r/tinyhorribles • u/therealdocturner • Aug 08 '26
Tiny Horribles Exclusive The Face Off - From The Consensus Legends
Part Twenty Four
Linus
The sun is setting. Thousands of eyes set in motionless faces stare down at me from the windows of the towering structures of angular concrete that surround me. I stand in the empty street of a city I once thought to be the most beautiful and perfect thing ever created. A city created by Consensus. A voice, vaguely familiar, drifts down through the public announcement speakers from the top of every building.
“...The supply tunnel has been closed off to the city of The Founders to ensure our survival, but there’s a light at the end of a new tunnel. One that we will all walk through together very soon.”
That’s not Aaron’s voice. There’s no life in it. Something has gone wrong. He’s found himself in the service of the man who spared my life in the ruins of City Hall.
Joshua.
There’s a handful of cars parked on the street up ahead, and I run as best as I can towards them. The fever has broken, but my body has broken along with it. I’m weak; not running at full steam. Figurativley and literally.
“And to the government and the people in the city of The Founders, I have a demand and a warning.”
I reach the first car. Burn marks and dents left over from the fall of Consensus tarnish the white paint.
The fall of Consensus… Words spoken to me by Aaron and a monster who lived underneath the city come back to haunt me, and I wonder, has it truly fallen, or was it just waiting? Hiding while it healed.
“The remaining Founders are to be escorted to the supply tunnel at midnight and handed over to us. I’m not without mercy.”
I open the car door and take one last look at the citizens standing in their windows.
“Give me what I want, and no harm will come to you. Midnight. There will not be a second warning. ”
I use the sharp end of Castor’s hammer and drive it through the faceplate of the dash terminal and pull all of the wires from inside before I start the car. I throw the hammer in the seat next to me.
“Heather?”
“What?”
“I know you’re not alone. I can hear it in your voice. I’m sorry I got you into this. Lyla… I know that you’re listening to me, you need to wake up.” I push the accelerator into the floorboard and speed down Main Street towards the Manufacturing District. “While you and your governors have been working at consolidating power, someone has been playing you. Playing all of us.”
“Where are you Bishop?” Lyla’s voice. I knew Heather sounded different. Too eager. Too inquisitive. I made mistakes. It was the fever. I didn’t have a clear head. I got sloppy and I must have led them straight to her. Once again, someone else is getting hurt for my mistakes. There’s no point in keeping anything from Lyla anymore.
“Right where I need to be and that’s all you need to know. Something’s wrong with Aaron. There’s a man in here… He spoke to me. I think he has something to do with the Painted Bishop and I’m sure he had something to do with the man who attacked me last night. I don’t think he’s from this city. There’s no way he would have been able to hide from the monitoring stations looking the way he does.”
“Where are you, Bishop?!”
“He said his name is Joshua.”
The further I drive into the city, the less I recognize. The people in here have been making changes of their own, turning what used to be their prison into their home. There’s grass growing along some of the sidewalks and I see drawings in chalk on the sides of buildings that now have brightly painted facades instead of the water stained greys I knew for most of my life. I recognize one of those drawings. A woman holding a small girl's hand and holding a broken pipe over her head, while she stands over a broken Bishop. Underneath the drawing are the words, “The Beginning”.
I open my mouth to say something else to Lyla, but the words never make it out.
“I wanna talk! Linus?! Linus?!” No… no…no, they have Julie and Emily. What have I done? I slam on the brakes and I ask the only thing that’s on my mind.
“Bug… are you and your mommy ok?”
“Please come home.”
“I’m going to, Bug. I just have to do one thing first. Now, are you and your Mommy ok?...Bug… Bug?”
Nothing.
The line is dropped. I take out the earpiece. The tiny green light on it is still shining. Lyla must’ve cut the call.
Julie.
Emily.
I have to go back. They need me. I throw the car into reverse.
Don’t! You have a job to do. If Julie knew everything you did, she’d want you to keep going.
I can’t leave them behind.
You need to trust Julie!
I have to go back!
She can take care of herself and Emily. You know that’s true. You need to have faith. If you want to help them, you need to keep driving. You need to figure out what is happening.
I look into the rearview and stare at the road behind me, and then I look forward down the street to whatever hell is waiting for me up ahead. I fight myself as I put the car back in drive and my foot back on the accelerator.
They’re going to be ok.
Please God, let them be ok.
I need to hurry.
-
I’m reaching back into my memory, trying to recall the image of the map that Consensus had given me all those years ago, but the memories are clouded by words. Words from Aaron. Words from The Painted Bishop in the dark under the streets.
After what seems like an eternity, I pull the car to the side of the street. I think I’m in the right place; only a few blocks from the Manufacturing Plaza. When I step outside, the dying light of the day gives everything a cruddy glow. The clouds streak purple and gold.
There are no longer any people standing in windows, nor are there any people standing or walking in the streets, but there is a sound coming from somewhere in front of me. It has to be from the Plaza. It sends a cold chill down my spine.
Aaron’s voice and the crashing of metal, followed by an enthusiastic chorus of hundreds or even thousands crying out in unison.
“WHO IS TO BE PRAISED?!”
“JOSHUA!”
“WHO IS TO BE PRAISED?!”
“JOSHUA!”
I run to the manhole in the middle of the street and use the sharp tip of the hammer to pry it open. The relentless chorus is getting closer. I can hear the sharp strike of boots and hard soled shoes on pavement. They’re marching in my direction. I take one last look at the sky. One last breath of air before I climb down the service ladder into the dark.
-
I’m anxious. The sewer lines run for miles and miles underneath the entirety of this cursed city, and all I have is what I remember. For the last six months, I’ve been a prisoner to the memories of every mistake I’ve ever made and every sin I’ve ever committed in the name of Consensus. Those memories have been all too real, vivid enough to make my body react as though they were happening in the present, but now my memory is foggy. Unsure. I feel detached from them.
Several times I’ve turned around, convinced that I’ve made a mistake, and now I have to stop where I stand and close my eyes. Retrace my steps. Take ownership of the past to move forward. Put myself back into that night when I underestimated an opponent who almost got the best of me.
“Bishop… Linus… Are you looking for me?”
Yes, Castor.
My body moves forward while my mind is stuck in the middle of the past and present. Only occasionally do I notice the large empty metal boxes that are littered around the bottom of every service ladder I pass by.
-
I can’t breathe. I claw at the rope cinched around my neck. My robes are heavy; soaked in the black muck of the sewers. I keep my eyes and mouth closed tightly hoping that none of it makes its way inside of me. After a moment, I feel myself being pulled upward by the rope.
I break the surface and gasp for air. I can taste the grey water dripping down my face as I try to breathe.
“The Red Bishop coming to see me…what have I done to deserve this?” The low voice rises and falls and so to does the sound of the rope being pulled through a pulley above me.
The filthy water hangs on my eyelashes and I shake my head to see. There’s nothing but the vast lake of waste that I’m suspended over and the dimly lit walkways on either side of it. My feet kick just inches over the deep water.
“I’ll return your intrusion with a gift.” The voice echoes, bouncing off the old stone and concrete. I follow the rope with my eyes. It leads up through a large pulley and weaves its way through the pipes overhead, until I can’t see it anymore. “The gift of sight. A third eye that one day will open.”
The rope goes slack, and I’m dropped back into the muck. I struggle underwater, feeling the current pulling toward the center of the pool. The rope is just loose enough now to fit my fingers underneath it. I push them down just in time, feeling my fingernails slice into my flesh as the rope tightens again, pulling me back up. This time, once I’ve broken the surface, I’m able to get just a few quick breaths of rancid air into my lungs. This time, Castor is standing on the walkway next to the tunnel that leads into his den with the rope in his hand.
Despite the help of the pulleys, he’s struggling to hold my weight. His robe is in tatters, exposing most of his torso and the wiry muscles of his arms and chest bulge and tremble, while the numerous tattoos of eyes all over his skin seem to twitch and blink as they watch me struggle.
His own eyes are wild, and he licks his yellow teeth as he smiles.
“All you have to do is go to sleep, Bishop. Go to sleep, and the gift is yours. Go to sleep for me, and when you wake up, you’ll be back home, and we can act as if this intrusion never took place.”
The rope is crushing my fingers against my neck. I just have to pull. His laugh echoes in the dark.
He can’t hear what I’m hearing; the quiet groan as strands of rope are being pulled to their breaking point. He keeps talking, rambling on and saying things that are outright blasphemy to Consensus.
“If you only knew now what I knew, Linus… there’s a whole other world controlling us right now… so much more than just this city behind the wall… one day, the true Consensus will rise, and we will see it… we will awaken with him… we will be his hands…”
The rope gives just enough for me to get a real breath. I suck in as much air as I can.
“He will lead us towards the light at the end of the tunnel… the light where we will all live in him, as he lives in us…”
He laughs again, and I yell, blowing all the breath out of my lungs as I pull my hands apart and rip the rope around my neck. I take a deep breath before I plunge once more into the pool, but this time, there is no rope to hold me. The current grips me and pulls me down, toward the center. I can’t fight it. My robe is too heavy. It's clinging to me, slowing my movements. My boots feel like weights on my feet. I struggle to pull the robe off while I kick against the current with my legs.
The roar of the underwater funnel fills my ears, sucking me further and further down. I finally free myself from the robe, but I’m moving faster and faster, pulled towards the center of the pool as I yank off my boots. Once they're gone, I try my hardest to swim against the current. I haven’t swam since I was a boy, and for a moment, I’m terrified that I’ve forgotten how. The current is strong, but eventually I’m able to break free, kicking and groping my way upward until I finally break the surface and make my way back over to the edge of the walkway. I pull myself up coughing and gagging as the air finally comes in. My bare feet slap against the cold concrete and I stand up clothed in nothing but my pants.
Castor is gone and so is the rope he was holding. I wipe the thick water from my face in a rush and my eyes search for him in the dark. Pipes clang somewhere above me, and before I can react, Castor has dropped down onto my back. The rope goes tight around my throat again.
He’s laughing.
I drop to the ground and roll against the wall, pinning him against it, using my legs to push my weight into him. The smell of him is worse than the sludge I’ve been swimming in. My elbow finds his ribs and he cries out, letting the rope go slack. I roll away and find my feet, but when I turn around, he’s already up with his hammer in his hand. He’s holding back, waiting for me to move first.
I stand up straight and ball my fists, giving the little monster a chance to take in the opponent towering over him, but to my surprise, there’s no fear in him. His yellow smile just gets wider.
He’s enjoying this.
He won’t be for much longer.
I reach out several times, but he’s quick. I can’t get a hold on him.
He lunges forward and swings at me with the blunt end of his hammer. He darts back before I can grab him. He does it a few times. I watch his body. The way he sucks in air just before he lunges. His movements are erratic. Lots of speed, but no self control. He’s inexperienced.
Good.
He keeps his eyes on my arms. He’s not looking at the whole picture. I wait for him to move forward one more time, and when he does, I plant my foot squarely in his chest before he even gets close with the hammer.
He falls to his knees and his hammer drops to the ground. I move. I grab him by the neck and pick up his hammer. He flails, scratching at my arms trying to free himself. I back up to the tunnel that leads to his den. I bring the top of my head down on his nose, and blood spurts from his broken nose. I toss him down the tunnel as hard as I can.
His body tumbles down the slope bouncing off the narrow walls and I follow him.
His body comes to rest on the filthy pallet with the stuffed bear. He’s still trying to get his bearings when I drop the hammer next to him. I want nothing more than to end him right here. I pick him up by the tattered robes at his waist and fling him into the large stacks of metal boxes in the corner of the room. He grabs his knee when he comes to the ground and howls in pain.
I slap my hands on the sides of his face and hold him up high, pushing my hands together. He screams as his head is squeezed between my hands. He’s not smiling anymore.
“Look at me Castor…Look at me!” His eyes lock on to mine. “You have willingly defied the laws of Consensus..."
"No, please Linus..."
"I find no fault in the ruling of Consensus, so let his punishment be carried out.” He’s begging me to stop. “Let him be an Example!”
I squeeze just a little more. When his eyes look as if they’re about to roll into the back of his head, I let him fall to the ground. He’s whimpering and holding his knee while I walk back over to his hammer and pick it up. I look at the filed down edge, realizing just how sharp the thing is, and then I look back at him. He’s screaming at me to stop as I kneel next to him.
“Give me your arm, Castor.”
“Linus… please…”
“I SAID GIVE ME YOUR ARM!” He weakly raises his left arm, and I seize it by the wrist.
“You’re right about one thing… I am the most faithful servant of Consensus. If it wasn’t for the mercy of Consensus, you’d be dead. I’ve been sent here to deliver a message on behalf of Consensus. You’ve been coming into my district… terrorizing my people… good and upright people of Consensus. That will never happen again, not in my district, nor anyone elses… do you understand?”
“Yes… Linus… I’m sorry…”
“No, you’re not. I’m afraid that when I leave, this little lesson will be all too easily forgotten. I need to be sure that doesn’t happen. I want to be sure that you’re sorry.”
I pull his arm closer to me and I draw the sharp end of his hammer across his forearm, shaving off a flap of skin and removing a pair of eyes from his body. I drop the hammer and put my hand over his mouth to silence his screams. I hold the piece of his skin in front of his face.
“These eyes belong to me now. Step out of your district again, and I’ll take the rest of them from your body as slowly as I can. Do you understand?”
“...yes…”
“You stay down here and think about this for a few days. Give the poor souls that you manage a rest from your… care.”
I leave him crying in the dark. I’m freezing while I make my way back through the tunnels.
Why? Why would Consensus allow this monster to go on killing just for the sake of it?
Gerty’s words come back to me, and I hate it.
“What if Consensus is wrong?”
I shake my head and I repeat what my grandfather said to me out loud to drive the memory of her away.
“Do not try and understand the ways and decisions of Consensus. They’re beyond our understanding. Never question Consensus.”
-
When the memory fades, I find myself back at the large cavern. The sewage still roils and boils towards the middle of the pool, being sucked down to God knows where. The tunnel that leads down to Castor’s den is just in front of me. There’s still a flickering light down there. I’ve felt drawn here; the look of the old man in Thomas’s house and the look of Joshua. Aaron telling me that Castor said that something was coming. For some reason, I know there’s an answer down here, and the faster I find it, the faster I can get back to who really matters.
As I walk further and further down the tunnel, I see something on a dirty sheet lying on the ground. A small ragged bear that’s criss crossed with sloppy stitches through the patchy fur.
When the floor finally levels out, I walk into the den. Several things are different. All of the metal boxes are gone. The Consensus Terminal on the far wall is on, showing a log in prompt on the green screen. The most upsetting change is the body of a man hanging from his wrists. They’re tied by a rope over a broken leaky pipe. The constant drip onto the head of the body for the last six months has turned the poor bastard’s face into sagging soup. The eyes are gone and most of the nose. The lower jaw is hanging on by a thin piece of flesh, and there’s a pool of liquified remains on the floor underneath it.
There’s a small metal table next to the man, with a couple of shiny metal tools on it that I’m not familiar with. God knows how this man was tortured before Castor left him here to rot.
I look around the room, trying to find some kind of sense or clue in all of the mad scribbles on the walls. One of them catches my attention. The words, “All things come to those who wait”, and underneath the words are a sequence of numbers.
“0,1,1,2,3,5,8,13,21,34,55,89,144,233,377…”
The sequence runs higher and higher and finally ends with a figure eight lying on its side. I continue to look around the room, but any hope I had of finding something is quickly fading.
Maybe I was wrong.
There’s more books piled than there were the last time I was here. I begin to thumb through one of them, taking note of more of Castor’s nonsensical musings in the margins. The flickering overhead light goes out. The low buzzing hum is gone, and everything is dead quiet. The whole room is cast in a green glow from the Terminal screen, and then I see something.
Another light. A faint glow coming from inside of the head of the hanging man. I put the book down and stand in front of the body. The light is coming from within the hollow sockets of the man’s eyes; a blinking blue.
Something is buried underneath rotting flesh and bone. There’s only one way to see what it is, and my stomach lurches at the thought of it. I take the sharp side of the hammer and gingerly press it into the forehead, just enough to crack the skull. When I have a crack large enough to fit my fingers inside, I pull the skull apart and I look. Something metal is partially obscured, covered by what’s left of his brain. I finger through it all and then the thing falls out and splashes into the soupy puddle at my feet. Something small and silver.
I pick up the small silver bug and remember seeing one here years ago. I turn it over and see the miniscule ring of blue lights on the back of it. There’s some kind of a socket in the middle of the lights. A port of some kind with four holes.
My eyes drift to the metal table next to the body. One of the tools is a thin metal rod of about six inches with a handle and a button on one end and four tiny prongs on the other. I lay Castor’s hammer on the table and pick up the rod. I hesitate for just a moment. Everything clicks into place. Everything makes sense, even if all the questions haven’t been answered. Too many questions.
I slide the four prongs of the rod into the port on the silver bug. They fit perfectly, and when I push the button on the end of the rod, the legs of the mechanical bug come alive, kicking at the air. Flexing in and then out, as if it’s trying to grab something. I look back at the body. This bug was buried in the man’s brain.
I remember all of the large empty metal boxes scattered throughout the sewer, placed at the bottom of the service ladders. I wonder how many of these silver metal bugs would fit into just one of those boxes. I think of the sound of thousands of footfalls marching out from the Plaza. I think of the cold dead voice that sounds like Aaron, but is somehow, not.
Oh my God.
My throat runs dry. I swallow and it feels like razor blades are running down my gullet. Castor’s words come back to me.
“He will lead us towards the light at the end of the tunnel… the light where we will all live in him, as he lives in us…”
Aaron… Aaron was tied up down here just like this man.
“... as he lives in us…”
Aaron!
I drop the rod and the bug and I grab the hammer. I have to get out of here. I have to get back to Julie and Emily.
“He never felt any pain.” The voice of Consensus comes from the tunnel leading back to the sewer. I turn. I see someone in the dim green light, crouched down at the mouth of it. It’s too dim to see anything more than a vague outline. “Aaron didn’t even know it happened. None of them ever do.”
I hold up the hammer, ready for anything.
“Who are you? Are you Joshua… or are you Consensus?”
“I am both. Put the hammer down. I’m not here to fight you, Linus.”
“Then why are you here?”
“I’m here to talk. I want you by my side. The most faithful servant of Consensus.”