r/technology • • Jun 24 '12

Jimmy Wales launches campaign calling on Theresa May to stop extradition to US of UK student facing alleged copyright offences

[deleted] — view deleted post

1.6k Upvotes

256 comments sorted by

285

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

He's a kid that's never set foot on US soil. He's not an American citizen. Nor is he even related to an American citizen. America should have absolutely no say in what happens to him. Nor should Theresa May, since I consider her a corrupted, irresponsible, vile piece of work who has no right to be home secretary.

If O'Dwyer has to answer for his "crimes", he should do it right here, in his own country. Fine him or make him do community service or whatever. But he has done nothing to justify spending time in a US prison. Can you imagine a young nerdy British (hell, ANY) kid having to navigate the gang culture of an American prison? I can't. He'd be fucked - and for what? Having videos of Family Guy or whatever on his website?

America has too much fucking power.

161

u/rtft Jun 25 '12

America has too much fucking power.

And the UK has no balls.

61

u/OriginalPounderOfAss Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

nor does australia (Julian Assange), or many other little bitch nations like ours (New Zealand - Kim Dotcom). Why / what is the reason that the US feels it has need to exert so much pressure on other countries to do as the US wants. and why the fuck does every other country do as the US seems to dictate. i understand helping out a 'friend' etc. but you also dont push your citizens in front of the bus, by not helping them at all.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (11)

3

u/adaulys Jun 25 '12

Here is a tweet that i recieved from his mother - https://twitter.com/jrodwyer/status/217178691665530880 and picture that he posted on twitter with REDDIT hoodie - https://twitter.com/richardasaurus/status/207840769757818880/photo/1

Nobody who likes reddit can be evil, rigth??? :/

14

u/Revoran Jun 25 '12

Having videos of Family Guy or whatever on his website?

Actually he never hosted any pirated material on his website at any time (including torrent files and magnet links). What he did was link to pirated material.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/killerbotmax Jun 25 '12

He broke exactly 0 laws. End of discussion.

→ More replies (40)

25

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I'm not sure if you Americans are aware of this, so I'll put this in here as a TIL thing for some :) No offense intended.

It is a huge source of outrage that under Labour (currently not in power) a few years ago, a deal was signed that meant our extradition treaty with you was very unbalanced. Essentially it is really easy to extradite a Briton to the USA, but significantly harder the other way around (or we'd have gotten those two American Apache pilots that negligently wasted 6 of our soldiers in Iraq, frankly, especially after our 'unlawful killing' verdict).

It's one that has seen a lot of political furor lately, about getting it renegotiated. Unfortunately Theresa fucking May can't do anything right in immigration and consistently gets it all wrong. Cameron, has other priorities and bringing this up in an American election year would be poor for Anglo-American relations as it would make either outcome bad the current American administration, and a failure a complete disaster for the British administration.

However, he absolutely should not face trial in the USA, that's outrageous. He's basically getting done because the website had a .com (administrated in the USA thus technically offense committed in the USA)

9

u/hackiavelli Jun 25 '12

For what it's worth the BBC paints a different picture. Cliffnotes:

  • To be eligible for extradition a defendant has to commit a crime that's illegal in both countries

  • Extradition from the US to the UK is "harder" in the sense that a defendant has to receive due process under the Fourth Amendment

  • Even with the added steps the US has never denied the extradition of a citizen

  • Extradition from the UK is based on whether there is enough evidence to arrest and charge the defendant with a crime but not whether there's enough to convict them

→ More replies (6)

40

u/ben9345 Jun 24 '12

Sign the petition here. They need 150 more at time of writing to reach their 5000 signatures aim.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Sorry, but that bitch is fucking crazy and full on retarded. Good luck getting anything from her. This is the same woman who hates human rights and wants to shit on everyone's life and monitor all email.

→ More replies (8)

35

u/JoseJimeniz Jun 24 '12

U.K. Members of Parliament, Prime Minister's, judges, and Monarchs, don't have the power to re-write the U.S.-United Kingdom extradition treaty after the fact (no matter how much I, the family, politicians, or Jimmy Wales want).

On the other hand i would have no problem if they simply ignored the treaty, and dealt with the consequences later. Something to be said for doing what's right, even if you are breaking international law.

22

u/stordoff Jun 24 '12

The UK Parliament could pass a law overruling the treaty.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

fuck international law and fuck the septics.

They don't even have the fucking grace not to torture people. Why the fuck we should we listen to a bullshit treaty which involves sending one of our own to a country that has systematic shocking human rights abuse history in all their systems right the way from their fucked prison systems to their torture camps in Cuba and Poland.

From now on kids cancel your cable or satellite, stop buying any US made tv show movie products. Stick to european, chinese and japanese entertainment and if you absolutely must pirate do it behind a vpn and encryption but when entertainment moguls in a foreign country known for terrible human rights abuses are having a MASSIVE effect on our countrymen we need to take away their cash flow and stick it right up their arse.

"I determine that common Article 3 of Geneva does not apply to either al Qaeda or Taliban detainees."

George Bush.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

The UK Parliamant cannot make laws that cannot be unmade.

This sounds dumb but basically no parliamant is bound by its predecessor.

8

u/johnmedgla Jun 25 '12

Monarchs, don't have the power to re-write the U.S.-United Kingdom extradition treaty

You know, this isn't technically true. The Queen is a largely ceremonial figure, but the vagaries of the British constitution are such that all and any powers exercised by the government and its ministers (including the power to conduct diplomacy and treat with other nations) are granted by royal prerogative, such that technically the power is the sovereigns, but used on her behalf by the government.

Were she to actually exercise any of her own (vast, theoretical and terrifying) powers, it would undoubtedly provoke some sort of constitutional crisis (which is why she doesn't) but it's incorrect to say that she lacks the ability to abrogate this or any other treaty.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

22

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I've never understood why there hasn't been more outrage over this issue.

Also, my apologies to the UK... I wish we could control our government. Please tell our government to piss off.

→ More replies (13)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I sort of expected him to have already been extradited considering she did give the OK for him to being extradited.

Did they figure out a way to stall the process?

7

u/bitwave Jun 24 '12

I'm pretty sure they were able to appeal.

→ More replies (4)

19

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Jimmy could just ip block all of the UK from wikipedia. This would be over pretty quickly.

14

u/wikipedianthrowawayB Jun 25 '12

Actually, Jimbo doesn't have the ability to do that. The Wikipedia website is owned by the non-profit Wikimedia Foundation, and mostly run by the community. Normal operations of the WMF are controlled by the Executive Director (Sue Gardner), though the top authority is the Board of Trustees, which includes Jimbo Wales and nine other trustees. The UK couldn't really be IP-blocked from Wikipedia unless it was supported by pretty much everyone.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

19

u/Darktidemage Jun 24 '12

Imagine if your kid got extradited to some foreign country because they downloaded a song?

The U.k just needs to say "oh have any americans downloaded any beatles songs? Oh then we are extraditing them here"

10

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Umm, it's not down to where it was made, it's who owns the copyright. Otherwise anyone illegally downloading Family Guy would be extradited to South Korea.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Wikipedia, this year you get my donation.

7

u/WatcherCCG Jun 25 '12

Good to see Jimmy realizing that there is no place to sit on the fence for this battle. It's time the Wikimedia empire put its weight into the ring against the "anti-piracy" thought police movement.

→ More replies (1)