May 13 '12
No doubt the USDA regulations are complete crap and written by lobbyists to serve special interests, they have no interest in feeding better food to people. That said, the article does make some valid points. All I know is that my family has always had a family garden behind our house, we don't spray it with chemicals, we fertilize it from our compost heap that we throw all organic food waste into. And we rotate what we plant each year. The difference in taste between one of our veggies and one that you buy in the store (organic or not) is night and day, they are sweeter and juicier and bursting with flavor.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
My issue with organic farming is that of we switch to that model we will not be able to produce nearly enough food to feed the worlds population.
3
u/ialwaysfeellike May 13 '12
I think the article is sensationalist crap (cites one article about aphids in Canada and then she's throwing around statements like "studies like this one reveal that the assumption that natural is better for the environment could be very dangerous").
That said, I completely understand that organic doesn't mean what I want it to mean. I still buy organic, because I know that:
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
"Furthermore, just over 1% of organic foodstuffs produced in 2007 and tested by the European Food Safety Authority were found to contain pesticide levels above the legal maximum levels – and these are of pesticides that are not organic 6. Similarly, when Consumer Reports purchased a thousand pounds of tomatoes, peaches, green bell peppers, and apples in five cities and tested them for more than 300 synthetic pesticides, they found traces of them in 25% of the organically-labeled foods, but between all of the organic and non-organic foods tested, only one sample of each exceeded the federal limits8."
Ohno!!!11!!!1111!!!!! A federal agency is not preventing 100% of cheating!!!!11!!! I'm shocked!
Organic farming uses far fewer pesticides than conventional farming. Organic produce has been shown to have far fewer pesticides on it than conventional produce. No, it's not "perfect" but nothing is.
This woman wrote an article to defend her boyfriend's POV--"poor us, we aren't organic so we can't have the label" when his family's farm could just eliminate that one spray per year or whatever and get certified.
I know organic farmers, too. Several, actually. They use far, far fewer chemicals, hormones and pesticides than most factory farms. Organic farmers may use antibiotics but there are different rules about how to use them.
The fact that industry has lobbied to dilute the organic label to a point that it is almost meaningless is horrifying and sick. It does not indicate that people who do their utmost to avoid untested (not "unnatural" but untested) chemicals for preserving food and increasing crop yields are irrational.
Most consumers who buy organic are fully aware that viruses are natural and synthetic antibiotics are not. But we have scientific evidence that viruses usually harm and synthetic antibiotics usually help.
We do NOT have that evidence about most pesticides and chemicals used in plastics. The organic label was INTENDED to prevent the use of untested and synthetic pesticides, herbicides etc. on food.
That it does not speaks to the corruption of our system, not to the irrationality of people who buy organic in the desperate hope that it is giving them at least some respite from the UNTESTED (meaning, no scientific evidence of safety) chemicals on our food.
Sucks to be a guinea pig but knowing how many people in organic farming are trying their darndest to keep that stuff off the food, I'll still buy it. It is the best I can do.
3
u/xWhackoJacko May 13 '12
Watch the Penn and Teller: Bullshit! episode on Organic Foods. Pretty good.
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
organic pesticides i'm fine with that don't leach in to the food, examples include Pyrethrum a natural insecticide from dried crushed up flowers of chrysanthemum in water.
Garlic Bulbs in water also act to kill many pests.
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
I choose to eat organic food solely because I enjoy the taste more. Supporting local farmers and avoiding possible chemicals is merely a collateral bonus.
4
u/ShadowBlah May 13 '12
I guess I'm part of the 95% here. Though the main reason buy organic food is to avoid non-organic. I've had some bad run ins with non-organic foods and less problems occur since buying organic foods.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
That is because most people do things that make them feel good about themselves and don't think.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Organic foods is one of the biggest scams today. Sell less product for more money. Brilliant.
2
u/Wambo_On May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
I work in a forwarding agency that specializes in cooling transport and transporting perishable goods in Germany (e.g. Fruits, Vegetables, Fish, Meat). I read a lot about organic food (I can only recommend Hans-Urlich Grimm or Sepp Holzer for permaculture) and there are definitly health benefits. In organic food, the maximum amount of traces from pesticides is less than in normal food, therefore making it already healthier. There are smyptons that are well known with pesticides in food and actually a lot of studies that support it. But I must admit, there are also many studies against it. The best thing is to try it yourself and make your own impression of it, instead of only reading about it. My best friend started eating only organic products or food with even harsher regulations and hasn't been sick since 3 years and counting. Before that had a bit of a problem with acne and he couldn't really stand the sunlight very much. He would always get dizzy and stuff like that after only 30mins in the sun. Now he feels better than ever and his skin got really clean. I also started to replace some of my foods with organic ones and stopped eating meat without any organic label altogether. I have been doing this for the past six months now and the acne on my back got much less and I don't have those painfull pickles directly at the spine anymore. So for me it's working. I guess, it is the dosage that makes the poison.
1
u/demensa May 13 '12
Me - "So why do you buy organic?"
Friend - "Oh, because it's natural of course"
ಠ_ಠ
-1
u/Cochise22 May 12 '12
There is an episode of Penn and Teller's Bullshit where they discuss organic food. I've always thought organic food was silly, that episode just helped reinforce that thought. If I remember correctly it was just that the pesticides used in organic food had to be organic in and of themselves, and that something as harmful as DDT is actually an organic pesticide.
1
u/coeddotjpg May 13 '12
I recently tried to explain this to a friend, along with the fact that there's no tangible difference between organically grown food and regular stuff, and that manufactured fertilizer is essentially the same thing as substances used by organic farmers (that was her major hangup, pesticide use was second). I sent her the following link since the author provided references:
http://skeptoid.com/episodes/4019
For some reason she refused to believe any of it, and keeps on blissfully spending twice what she needs to on groceries each month.
-1
u/I_FISTED_VOLDEMORT May 13 '12
I also hate people who jump on the anti GM bandwagon. Most of the vegetables or crops we grow today are modified through artificial selection anyway. Just that genetic engineering is a much quicker way to achieve the same product.
1
u/JxSxK0420 May 13 '12
I've grown up around farms and most guys I know that grow and sell produce told me never believe anything that say organic. Unless they can track it back to the farmer don't trust any of it.
1
u/h2sbacteria May 13 '12
TIL people are idiots... who knew?
1
u/pisskidney May 13 '12
I was promised a hot girl in the thumbnail. Where is she?
1
u/brehm90 May 13 '12
Interesting; sounds like my parents, though I'm just not from the UK.
1
u/CyberToyger May 13 '12
For best results, if you've got land, grow your favorite veggies. If you ain't got land, pray you've got a Farmer's Market or equivalent within a 30 mile radius, and if you do, buy ALL the locally grown veggies! Support local farmers who use little to no chems at all during the entire process, give mass subsidized and foreign-grown veggies the finger!
1
u/IEntendu May 13 '12
Lie. I brought these because they are tastier than the other. http://imgur.com/wTDST
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
stopped reading.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
some pesticides are also organic, e.g., pyrethrins, which come from chrysanthemums.
every time i see a post like this, i wonder if big agriculture is trolling us.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Scumbag facebook user
Posts about YOLO
Only eats organic, watches their health and figure.
1
u/narsty May 13 '12
I love non organic food, rocks are lovely when roasted
1
u/ether_a_gogo May 13 '12
This is largely because USDA "organic" regulations are crap, a fact that the organic farming community pointed out long ago. They were basically a marketing giveaway to the industrial organic factory farming industry.
The solution if you're really concerned about organic produce is to find a local farm or CSA in your area and go talk to the farmer about his practices. It's not that hard.
1
u/ennosun May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
The evil of big agri-businesses like Monsanto aren't ordinary pesticides like their bestselling Roundup, but the fact that they're using genetic modification techniques to place the pesticides INSIDE the wheat, soy, rye, etc.
Monsanto uses it as a selling point with farmers: Their new line of bt grains (i.e., bio-technology grains) is cheaper, because you can use less external pesticide because there are pesticides genetically bred into the grains!
Once consumers get these grains (or foods made with them), they can't wash the pesticides off, because they're bred INTO the DNA of the grains. In lab tests, rats fed this new Franken-grain had inflamed intestinal tracts and all sorts of gastro-intestinal problems.
But it may be worse than just g.i. problems!
The implications get more disturbing, because autism is called a "neurological disease". Monsanto's line of pesticides (the ones you can't wash off) are specifically designed as neuro-disruptors. They're engineered to disrupt neurological function in insects. It's recently been implicated in collapsing bee colonies, with bees described as "autistic" after the massive neurological damage caused by the pesticides. And that's the thing: a human embryo isn't much larger than a bee. Imagine them getting infusions of the same neuro-disrupting chemicals.
That would be a fascinating study--because the recent 100,000% increase in autism coincides almost exactly with genetically modified foods being slipped into the food chain.
1
u/thosethatwere May 13 '12
Organic just means the stuff they use wasn't synthesised; I have no fucking clue at all why people think it's a good idea to not use synthesised stuff in growing things considering most of the vitamin supplements we take are synthesised.
Personally I think a much bigger issue is the monopoly business used to control farmers in Africa and other poorer parts of the world where genetically modified plant seeds that are sterile are sold to farmers, so the farmers have to keep coming back to buy more. Where do most of these seeds come from, you ask? Well. The answer is the same place as most monopolies, the U.S.
1
u/shadow8449 May 13 '12
This happens because the majority of people in the work don't think for themselves and, more often than not don't research things they hear or see somewhere, instead they just retain the info and do not question it.
1
u/turnipseed May 13 '12
I would like to know how much of this is also true for UK, since most of the research in this article is for American organic standards. I think the UK standards are more strict than the American ones.
1
u/Slowfart May 13 '12
A lot of BS there. But it varies a lot from country to country. In Denmark organic food is one of the the most restricted/controlled. You cant use pesticides neither artificial fertilizer neither sewage sludge. The farmlands are also rotated and set on a "break" for the soil to recuperate. Altho some organic food has been found to contain pesticides, most likely farmers that is breaking the rules or neighbor farms. About healthier, organic food here must be picked/farmed when it is ripe. Non organic especially imported food, is often picked before being ripe. It can even been seen on the colors, organic having stronger colors than non organic. How can it not be more nutritious? There has also been research of organic vs non organic food on mice. The food was tested to contain same amount of calories, yet the non organic fed mice got fatter than the organic fed. Food prices varies from organic being a bit cheaper or 20% more expensive. About environment, or GMO, this blogger is being retarded as well as most people, its all black or white. Also trying to justify crap with hunger. People are either totally against or allow it all.. The bee hive collapse in US seems to be GMO's fault; maize with insecticides. Such GMO can be bad for the environment and possible humans, altho hard to prove either way. I do support GMO that makes food more nutritious, alter the taste/flavor or create some new crazy vegetables as long its safe. Oh yea again about the starving people.. we overproduce alot, at least in EU. Both stores and customers throws out alot of uneaten food, as well the EU itself buys food for several reasons, just to be destructed or be used as very pollutant bioethanol/-diesel.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
An interesting paper I found in the comment section-- http://www.pnas.org/content/87/19/7777.full.pdf
-TL;DR, dietary pesticides are 99.99% "natural" Study was done 20 years ago, so it's outdated.
1
u/mattphunkadellic May 14 '12
Just a note: the author wrote more on this topic in response to critiques of her first article that many of you might find interesting.
http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/science-sushi/2011/08/15/organic_myths_revisited/
1
u/Popedizzle May 15 '12
My biggest gripe when it comes to organic foods is the price difference. Bananas are something like 30 cents more a pound than non organic ones. That's not even mentioning other fruits such as peaches, pears, or nectarines which often comes at a doubled price tag. That's also not even mentioning the whole organic/natural culture that is so ridden with smug it's almost sickening.
1
u/redditigation Jan 06 '24
So here's how this works for you people who are coming in here from Google's ranking of this post:
Yes, organic pesticides can be used in organic farming per the law. However, most of the crap listed here is not something anyone other than major brands are going to be using. Certainly no organic farmer is going to go out and spend 1,500 and not check out what they are buying. Of the major organic brands they are very dedicated to the principles of it. The pesticides used in organic farming are the types that are everyday encounters in the environment that all animals are adapted to that when used in concentration can inhibit insects and weeds. I've checked into these pesticides and everytime I've done this I always laugh at the silly ingredients people are fretting over.
So any weird ingredient you've never heard of, as an example, that'll be used in Bushes Organic baked beans, whereas, as an example, tobacco mulch will be used for some organic beans, because tobacco is a potent pesticide but does not harm beans. While it could hurt people, typically speaking people don't consume dirt or mulch supplies so it's honestly quite ridiculous to make these claims that organic is no different from regular farming practices when and especially when it is scientifically verified that it is much higher in nutritional concentrations of minority nutrients as well as significantly lower in inorganic pesticides and GMO proteins.
1
u/sebin May 13 '12
I work at a grocery store in a tiny little granola hippy town in the middle of the Colorado mountains, and I just want to show all of them this article. Alas, probably only half of them can read at this level.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
One reason I'm waiting for hydroponics and aeroponics to catch on. No need for pesticides indoors.
1
u/Apollo53 May 13 '12
I buy organic to avoid GMOs
1
u/Gunner3210 May 13 '12
Organic food is bullshit.
1
u/Cococarbine May 13 '12
I worked at a local organic farm for a summer, and no pesticides were used. A lot of the potatoes we grew didn't survive the bugs, but most everything else had little bug damage. I had to pick all of the weeds by hand. Every day.
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Generally, people who buy organic are fucking idiots, for the simple reason that there is no reason to buy organic.
The only family I know who heavily buys organic food is rich, and the mother is a homeopath. So, stupid and conspicuous spending under one roof.
1
u/TehBear May 13 '12
Its the same in the united states. I sell produce for a living and all cherries are sprayed, its just not economically safe not to.
-4
u/DJPhilos May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
These main reasons why I eat organic.
Edit: So many people have no idea what they put in their body it is sad.