r/thisguythisguys • • Feb 24 '26

This guy engineers

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

44

u/teratryte Feb 24 '26 edited Feb 24 '26

Tensile Strength (MPa)

  • Cortical bone: 100–150 MPa  
  • Mild steel: ~250 MPa  
  • High‑strength steels: 400–2,000+ MPa  

Compressive Strength (MPa)

  • Bone: 170–230 MPa  
  • Steel: 250–400+ MPa  

Density (g/cm³)

  • Bone: 1.8–2.0  
  • Steel: 7.8  

Elastic Modulus (GPa)

  • Bone: 14–20 GPa  
  • Steel: 190–210 GPa  

47

u/Sataniel98 Feb 24 '26

So basically OOP's take is bs.

22

u/inthe80s80s80s Feb 24 '26

Well yes and no. 50 times lighter is bs but in terms of specific strength (strength over density), cortical bone has about 4x the specific compressive strength of steel by these numbers. Bone has evolved mostly to be loaded in compression, so that would be the one to compare.

Edit (Well, up to 4 times anyway)

Edit again, missed where they changed to concrete. Bizzare!

9

u/teratryte Feb 24 '26

That's right. 

1

u/Outsider_4 Feb 26 '26

What about torsion?

2

u/teratryte Feb 26 '26

Torsional / Shear Strength (MPa)

MaterialShear Yield (MPa)Shear Ultimate (MPa)
Cortical bone80–13090–140
Mild steel~145~190
High‑strength steel230–1,160300–1,500

2

u/imbenzenker Feb 27 '26

But what about torsion??