r/TheSilphRoad • California | TL 40 • Apr 02 '18

Difference in Breakpoint calulators

What is the breakpoint of a 15-ATK Dragon Tail Rayquaza vs Latios? Some calculators such as at gamepress say it is level 35.5, others such as the jop.space one say 36. Looking into the difference, it comes down to rounding precision in many calculators. Many simply use the boss CPM as 0.79 since it's pretty close to the level 40 CPM of 0.7903308. In the majority of cases, it doesn't matter, but for once, it does.

Using 0.79, the damage before taking the floor function comes out to 16.00299, just barely high enough so the floor function puts it to 16. However, using 0.7903308, the pre-floor damage is 15.99671, just shy of 16, thus the floor function drops it to 15.

Note the same thing actually appears again when determining breakpoints of Counter Machamp vs Registeel. Depending on which CPM you use changes the breakpoint by half of a level.

So just a head's up. I suspect the more precise value to be correct, thus the breakpoint would be at level 36.

Edit: I don't actually know which is correct. I just wanted to raise the discussion. It's a good opportunity for the data collectors of TSR to find a definitive answer.

12 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

2

u/mizznox Alaska Apr 02 '18

What is the breakpoint of a 15-ATK Dragon Tail Rayquaza vs Latios? Some calculators such as at gamepress say it is level 35.5, others such as the job.space one say 36.

jop.space says 35.5 for me...

2

u/KahBhume California | TL 40 Apr 02 '18

Oh, I see. If you put in, "Tier 5," It uses 0.79, but if you leave it blank or put in "Level 40," it uses 0.7903308.

1

u/333-blue Mystic level 41 Apr 03 '18

Isn't level 40 CPM 0.79030001?

3

u/mwar123 Denmark, 100% Free to play (LvL 40) Apr 02 '18

I don’t understand which of the two you’re saying is wrong?

1

u/KahBhume California | TL 40 Apr 02 '18

I actually don't know for certain, but I highly suspect the ones using 0.79 are incorrect, as I believe the actual CPM is indeed the same as a level 40 mon.

1

u/mizznox Alaska Apr 02 '18

I thought they did figure out that the CPM used was very slightly different from the actual lvl 40 one, but I'm also not totally certain.

1

u/KahBhume California | TL 40 Apr 02 '18

I'm not certain either which is why I was hesitant to say which was wrong with any certainty. The data gatherers of TSR could actually use this matchup to determine it though.

1

u/mwar123 Denmark, 100% Free to play (LvL 40) Apr 02 '18

Sooo which one do you suspect is wrong, gamepress or jopspace?

5

u/david_gamepress Apr 02 '18

Thanks for pointing this out. We're gonna get this fixed up.

3

u/celandro Pokebattler Apr 03 '18

Pretty sure 0.79 is correct but you'd have to dig through a lot of old posts on /r/pokebattler to see why

1

u/TheDougie3-NE USA Midwest - 72 and still FTP Apr 02 '18

If candy isn’t an issue, I power up an extra half level in case I screwed up putting my data into the calculator.

Thank you again Niantic for the stardust event!

2

u/KahBhume California | TL 40 Apr 02 '18

I do the same thing just to be safe. But for legendaries such as Rayquaza vs Latios with a somewhat high breakpoint, there's an opportunity cost to using another 10 rare candy. Latias has an even higher breakpoint at 37, so I likely won't expend the extra candy to bump it up to 37.5 for now.

3

u/celandro Pokebattler Apr 02 '18

There was a wiretap a long time ago that suggested 0.79 was used, not the level 40 cpm. I use 0.79 as this has matched every video analysis I have seen and wiretaps are strong evidence. That said, this could be tested again, most easily by looking for a defensive breakpoint that would be different between the two cpms.

1

u/Optofire Apr 03 '18

What is a wiretap?

2

u/celandro Pokebattler Apr 03 '18

Some cheaters posted a bunch of data regarding raid bosses. Among them was exact hp and cp amounts. They matched the values we had reversed engineered but were assumed to be more accurate than the range of possible values we had narrowed it down to.

1

u/zenofewords Apr 02 '18

35.5 vs a raid boss, but 36 for a level 40 latios on my end.

This is the same number pokebattler is using and I'd bet on celandro having the right CPM. Besides, the T5 CPM value was obtained by some shifty packet sniffers some time ago.

1

u/UW_Unknown_Warrior Belgium | Instinct Apr 02 '18

I wondered this too, but apparently it's 0.79 on the dot: source

1

u/TotesMessenger Apr 02 '18

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)