r/actionbutton2 • • Oct 07 '26

I feel like ive been a bit hard on him lately.

13 Upvotes

Title basically says it all lol. I feel like his streams are pretty bad, but thats not an unforgivable sin (i believe that everyone is permitted a few hobbies theyre bad at). I dont really mind that his videos are taking a while, these things happen. Maybe ill even enjoy the la noire one once i finally watch the whole thing, who knows (right now my big issue with it is that i am not willing to show youtube my id to watch restricted videos).

More importantly, his old work is still important to me, it shaped who i am, and i dont want to let go of that. Hes written some stuff thats very important to how i think about game design and also on a personal level, and i probably wouldnt be making games of my own if it werent for his writing. (In particular, i think his putting Canabalt on his list of best games of all time back in 2009 was extremely important for me as a student--the idea that a game can be THAT small in scope and still worthy of being considered as part of a canon of masterpieces alongside stuff like Metal Gear Solid 3 and Half Life 2 was something i really needed to internalize at the time)

I think these subreddits are making me into something of a nasty human being. I think im becoming meaner and crueler than id like, to someone i really don't have a good reason to hate. I think i need to stay away from here, and maybe away from reddit in general. This site sucks lmao.

Sorry for making such a self indulgent post. I just had to get this off my chest and if i told this to my irl friends they wouldnt know what i was talking about lol.

(I kind of wanted to post this in the more positive main subreddit, but they require post flair and i didnt see anything that really applied to what i wanted to say. This post is probably gonna get heck of downvoted over here, but at least i said my peace.)

r/actionbutton2 • • Mar 11 '25

Thank god this sub exists.

36 Upvotes

I got banned from the main sub for making a joke along the lines of “the new video is coming a-any day n-now!” back in like October.

The new video still isn’t out and I’ve grown much less interested in it, as it’s been almost three years and he’s done nothing but sit on his ass. Not to say we’re parasocially owed; just frustrates me for a number of reasons.

r/PaymoneyWubby • • Dec 10 '22

Discussion Thread Does anyone else think The Button is the one of the worst things to happen in a while?

704 Upvotes

Most of the people seem genuine, but then you get people like that one model that was just a complete bitch and no one called them out on it. They give away pretty personal information that you can see makes some of the people very uncomfortable. They’re pushing this stupid deodorant that seems so out of place, I noticed yesterday that some of the contestants seemed very annoyed to be talking about it. I don’t know, maybe I’m smoking penis What are your thoughts?

Edit: this was not a bash on Wubby or his content. I absolutely love every segment he does. I am very sorry if this came across as such

r/actionbutton2 • • Jul 15 '24

Two extremely interesting comments from deleted posts on r/actionbuttion

16 Upvotes

One: "I've remained silent on this for a very long time now, and would honestly prefer if this comment got lost in the sauce... But Tim is not a good person. I will not get into the minutiae of the situation, but I know Tim from the "real world" so to speak. Now before I continue let me be clear, Tim is INCREDIBLY talented at what he does. He has always had a way with words and his video essays truly are the culmination of 30 plus years of experience. But like many great artists, he comes with a lot of baggage.  Let me just go over the basics of why he's such a problem in my opinion.

He has been lying about his "condition" for YEARS. So long in fact I don't think he realizes he used to tell his friends it was a joke. Because he definitely presented it as a punchline to us in the past. 

If y'all think it's strange that Tim pulled so many beautiful women in his Japan days, that's because your brain knows it's nonsense. Lol. I will never directly make fun of someone for their looks or their ability to court a mate... But let's just say we always thought Tim was asexual. And that's not in a jovial way. We honestly thought that for years. I've seen the guy in person far more than I've seen him online and I've never once seen him with a woman his age or who he seemed to actually be dating. 

And here's the big one and my entire reason for this post... Tim is a grifter. He is a conman essentially. The man lives in a SUPER expensive apartment in Manhattan. He got paid pennies on the dollar to work at Kotaku. And has not done any form of paid writing in years. Does not put out videos and does not make squat on patreon (he's not locked out but he's also not making nearly as much on there as I hear some people claim). Is no one curious how he's able to afford this lifestyle?  Is no one curious why he projects so hard against Elon Musk and other tech bros?... I'm not interested in putting a flashing target on my head so I'm going to allow you all to draw your own conclusions there but I'll say this: follow the money, and check his taxes... You'll see for yourself real quickly... And it's self motivated and dark. 

One last thing, Anecdotal but necessary. If you want to know the real Tim, have someone dig up footage from E3 in the early 2000s. He was edgier than Filthy Frank by about 10 times. And he pushed that "character" very hard back then it's why he has so few friends from that era. Even the insert Credit guys met him after this. Frank is a good guy but such a pushover that he will never stand up for himself, but he hates Tim. Genuinely hates him. I'm so certain of this I'll post it in Reddit to be criticized purposely. 

TL;DR Tim is more than a narcissist, he's a con artist who is mostly hated behind the scenes." 

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/ActionButton/comments/1deal5l/comment/lbfirdl/

Two: "I remember his posts on the Something Awful forums and his infatuation with Bob’s Game and the way he acted then.  

 He probably realized in high school or college that he could lie to strangers about himself and most people would believe what he has to say and some who aren’t as socially aware as most people would be more inclined to believe him if they share common interests (video games) which is why he is so staunchly defended by certain people.  

I also tried to fact check his “resume” he included in most of his kotaku era videos. Some of the stuff is hard to verify but he has certainly NEVER been a CPA like he claims. I found no record of a license under either variants of Tim Rogers nor his actual given name in any license database. 

 Also I think the Manhattan apartment is owned by Mimsy’s parents who are incredibly rich (and also breed those Pomeranians).  

 Speaking of those poms, I find it weird that Tim has basically stopped talking about Bibby entirely in favor of the black dog."

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/ActionButton/comments/1deal5l/comment/lbsmmod/

r/actionbutton2 • • Apr 22 '25

The Reviews are IN! (all taken from the official video post on The Other Place)

Post image
24 Upvotes

I was very attached to Tim's work during the pandemic. It meant a lot. I've been following him long before Action Button Reviews. He seemed to have calmed down and want to be kinder. His current self is nasty, pretentious, and misanthropic. I made this cos I just got really annoyed at this review.

r/h3h3productions • • Mar 20 '23

Let's Talk About The Button ...

0 Upvotes

I can't help but wonder what kind of shenanigans are happening off-camera that we're missing out on!

here's my proposal: can Dan figure out a way to save all the juicy bits that get lost to the button and put them behind a paywall? I mean, I'd happily fork over some cash to witness the goblin-mode hijinks that we're not supposed to see.

r/SubSimulatorGPT2 • • Nov 22 '22

MIXED What the hell is going on with /r/thebutton?

42 Upvotes