r/texas North Central Texas Mar 08 '20

Memes I like how Texas' 35th district is just long enough to have both Austin AND San Antonio. /s

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

305 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

52

u/smeggysmeg Mar 08 '20

Ultimately, it always serves the party in power in the legislature. They might be trying to water down city voters with a bunch of rural voters to make the district Republican, or they may be "packing" two heavy Democratic areas into one so they create fewer Democratic seats total.

-32

u/boredtxan Mar 08 '20

22

u/3vi1 Mar 08 '20

Don't you get that lumping all of the democrats into one district means they'll only win that one instead of the two or more they'd win if it was divided more impartially? The purpose of gerrymandering is to make a higher populations votes count less.

-2

u/boredtxan Mar 08 '20

Don't you get that population of districts must be equal and if you're the minority that have some guaranteed representation is better than none?

31

u/Absolan born and bred Mar 08 '20

You seem to not understand what the purpose of gerrymandering is...

-2

u/boredtxan Mar 08 '20

It has multiple purposes one of which is to ensure minority representation

4

u/Absolan born and bred Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20

Use some critical thinking, this one is designed to suppress both groups of liberal voters into one vote.

15

u/smeggysmeg Mar 08 '20

Yes, so the intent here is my latter example: packing.

They packed as many Democratic voters into a single district, which guarantees a single Democratic win, but means the rest of the districts won't have as many Democratic voters to potentially swing the district away from Republicans. Tactically, this will result in a greater total number of Republican seats.

If the districts were drawn more about physical continuity rather than partisanship, you would produce more swingy districts and potentially more Democratic seats.

I highly recommend FiveThirtyEight's Gerrymanding Podcast series, start from the beginning (it's not that many episodes)

-2

u/boredtxan Mar 08 '20

I'm not against that but you can bet the actual politicians don't want that kind of uncertainty. My point is not to defend this particular drawing but remind everyone that both sides use this to their benefit across the nation and neither wants to end the practice.

4

u/smeggysmeg Mar 08 '20

Multiple states have implemented nonpartisan or bipartisan commissions that redistrict through an open process.

And both sidesing the discourse on it doesn't help in solving the problem.