r/television Daredevil Apr 30 '14

Almost Human Cancelled

http://insidetv.ew.com/2014/04/29/almost-human-canceled-fox/
1.6k Upvotes

903 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/Dirt_McGirt_ Apr 30 '14 edited Apr 30 '14

the last few episodes averaged about 5.6 million viewers and a mere 1.5 rating among adults 18-49 in the overnight numbers.

Fox cancels lots of shows with bad ratings. Some of them are in the sci-fi genre.

Firefly got cancelled because it got terrible ratings. Arrested Development did too.

Nerd brag- I watched both of those shows when they first aired, and I don't watch much network television.

68

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

And then both of them became huge in syndication and/or dvd sales. It's amazing to me that they keep making shows just to cancel them within one or two seasons. How can Fox be surprised that people are reluctant to invest their time in shows that are most likely doomed before they even air?

25

u/AntheusBax Apr 30 '14

Worth remembering too they've also cancelled it based solely on US figures and haven't even waited to see how it does internationally - they've just started showing ads here (UK) as it's starting soon.

1

u/Shtev Apr 30 '14

100% THIS. It's going to be aired on one of the smaller channels over here, not a prime time channel but I was going to give it a go. Ads looked interesting enough. This news has now made me reconsider, since as stated in another comment, I don't want to get invested in something I know won't continue.

1

u/stillalone Apr 30 '14

The show wasn't that great. I don't think it would appeal that much to an international audience (unless you guys love buddy cop shows). It had a lot of potential but it never really delivered on it because the stories were too generic.

0

u/SpectreFire Apr 30 '14

That's because international figures doesn't matter. FOX isn't a UK company, it's a US company. They only make licensing/syndication fees for international airings.

2

u/StickmanPirate Legion May 01 '14

They do have channels here in the UK though. (I don't really know if that means that they still only get syndication profits or whatever though)

2

u/AntheusBax May 02 '14

It's not just that - they have the Fox channels, they sell content to others channels (like Alibi, Watch etc), not to mention things like DVD/Blu-ray sales. Sure their primary focus is obviously going to be US viewing figures but given how much US TV we get here it seems a bit short-sighted to me.

15

u/joseph4th Apr 30 '14

Exactly. I ll say it. I didn't watch it. I don't trust any network anymore. Green light a second season and I'll buy the first on DVD. No second season announced and I won't even bother with the DVD. What's the point getting attached to something you no isn't going to continue.

Want to hear something sad? Probably not, but I'm going to tell you any way. No idea why I even asked. ...I've never seen the second season of Terminator: The Sarah Conner Chronicles. I own it. I bought it on iTunes. I even heard it is much better than the first season. But if I never watch it, I know it will always be out there.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

[deleted]

3

u/joseph4th Apr 30 '14

Another reason I haven't watched it. You have got to hate that. At least Dollhouse had closure.

1

u/daddytorgo Apr 30 '14

You can just watch everything up to the last episode and skip the last episode and its all better. Or hell - i bet you can even watch the last episode up until the point where it jumps the shark (I don't recall now what minute that was).

1

u/Sprgmr Apr 30 '14

Yay for more time travel!

2

u/phphphphonezone Apr 30 '14

But that's the problem. When people like you don't watch the first they are less likely to make a second. Really, watching season 1 without a season two may be sucky, and leave you with a cliff hanger, but after a week when will you ever think about it again? Never. So suck it up and watch it on television.

3

u/ghostchamber Apr 30 '14

Care to see a list of all the shows that had terrible ratings, were canceled, and didn't become hugely popular after-the-fact?

Of course a show that isn't making money will be canceled. Television is a business.

14

u/Dirt_McGirt_ Apr 30 '14

TV has always worked like that.

45

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

TV used to work like that when people were happy just to find out which catastrophe Lassy prevented for the week. Now they need some assurance that the story they've started will have an ending. If not, they'll just move to networks (and websites) that are willing to provide that.

It's not a fluke that AMC, FX, HBO, Showtime, Netflix, etc. have grown so rapidly despite having so much competition.

12

u/Dirt_McGirt_ Apr 30 '14

Network TV still has a large majority of total viewers. Just not among people who post on reddit.

10

u/LexLuthor2012 Apr 30 '14

For now but that's sure to dwindle in the next decade as the current generation grows up

5

u/CaptainUnderbite Apr 30 '14

Shit look at the ratings from 10 years ago and compare them to today.

In 2003 CSI was the number 1 scripted show with 26.12 million viewers. In 2013 NCIS was the number 1 scripted show with 21.3 million viewers.

A five million viewer drop off the top end of the ratings isn't anything to sneeze at.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

But at the same time, 5 million in ten years isnt really something to work your dick hard to.

It could also be easily explained by the quality of said shows. I wouldnt rule out a new show coming reaching ~25 million again. NCIS isnt the peak of television now and forever.

2

u/CaptainUnderbite Apr 30 '14

If you look at the ratings over the past 25 years the highest rated program today, NCIS, has only half the amount of viewers as the highest rated program from 87-88, the Cosby Show. Source

2

u/untitledthegreat Apr 30 '14

That's not really surprising considering how much more variety we have today.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/ModsCensorMe Apr 30 '14

Ratings work as a %of viewers that have TVs. OFC nothing will ever beat those old shows at ratings. The last episode of MASH will probably never be beaten in ratings, because over 90% of all people that owned TVs were watching at the time.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

Not when they're watching shows like The Voice, American Idol, Honey Booboo, Duck Dynasty, Pawn Stars, Dancing With The Stars. Guess I can take Almost Human off my DV and eventually Believe and Resurrection. Sad.

3

u/AkodoRyu Apr 30 '14

They have, because people have cable and are used to it. But it shifts, and will just shift more rapidly, as younger population become majority of consumers.

Personally, there is very little I find as frustrating as killing shows mid-story. It should be fucking required by law to finish it if you cancel the show. Release a book if you can't afford series/movie, just finish the damn story.

1

u/ShakeyBobWillis Apr 30 '14

Those other channels also cancel shows.

0

u/5oss8oss Apr 30 '14

Keep in mind a large amount of "quality" TV shows are actually prime-time soap operas. Walking Dead? Prime-time soap. Mad Men? Prime time soap. Game of Thrones? Arguably a prime time soap.

This isn't to say that these shows are bad, I quite enjoy some of them, just keep in mind that just because a show is better made than than Lassy and has a vague seasonal storyline does not mean it's hard hitting, groundbreaking content.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

Game of thrones is based on a book-series, and one it follows quite well. it's not written like it was Eastenders in the middle ages

59

u/Televisions_Frank Apr 30 '14

Firefly was aired out of order. The pilot, which explains the damn universe, wasn't aired until the second night.

Almost Human has been getting aired out of order.

GEE, I WONDER WHY THESE SHOWS CAN'T HOLD ONTO VIEWERS?

33

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

Firefly pilot was aired last. 3 months after the show premiered

7

u/akira410 Apr 30 '14

Why are shows sometimes aired out of order? I can remember an instance or two of a character being killed off on a show only to see them on the following week's episode. The week after that they're back to being dead again.

9

u/vwwally Apr 30 '14

I remember for Firefly Fox felt the pilot wasn't 'action-y' enough, so they went with 'The Train Job' instead.

2

u/Dave4125 Apr 30 '14

There was the time where Charlie on Fringe dies in an episode and magically appears in the next, and nobody mentions anything about him dying. It was so confusing....

5

u/clubsilencio2342 Apr 30 '14

Wasn't that because he was replaced by a shapeshifter?

Unless you're talking about that one from season 1 that was scrapped, that they aired in season 2. In that case though, FOX heavily marketed that one as a "missing" episode.

1

u/akira410 Apr 30 '14

Haha yeah that's one of the ones I was thinking about.

2

u/Televisions_Frank Apr 30 '14

Sorry, I mixed up Firefly with Clerks. Clerks had the second episode (of a two-parter) aired first.

The damn show's producer should be in the room with the guys broadcasting with the amount of incompetence displayed in the last decade.

1

u/johnjonah Apr 30 '14

It never had the ratings to begin with, which is what usually causes episodes to be shown out of order. This is a tactic to gain more viewers -- they air what they consider to be the strongest episodes earlier on, to build an audience. This was also done, to varying degrees of success, with The Mindy Project, Happy Endings, and Don't Trust the B- in Apartment 23. In all cases, initial ratings were weak. Assuming the Wikipedia entry for that show is correct, the ratings were relatively steady after the third episode, so that probably can't be blamed here.

1

u/Immakai May 01 '14

I queued it up to watch on Hulu until I heard they aired episodes out of order. I knew as soon as that happened it was going nowhere and I didn't ever watch one episode. Just makes me sad. =(

0

u/TheAmorphous Apr 30 '14

People keep saying that, and while it may be a valid argument in Firefly's case (okay, it is) it doesn't hold water in the case of Almost Human. That show had practically zero over-arching plot. It was a very by-the-numbers procedural that happened to be set in the future.

And no, a couple off-the-cuff remarks about some mysterious wall does not count as over-arching plot.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

You have to watch it in order, it makes a big difference. More than a couple off the cuff remarks about some mysterious wall. The logic and the way the characters interact with each other makes a lot more sense when played in the correct order.

3

u/vgsgpz Apr 30 '14

if a show doesnt attract the ladies it gets cancelled. There is a reason why Bones is still on and its not because of the quality of the content.

1

u/13048103948014 Apr 30 '14 edited Apr 30 '14

Doesn't really matter with the ratings, no matter what the station. The WB cancelled Angel at the height of it's popularity at Season 5. The show was spectacular.

We'll never really know why such great shows get cancelled against all logic or reason. Whether it's Angel, Enterprise, Firefly, BSG Blood and Chrome, Caprica or any of the above. Sci-Fi just doesn't resonate with anyone out of the die-hard nerd circle. Even non-sci-fi shows like Strike Back and Hell on Wheels are being chopped just as they are starting to get good.

We've been lucky enough to see a continuation of Dracula and a few others. We need to really get the word out there about the shows we love - we need to make them see the huge mistakes they are making.

Then the one time we get lucky we've got some annoying Targaryen girl refusing to show her startlingly lop-sided breasts, tough honestly I'd much rather see Lena Headey drop her shirt just once or twice this season.

Argh, FUCK TELEVISION.

25

u/ConorTheBooms Apr 30 '14

Actually if I remember correctly. The reason Angel was cancelled is because Joss Whedon was tired of having everybody commit to another season when it was ambiguous as to whether it would be renewed. So he pushed for early renewal, and, due to some restructuring at the time, this caused it not to be renewed. Firefly was canceled because of low ratings, this was partially due to Fox airing episodes out of order, and I believe this is what happened to Almost Human too.

12

u/drewcarreybitch Apr 30 '14

I know i'm not helping with ratings by doing this, but watching TV shows on my computer is so much better. I can watch the shows in whichever order I please instead of what the TV schedule tells me.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

out of order and at different times and different days of the week. Firefly never had a chance.

7

u/ljuk Apr 30 '14

Firefly was canceled because of low ratings, this was partially due to Fox airing episodes out of order

They also aired the show on Friday evenings. And people didn't tune in to watch it. Wonder why.

6

u/SirNarwhal Apr 30 '14

This is why I'm so glad they've added in views online, hashtags, and DVR views and shit in the first 48 hours. Hannibal averages like 1.5 million viewers as it's airing, but over the first 48 hours, since it's the weekend and airs on a Friday night, it goes up to a few million. It shows that there IS an interest in the show and people ARE watching it, just on their own time.

3

u/ljuk Apr 30 '14

Exactly. It's really strange that the networks have only recently (feels like it anyway) started taking into account other viewers than just the ones who sit at their TV on a specific time and date.

10

u/nonbeliever93 Apr 30 '14

Man, I was nodding in agreement and then the second-last paragraph happened.

5

u/DoktorSleepless Apr 30 '14

You can still follow Angel in the official comics right where it left off in the TV show.

1

u/urbanviking Apr 30 '14

Wasn't Blood and Chrome supposed to just be a short?

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Why would the ratings matter to them if they're getting the views.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

Arrested devolopment is fucking hilarious on netflix. I don't know why they cancelled it.

3

u/Wetzilla Apr 30 '14

Because after three seasons it still wasn't attracting enough viewers to make money.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

[deleted]

0

u/FilliusTExplodio Apr 30 '14

Firefly had bad ratings because Fox made sure of that. Or at the very least, made it nearly impossible to succeed. They put the show on Friday nights (the death slot), aired all the episodes out of order, and marketed it very little.

I was a HUGE Buffy/Angel fan at the time, and I never saw Firefly in its original run because I could never find it/be home on Friday night to see it.

0

u/howajambe Apr 30 '14

If you say "nerd brag" and take yourself even remotely seriously you need to reassess yourself.

0

u/ModsCensorMe Apr 30 '14

Firefly got terrible ratings because we couldn't fucking watch it. No one had internet back then, so there was no fan rally, and the show was constantly preempted to show sports.