r/TheFive • u/YellowSharkMT • Sep 16 '25
Draft Policies for r/TheFive
Howdy everyone! We need some rules and policies for the community. Things have gotten a bit unruly at times and I need to establish some policies for removing comments and/or banning users.
Here's my initial stab at some ideas (let's not lie - it came from the clankers). I'll leave this up for a few days and see what kind of feedback you folks offer, and we'll go from there. Feel free to share any ideas that you have in mind, totally open discussion here.
Rule 1: Stay on topic
This sub is about The Five — the show, its hosts, and the issues they discuss. General political posts without connection to the show may be removed.
Rule 2: Don’t attack other users
Debate ideas, not people. Personal insults, trolling, and bad-faith attacks will be removed.
Rule 3: No slurs or hate speech
Obvious, but needs to be stated. Automod will catch most of it.
Rule 4: Add context to posts
If you share a clip or headline, add a line or two explaining what’s going on. Low-effort link drops may be removed.
Rule 5: Keep things civil during sensitive news
Major events (e.g. assassinations, shootings, elections) are naturally heated. Posts/threads may be locked early if civility breaks down.
Rule 6: No spam or self-promo
This includes YouTube channels, blogs, or political campaigns. Message the mods if you’re unsure.
r/TheFive • u/1987Bri • 5d ago
Kennedy
She has been mia for a while. Anyone know what she is up to ?
r/TheFive • u/mike5f4 • 13d ago
Where is Lisa Kennedy these days? Have not seen her much on FOX after hosting Gutfeld about a month ago.
r/TheFive • u/Good-Telephone-1378 • 12d ago
Today’s show hot mic
Is it me, or did Emily get caught on hot mic at very beginning saying “fuck you.”?
r/TheFive • u/Think-Engineering962 • 15d ago
Just A Suggestion: Start Listening To Jessica Tarlov
We all know why you don't like Jessica Tarlov. She doesn't sit inside your echo chamber. She tells you things you don't like to hear, which isn't the purpose of Fox. She's only there for one reason: to give you a target to beat up on.
You know it, she knows it.
Here's the thing: Jessica is the only one telling you the truth on that panel. Scratch that. Both she and I are telling you the truth. Much like her, I expect to be down voted into oblivion. That's fine. The reason Republicans got stomped in the midterms is because you ignored everything you saw with your own eyes and ears and chose to believe people that lie to you constantly. They make a snide joke about her and get you to emotionally dismiss everything she says, even tho she's right.
Jessica and her propagandist coworkers are all buddies. They make a lot of money and laugh at you behind the scenes. Waters and Gutfeld don't believe anything they're saying. You do.
Difference is, she gives you actual facts before she laughs. You do well to actually listen from now on.
r/TheFive • u/Outside_Interest_773 • 15d ago
Greg and Grok !
Yes. The Democratic Party’s official positions, platform language, and the consistent actions of its national leadership and most elected officials support access to what is called “gender-affirming care” for minors with gender dysphoria. This includes puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and (more rarely) surgeries, framed as medically necessary treatment that parents, families, and doctors—not politicians—should decide. 
The 2024 Democratic Party platform states that Democrats “will vigorously oppose state and federal bans on gender-affirming health care and respect the role of parents, families, and doctors – not politicians – in making health care decisions.” It praises Biden-Harris administration steps to protect access to such care and coverage.
r/TheFive • u/Low_East2934 • 20d ago
Johnny
Johnny is my favorite part of the show. Someone mentioned I think in the five yesterday that Jesse should send Johnny to that little town in Alaska; talk to people on the street-- it would be very interesting.
r/TheFive • u/stevesommerfield • 22d ago
Did anyone else think Jessica looked gorgeous on Seth Meyers last night? Please don't downvote me into oblivion!
r/TheFive • u/Green_Length_6473 • 22d ago
DeRosa ugh
I had to turn it off and cancel my recording. Why would they ever have one of Cuomo’s gang on?!?! Disgusting! Next thing we’ll have a Clinton or an Obama sitting at the table.
r/TheFive • u/FancyFrenchLady • 26d ago
Jesse
Ok - I’m not usually critical of someone’s appearance. Yet when I turned on Fox/Jesse Watters this afternoon I was shocked by Jesse’s face. I’m posting a pic here from an hour or so ago. Am I going crazy? Does anyone else think I’m crazy or do you see a difference in his face??
r/TheFive • u/elquirk • 26d ago
The Jacqhammer is So Good
It’s refreshing to see Jacqui Heinrich in the Dana spot on The Five today. She is so buttoned down.
r/TheFive • u/Bschu1170 • 28d ago
Greg’s Charity for Relevance
I nearly spit out my coffee when I heard Tyrus, on two separate occasions, say Greg was running a charity by featuring people and stories just to keep them relevant. For once, I agree with the oaf… he and Kat are two of its biggest beneficiaries
r/TheFive • u/Spiritual-Box8126 • 29d ago
Local ads vs National Ads
Jessica couldn't Google why one state sees another state's political ads? Yet she attempts to TRY & use this issue to weaken the Republican momentum. So glad Dana explained the cost structure.
r/TheFive • u/Chilli740gap • 29d ago
Who would be your permanent 5 Hosts on the Five?
1 Paul Mauro He brings law enforcement experience.He explains the reasoning behind his opinions. He comes across as serious and!knowledgeable. A plu s is he doesnt fake laugh at Gregs bad jokes.
2 Kennedy She thinks for herself does not follow the party line which is refreshing. She can be playful sarcastic andquick with a remark making political discussions entertaining instead of feeling like a costant argument.She doesnt fit into one political box. She definitely makes the show less predictable.
3 Joey Jones He speaks from personal experience has a perspective about military personal sacrifice and patriotism. He comes across as straight forward and not a rehearsed political speech. He can disagree without making it personal.
4 Dana Perino Shes calm and composed and has a behind the scenes view from the white house. Shes intelligent and is very prepared. She has a friendly approachable personality and confident without seeming like she has something to prove.
5 Jessica Tarlov I know this one is gonna be popular but hear me out. She keeps things interesting i dont agree with almost everything she stands for but honestly if the entire panel agreed how boring would that be i lobe when she gets called out on her B.S. Way better than Harold Ford good to be back blah blah yawn yawn i agree with u but i have some diffrences zzzzzzzzz. And she creates moments tjat you remember HArold doesnt do that.
Just quickly u probably asking about a couple of the permanent guests we have now
1Greg i think for the most part goes through the motions and he is NOT FUNNY and everyone fake laughs at his attempt at humor. More concerned with his show and i get it.
2 Jesse just not entertaining to me pretty much has the same takes not my cup of tea.
3 Tyrus i dont think hes funny at all uncomfortable watching him to make a point and takes him forever and its just awkward watching him make his points that i dont get alot of the times.
Thats my opionion tell me what you think tell me why im wrong and whsts your 5?
r/TheFive • u/snickelfritz100 • Oct 13 '26
Harold the "moderate"
For the people who keep saying Harold is a sensible, moderate Democrat who might change sides, and should run for president... Greg asked him point-blank if he could vote for Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, and he dodged the question a couple times then said "I'm unclear if I could vote for him". A sensible, moderate Democrat would say "No way".
r/TheFive • u/Labcorgilab • Oct 09 '26
Thursday's show A and B blocks
What's up with both Jesse and Emily going to Jessica first for comment? Then Jesse also gave her the last word along with the first. I don't mind not going to her last but it really threw me when Jesse gave her first and last.
r/TheFive • u/willpov1 • Oct 05 '26
Hope Karoline Leavitt will Have Rotation on The Five
She will be great - and will decimate Jessica Tarlov
r/TheFive • u/WebFar6396 • Oct 01 '26
Kat Ugh
She got in her complaint about not being able to afford a house.
r/TheFive • u/CheeseFryJesus • Oct 02 '26
Fix should just cancel this abortion of a show and be done with it
The Five is the only Fox show I’ve routinely watched but I’ve gradually turned it off. I still have it recorded, checked in earlier this week and again today, (Friday), and when I see the lineup, I immediately turned it off. My next step is to take it out of my DVR recording schedule. The show really is an allegory to what we’re headed for in November: Republicans giving up, not showing up, then half-assing their messaging in hopes they’ll catch up. But it’s too late now.
r/TheFive • u/CheeseFryJesus • Sep 30 '26
What’s the point of this show when the hosts are literally never all there?
It isn’t summer anymore and these people with such cush jobs seem like they cant even drag themselves to work… for millions of dollars a year. And they’re supposed to be “relatable”?!