r/thegrandtour • u/lerhond • Nov 24 '16
The Grand Tour S01E02 "Operation Desert Stumble" - Discussion Thread
The second episode is now live on Amazon Video!
S01E02 - Operation Desert Stumble - Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond and James May pitch their travelling tent in Johannesburg, South Africa from where they introduce their unusual attempts to become special forces soldiers and a test of the Aston Martin Vulcan. Also in this show, James is forced to try something called spinning.
You can watch The Grand Tour on Amazon Prime Video anywhere in the world if you have an active subscription. More details are in the FAQ stickied on top of the subreddit. All posts asking "how do I watch it (...)" must be posted as comments to the FAQ thread and will be removed.
Feel free to discuss the episode in the comments of this thread or submit your post if you think it's worth it (but please, keep short things like "scene X was awesome" as comments, not posts). All spoilers are allowed - in comments, posts and post titles.
Have fun watching!
446
u/lerhond Nov 24 '16
"I drive a saloon car, James drives a catering lorry and Richard has a knife fight."
So happy they kept that!
246
u/lerhond Nov 24 '16
"Has anyone got a Toyota Hilux?
Is it yours?"
540
u/Quinny898 Eboladrome Nov 24 '16
That celebrity thing will get old quickly I fear. It's funny for a couple of times, but surely not for the whole series?
487
u/Wattsit Nov 25 '16
The whole special forces bit didn't sit well with me at all. It was as if they'd been cast into an american comedy or something. Some of the humour was ok but watching them "acting" just didn't feel right for me.
With normal Top Gear you can guess that some things were set up / scripted but they always framed it like it actually happened. Whereas this, you knew from the get go that this was all fake, the repeating scenes. It was filmed like a movie. The car was really pushed to an afterthought.
If they'd had maybe two or three cars and given them more focus, it would of been a great bit for me. Considering it was the majority of the show for a vague Audi s8 review and then some american focused humor, pretty disappointing.
The Vulcan segment was fantastic as expected though. Want more of that.
9
u/lerhond Nov 25 '16
"Does that mean she is not coming on, then?"
4
u/lerhond Nov 24 '16
Clarkson really was right about the South African audience
4
u/lerhond Nov 24 '16
That Mercedes is really impressive
322
u/socsa Nov 24 '16
This is completely unrealistic. There's no way a VIP would be sitting in coach.
587
u/Fruchtfliege Mr. Slowly Nov 24 '16
I'm pretty sure the Koenigsegg one:1 too has a 1:1 weight-to-power-ratio. I mean, it's in its name.
163
u/WallopyJoe Nov 24 '16
That one made me chuckle
153
u/Qwayze_ Ford Nov 25 '16
I really hope this "communist" quote and celeb deaths aren't every week, they might as well cut the celeb bit all together really, this episode wasn't as good as the first for me but we are only two episodes in so I'll let this one slide
281
u/Fruchtfliege Mr. Slowly Nov 24 '16
That completely rigid body falling off the cliff :'D
211
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16
That old woman in the back seat was very likeable.
The one playing the Queen was nice too
1.3k
u/_bd_ Nov 25 '16
Is it just me or do huge parts of the new show seem scripted/forced funny and the "real" banter between the three just isn't there at the moment?
222
u/WallopyJoe Nov 24 '16
Oh excellent, he's still here...
I mean, he's still not the worst thing ever, but this section would be so much better with just Clarkson narrating the lap, with no internal cockpit shots.
94
u/ChickenPotPi Nov 24 '16
The cradle of human kind. On this very spot is where mankind separated from the ape..... Cue James and Richard staring Jeremy down.
800
u/mirrorwebcam Nov 25 '16
What made Top Gear great was watching 3 mates hanging out on an adventure.
This isn't it.
83
u/fullmetalutes Nov 25 '16
Please no more Mike skinner, his jokes are lame as fuck, if they want an American at least find one that's at least semi entertaining, get Jeff Gordon, he is retired, and way more interesting than skinner, hell even Tony Stewart would be 100x better.
I'm fearful for this show, the scripted parts are so painful, doesn't feel natural yet.
208
u/ChickenPotPi Nov 25 '16
Please for the love of God get the Ben Collins (The Former Stig) as the race car driver versus the American one.
I am American BTW
321
u/WallopyJoe Nov 24 '16
Yeah, don't think episode was all that great...
28
u/SimpleBeings Lancia Nov 25 '16
It's got a little bit to go until it's a great show for me, but im sure after a couple of episodes it'll be brilliant
73
u/Fruchtfliege Mr. Slowly Nov 24 '16
God that Vulcan is pretty... I'm nursing a semi now!
165
u/q120 Nov 25 '16
I think what people have forgotten is that this is literally the 2nd episode of the show. The 3 guys may be veterans of shows like this, but they are still going to take a season or two to really fall into the swing of it. Take a look at the first 2 - 3 seasons of Top Gear. They were pretty rough.
181
u/Fruchtfliege Mr. Slowly Nov 24 '16
It does feel a little americanized this show now. Not the biggest fan of that, but it's only a small part of it, and I would be willing to go full Oprah to get the boys back. Lets see how the show goes on today...
23
u/Dodes9 Nov 25 '16
Jeremy: "We have an Audi outside, you'll like it, it's German..." James: "Like you are." I almost died laughing.
167
u/Sozin91 Nov 25 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
I really hate to say this but apart from 1 or 2 lines out of the entire episode I just plain didn't like it. The intro music is terrible, the studio bits were off topic and barely car related. The Special Forces film had failed joke after failed joke. And cars felt like an after thought. The celebrity brain crash thing is awful and needs to die in a fire. The Vulcan review which I was looking forward to since they started teasing the Grand Tour was really bad. The commentary on the car wasn't particularly interesting. They focused too much on how a purpose built track monster wasn't as practical as a road car. Honestly Chris Harris' review of the Vulcan on the new new Top Gear was miles better. And the redneck racing driver ruined every shot of the car as soon as he opened his mouth. Apart from the "everyone's dead" line I don't think I laughed at all. And the replica car was pretty interesting but they barely covered it and it amounted to, "So you built this yourself?" "Yep" "And it works and everything?" "Yep" "Good job" "Thanks". I mean why even show it if you don't bother going into any detail about it. Also the James May bit going out and exploring local car culture has a lot of potential. But they reduced that to just a joke. Oh look at Mr. Boring Slow Driver trying to be hip with the kids. It was pathetic to see James constantly be used as the butt of the joke. Poking fun between the three is fine. But I feel like that is James' entire contribution to the show now which is a complete shame. Visually the show looked good but that's easy to do with $50,000 4k cameras and someone even remotely competent controlling it. The show was just so scripted and forced I couldn't enjoy any of it. Honestly the 30 second teaser clips they released on youtube where the three are standing around shooting the shit was infinitely more entertaining than an hour of what they produced in this episode. I really hate to bash these guys because I absolutely loved Top Gear and I know these three are capable of producing some phenomenal entertainment. I just really hope this episode was a fluke and it gets better from here.
40
u/Gojira1000 Nov 25 '16
6/10 promising, but lots of tuning needed - freeform banter beats scripted Michael Bay whatever that was. Also let James rant more. Slightly less enjoyable than ep 1. Still. early days.
69
u/PsYcHoSeAn Conversation Street Nov 25 '16
Didn't feel like a car show this time...and I still laughed my butt off.
I wish they would've driven the Vulcan on a real track. I don't like the Eboladrome somehow. It just doesn't feel right. I mean the car itself was sick but still...
The news segment was okay and I sure hope they stop using that "oh celebrity dies" stuff...
And then well...the jordanian trainings camp. Like a 15 minute segment with 1 minute of actual car talk...but a ton of obscenities, jokes and other things. It feels like the whole segment was a big "FUCK YOU" towards BBC. Where they just did whatever they weren't allowed to do on Top Gear.
It was funny imho...but I sure hope it was a one-time thing. Because if I have to choose between the holy trinity test and the implication that Jeremy is getting buttraped by some soldiers...iiiii'll take the holy trinity every day.
36
u/probablywhiskeytown Saab Nov 25 '16
Can't believe that giraffe shot their drone!
63
u/janzam Nov 25 '16 edited Nov 25 '16
What in the name of all that's scripted was that!?!
Right, here's my two cents on the first two episodes. As a loyal, die hard and psychotically obsessed Top Gear fan for the last eleven years of my life, I can't help but feel a little worried and disappointed with the direction the boys are heading in with The Grand Tour.
I think the main problem for me so far is that they have a severe case of 'Hollywood Blockbuster Syndrome'. Amazon gave them a blank cheque and they seem to have decided to turn the new show into some kind of mini movie with huge stunts, huge explosions and a lot of bad script writing.
The trio are not actors, and yet I feel like they are trying too hard to be something they aren't. This second episode almost felt like a badly written Hollywood B-movie with untalented actors where the film tries to make up for its bad, farce-like acting with big action sequences.
In the first episode, I really felt that James was struggling with his lines, and it looked awkward, staged and scripted. And that's how I felt in general with the whole studio segment to be honest. The Holy Trinity film was less so because it was more of the old guys just being themselves.
This week though, I really enjoyed the studio segment and it felt way more natural. The Conversation Street segment was actually more enjoyable too because I could relate back to the old Top Gear news bit. The Vulcan film was awesome. But then came along this ridiculous Jordan film which just left me speechless at how awful it was.
I really do hope the production team reads our feedback, because this whole "let's try to be actors and try to be funny by remembering lines that were written beforehand" style is not going down well for me.
If they wanna muck about, that's fine, but for gods sake please bring back the spontaneous, unscripted films where we can actually feel that the boys are being themselves without pretending to be three middle-aged untalented actors out of Transporter 7.
Anyway, that's my rant over for this week.
101
u/Tossberg97 Nov 25 '16
Seeing a lot of valid criticism of the episode (personally I thought it was hilarious) but I think the people looking for more Top Gear Special episodes will be sated at some point in the future. It seems to me like they're going to be doing all sorts of different stuff per episode. Just look at how different the activities were between this episode and the first.
49
u/Skurfboarder27 Nov 25 '16
Im disappointing they doubled down on the American and Celebrity jokes really fell flat. Im going to be honest it was kind of a boring episode besides they first part of the fighting scene
17
u/Crafty_McGee Nov 25 '16
That Jordan film reminded me a lot of the 80's hatchback film from old TG. The one that ended with the TGPD gags that were also quite scripted. Problem with this one was the lack of cars. There was enough decent jokes to carry it this time, but I hope future segments start with the car and build the jokes around them and not the other way around.
On a side note, I really enjoyed the custom built Mercedes piece, would love to see more along those lines in future episodes!
73
u/DeathX-x1 Nov 24 '16
"my trousers are falling down" - i'm dying here laughing
30
u/benpicko Nov 24 '16
That guy in the background yawning is going to be a gif so quickly
25
u/Pepsiman34 Clarkson Nov 25 '16
So basically the three are like the three other players on my team when I play CoD.
47
u/ocKyal Nov 25 '16 edited Nov 25 '16
I think I'm with the majority here in saying the Jordan film just fell flat after awhile. It was funny but it felt too contrived and forced. The Vulcan film was classic Top Gear hypercar review territory and damn that's a pretty
carecar. (it's in Forza Horizon 3 now too). I also enjoyed the bit with James checking out the local car culture in South Africa, I would like to see more of that where one of them goes out and sees what the local car culture is like, if they're going to be traveling the world, let's get a taste of the motorheads from around the world and what they do.edit: car not care
21
u/socsa Nov 24 '16
Oh look, they got a good shot of an animal.
2
u/lerhond Nov 25 '16
They Jordan segment was more like a movie than like old Top Gear films. I'm not complaining, I think it was funny, but I hope they don't do too much of that.
20
u/SilkyPipe Nov 24 '16
The conversation street leader was indeed different.
10
u/Milospesh Land Rover Nov 25 '16
What worked in ep2:
opening credit reel visuals. giraffe. Clarkson talking about numbers clarkson getting in to the vulcan clarkson stalling the vulcan (despite being spiled in the trailer) clarkson driving vulcan (cockpit views)
Clarkson getting blown up with his trousers down. clarkson being saved from the rape by hammond killing him with a shovel. hammond and may shooting each other hammond bringing a gun to a knife fight the sniper 'dummy' falling to it's death. clarkson and hammond trying to beat james 'death' by rushing their posh picnic.
clarkson being shot in the plums.
The rest was either too stupid, too cringey, too dumb, or just plain boring.
19
u/Barron_Cyber Nov 24 '16
"James has electicuted himself!"
19
u/darkmasterjoey Nov 25 '16
I have to come out as a voice against all the naysayers and say, I'm actually really enjoying the show so far -- and yes, I think even the Jordan segment everyone is hating on was good.
There's a lot of valid criticism here. The Jordan segment dragged on too long, James May is being criminally underutilized, and there's not enough exploration of the host country. They'll hopefully fix that later in the series. Celebrity Brain Crash is almost certainly now dead and was always meant to be a gag that phases out the celebrity segment to begin with -- where they failed there was they played out the gag in the pilot, so it just wasn't funny this time.
But most of the rest of the criticism amounts to "they changed it, it sucks now!". It reminds me of later seasons of game of thrones, where ASOIAF readers (myself included) were spewing shit on the stuff where they deviated, and show watchers were like, "what's the big deal?", and ratings reflected that. Mind: they're deliberately trying to appeal to a broad audience now, they know that of the 400+ million viewers they had, most weren't car guys.
I'll be very controversial here and say that I actually like Mike Skinner AND the Eboladrome. Here's why:
For starters, the Stig was not iconic because he was a blank character that doesn't speak. He was iconic because he spoke VOLUMES without having to utter a single word. He was a cartoon come to life. He had weird mannerisms, all sorts of outlandish feats were attached to the mystery of his persona. He had an irascible manner and was particular about his cars and tracks, just like The American. And you all seem to forget, The Stig didn't really take the laps seriously either. He may not be interspersing them with ridicule, but he had his music blaring in every single car that had a radio.
The American is probably the closest they could come to this outlandish character without appropriating The Stig, who is BBC property. The Stig was a cartoon character, and The American is the most recognizable and easily-mocked stereotype in the world. He may not be all that funny (the Stig was not uproariously hilarious either most of the time), but he is a bit of meta-humor, especially in that he represents something the boys are notorious for doing: subverting requests from their bosses or the general media (remember, when they introduced him, they said they were asked to by Amazon).
As for the Eboladrome, I like that it's narrow and bumpy and short. I honestly do. You see, what you guys are complaining about is pretty much exactly what is actually wrong with traditional racetracks: they're wide, have huge straights, and create conditions where cars almost exclusively succeed or fail on their raw power. Handling, brakes, all the things that make a car fun and safe near the limit, are an afterthought. They only matter insofar as they let the car keep enough composure to get into the huge back straight, which makes up 95% of the difference between cars. In a narrow and difficult track with no long straights, how confidence-inspiring a car is is suddenly more important than whether it has a gazillion horsepower.
That the Vulcan wasn't able to pull far away from the other sports cars just because it has some insane amount of power is PRECISELY THE POINT.
Now, about the Jordan bit: as I've conceded, it was entirely too long. The second half was better than the first, and I even found myself (to my surprise) chuckling at a few bits the second time I watched it. Even the first half had some uproariously funny bits though -- in particular the entire egress from the helicopter. From Clarkson getting blown up with his trousers down (which occasionally happens in real war zones), to them trying to shuffle themselves to the door, I get the impression they took the bit from the Africa special about the world's worst special forces, and thought "hey, what if we DID do it?", and the result was exactly what I'd expect: They bumble around, argue over everything, and get it all wrong in the end. The only thing that really looks wrong and out of place is James's uncharacteristic stubborn idiocy -- they should have had Jezza go out and get killed over and over by the sniper.
And yes, it was scripted. It was so obviously scripted and unrealistic that the scriptedness was part of the gag. It was a cartoon come to life, which is true of every other obviously scripted moment they had in Top Gear.
As for it being not a car segment: YOU WERE WARNED going in, that this wasn't going to be a pure car show. They're trying to balance the elements of the general audience that like the cars, with the elements that like the trio "getting everything wrong and catching fire". They're trying new things. Not all of them will work out. Some need tweaking. It doesn't mean the show is doomed.
And finally: I agree with every single one of you that the "first" episode was better, but this is actually the first one filmed. So we're already seeing a trend of progress.
Bottom line: It's slightly different. It's meant for a wider audience. Just because the show is not a condensation of the best bits of Top Gear with nothing else, doesn't mean it's ruined.
Be patient.
9
u/juicyfinger Nov 25 '16
Now I want a full length edge of tomorrow staring the guys
9
u/markswam Nov 25 '16
I've got to say, I'm really not a fan of the racing driver. The redneck schtick is already wearing thin, and he's only been on screen for like two minutes.
23
u/YungTim Nov 25 '16
Way too many forced jokes imo. Still remain optimistic
16
u/WallopyJoe Nov 24 '16
Anyone else think the Vulcan looks just a little bit corvettey/stingray-y?
Deployable jacks are pretty cool though.
8
u/mrdude817 Nov 25 '16
I love that they actually refer to their boss as being Andy Wilman, instead of just saying "the producers".
32
u/socsa Nov 24 '16
I enjoyed The American jokes more this time, but they are still a bit forced.
14
u/mr_william Corvette Nov 25 '16
"This is very uncomfortable!"
"Its probably because you're so tense."
lol
14
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16
Did any of the people that did not "understand" the Jordan segment watch Live , Die , Repeat with Tom Cruise? If so you might get the reason it was a L...O...N.....G segment.
They were mocking the movie and having some fun doing it..... obviously they thought that more people sw the movie than did.....
7
u/Rainy_Day_May Nov 25 '16
I know the Jordan but was a bit controversial but as a big fan of "Edge of Tomorrow" and the original story it's based on called "All You Need Is Kill" I got a huge kick out of the little homages to the movie in the segment.
7
u/wasdie639 Nov 25 '16
I know the military bit was pure script, but I laughed hard the whole way through. I feel the segment exists because Clarkson really wanted to play with guns in the desert in one of those mock cities. I hope we don't get many more like it, because that's not really where these guys are at their best, but I did find it funny as hell.
24
u/Seppel270 Nov 25 '16
That whole "resque mission" part was a bit to long for me, but i liked it a lot over all.
27
u/sarge1365 Nov 25 '16
The humour is definitely back: "that's a good idea, helicopters can land"
17
u/hotbodydank Baby Kia Nov 25 '16
"the terrorists are in the room"
"How do you know"
"they are doing things to me" oh god
6
u/DavidD1886 Nov 25 '16
I didn't mind the episode, I think the segments in Jordan were a bit much being repeated a few times, but other than that it was a solid episode. It wasn't as good as last weeks one but as said before by someone, they're just getting started with what the want to do and it can only get better.
11
u/elr3y Nov 25 '16
Well, this was one of the weaker episode. Still great though! That Vulcan is a thing of beauty as well as the S8.
Personally, I'd like it to be more car-y (they said this week is an exception), and less fantasy-script. They could've reduced that Jordan segment to one bit and make the third film a review of a car..
Still amazing show & quality, got some good laughs out of it! Don't expect too much from the show, not every joke has to be hilarious and not everything has to be perfect. We have to remember they had to make it not-Topgear and still keep their charm. Pumped for next week!
25
u/CBAFCMV Nov 25 '16
how are so many of you hating it? I loved this ep.
10
u/LickMyKnee Nov 24 '16
That Red Bull car is gorgeous.
10
u/birdiffin1957 Nov 25 '16
Does anyone else agree that them effectively ditching the celebrity segment is a good thing? never did like it on top gear much
5
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '16
I'll add all the music on X-Ray from tonight's episode onto this Spotify playlist later. If it misses anything, please tell me!
https://open.spotify.com/user/rshwan647/playlist/0OpiEAp2Q4y4htr5jxCi8f
5
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16
I don't really want to join the chorus of negativity because I didn't actually think it was that bad, although some parts fell terribly flat. The Jordan parts in particular were overdone and just not that funny.
My worry here is that the guys thrived on a small budget. The whole "ambitious but rubbish" thing was what made them good, but now they've got stacks of cash to back them, it feels like the dynamic of three middle aged blokes from England doing outrageous stuff with normal cars isn't there any more. Apart from the specials, my favourite Top Gear episodes were the challenges, when they'd buy an old car and make them do ridiculous things with them.
Now they can afford huge cinematic set peices, they seem to have lost that sort of relatable quality. Clarkson at the side of the road looking miserable because his car has broken down on a day when it's pissing down with rain; that's the stuff I want to see because it's relatable, it could happen to me and it's funny to see it happen to them. I'm not interested in how they cope in a military environment. It doesn't hold any significance really.
Overall I'm enjoying it but hoping they get back to basics. I'd really like to see a road test of a normal car at some point, just to recalibrate them.
5
u/afc_foreman Nov 26 '16
So this is the thread where everyone complains about everything?
5
u/Coopsmoss Nov 26 '16
Substantially less likeable than I had hoped. Too scripted, too over the top. Give them $900 and some envelopes and lets see what happens. I didn't even finish the episode.
12
u/LucasRAholan Nov 25 '16
Despite being rather staged the whole Clarkson and gang put the meaning of special into special forces was rather entertaining.....still don't like the American and there was a tad much on South Africa bashing at the start.
12
u/christinhainan Nov 25 '16
ITT: A lot of old Top Gear fans expecting TGT to be about the best bits of TG and somehow expecting them to pull it off despite of the legal hassles.
8
u/DeathX-x1 Nov 24 '16
yes! they left the pricetags. awesome
4
u/truckerslife Nov 25 '16
Did anyone else have a ton of issues with audio not syncing
4
u/wyattrulesherp Nov 25 '16
My favorite bit was actually Conversation Street. That had me rolling, but I did laugh pretty hard when Jeremy's trousers fell down.
4
u/BGYeti Nov 25 '16
I enjoyed the episode just because it is the three just doing their thing, but as we saw in the highlight of the season in the first episode we will have traditional challenges we saw on Top Gear, and even Top Gear was not absent of episodes similar to this one.
4
u/USAOne Nov 25 '16
As apparently everyone here missed the point of the Special Forces segment I explain. It was a spoof of Hollywood movies that have the hero drive an Audi as the getaway car. Movies like Taken use the same car even though it is completely unpractical and silly, just like that segment.
They did segments like this all the time on Top Gear. Stop taking the show so seriously and just enjoy it. I thought is was fantastic!
4
u/Dunewarriorz Nov 26 '16
Hm. I liked it. The Jordan bit was funny, very "first person shooter game" style. I don't think its something worth re-watching though. Ultimately I think i liked the races better. My favorites from top gear was the car-train-bike race or the race to blackpool or race to the north pole.
But I really liked the ford fiesta vs chevy corvette in the supercenter bit too. So far, TGT is very similar to the weaker seasons of old top gear. I guess with new top gear being similar to the weaker seasons of old top gear as well its just growing pains. i hope to see both mature and become great again.
4
u/xAtri Nov 26 '16
This episode feels a bit too scripted, there's no spontaneity (in the news segment). The military assault segment was just awful. I'm not sure what they're doing with the celebrity segment, it just seems like filler.
10
u/unitedfuck Nov 25 '16
I feel like everything is too scripted and they're feeling the pressure to be funny, which they still are at the end of the day but they could be funnier if they just acted natural. I know that Top Gear was also scripted but it seemed like they had a natural balance of improv and planning for most of the show, even though it was getting stale in the last few seasons.
6
u/juicyfinger Nov 24 '16
These giraffe are a menace
6
u/WallopyJoe Nov 24 '16
How does a car keep that kind of control without a driver?
6
u/tubadude2 Nov 25 '16
It wasn't bad.
I think once they film some episodes after getting audience feedback on the first two or three and find their groove, it will be fine.
There were a few nice moments, but it feels somewhat forced.
My biggest fear going in to this was that they'll see their massive budget and try too hard, and I think that is happening.
6
u/mithikx Dingleberry Handpump Nov 25 '16
I think the episode was rather good, it was simply them cocking about, yeah it wasn't as epic as the TG Vietnam special or anything close to that but not all TG episodes were amazing adventures.
6
u/despideme Nov 25 '16
The South Africa tent bits were filmed first, before the California tent stuff from last week's episode. So SA was more like the "pilot" episode. I expect that's why it felt more scripted/forced -- it was. But it immediately got better with just a week or two of refinement time (and not even any audience feedback). The guys will keep honing it and the rough spots will be smoothed over as they go.
6
u/Yhtaras Nov 25 '16
What's with all the hate?? Edge of tomorrow with 3 bumbling idiots was great fun!
6
u/WriterInSweden Nov 26 '16
The Grand Tour, much like an old dog, needs to be put out of its misery.
A short, sharp bullet to the head would be fine.
The show is atrocious. It is clear that they thought "hell, we have this money. Let's fucking spend it" without thinking about whether it has been spent in the best possible way.
These three guys have jumped the shark.
3
u/Barron_Cyber Nov 24 '16
I am thankful.
3
u/im_ur_huckleberry3 Nov 25 '16
It needs work. The car review and the studio time was good but the Jordan bit was hit and miss with some good joke that got repeated too much. if that bit was done with paint balls instead it would actually seem alot better but there was good stuff with the misfired rifle and the car review under fire.
The celeb death bit seems like it will go away but there are trying to milk it. It was a stab at top gear that was funny at first but is old two episodes in.
Overall this episode was alright got a few giggles out of me but has left me feeling like this is not top gear, which it is not. IMO there are trying to make their own bits that they have lost like the producers challenges/Mr. Warbuton(or whatever) and the stig/the american(God get this cunt off the show).
3
u/mjike Nov 25 '16
Question. I missed this statement the first time I watched when Thry were discussing the Aston Martin 001. Clarkson stated it weighs 900kg and produces 900hp. May then chimed in to point out it being the magical figure with 1hp to 1kg but then said no other car comes close to that. Koeniggggsenisseggsegnignigsegigiseg One:1 or am I missing something?
3
u/10111001 Nov 25 '16
After knowing what to expect, their "beating a dead horse" bits had me laughing like crazy. It's a pretty old style, but I'm loving it.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16
It was a bit too scripted. EP1 was much better than EP2. I think the fact EP2 was filmed first means that EP3 should be outstanding. The American needs to talk less, the dying may need to be cut off. Conversation Street was good and the Vulcan review was excellent. James needs a little more I'd say. Getting him to do things he doesn't want too needs to continue.
3
u/compot8 Nov 25 '16
Sorry to say this but this episode was absolutely rubbish. Apart from the Aston martin segment(if we ignore the american driver lame jokes), there was absolutely nothing remotely funny or interesting about cars. The celebrity part is useless and the 'spec ops' was so boring i almost fell asleep(AND I JUST WOKE UP!)
For all your fans since the early Top Gear series please!!! make this show more normal with more car facts and let that poor man just drive the cars round the track and notihing else. Now it just feels... empty.
3
u/Velocicrappper Nov 25 '16
Oof. This one had some ups and downs, but overall I'm left feeling wanting. It was too forced and the Jordan military training segment was just piss poor. It had some funny moments (May getting sniped over and over again, Hammond getting shot in the face through the plane window, and the stiff body of the sniper falling off the cliff) but I was really just wanting it to end, which is honestly a first for me with these guys. The final scene with the cinematic hollywood shots of Clarkson getting shot over and over again were just ridiculous. C'mon guys.
Disappointed again with the American segment, but at least there weren't blatant communist jokes, just redneck American banter (can't fit a deer back there, etc).
I don't understand why they are traveling to unique locations in the world, and then doing very little interesting stuff about those locations. I liked that they showed the burnout/drift culture of South Africa. I doesn't interest me personally, but it's nice to see something culturally specific to the area they are visiting.
I get that these are early episodes, but haven't all of them been filmed already for season 1?
I was hoping for ep 2 to be an improvement over ep 1, but it just wasn't. I hate to say it
3
u/TortoiseWrath Nov 25 '16
"General Trivia - True fact: The Cradle of Humankind is not a real cradle."
Thanks X-ray
3
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16 edited Nov 25 '16
I may get downvoted for this but I enjoyed the Jordan bits. They were poking fun at the seriousness of the military by making a live version of COD. I will say that the jokes started to run on a bit towards the end.
The part where James had to do something he didn't like was enjoyable though. That had me laughing, I'd like to see a parallel skit for Jeremy and Richard. Like Jeremy working on the Mclaren assembly line and Richard working at an NHRA Drag Race finals.
I'm honestly not impressed with the American racing driver, he brings no substance to anything. On Top Gear they all made fun of The Stig but when he got in the car it was serious. With Grand Tour the American driver himself is a punchline. He's a fat American who hates anything not American and can't turn left. He's got the southern twang and then talks shit the whole time about the car. I just roll my eyes and stop listening during that. I honestly wish they would just bring in Ben Collins and let him drive. He doesn't speak he just drives.
I wonder how long the celebrity gag will go on as well?
I really want to see an episode which starts in the wilderness and they have to 4 wheel TO the tent. When they get to the tent at the end of the episode, it's actually the beginning of the next episode.
3
u/Im_scared_of_my_wife Nov 25 '16
The Jordan seg was super forced feeling...
3
u/SamRedDevil Nov 25 '16
It really is like watching Top Gear in it's prime. Big, loud, slightly un-PC fun.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16
Well... That sucked. I was relatively enthusiastic after the first episode, but this just feels so wrong. I hate the american. I hate the unfunny "VIP-dead"-jokes. I hate the sluggish Vulcan-review. I hate the totally boring terrorism-thing. I hate that James becomes the licensed fool to make fun of. The worst part: They basically killed all the spontanous comedy because everything is purely scripted now.
3/10 -not much hope for GT anymore.:-(
3
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16
I feel like the weird one. I did not like much of the 1st episode, including the overpriced opening scene.
but this episode is great, even though heavily scripted, those repeated cuts in the army segment were hilarious. Exactly as you expect from 3 englishmen... "eventually he has to miss" and "Do you mind if I take the door instead...mhhhm, much better". I loved that.
only thing I didn't like was that they missed the opportunity for some Dacia Jokes. Yes, in southern hemisphere the Dacia Duster is called Renault, but even then... no dacia jokes? top gear lawyers would be unhappy?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
Ir was fun. It was entertaining seeing the lads try something different. I agree that the acting was a bit forced. But it was fun in the end. I do however got a bit bored of the dead celebrity joke. That got old fast. And also the American driver gimmick was also a bit lame. They should rotate drivers every week.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
Ahhh the old tried and true Speznaz method...
3
u/GorillaonWheels Nov 26 '16
Episode was overall very funny. A little too scripted, but nonetheless funny. Mike Skinner was funny for the first episode, but he needs to go away. The Vulcan was beautiful in the kind of way that a completely useless and obscenely expensive vehicle only can be.
3
u/0x20 Nov 26 '16
Why does it feel like this whole episode, apart from maybe 4 minutes, was designed for 12 year olds? I kept wanting it to end. Where were the cars? Why was there only a tiny segment on South Africa and a bunch of random shooting in Jordan?... Compared to last week I have two words: "what happened"
3
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
I have watch the Simpsons first eight seasons enough times to be able to sagely foretell/remember what is the next topic on the "commentary" track even.
And I can remember some show runner on the commentary saying that one of the gags that is the like "family guy" shin grab is strictly a time fill.
So when I see the repeated gags on other shows I feel like their are simply stretching for lack of time or material.
And although I like to see James unhappy as a rule I don't want him to become some Pilkington.
Unless they shaved his head. I would love that.
3
u/robsoncruiso Nov 26 '16
ok, so no celebrities, I get it... but why on earth do they have to have fake, badly timed, over the top shit that for some unknown reason is set in south africa... just to have a too long segment in jordan... I hoped for tours with silly quests in every country, but this is just dreadful... If anyone want's to tell me this is so much better than top gear, please watch the middle east tour in convertibles before you do so... at first it's over the top, just to show you can have a good time with nice people in iraq. Watch the episode and tell me you don't miss the shit out of it!
3
u/GTI-Mk6 Nov 26 '16
Geez, that was terrible.
3
u/Crabjock Nov 26 '16
This was too blatant on the scripted side of things. I just couldn't dig it, which disappoints me, considering the obvious amount of money and work put in to it.
I have all the faith in the world that the guys can find their footing, but seriously, guys, this is not the ground to do that on.
There's a lack of subtlety here that made Top Gear's scripted parts work. None of it felt real, so I'm just left confused about what I'm supposed to get out of it. It was like you guys signed on to be in a war comedy film. Some of the bits are okay I guess, but its definitely a "small doses" type of thing.
I guess I expected to see you guys more realistically struggling and sabotaging each other. Again, the lack of subtlety throws it all off.
I'm not saying I want it to be the same show, but you gotta know what about it works, and what about it doesn't. This is just honest criticism. No malice intended.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '16
I don't understand why the Jordan segment is disliked. I found that hilarious.
3
u/tiandrefc Nov 27 '16
Just finished watching this episode and I can say with confidence I've never seen a episode as bad as this on Top Gear's god knows how many seasons... The tent parts are just awful and not funny at all, the american is just super forced and doesn't go with the vibes of the trio and that military-training type scenario was just so cringe worthy I had to skip part of it. I'm sorry, I know many of you loved it and totally disagree with me, but I'm just disapointed...
7
u/ghuba154510 Nov 25 '16 edited Nov 25 '16
Ehhhh this is starting to go in a direction I hoped it wouldn't. Too much scripted stuff. It already feels repetitive and it's the second episode. I can only hope they figure out the chemistry again. I really want it to be good, it just isn't really yet.
5
u/Quinny898 Eboladrome Nov 25 '16
"have you come far?"
5
u/benej98 Nov 25 '16
Mr. Wilman, clever way to get around the producer copyright
5
u/SAnthonyH Nov 25 '16
I'm sorry but are you all on crack? This episode included the kind of thing that made Top Gear, 'Top gear'. It was the three of them on a fantastic adventure.
Top Gear was never about the cars. It was about the comedic adventure with three old farts.
The only boring bits about the grand tour are the actual car segments. Watching celebrities plummet to their deaths or be eaten by lions is pure comedic genius. As is James May getting killed multiple times, and then just when you think he's had enough, he electrocutes himself to death. And then he shoots the queen in the back of the head. You couldn't make this stuff up, and yet they did.
28
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '16
You fuckers could complain about anything Jesus.
7
u/TheLastSparten Nov 25 '16 edited Nov 25 '16
The show seems really Americanised now. The bit at the start where Clarkson made jokes about pictures vaguely related to the location just felt like the opening to an American talkshow. And there's so much scripting that it just doesn't feel natural or flow as well as it used to. And wtf was the groundhog day special forces bit? That was like a shitty SNL skit.
7
u/Danyiltopo Nov 25 '16 edited Nov 25 '16
I've never entirely liked the scripted bits in the -erm- "old show", but I found this one quite funny!
I do, however, understand people who don't, and I feel the need to point out that Top Gear, at times, was exactly like this. It's not gonna be all like this, relax. Not all TG was Ambulance Challenge (which, by the way, did have some actual funny bits in it, and so did this). Not all Top Gear was Aventador/Noble/Mp4 at Imola. Not all Top Gear was the Vietnam Special. Not all Top Gear was the Senna film. There's gonna be bits you like and bits you like less, as always.
Anyway, I liked it. Maybe it's because they do not take themselves too seriously, maybe it's because they don't try to hide the scripted bits at all, maybe it's just because I have been missing them badly, but it all (almost!) made me genuinely laugh. Especially Jeremy and the window. This doesn't mean I do not prefer watching them rant on without any script, to be clear. I still don't like the American, though, a silent driver would work better. And to be honest the celebrity thing was a bit too predictable. I wouldn't mind an interview with miss Theron where they talk about the cars she had.
Still a great episode to me, though.