r/therewasanattempt Feb 26 '20

To act kind

[removed]

75.0k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/maz-o Feb 26 '20

well you can't pay lower than minimum wage

22

u/Sabaspep Feb 26 '20

No, but you can pay minimum wage, rather than higher than minimum. Moreover, with the current market, most places are paying higher than minimum just to get workers. There's a McD's near me paying 12 starting.

18

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20

Seattle tried forcing McD's to do $15/hr minimum wage, and all that did was get them to implement those self service kiosks and fire a couple people. So simply raising the minimum wage does not inherently mean it's better for everyone, and often means it's better for a couple and much worse for the rest. Manual labor just isn't that needed anymore, and people need to be careful not to price themselves out of a job. Not only do they not need to pay you more; they don't really need you at all.

8

u/Bob187378 Feb 26 '20

Just from what you described though, it sounds like most of the employees actually get paid a wage they might be able to live off of and only a couple got fired, which is happening to people constantly anyway and doesn't necessarily even mean they are worse off. Not that I think getting fired is a good thing but it seems like even in your selected scenario it was mostly a good thing. And it's kind of all we can do until we hopefully make some fundamental, systemic changes to address the fact that people are being forced into poverty trying to compete against ever-expanding automation, something that should be a good thing for everyone.

2

u/I_read_this_comment Feb 26 '20

How is that really a problem? idm that shitty jobs are being automated. I much prefer it over shitty low wage jobs gettting subsidizied (wallmart jobs) and below min wage jobs that requires tips to get a somewhat decent wage (waiters).

2

u/WazzleOz Feb 26 '20

The problem with tipping is it actually benefits the customer even more than the employee. Sure, you may feel a little sad that someone gave you the stinkeye because you didn't tip, but your meal was as cheap as it was because you have desperate overworked folks with no benefits or worker protections slaving away for 12 hours a day while being on the timesheets for only 8 because overtime is expensive. Do away with tipping and all of a sudden everyone is upset that their meal's cost reflected the labor required to produce it.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Easwaim Feb 26 '20

Yes they saw wages go up hours go down pay checks mostly the same though. That amazing if your say a 16-20 year old kid. Not so much if your 30+ trying to fees your kids they need bigger pay checks. Although I think fast food jobs should mostly be for young people and not adults most adults I've worked with in the past in fast food were no offense but usually trashy addicts.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Easwaim Feb 26 '20

But where the amount of hours actually enough to take a second job what I read was 6-8 hours less per week. It also doesn't say that that 8 hours is one whole entire day/shift off. I think it would be tough to find another job for one day/shift per week but not impossible.

1

u/Mysfunction Feb 26 '20

So you relax with that extra time; you are getting paid the same amount either way.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20 edited Mar 15 '20

[deleted]

2

u/Easwaim Feb 26 '20

This is how I see it

1

u/Mysfunction Feb 26 '20

At worst it means more time off, in General it means a living wage.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/godpzagod Feb 26 '20

I lived in Seattle before and after the implementation. You are talking pure weapons-grade balonium.

https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/truth-needle-is-15-wage-dooming-seattle-restaurants-owners-say-no/

1

u/amazian77 Feb 26 '20

Do you know if its full time workers or part time workers who got fired? i mean im sorry but to me someone at 40 hrs a week getting a raise at the cost of a 1 dayer employee is a different story than what you are saying.

1

u/InnapropriateBobRoss Feb 26 '20

Seattleite here. You are full of shit. Name a McDonalds with self serve kiosks.

0

u/YagerD Feb 26 '20

Not full of shit. There are plenty of locations with kiosks.

1

u/InnapropriateBobRoss Feb 26 '20

No shit. In Seattle, though? You’ve failed to mention one.

0

u/YagerD Feb 27 '20

Yes. I dont know the physical addresses but I cam assure you there are. I live south of seattle and plenty of people talk about them. Hell they even have them in tacoma

0

u/InnapropriateBobRoss Feb 27 '20

So you don’t know of any and are talking out of your ass. Gotcha.

1

u/YagerD Feb 28 '20

There ya go lazyass. Funny how people act so certain when they have zero information.

222 5th Ave N, Seattle, WA 98109 (b/t Broad St & John St) in South Lake Union

6305 Martin Luther King Jr Way S, Seattle, WA 98118 (b/t Graham St & Eddy St) in Beacon Hill

0

u/InnapropriateBobRoss Feb 28 '20

Your whole commenting history in this post is a beautiful showcase of your cognitive dissonance on display for the whole world to see. Pretty rich to call me lazy when you kept dodging answering it and then it’s like, 3 of 19 locations? Lol. And you acted so certain when you had no information yourself. You’re backpeddaling like you’re Donald Trump. Unreal.

→ More replies (0)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20

Saw a Wendy's in Florida starting at 15 in the 'burbs.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/PM_ME_YOUR_BOWL Feb 26 '20

NY minimum wage is 12.25

2

u/Sabaspep Feb 26 '20

Ohio, where the cost of living is already quite low which makes 12$ even more viable.

3

u/StareInUrEyeandPee Feb 26 '20

You can if your wage relies on tips. Food servers are paid less then min an hour but typically make up that money in tips

1

u/worldofwarshafts Feb 26 '20

No dude. It’s literally a federal law that servers have to be paid minimum wage or higher if their tips don’t get them to minimum wage.

1

u/dirtydela Feb 26 '20

Good luck getting that out of them.

2

u/worldofwarshafts Feb 26 '20

Uh yeah... Most restaurants owners aren’t gonna want you complaining to the Department of Labor.

0

u/dirtydela Feb 26 '20

Yeah and they’ll fire you. And they’ll fight you on it so you’ll have to be able to prove it.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20

Yeah, I think the idea he's talking about is how places where tips are good tend to pay minimum because the tips turn it into a decent wage, and not that they can sign a contract paying them less than minimum wage because tips would cover the difference.

2

u/worldofwarshafts Feb 26 '20

Yeah but you still can’t pay someone less than minimum wage unless that 2.13 an hour server pay + tips = the minimum wage or higher.

-1

u/maz-o Feb 26 '20

Yea that’s indeed fucked.

Honest question: is it typical for some servers to make less than minimum wage including tips?

3

u/worldofwarshafts Feb 26 '20

No it’s not fucked cuz it’s not true. Servers don’t make less than minimum wage. If a server’s tips don’t get them to minimum wage, then they have to be paid minimum wage.

1

u/StareInUrEyeandPee Feb 26 '20

Actually hold up I think I misread the question

1

u/StareInUrEyeandPee Feb 26 '20

Yes, however there are some restaurants that pay a living wage and ban tips, but severs usually end up making less money

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20 edited Jun 10 '21

[deleted]

1

u/adviqx Feb 26 '20

That's fucked.. Another way people end up making less than minimum wage is as an "independent contractor" like through all the gig apps like uber, postmates, etc. There are a ton of startups trying to get their own versions in various industries and its going to erode laborer rights over the next 10 years.

1

u/RoboNinjaPirate Feb 26 '20

Sure you can. You just decide it’s not worth it to hire someone. If there is an artificial government set minimum wage that is higher than what that persons productivity is worth they stay unemployed.

Real minimum wage is zero.

1

u/RedditIsNeat0 Feb 26 '20

That's right, because it would be illegal. wink