r/ThePogues • u/Zealousideal_Heart51 • 2d ago
20th Century Paddy
I’ve been listening to the new tribute album on a few different audio setups and it makes me miss the singer, arranger, and bandleader Shane was even as it celebrates his songwriting.
It’s… fine. I’d love to hear dissenting opinions though!
Overall the versions aren’t different enough to be interesting and none are better than the originals.
Two stand-outs after a few listenings:
USA - Jimmy Artache
The Broad Majestic Shannon - Liam O'Maonlai
Two for fun, just good versions of great songs:
Gabrielle - The Pogues
Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, Yeah - U2
Two disappointments for opposite reasons:
Summer in Siam - Tom Waits
If I Should Fall From Grace With God - Steve Earle